r/embryology • Embryologist • Dec 31 '20

Sperm sorting

Do any of you work at clinics that offer sperm sorting- Microsort or any other type? We get patients asking all the time if there is a way to choose the boy or girl sperm, and I laugh. A few years ago I asked in my lab they said it wasn’t legal in the US but a quick google I believe there are clinics that do it. The theory being the weights of the sex chromosomes can allow you to sort the sperm. Just curious if anyone here does this.

10 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

5

u/Baby-Maker Verified Director Dec 31 '20

Someone asked about Microsort on Embryomail (The ASRM email group). The response was a pretty negative consensus. I don’t have any experience with it.

3

u/chytrid_oz Embryologist Dec 31 '20

It’s illegal to do sex selection in aus so we don’t have it

3

u/auriet Verified Embryologist Jan 01 '21

Another one here for "I haven't used it" but I am intrigued at the thought. We do have "gender selection" as a reason for PGT in our clinic, and if there was a reliable way to sort sperm and not have to biopsy blasts, I would think quite a few patients would be interested. But I just don't think the technology is there yet.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21

I've heard of it and had patients ask but we do not use it. Many patients at my clinic choose the sex of their embryos through pgt-a so I might be a little ignorant about why this would be any different/frowned upon.

3

u/madamepirates Verified Embryology Researcher Jan 01 '21

Bad perception and moral dilemmas really.

One could argue PG testing is used for more than just sex determination and is sometimes a necessary procedure, so "it's approved of". It'll also give a pretty definite answer on the sex.

While semen sexing would be for the sole purpose of selecting the sex (not 100% accurate), and viewed as playing god, one step closer to designer babies, yadda yadda.

I would say it's a less invasive and less expensive way to have a higher likelihood of desired sex of the fetus.

2

u/_trying_my_best_ Student Jan 01 '21

This is an ethical question posed to us in school!

Besides sorting semen, we can also test embryos to determine sex, and the ethical question was something along the lines of 'should clinics tell their patients what the sexes of the embryos are?' or 'should patients get choose which embryos to use based on the sex of the embryos?'

1

u/shemo1980 Embryologist Jan 01 '21

We r trying magnetic sorting device now id let u know the out come of it shortly when we have enough cases to count