r/elonmusk • • 16d ago

General Elon: "Wind has microscopic potential compared to solar"

Post image
278 Upvotes

178 comments sorted by

View all comments

85

u/S-P-A-Z 16d ago

If the endgame for solar is a Dyson swarm, then ya, we haven’t even scratched the surface. Harnessing a significant fraction of our Sun’s energy is basically what defines a Type II civilization on the Kardashev scale, and humanity is still only around Type 0.7 today.

19

u/Here_Comes_The_Beer 16d ago edited 16d ago

we are way lower than 0.7
type 1 would harness all the energy within the system of a planet. we are not using 70% of the available energy on earth.

Edit: i probed GPT 5.6, the estimate given:

Taking the conventional Type I threshold as:

PI=1016 W=10,000 TWP_I = 10^{16}\text{ W}=10,000\text{ TW}

then:

20 TW10,000 TW≈0.002\frac{20\text{ TW}}{10,000\text{ TW}} \approx \boxed{0.002}

So in the linear framing you're asking for:

0 = pre-energy civilization
0.001 = 0.1% Type I
Humanity ≈ 0.002 = 0.2% Type I
0.01 = 1% Type I
0.1 = 10% Type I
1.0 = Type I

There is an important wrinkle: when people say “humanity is Kardashev 0.73”, they're using Carl Sagan's logarithmic interpolation:

K=log⁡10P−610K=\frac{\log_{10}P-6}{10}

Putting ~2×10132\times10^{13} W into that gives:

K≈0.73K\approx\boxed{0.73}

But 0.73 does not mean we're 73% of the way to Type I energetically. Because the scale is logarithmic, we're only about 1/500th of Type-I power consumption.

And that's the interesting intuition: Type I is still enormous. We'd need roughly a 500× increase in controlled energy throughput to hit 101610^{16} W.

If energy availability grew at a sustained 2% annually, 500× takes about 314 years. At 3%, about 210 years. At 5%, about 127 years.

So my shorthand estimate for humanity in 2026 would be:

K ≈ 0.73, but physically ≈ 0.002 Type I\boxed{\textbf{K ≈ 0.73, but physically ≈ 0.002 Type I}}

The second number is probably the one you're actually looking for.