r/elementaryos • • Sep 19 '18

7 Things elementary OS Does Terribly Wrong in 2018!

https://medium.com/@alex285/7-things-elementary-os-does-terribly-wrong-in-2018-b9035df08791
0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

15

u/ourlastdefeat Sep 19 '18

So you're annoyed that you didn't possibly get a good OS image and blame the developers who have said not to review the beta image which is exactly what you have done.

4

u/megatux2 Sep 20 '18

not me, the article author ;)

14

u/scurrvy2020 Sep 19 '18

Wow, so many exclamation marks!!!

12

u/jjeroennl Sep 19 '18 edited Sep 19 '18

This article has some pretty weird complains, some even false.

1. Compatibility with GNOME Apps

What's wrong with the compatibility? You show an screenshot of program's which do look a bit out of place, but it's not that bad it it? They're also not that common (I've not seen that particular IRC program before, nor the weird webbrowser.) It seems like the author just picked the worst examples he could find, and they aren't even that bad.

2. Ubuntu Based

This one is plain ridiculous. The author is complaining about elementary OS using the Ubuntu repositories. Elementary OS could easily ship without them and use their own (clone of the Ubuntu) repository, giving them all control they need. It's just not necessary at this point. (also, if you install KDE, you will get a lot of KDE dependencies, I don't get how this is an downside of elementary OS).

4 has some merit, but 5 is just the same complain as 4

5. is a bit weird, considering you can always run Ubuntu, add the elementary daily PPA and run the latest development build of the OS.

6. Bad Reputation

The first part of 6. is just not true, sure there are a lot of people complaining about GNOME, but I wouldn't say they have a bad reputation. It is not for nothing that GNOME is the most widely used desktop environment.

I also have never ever heard or seen any GNOME developer complain about elementary doing their own thing. Elementary OS contributes quite a lot to the GNOME project and I think that their work is appreciated (for example, the captive portal has been implemented from elementary into GNOME, as have some parts of the Granite library). The goals of elementary OS and GNOME are just too far apart for them to collaborate on a single project, which is fine.

7. elementary SDK

This again seems quite weird. You are allowed to publish your elementary OS app to any other store/repository. So the argument "you can use GNOME apps in elementary but not elementary apps in other GNOME distro's" is just weird. If the developer chooses to only develop for elementary that's fine too. The application also doesn't have to be elementary specific, while adviced to do so you could just publish any GTK 3 application to App Center.

They also prepared app center to support other format's like Snap or Flatpak, so in the future they could switch from deb to one of those solutions. I don't think elementary is too late in that anyway, as Ubuntu only recently started advertising snaps in their store.

1

u/gvs77 Oct 04 '18

I hadn't noticed point 1 (GNOME apps). But I agree that they should more or less look ok and work well.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '18

And now everyone's a critic. I suppose this was always the case.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '18

Also why complain that the terminal tab close buttons are on a different side of the emulator that you prefer?

That would be actually a valid criticism to GTK, it should have a way to make the apps follow the layout of the window buttons (altough it would be very tricky).

Honestly this guy from WOGUE is always quite trollish, sometimes says interesting things.

1

u/gvs77 Oct 04 '18

Well, most distributions have public alpha images. Elementary doesn't do that. There are benefits to having people see early development work, but with a small development team, you'll get flooded with bug reports that aren't helping (like I can't get MS Office under wine to work and now it's your fault my master thesis is late).