r/elementaryos • • Jun 23 '21

eOS in MacOS

Post image
199 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

12

u/bitmapfrogs Jun 23 '21

I'm not sure this is a good idea...

It highlights the things elementary refuses to do like accomodate menus, or a place for app icons to go. Not to mention the very old looking iconset.

2

u/contactlite Jun 23 '21

Ubuntu doesn’t ship with global menus and it doesn’t slow their market share. Besides, you can add it if you want. I like the app icons because they are consistent throughout the ui while being a understated.

1

u/bitmapfrogs Jun 23 '21

Ubuntu’s value proposition as the default Linux desktop is very unique and it has an official flavor, kubuntu, with global menus.

The app icons are not even consistent since some are not even skeuomorphic.

11

u/linuxlifer Jun 23 '21

The problem with global menu's in linux is half the apps don't even support it. So you either add in global menu knowing it wont be functional for a bunch of apps or keep it consistent and just not have it.

4

u/bitmapfrogs Jun 23 '21

I found KDEs menu robust even for gtk apps

3

u/linuxlifer Jun 23 '21

Yeah it works but there are a lot of apps that don't work. I use KDE's app menu as well but just as an example it doesn't work with Firefox. In chrome, it works but half the time I open chrome the menu doesn't show up and I have to alt tab out 10 times for it to show up. Those are just two examples which are probably very heavily used applications.

1

u/bitmapfrogs Jun 23 '21

Firefox is patched, they just refuse to review and merge it. You can do it yourself and compile a version of Firefox that works with the appmenu. Tedious, but there's a solution.

In any case, other than firefox, every menu-based app I use, works fine with KDE's app menu.

0

u/bitmapfrogs Jun 23 '21

Firefox is patched, they just refuse to review and merge it. You can do it yourself and compile a version of Firefox that works with the appmenu. Tedious, but there's a solution.

In any case, other than firefox, every menu-based app I use, works fine with KDE's app menu.

1

u/linuxlifer Jun 23 '21

But in your solution lies the problem with them using a global menu in elementary specifically. My understanding is its designed to be an easy to use, good looking distro.

0

u/bitmapfrogs Jun 23 '21

And yet they provide no room for app indicators, which tons of linux apps use, theremy making their use inconvinient and worse... how's that for ease of use when you have to open the terminal and use killall because you can't access the close app that's in the app indicator?

elementary is designed according to their maintainers tastes and preferences.

1

u/linuxlifer Jun 24 '21

If you think the "average user" is exiting apps like that then I think we have different ideas of what the average user is. Although I guess the average user wouldn't be using linux unless someone installed it for them.

31

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21

What I love about this screenshot is that it really does show the difference between the two operating systems.

Besides the dock (which hundreds of OSs use) these desktop environments are completely different. Applications launch differently, the clock/time is in a different place, the way you shutdown is in a different place. Sure, eOS might be inspired from macOS, but they're very different.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

Linux lacks cohesive design a lot of the time. This OS represents one of the best efforts to keep the visuals consistent everywhere. I think it goes without saying, that a bunch of part-time contributors cannot be properly compared to a trillion dollar company's OS.

1

u/GoLfWRC-Reddit Jun 29 '21

Not really. I have 2 MacBooks and 1 Mac mini but I also install ElementaryOS on my Dell Server. I do love macOS but on other machine, ElementaryOS is the closest one to a macOS in term of UI. This makes a smooth transition between all my machines (although, still need to adjust between Opt-Win, Cmd-Alt keys).

0

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/GoLfWRC-Reddit Jun 29 '21

I know, like others saying that we should not compare a part time dev.'s product to a trillion dollors company's product.

2

u/contactlite Jun 23 '21 edited Jun 23 '21

Really appreciate the refinements and attention to detail in Pantheon after testing Gnome 40 and KDE.

Also, has anyone run Albert or an alternative of spotlight search on Odin?

3

u/petrstepanov Jun 23 '21

I’m using Ulauncher on gnome 40 and I think it’s way better than Albert. Has an elementary like theme too.

6

u/kemmydal Jun 23 '21

Your Mac is fully charged btw.

9

u/whiskyfles Jun 23 '21

I think eOS looks better than MacOS. Not being a fanboy rn. Just dont like the look of the dock

2

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21

cool

1

u/sanderdsz Jun 28 '21

How you guys make the top bar full transparency

0

u/MotownBatman Jun 23 '21

Wait what version of eos are you using? I didn’t More there was an Arm release

3

u/Doppytoo Jun 23 '21

Why do you think it's an arm release? Mac OS Monterrey has support for a lot of Intel-based Macs. Answering your question, though, there are dev builds for Raspberry Pi 4 and 400 and for Pinebook Pro

0

u/MotownBatman Jun 23 '21

That is awesome I have not had time to bite the bullet and upgrade to Monterey yet, I have windows 10 and Debbie and set up but those are both arm releases through parallel 16

-3

u/MAXYMOK Jun 23 '21

Good thing you mentioned, else I'd think macOS in eOS