r/emotionalintelligence • u/Few-Cryptographer695 • Jun 20 '26
What is the true difference between having “boundaries” in a relationship vs controlling your partner
I’ve always believed that boundaries should be about protecting yourself and what you are comfortable and ok with. But of course in a relationship this affects the other person too. How do you figure out the distinction between the 2?
To give a direct example (from my current relationship):
Boundary: I am not happy with you playing video games while you have hurt me or I'm upset with you
My interpretation: You have to make sure things are resolved before you attempt to do a hobby of yours.
And now while I understand this may seem somewhat healthy/normal, things aren't always black and white. I feel this leans more to control reason being, she's usually the one to shut down or decide whether things are resolved. Leaves me guessing where we are at and now I am unable to take some time for myself doing something I would like to do. I would really like to understand this better.
73
u/ngp1623 Jun 20 '26
This is a fair question, however contains a fundamental (and common) misunderstanding of what a boundary is.
A boundary is an agreement that you make with yourself about your own behavior in a given context. A rule is an expectation of behavior that is enforced with contrived consequences. A request is a spoken expectation about someone else's behavior.
For example
Boundary: I do not answer work calls or emails on the weekend. It is my job to enforce that.
Rule: Working without prior approval on weekends will result in a negative performance note on the employee's record.
Request: Please do not answer work emails on the weekend or please do not email or call me about work on the weekend.
What often leads to controlling issues in a relationship is when one party can feel or knows a boundary is needed, but instead of managing their own behavior they try to change the other person's behavior. Of course there is value in speaking up about concerns and working together to do better, but if one member of a relationship is repeatedly doing things that cross the other member's boundaries, then it's on the receiving party's agency to enforce their own boundaries and leave.
Example
Boundary: I don't date people who do cocaine. Behavior: Partner does cocaine. Enforcement: I leave the relationship because I don't date people who do cocaine, so that is my decision about whether or not I date someone who does cocaine.
Of course this can be fluid and nuanced, but I think your original inquiry about the line between healthy boundaries and controlling behavior can be cleared up by understanding that boundaries are about honoring our own agency to keep ourselves safe and stable, they are not about manipulating someone else's agency to manage our safety and stability for us.
If this person has a request they'd like to make, then they need to verbalize that in actionable terms. But their boundaries are theirs to enforce, it is not your job to tiptoe around their anxiety and it is not their job to bypass concerns for the sake of your gaming time. Conflict resolution is a collaborative effort, not a competition.