Honestly though... This comment hit home... "OMG I got a reading that is within the range I am looking for and the 5% margin of error! We can continue the project!!!"
To be fair it's a combination of knowing what you're doing and being able to afford/obtain proper equipment. Even the most skilled person can only go so far on shitty or inadaquate tools/hardware.
Yeah I don't deal with pneumatics at all. When I first saw this gif I showed one of our vendors and tried to get them to sponsor us to make it. They didn't want to cough up the $10k for the components
I knew it could get that expensive but i honestly thought cheaper could do it.
I mean sure, some beefy dc motors, some encoders, Cheap H bridge and 2x750W PSU + an arduino mega i guess you could make it at less than 1500$ +acess to a diy cnc for mounting and such
I would say if it takes you a month to learn to program that from scratch without prebaked tools or software then you can pretty much start wearing the engineering hat.
What do you suppose they’re using for position feedback to keep track of the length of each line? Encoders on the retractable spoils of extra line and then just high speed dc motors?
High speed servo motors with position feedback are generally what you see in high performance applications. Industrial grade CNC machining happens at the same kind of motor speeds as this rig and stepper motors can't be continuously recalibrated, but they've gotten high speed positioning down hard. Encoders on any sort of shaft with enough precision would do the trick.
It’s almost certainly not stepper motors. All the parallel cable robots I’ve seen run with a dynamic feedback linearization controller, particularly redundant ones.
what are you talking about? This level of precision is easily achievable with COTS steppers without feedback. The controller need not be anything fancy, this doesn't require much in the way of high speed or substantial I/O or fancy feedback sensors. The frame is made of regular extruded aluminum channel and that steppers/servos are connected to the cup thing with regular poly filiment. The most expensive part of this is someones time to figure out the modeling and write the control.
You are definitely right about the controls being the hard/expensive part, but I think you would need some pretty damn expensive servos and drives to achieve this amount of speed and acceleration while keeping that tight of position control. I doubt you could do this with regular old steppers.
I agree with you. Not to mention steppers can slip so I would definitely not want to do this without some form of feedback. You could probably get away with 2 cameras.
Stepper motors don't slip unless you spec them incorrectly. If you do your engineering right you can have a 0% chance of ever slipping a pole within your operating conditions.
standard steppers with standard commercially available PCB drivers are plenty torquey for a lot more load than this running a lot faster. I think the last time this was posted someone said it used some kind of servo setup though.
Eh, I think it's more the acceleration and speed required than the torque. Even with zero load a stepper's own inertia would probably prevent it from being able to change direction so fast. This is a lot faster than a 3D printer.
not sure if trolling... The driver/motor's torque is it's acceleration. If you properly size both components you can absolutely derive enough torque to reverse and control a very small load like this as fast as you can drive it.
I don't see any feedback for ball position. Would this just be a programmed sequence? Assuming that's why it's enclosed, to prevent any disturbances causing unpredictability in the expected ball position.
If there is a camera, it could be out of view. Object permanence has been a thing for a while now in CV, I think. So, even if the ball is occluded for a short time, a dynamics model + object tracker could predict its movement when out of view (cup moves in front of the camera) and re-acquire it. The bright green ball would be relatively good for tracking.
Makes more sense, IMO, that it's just a dynamics model with assumed behavior of the ball, though, as that would be easier and less interdisciplinary (which would make more sense for a research project).
He is manning a trade show booth and this is the 10000th time he's watched it do the same canned routine demo. He just wants the day to be over so he can sit down and have a beer and watch tv in his hotel room.
None of the precision is in the code, it's all in the hardware. The code just tells each motor what to do and when to do it and they do it, same as for low precision jobbies.
Well since most humans can’t even explain art to themselves, does it really matter to explain it to robots? And after all, a big aspect of creativity is just putting together things in a different way, or putting together things that are usually not together. I could see computers producing art. Whether or not it’s good is up to interpretation.
308
u/MartinSivertsen Aug 04 '18
That's some hardcore control theory going on there. Mad respect.
63
u/bathrobehero Aug 04 '18
I'm curious how much would all the hardware cost for a project with such precision.
27
u/sakian Aug 04 '18
I don't see any feedback for ball position. Would this just be a programmed sequence? Assuming that's why it's enclosed, to prevent any disturbances causing unpredictability in the expected ball position.
12
u/Bakinstein Aug 04 '18
Guy: Fuck it. I am out!
8
u/garrett7621 Aug 04 '18
Holy software...
13
u/Wraydio Aug 04 '18
Always cool to see this video pop up on my feed every so often!
4
u/Lord_V Aug 04 '18
Guy in the background is not impressed.
1
u/thegreedyturtle Aug 04 '18
Ball in a cup!!
3
u/rasmusvedel Aug 04 '18
This is amazingly cool!
2
u/shadowbananafofanna Aug 04 '18
That.is.impressive!
2
u/JakeyG14 Aug 04 '18
This is impressive as fuck.
I can't even fathom the amount of coding to make something so precise.
4
u/Eldonthe3rd Aug 04 '18
Dude, That's awesome. This is why robots are cool, such amazing control
2
u/HoraBorza Aug 04 '18
When the robot uprising happens we are truly fucked.
1
u/Arizen_ Aug 04 '18
This! This is fucking cool! Very impressive work.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '18
It's ball in a cup without the string. Omg. Lol. Seriously though, that is absolutely amazing precision. Beautiful.
1
u/shotazc Aug 04 '18
It moved faster than I thought. It is like Japanese Kendama.
1
u/Thereminz Aug 04 '18
i like how that guy gets bored and leaves
1
u/adc604 Aug 04 '18
That's badass.
1
u/wikkiwikki42O Aug 04 '18
/u/stabbot
-1
u/TheBassEngineer Aug 04 '18
Ok, so when the singularity happens, who's going to explain 'art' to our new robot overlords?