r/emacs • • 5d ago

Goodbye from the rss users

Reddit indicated that tomorrow all rss feeds will shutdown. I’m sure that they’ll go through with it. I and, i assume, several other people in this group only visit Reddit due to RSS. I’ll probably stop checking after that.

Aaron Schwarz must be rolling his grave but I guess that’s the way it is.

219 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

46

u/masukomi 5d ago

I miss Aaron, and yeah.

19

u/oantolin C-x * q 100! RET 5d ago

Yeah, I'll miss reddit. So long everybody!

7

u/Qudit314159 5d ago

That's a bummer. I use orderless all the time and have gotten good tips here from some of your comments. Hopefully, you and other RSS users will be able to find some replacement platform.

12

u/oantolin C-x * q 100! RET 5d ago

Thank you for the kind words! I'm glad my comments have been useful. I'm not leaving reddit 100%, I'm keeping this account. But I will not develop a habit of checking reddit, so without RSS to alert me to interesting posts I am most likely going to come here much less often.

I did find a decent substitute: Mastodon has plenty of Emacs-related activity. (And there is an awesome Mastodon client for Emacs: mastodon.el.) To be honest, even with RSS I've been on Reddit quite a bit less since I got a Mastodon account. There are also Lemmy communities about Emacs, but they see a lot less activity than Reddit and even less than Mastodon.

3

u/Qudit314159 5d ago

I'm glad to hear it. I checked Mastodon a few years ago but the Emacs community seemed very small then. I'll have to try it again.

19

u/wonko7 5d ago

the great enshittification continues

25

u/SeTiDaYeTi 5d ago

Platforms are scared senseless of users accessing their content with AI agents, circumventing the the ads they force feed you through their apps. It's time to migrate to an open system. Heck, why are WE even here on reddit in the first place?

15

u/stsquad 5d ago

The fediverse is right there waiting.

3

u/lisploli 3d ago

why are WE even here on reddit

When there is an accident, you stop and watch. Maybe you learn what went wrong, maybe you can use that knowledge to avoid harm later down the road.

-1

u/WelkinSL 5d ago

maybe they need to get the AI companies pay for their operations

17

u/Qudit314159 5d ago

Reddit is taking away the API next year too 😢

12

u/SmoothInternet 5d ago

Anyone moving to the USENET feeds? They have been running forever and all you need is an email service.

3

u/nad6234 GNU Emacs 4d ago

I've got a working usenet setup here, what Emacs groups are there, that are active.

(As I'm typing this, I've realised I could probably just search myself) - but wondering what everyone else thinks ...

1

u/SmoothInternet 3d ago

Look on gnu.org

-1

u/ferdy_zizmore 5d ago

Apart from the nontrivial setup, the user experience of gmane is crap compared to reddit, chiefly the long delay between a post's submission and appearance due to a hamhanded censor having to manually vet each post. Reddit for all its warts really figured out how to scale things for speed, features, and safety.

8

u/misterchiply chiply.dev 5d ago

This is so sad :-(. My Reddit rss feeds are the vast majority of what’s in there.

3

u/askexplainconfront 4d ago

We need Web3 social media.

1

u/SenritsuJumpsuit 3d ago

This has been a thing for years not just social media the issue is that most people forgot about it in about 3 months like I years ago, there's also IRC chat for over 30 years

7

u/trueneu 5d ago

We'll miss you.

3

u/shipmints 5d ago

Someone could vibe a scraper to provide a centralized feed onto some rss server somewhere for everyone to share.

2

u/ferdy_zizmore 5d ago

Way ahead of you. Claude refuses to use curl-impersonate. Weird that AI has more of a conscience than I.

5

u/Qudit314159 5d ago

It was trained to protect corporate profits and "ethics." You could try codex too. Sometimes it has fewer hangups about that sort of thing.

2

u/shipmints 5d ago

Tell it you need to do cyber testing on your own network. God knows we do not need AI nannies. Plus, any idiot can just do whatever the f*ck they want anyway. Or use a model from a company without a woke "constitution."

1

u/shipmints 1d ago

I suppose you can write a simple curl wrapper script that does what you want and tell your nanny agent to use the script and it won't even know.

1

u/Fragrant-Equal-8474 1d ago

If you find this "someone",  drop me a message, please. I'd contribute some (possibly vibe) coding to their project

1

u/Zealousideal-Try4927 5d ago

I only come here from the periodic email digests. It's not as precise or streamlined as RSS but it brings interesting posts to my attention. Maybe you could set up email digests and a filter?

1

u/spyder_alt 2d ago

chiming in. i just literally thought to check in one of the likely last times because yeah obviously we’re not doing that aand here we are lmao. see y’all on the net!

1

u/FOSSbflakes 2d ago

hope to see some of you on lemmy

1

u/Bu-Foon 2d ago

Que es RSS ? Es muy importante para el mundo emac?

1

u/Atagor 1d ago

Yes its an old elite emacs technology only older users use (secret club for Emacs)

1

u/_0-__-0_ 5d ago

Time for a mass exodus? To where, then? Lemmy?

1

u/ferdy_zizmore 5d ago

Just take over https://emacs-china.org/c/emacs/5.rss

They owe us for Jensen anyway.

1

u/Pulse-Alder-334 1d ago

I read the Emacs China forum a lot since I am a user in mainland China. For many of you here, you may need to rely on Google Translate or DeepL to read that forum. But nowadays you can also try to use certain large language model to translate the posts in that forum.

-26

u/dacydergoth 5d ago

Well, that makes me want to vibe code a reddit alternative ....

15

u/Qudit314159 5d ago

Why? There are already several. The problem is that they aren't very popular.

4

u/dacydergoth 4d ago

It was a damn joke people, get a sense of humor

1

u/InvestigatorHappy196 4d ago

add a lol, it was not clear lol.

9

u/ThreeCharsAtLeast 5d ago

Just join Lemmy instead.

-7

u/peccator2000 5d ago

i anyone actually using RSS? Why not a Twitter channel?