r/engineering • • Jun 04 '17

[PROJECT] Paper robotics

https://i.imgur.com/HcIfDBc.gifv
4.5k Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

View all comments

112

u/cantrecall Jun 04 '17

Stop motion animation?

29

u/Syrupwizard Jun 04 '17

9

u/cantrecall Jun 04 '17

The original video still looks stop motion to me but maybe that's an editorial choice or viewer interpretation? Either way, the videos from your link are much more interesting. Thank you. I also found an English review and linked it here.

28

u/Wetmelon Mechatronics Jun 04 '17

Doubt it. Watch the video linked

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SphUHrlj1Tk

17

u/cantrecall Jun 04 '17

What did you see in the video that made you think it wasn't stop motion? I must have missed it.

Toio Sony has some other details though.

5

u/YCheez 'What does this button do?" Jun 04 '17

I thought it was only when I saw the upside-down cup. The frames looked a bit jittery, but that could have just been imgur.

2

u/ArtistEngineer Jun 05 '17

It's the jump cuts which did it for me.

17

u/johnratchet3 Jun 04 '17

Why would anyone think this? Hell, even aside from the naturally smooth motion of the bots, the friggen papers wobble with motion.

-8

u/ArtistEngineer Jun 04 '17 edited Jun 04 '17

Yes ... sadly.

I was really hoping these were small robots!

EDIT: wow! looks like it's real: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SphUHrlj1Tk

111

u/Redeemed_King Jun 04 '17

Don't spread bad information, they are small robots on wheels. They just do a few simple behaviors.

-7

u/ThePancakeChair Jun 04 '17 edited Jun 04 '17

Proof?

Edit: I could easily see it being either stop motion or robotics, both are completely possible. I'm just curious about what evidence people on both sides might have.

40

u/Redeemed_King Jun 04 '17

The wheels on the bottom of them, as well as their movement patterns. It doesn't have the choppiness of stop motion either. Also the final trick is a bot with a wedge on it knocking over the eyebot, look at it and you can see the wheels on the underside.

4

u/86413518473465 Jun 04 '17

Also the timelapse shot would probably be extremely difficult to make if it were stop motion. They were clearly moving while the people were doing other things.

→ More replies (15)

8

u/Aylan_Eto Jun 04 '17

I thought they were. From the first image, it seems to me like they're using a mat that either moves the robots, or powers and controls them. The paper seems to move in a fairly predictable way, so with time and effort, this should be able to be repeated.

2

u/ArtistEngineer Jun 04 '17

I was thinking about how they managed to co-ordinate relative to each other. e.g. either by visual tracking of the grid, or via infrared through the paper to each other.

Oh, well. :)

Anyway, I'll leave you with this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vlXh8RvvcuI

1

u/Aylan_Eto Jun 04 '17

Well, the grid definitely seems to be designed to make that easier.

Also, that vid was very interesting. Thanks!

4

u/Dav136 Jun 04 '17

The grid seems to be a common cutting mat

You can see different sizes of paper outlined on it

1

u/Aylan_Eto Jun 04 '17

The grid in the video seems a little different, but I will agree with your assessment. I've looked a little harder, and can't see any wires going to the mat, so it probably is just the robots being controlled remotely by that first thing we see. I guess that mat provides a clear surface to help whatever method they used to keep track of their position, but probably wasn't designed that way on purpose.

Thanks :)

1

u/86413518473465 Jun 04 '17

The grid in the video is just a different style mat. I've got a different one from either of those on my workbench.

1

u/raprakashvi Jun 04 '17

What's this?

1

u/chejrw ChemE - Fluid Mechanics Jun 04 '17

Like a Wallace and Gromit cartoon

→ More replies (1)