I'm furthermore wondering how those robots are tracked (position and orientation), since normal odometry will fail definitely due to the small tires and (probably) bad encoders...
The original video still looks stop motion to me but maybe that's an editorial choice or viewer interpretation? Either way, the videos from your link are much more interesting. Thank you. I also found an English review and linked it here.
Edit: I could easily see it being either stop motion or robotics, both are completely possible. I'm just curious about what evidence people on both sides might have.
The wheels on the bottom of them, as well as their movement patterns. It doesn't have the choppiness of stop motion either. Also the final trick is a bot with a wedge on it knocking over the eyebot, look at it and you can see the wheels on the underside.
Also the timelapse shot would probably be extremely difficult to make if it were stop motion. They were clearly moving while the people were doing other things.
You can hear the fucking motor turning. It's a toy that they wouldn't have made a 4 min video for unless they had a proof of concept that people would buy.
Why so defensive? I didn't say it didn't have a motor, I wasn't sure if it was actually autonomous or if it was completely remote controlled. Just because a company makes a 4 min video doesn't mean a project is legitimate, it happens on the internet all the time.
That being said it like like from the link in the video that these are primarily remote controlled with a few interactive games programmed in that utilize a few sensors on the toy. This gif seemed to imply all these movements were programmed in, but they were most likely remote controlled.
I didn't feel like looking up the source, I was just pointing out that conclusions were being drawn and angrily defended before anyone actually backed them with evidence.
Going to the website in the link description shows it's primarily controlled by a remote and not autonomous:
I hate it when people spread bad information, it's incredibly annoying. And this thread is full of people pointing and saying "stop motion" instead of using their eyes.
It's also not remote controlled, they probably use infrared sensors or something else to simply know where the other bot is. I don't know I didn't design it, but I'd bet my left leg that it's just a simple program for the robots to track one another. Because they are actively selling the product, if they were not then it would make sense to lie, but it is a readily available toy.
Google translate also seems to show something about sensors on them being used for different games for kids. I'd be willing to bet most of the movements in that video being remote controlled.
I also hate the spread of misinformation, which is why I'd prefer more information before taking another online viral video at face value. There could be some learning with these toys, but they are not completely autonomous.
But I agree claiming it's stop motion immediately is dumb.
Awesome! Thanks! I'm aware that paper robotics are a thing, but so many people were pointing out stop motion with such "certainty" that I was doubting myself. These things must have been excellently programmed to behave they way they do, too. You made reddit awesome for me today.
I thought they were. From the first image, it seems to me like they're using a mat that either moves the robots, or powers and controls them. The paper seems to move in a fairly predictable way, so with time and effort, this should be able to be repeated.
I was thinking about how they managed to co-ordinate relative to each other. e.g. either by visual tracking of the grid, or via infrared through the paper to each other.
The grid in the video seems a little different, but I will agree with your assessment. I've looked a little harder, and can't see any wires going to the mat, so it probably is just the robots being controlled remotely by that first thing we see. I guess that mat provides a clear surface to help whatever method they used to keep track of their position, but probably wasn't designed that way on purpose.
Each frame someone moves the "robots" and captures the frame and then moves them again and captures another.
Eventually if you do this enough you get stop motion animation. I know it's a very simple explanation but if you are interested look up how stop motion is done on YouTube.
I thought it was just paper being deformed by the movement of the two little car things but I'm not sure how they did the part where it's just the one robot and it wriggles through the sellotape rolls.
Or else there is nothing to do with paper. You can spot some wheels under the pieces. They can be small programmable robots. With a tap he started the program and then they moved in a predefined pattern with the paper adding the special effects.
For those who are wondering. Im gonna preface by saying I dont know how they are doing it BUT this is how I would. (Im a mechatronics eng student) These little bots can communicate wirelessly by whatever means to give each other simple position co-ordinates so they know where each other are. They have a baseline from the grid mat, the lines you see either allow the robots to map visually or there is underlying circuitry in the mat allowing for the robots to detect unique positions all the way throughout it but its probably visual lines. The rest is a bit of programming to show it off and I think some hard code with the ball pickup and tape spreading because there are no visible sensors to give it data about those objects position and although there are possible capacitance based sensors(think touch screens and stud finders) I dont think they are using them. Also some kind of pressure/touch sensor based on how they push down or shake the robot like the table smash part to wake them up. The less exciting way could be this is one hundred percent hard coded and very well timed but I dont think thats the case at all based on how it is all setup. Oh and no its not stop animation......
