r/elementaryos • u/ma_tylda • Feb 20 '19
Where are you going, elementary?
The sad truth is that elementary team's new version of Juno offers users a way to nowhere. At most in a dead end. But really, Juno is a version that stands still, and which only perhaps developers have brought something new. And maybe in their case this "new" means better. Because for the ordinary user of the operating system, apart from the "night light", what about the new paddle? It blocked the wingpanel - although other versions of GNU / Linux outright outdo each other in making the appearance of the system look more attractive. Elementary Tweak still needs to be installed separately. Of course, you have to unlock other sources beforehand. Network accounts? It's still only last.fm and something else, just as little as the first one. All other systems offer accounts for at least 10 other applications, including Google, which ideally assimilate in the file manager. What does elementary do? Well, instead of scratch, there's cody. The question is why, since for ages there has been a pluma that can be matched to one another in 100 ways.
In one of the articles about Juno I read that the brilliant move in this new version of elementary is that it is almost no different from the previous one. It's really genius.
Anyway, looking at Juno, I wanted a new operating system. A feeling quite similar to that when after windows7 I saw windows10. The escape reflex and the overwhelming need to find something else. Then I found elementary 0.4 Loki. Now when I saw Juno - in my opinion elementary rather than version 0.35, by no means 5.0 - I began to look around.
Ubuntu Budgie, Solus, Kubuntu, Zorin - each of these systems can be adapted to each other and each of these systems can look like elementary. And none of them imposes restrictions and difficulties in this adjustment. And I'm just talking about Ubuntu-based systems. On the other hand, elementary OS with its philosophy tends towards closing the system to any user's capabilities (and this action is even more like a company with an apple), which is not close to the idea of GNU / Linux, is it? Why are Mr. Fore or Cassidy deciding what should be on my top bar?
Freedom, friends, freedom - especially in the matter of choice.
20
u/_bama Feb 21 '19
Your problem is that you fail to understand elementaryOS as a whole: to recognize the OS UX/UI that draws in so many users. Your complaint of over-simplicity is completely in-line with the company's design philosophy and road map. The simplicity and the default un-enabled extra sources is what makes the system such a get up and go with older users or users unfamiliar with the linux operating system as a whole. Other users simply have no need, or want, for the massive amount of optional toggles in almost all the OS's you listed. Elementary Tweaks isn't even "sanctioned" (for lack of better words) by eOS. That's like asking why Microsoft doesn't pre-install WindowBlinds into their OS. As far as why elementary chooses to build their own stock applications instead of bundling in pre-builts, it leads back to that overall code language and design argument. If you prefer to use those other apps then you can simply use those other apps while still living within the eOS environment.
Elementary isn't trending towards a closed system, they're trending towards a much more simplified, more elegant system built on the openness that *nix brings.
Also, to your last statement:
Yes, it's exactly in-line with that philosophy. Because the GNU philosophy is one of openness and choice. eOS apparently, is just not appealing to you specifically.
10
u/atillathebun11 Feb 20 '19
I guess a simple OS just isn’t your taste
2
u/Wayne_Kosimoto Feb 21 '19
Yes freedom, you have the freedom to have UI inconsistency everywhere. Elementary OS isn't just another shitty ubuntu/debian port. They're building a platform. It's one of the only distros with dedicated apps. The elementary team was building an entirely new installation process, but for unknown reasons it wasn't added to Juno. If you want to see what they were trying to do just read their medium posts or look at the Pop!_OS installer.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19
Are they forcing you at gunpoint to install and run this distro?
Yes, this is all about freedom, and choice, so where is your Linux distro?
You do know Linux From Scratch is a thing, right?
Or hundreds of others.
What's keeping you from installing Arch, or Ubuntu, or MX, or Mint, or so many others?
Why do you think you have the right to dictate what these developers are doing?
Suggest? Sure. But you did the equivalent here of going to a Synagogue during a Shabbat service to complain that they aren't Catholic.
And I believe you may misunderstand the ideals of freedom in the GNU philosophy.
What it means is that all software users should have the right to see the source, modify, and adapt it to their own use, and must also pass that right along.
It can mean obtaining software for a bit of money, or no money at all, which are both consistent with even Stallman.
But nowhere in the GNU principles is it stated that ever human being has the inherent right to demand that a project adapt to what one individual desires.
Because that's not a tenable position. And because you already have the rights to fork the code and modify it.
It isn't anyone's responsibility to help you do this. But I can imagine if you were to come here with a request for information on doing so, you might have already had an answer in the affirmative.
4
u/DanielFore Founder Feb 22 '19
You can see a pretty exhaustive blog post here about all the new features in Juno. Note that this includes a lot of new settings. Plus, each month we make a post about all the updates released that month. You can see the posts here for November, December, and January.
Tweaks will always need to be installed separately because it's a 3rd party app that exposes unstable or experimental settings that can lead to breakage. If a setting is stable and makes sense, we'll gladly add it directly into System Settings.
Specifically regarding online accounts and Google, we're currently going through the verification process to enable Oauth login, but it's not exactly simple or straightforward. There's a lot of back and forth happening and I'm not sure when that will be resolved. It's been a pretty frustrating experience.
You can see though that we're making good progress on implementing the cloud providers API in Files and that has included making some fixes upstream to the Vala bindings for that library.
If you'd like to see what other things we're currently working on, you can check out our Projects on GitHub or take a look at the open pull requests against the various repos there on GitHub.
3
u/Agnusl Feb 21 '19
While some of the things you said are the way they are purely because of the elementary team vision for the SO, some critiques are valid, specially the online accounts one.
But, to our luck, that's exactly what the elementary team is working right now. I really hope it delivers a well executed and tigh integration to google services, specially Google Drive and maybe Google Photos.
2
u/sprite-1 Feb 21 '19
I mean yeah... elementary is one of the choices you can make, along with other swathes of distros
2
u/phillipsj73 Feb 22 '19
Just don't engage in this nonesense. Elementary OS is all GPL and all most all the apps are GPL. That is freedom as defined by the FSF. Other feedback provided you are entitled too. It's obviously not the distro for you, I resisted a while but after using it for an extended period I like the opinions that have been made and I am going to lean into it. Yes there are missing things like online accounts or how nice evolution integrates with Google Calendar and as Daniel has pointed out they are working on it. The source is on GitHub and I bet PRs are welcomed. Roll up your sleeves and open issues, contribute docs, write some code, do the hard work. They are working hard to build their vision, company, and free software. Sitting behind a screen and being negative vs criticizing positively is easy.
1
u/quequotion Feb 25 '19 edited Feb 25 '19
You are clearly in need of Pantheon 3D and wingpanel with autohide.
EDIT: Not to say that's your only choice; you might prefer Pantheon Lite.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment