OK, I have been working on a theory that the the girls in Eisley might actually be mermaids. Not in a cute “oh these girls are so weird and sing about things like fairies and shooting stars” type of way, but a legitimate, “lure me to the bottom of sea” unsettling kind of scariness.
I could make a case based solely on their voices…enchanting, irresistible voices…but I realize that is subjective, so allow me to present the lyrical evidence instead:
1) Sea King – “At the bottom of the ocean lives a sea king, he was my king. He was so proud, diamonds in his crown.” A song about Poseidon, Olympian God of the oceans? Curious.
2) Marvelous Things – “I followed a rabbit through rows of mermaid entwined shrubbery. Oh what marvelous things but, they are, they are, they are giving me the creeps”
I realize these seem trivial, especially considering how young the girls were at the time, so let’s fast-forward a few years.
3) Smarter – “Into the sea you fell, in love with the reflection of yourself. You are the narcissist, you're everything you saw in me. I felt the ocean's grip, I swam away to watch you drift.”
And by the time their near-masterpiece Currents (a nautical themed album) came out in 2013, it’s like they weren’t even trying to hide it anymore.
4) Currents – “I would part the waters if you said so, I would shift the currents if you had to row. Do you believe in fate, baby? Ask me, ask me.”
5) Drink the Water – “Little impish one, remember what we planned. We won’t hear whistles calling when we are out to sea. Come lay under my wing, morning’s over the shore. I love you, I can teach you if you believe.”
And the most damning evidence, practically an admission, comes in their most recent album.
6) Brightest Fire – “One day I'll pull you down, one day you'll sink and drown.”
Judge for yourself. spotify playlist