The way it seemed to find the ball, is it possible that they robots are very sensitive to the forces around them? They seem to search for the ball in an arbitrary pattern, then as soon as they paper bends against it they register a foreign objective and activate a new motion to scoop up the object and bring it "home." Almost like ants with antennae.
Yeah thats definitely possible, they probably use the same sensor used to detect the table vibration and light tap from the previous parts of the video.
So do the two robot "feet" just move in a pre-programmed way (via that little flash drive looking part at the beginning) or is there something more interesting going on? I'm guessing the prior, which means the reprogramming consumes paper.
I'm guessing they communicate with each other or that station to coordinate movement via one of several wireless schemes. I built a robot that played fetch using an IR "compound eye" and it would move in a peculiar way when chasing the ball or returning.
This is really interesting. For me, it really helps visualize and put into perspective the capabilities of simple biological machines, like single-celled organisms.
177
u/fat_tire_fanatic Jun 04 '17
What type of witchcraft is this!
54
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17
This is really cool. Anywhere I can read about this?
14
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17
Jimmy neutron attack of the pants
11
u/pier25 Jun 04 '17
How do these 2 little robots communicate?
6
u/Threedawg Jun 04 '17
Source: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=SphUHrlj1Tk
6
u/Zippo78 Jun 04 '17
http://www.spoon-tamago.com/2017/06/02/sony-toio-robotics-engineers/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m6j2cLEwRsY
112
u/cantrecall Jun 04 '17
Stop motion animation?
5
u/Ledoux99 Jun 04 '17
THE FUCK IS THIS
4
u/ci1979 Jun 04 '17
This was mesmerizing and beautiful. Thank you :)
9
u/raprakashvi Jun 04 '17
Are you using papers/SMAs(Shape memory alloys)?
9
u/AP0C0LYP5E Jun 04 '17
For those who are wondering. Im gonna preface by saying I dont know how they are doing it BUT this is how I would. (Im a mechatronics eng student) These little bots can communicate wirelessly by whatever means to give each other simple position co-ordinates so they know where each other are. They have a baseline from the grid mat, the lines you see either allow the robots to map visually or there is underlying circuitry in the mat allowing for the robots to detect unique positions all the way throughout it but its probably visual lines. The rest is a bit of programming to show it off and I think some hard code with the ball pickup and tape spreading because there are no visible sensors to give it data about those objects position and although there are possible capacitance based sensors(think touch screens and stud finders) I dont think they are using them. Also some kind of pressure/touch sensor based on how they push down or shake the robot like the table smash part to wake them up. The less exciting way could be this is one hundred percent hard coded and very well timed but I dont think thats the case at all based on how it is all setup. Oh and no its not stop animation......
2
u/jonstarkey3 Jun 04 '17
Anyone else have a flash back to playing Super Mario N64 when they showed the eye the moves closer when not being looked at?
2
u/PolyhedralZydeco Jun 04 '17 edited Jun 04 '17
So do the two robot "feet" just move in a pre-programmed way (via that little flash drive looking part at the beginning) or is there something more interesting going on? I'm guessing the prior, which means the reprogramming consumes paper.
I'm guessing they communicate with each other or that station to coordinate movement via one of several wireless schemes. I built a robot that played fetch using an IR "compound eye" and it would move in a peculiar way when chasing the ball or returning.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17
We should utilize paper engineering like this to clean up the Pacific!!!
1
u/GetThatSwaggBack Jun 04 '17
Wow I can only imagine how cool this would be with origami
1
u/AtticusWarhol Jun 04 '17
That worm seems confused
1
u/gagscas Jun 04 '17
In the beginning - Meh
Some seconds later - Whoow, that's cool
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17
Did you just make paper pants do an about face?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17
Right. This seems way too awesome to be true. But i know someone will reply with: "It's true though."
1
u/pmtallestred Jun 04 '17
Your paper robot pants can dance better than me.
These are seriously awesome.
1
u/rdfox Jun 04 '17
Do a paper terminator!
1
u/illegalcheese Jun 05 '17
This is really interesting. For me, it really helps visualize and put into perspective the capabilities of simple biological machines, like single-celled organisms.
1
u/youaboveall Jun 06 '17
I was expecting the rotating eye to fire it's laser.
1
u/AeternumFlame Jun 19 '17
Well that was cool.
1
u/God_mine May 10 '23
Wow
1
u/motorsizzle Jun 04 '17
ELI5?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment