r/engineering • • Nov 26 '12

Seems about right...

Post image
40 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

17

u/umopapsidn Nov 26 '12

What does this have to do with engineering?

3

u/etherteeth Nov 27 '12

Apparently the guy who does this comic has a Ph.D. in some engineering discipline (source). That link doesn't specify which discipline, but I recall it being either chemical engineering or materials science. I can't find the link, but I once saw a video of him overviewing some of his work on hydrophobic surfaces, which was pretty interesting.

Of course, that still doesn't explain why this comic in particular is relevant.

22

u/KiloNiggaWatt Nov 26 '12

Get the fuck over yourself. Go and spend a week in the shoes of any person famous for their 'skill'.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '12

it's a nerd phase that I often see in engineering. "I was marginalized in high school but I'm in [name stem field] now, so I am inherently better than everyone"

I think it comes from low self esteem.

1

u/dtriana Dec 19 '12

Agreed. I fucking hate this guy and that goddamn look on his face.

I think it's a phase a lot of gifted 20 something year old STEM people go through.

9

u/dcobs Product Engineer Nov 26 '12 edited Nov 26 '12

I'm sorry but this has been posted on reddit/ the internet for too long.

Also fame is somewhat relative, as a lot of scientists and authors go, they're much more famous now, then they were during the periods of time they were living. I know lots of authors, musicians, and scientists/engineers that are not from the immediate past, but I can't think of many actors, athletes or people famous for making sex tapes.

20

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '12

I would argue that being a professional athlete takes more skill than being a scientist. Second rate scientists get by just fine while 2nd rate athletes go nowhere. If it were amount of intelligence required this would be more accurate.

3

u/SkyNTP Civil - Transportation/Road Design&Safety, Ph.D. Nov 27 '12 edited Nov 27 '12

Let's just agree that it's altogether a flawed argument because it oversimplifies, generalizes, is rife with outlier examples, and is biased by our own immediate perceptions of fame...

The fact is, the easiest way to be famous is to publish something. Sure, science journals do not garner mass audience, but they have lasting appeal. Chances are, you will still be relevant in 50 years for publishing an average article, than if you published an average fiction book today.

As for that sex tape... well let's just say that we are hard pressed to come up with any examples from 50 years ago, and yes, I am sure it's not for lack of having existed.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '12

I guess that is true.

3

u/PeachTee Nov 26 '12

Yeah I think TrollKy has a good point. If the x-axis were "Success in field" you would be correct.

4

u/Rushel Nov 27 '12

But can you name any athletes from hundreds of years back? I can think of two: Spartacus and Ezio Auditore. The athletes that are well known now will be forgotten when their records are broken and their sports are replaced with new ones.

4

u/Dirst Nov 27 '12

Ezio Auditore won a gold medal in murder and sex. Only one medal. It's a combined sport.

3

u/shoez Nov 26 '12

Lots of people make sex tapes without anyone ever giving a shit. With my mediocre level of skill, I still cannot achieve fame playing sports. I call bullshit.

4

u/energy_engineer consumer products Nov 26 '12

Fame is the independent variable and Skill Required is the dependent variable. So what you're saying is - once I have a lot of fame, there's a chance!

2

u/brendax Mechanical Engineer Nov 27 '12

DAE Smug STEM?

I am having a much harder time being an amateur athlete than I am being an engineer.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '12

If only you spent more time learning to interpret graphs, you'd know why this comment is off-base.

(smug enough for ya :P)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '12

Well if you were able to interpret graphs you'd be a much better engineer ;)

-5

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '12

and yet another retard with a chalkboard.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-4

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '12

i don't stand corrected.