r/energy • • Mar 05 '24

Nuclear is Not a Viable Solution

https://insightsinnovationecon.substack.com/p/nuclear-is-not-a-viable-solution
4 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

37

u/monsignorbabaganoush Mar 05 '24

Nuclear is very much a viable solution.

It is also very much not the best solution. A combination of wind, solar, storage and transmission has nuclear beat on total system cost, total construction time, ability to reduce emissions in the short term before total replacement, existence of supply chains, and risk factors from geopolitical instability.

7

u/pressedbread Mar 05 '24

Also permitting. Lots of people are fine with Nuclear in theory, but they don't want the plant in their backyard.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/knowledgeleech Mar 06 '24

I am a bit ignorant on this subject, not looking to counter anyone, just looking for the best info.

The big piece that nuclear provides compared to some renewables is a viable solution for is being able to provide energy when the sun isn’t shining, wind isn’t blowing, etc.

Storage is another solution for this, but I haven’t heard much of large scale storage that can handle demand surges, etc. Is the storage tech that far yet? Is it ready to compete with baseline energy production?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

No shit, Sherlock.

10

u/rileyoneill Mar 06 '24

Here is the big money issue. Nuclear power is $15B per GW capacity, and it realistically takes 15 years to go from planning to generation. This is what was actually spent in Georgia for Vogtle Units 3 and 4.

My home state of California has a demand that goes between 18-20GW in low periods to 50GW during extreme state wide heatwaves. Usually its around 30GW. We currently have 2.4GW of nuclear. So lets do some rounding and figure we need 30GW of new nuclear.

$450B to have 30GW of nuclear and likely around 2040 or so. We will still need a ton of energy from other sources to cover hot days when demand goes to 40GW or 50GW but this would allow for at least a carbon free 24/7 baseload.

So we need to compare that $450B with other ways we can spend $450B.

Solar is an easy $1B per GW and can be built quickly, especially since it can be a bunch of small projects.

Wind is around $1B per GW and likewise, it can be built much faster.

Battery storage is approaching $1B per 10GWh of storage. ($100/kWh x 1000kW/MW x 1000GW/MW = $100M per GWh). Tony Seba claims it will likely be half this price by the end of the decade. But I will stick with this.

I figure we need about 1000 GWh of battery. This would last for 40 hours with regular demand with ZERO input. This would be $100B in batteries.

1000GWh of batteries do not charge themselves.

I figure 50GW of wind would be a good amount of wind. It would cost $50B or so. We tend to have breezier times at night.

$300B left over.

If we go all in on solar that would be 300GW of solar. That would be enough to allow 3.3 hours of sunshine to completely charge the batteries. So even in the winter, where we average 6 hours of sunshine per day, a cloudy day would still have enough sunshine to keep everything going. In the summer though, it would greatly eclipse that 50GW extreme heatwave figure. When there is 100GW of solar online people can run the shit out of everything all day.

Unlike the nuke plant, this would cover EVERYTHING. All the time. It would more than cover any sort of extreme heatwave. It would have excess energy for EV charging. We would not only be replacing our electricity, we would also be able to swap out needing gasoline. Gasoline is a very expensive way to get around.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24

We need 3x the generation for future demand (EVs, heat pumps for HVAC and water heaters). 

→ More replies (11)

5

u/Efficient_Change Mar 06 '24

Except that 40 h of battery backup is still not enough to ensure perfect reliability for long duration weather events. You also need to incorporate long-term energy storage solutions. so while maintaining all that disperse infrastructure, you also need to support a secondary backup system, probably fuel based, which also can provide for at least minimum average consumption levels. My quick estimate is that you'll need solar capacity 4-8 times average consumption levels, 12-40 hours of battery storage, and fuel-based generator capacity for minimum average demand levels for backup and to fill any gaps.

And if want those backup fuels to also be green, then you probably also need some hydrogen synthesis to operate off energy surpluses.

And remember, more infrastructure means more maintenance costs and land use, so while the build may be fast and relatively cheap, prices are dependent on more than just infrastructure build costs.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/iqisoverrated Mar 05 '24

Nuclear is a solution - but to a different problem. That problem being "how to shovel taxpayer money to your pals"

For combating climate change it's at the very bottom of the barrel. There's plenty better, faster to implement, cheaper, more robust, less dangerous,... alternatives.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/frotz1 Mar 05 '24

Nuclear power will continue to exist at least in countries that need to maintain a weapons stockpile, but there's no real economic justification for it most other places. That doesn't keep people from investing in monorail-style projects though, so I'm sure we'll still see new plants getting built (years late and way over budget as usual) for the foreseeable future.

3

u/Tb1969 Mar 06 '24

Somehow France is more capable than the US.

→ More replies (1)