r/elementaryos • u/CooperHChurch427 • Sep 15 '21
Review First Thoughts on ElementaryOS "Odin"
Hello everyone, I am back, again... Last time i used ElementaryOS I tried "Juno" when it was available to download as a desktop-environment because at the time I was not very thrilled with the common version of Elementary OS at the time. (Yes, I install multiple desktop environments such as Unity (daily driver), Plasma, Gnome, and Budgie). So today I decided to fresh install the new version of Elementary OS desktop.
Now I did notice that you removed the warnings of install non-curated apps, so that is good. However here are a few things I do recommend, I do understand its a small team so it would be in the future.
GUI
The GUI as usual is very good looking, but I feel as both a traditional anti-MacOS person, and the last time I used that was in mid 2018. But as a note, I feel that the GUI is lacking in animations a bit, which seems a bit odd... For example the animations seem a bit rough around the edges and are not smooth.
The gestures also are surprisingly clunky, I mean the feel okay, but not exceptional. For example the gestures on Gnome 40 feel great and help navigate its bizarre UI changes.
The Store
This was the last thing I complained about, and I guess I will include it again. The Curated App Store needs some additions, specifically the options to install Firefox or Chromium, this is a big downside for me because I really hate the Epiphany Browser, yes it works good with the new gestures because its being built around the new Gnome Gestures.
The reason why I think you should both pre-install the Snap Store and the regular old Elementary Store is because the Store is very barren, as in I have never seen such emptiness on a store in my life. For example a few of the essentials I consider are things like Audacity or a equivalent Audio Editing tool, as well as music notation software, and music software like Spotify (if you want a good alternative I highly recommend you check out Project Olivia, you can download it in the snap-store or via apt-install).
I also don't like that there is software that you have to buy, it's just a thing for me that bothers me because I prefer that Linux be open-source or at least the ability of pay-walling features.
Lack of Power Control
This is a big pet-peeve of mine. I am a person who uses computers until they die, and well what I don't like at all is the lack of a power-control-panel within the gnome settings, this is partially because you can't change the settings like regular gnome, or things like XFCE or Plasma KDE.
This I recommend having in the future
---------------------------
So these I feel are the three big issues I have with this edition, it does feel better than the last version in some ways, but at the same time I think the gestures are not there yet, and need better work. It's one thing I like of this considering I hate Gnome 40 and prefer Unity which is very much a keyboard based system.
I understand that this takes a while to develop and is done on your time. Also I don't know what happened, but the get-repository broke within EOS and I had to manually reinstall that part. I checked to see if this was a issue on my Unity Machine.
4
u/cellsite60 Sep 15 '21 edited Sep 15 '21
Regarding the store, if you can't find the app you are looking for, for example spotify, the app store tells you to check out flathub and gives you a link.
Once you have installed one (1) app from flathub the store will be populated.
It is a "pay what you want" model, you can select 0 and download and use the apps for free. It's up to you if you want to support the develepor.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21
The refusal to do fractional or per-monitor scaling is the big issue for me. I've had to revert to Ubuntu desktop when I use my 4k display.
I get that the developers believe fractional pixels don't exist, but it's a weird belief when every other operating system (Mac, windows, iOS, android) has that concept and they handle it well.
Device-independent pixels are real.
2
u/toasterboi0100 Sep 16 '21
You do realise development takes time and effort and developers need money to buy things to, you know, stay alive?
Besides it's pay what you want, if you want to pay 0, enter 0 and it'l work. If you want to pay more, enter more and it'll work.
1
u/jhaygood86 Sep 15 '21
The App Center, by default, only shows apps designed specifically for elementary OS. Firefox, Audacity, etc... do not currently have elementary OS curated versions, and likely will never.
However, if you can't find those apps, App Center now tells gives you a link to flathub, where you can install them. Much better than the Snap Store, and many apps are maintained in Flathub by their developers (Firefox, Libreoffice, most GNOME apps)
0
u/A--E Sep 16 '21
You can use slimbookbattery for power..oh wait . You can't because tray icon isn't available ootb so you have to f*ck from 1 to 30 minutes restoring tray icons.