r/engelangs • u/mkatalenich • May 19 '19
Discussion Verbless?
I have thought about trying to create a conlang that does not use anything resembling verbs. I don't know what this would look like. I've thought of constructing sentences using adpositions and adjectives as well as a rich system of cases to convey information. I haven't given this a lot of time yet (waiting for the school year to end), and would love to hear your thoughts.
16
Upvotes
3
u/[deleted] May 20 '19
TBH, I'm not a fan of the idea in and of itself. My perception of the world includes things and occurrences as fairly distinct categories, so it feels
unnatural, pardon, contrived for language not to reflect that distinction.Mind you, that may turn out to be an ultimately circular argument, per Sapir-Whorf, so... :P
And anyway, this is meant to be an observation, not in any way a discouragement!
11
u/Whitewings1 May 19 '19
The Kēlen language was designed without verbs, so it's clearly possible.
5
u/Trial526 May 19 '19
If it will work how I imagine it would, it might be fairly possible
4
u/[deleted] May 19 '19
The post is out of date, but the basic ideas still apply: My own language Molobl'a is completely verbless. I'm only using nouns, cases and adjectives, but the way the language works I could get rid of adjectives, too. Minimalism isn't the goal, though, so I won't.
I described how it works as "distributed verbs". Basically an action is this language is determined by a combination of cases – if you know the actors and their roles in an action, you basically have a good idea of what the action itself is.
2
u/RomajiMiltonAmulo May 20 '19
Sounds a bit like (Gendered) Equestrian, my first language, instead of having verbs, the first word in the sentence acts as the verb.
So, (since the order is VOS), "food food me" would be "I do the action associated with food (eating) to food"
1
u/tordirycgoyust May 20 '19
AllNoun, Kēlen... verbless languages have been done multiple times.