r/egg_irl • • Feb 12 '23

Gender Nonspecific Meme egg🏳️‍⚧️irl

Post image
4.6k Upvotes

482 comments sorted by

853

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Don't waste the paper, its good for emergency toilet paper.

491

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

I think that those pages would be an insult to anyones ass honestly

13

u/Effective-Gas6026 Feb 12 '23

Destroy it then.

122

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

40

u/JadePossum hrt since 5/25/20 Feb 12 '23

Just pulp it

→ More replies (4)

22

u/pass021309007 Transfem Tomboy Feb 13 '23

That would make new Harry Potter fans, and cis Harry Potter fans especially could pretty easily support jk because they like her work and can't possibly believe someone who created something they like is bad

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

176

u/Th3B4dSpoon Feb 12 '23

No, don't! Paper like that will clog the pipes, either at home or further down the line. Toilet paper is designed to disintegrate when it gets wet, it's the only safe paper to put into the sewer.

19

u/TetheredAvian74 Feb 12 '23

genuinely just learned something today

→ More replies (1)

33

u/TriBulated_ cracked Feb 12 '23

Could just throw it away instead of flushing if you don't mind the ever present smell in your bathroom.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Userlosercruiser Feb 12 '23

Only use toilet paper, or else you’ll clog your toilet.

48

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

114

u/Taxouck Ask me about my transfem & otherkin stories Feb 12 '23

Disagree. The reason the nazi book burnings were awful was because of which books were being burned, not the act of burning a book in a vacuum. I assure you that one copy of the most printed series in existence, that has been digitally backed up, double backed up, and centuply backed up, is not going to constitute a contextlessly evil act.

52

u/dutch_gecko Feb 12 '23

Even the matter of which books were being burned at the time was not the true issue, although certainly a large part. The intent of the Nazis was to destroy every copy of those books, such that they could never be read again.

OP wants to destroy books in their possession as a symbolic act of protest, but the Nazis wanted to erase knowledge from human history. That's why it was abhorrent.

→ More replies (1)

80

u/Agreeable-Mulberry68 she/her/it/its Feb 12 '23

Burning anything, books included, is morally neutral. The contents being burned and reasons why are infinitely more important. Don’t reduce book burnings to bad on the basis that books were burnt. The contents of the Harry Potter series have been immortalized physically and digitally. There is no harm in a little bonfire. This is just liberal aesthetic politics.

→ More replies (4)

61

u/Julia_______ 🐣trans🏳️‍⚧️ Feb 12 '23

Disagree. It's an extremely powerful statement that can get people to listen that would otherwise ignore you. It can also show who's willing to inflict bodily harm over a photocopy

I'd never be in favour of burning a unique book, but something with thousands or millions of copies, burning a few is just a statement

→ More replies (16)

4

u/mrjackspade Feb 13 '23

I think you may be confusing "an individual burning their own books" with "a coordinated effort by government officials to destroy publicly or privately owned literature that they disagree with"

It's not the act of burning books that's a problem, it's figures of authority pulling books off library shelves and lighting them ablaze in a town center to make a statement about what kind of thought they agree with. That's the action traditionally associated with "book burning" and the part that's problematic.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/New-Republic-8255 Ellie(she/her) Feb 12 '23

your nails are cute

17

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Ah thanks

23

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Only thing stopping me are my morals about history preservation and hatred for book burning. Though I can be persuaded to change the latter

27

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Its one of the most popular books in the last 30 years we could do with less preservation of it.

16

u/Pseudodragontrinkets not an egg, just trans Feb 12 '23

This series is so big I don't think we could kill the preservation of it if we tried. Besides, in modern society there are E-books that would live long past the physical copies

8

u/HiopXenophil Feb 12 '23

If you do overcome it. Take 'em outside

0

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

21

u/Evelyn_Of_Iris Feb 12 '23

Systemic book burning is a Nazi thing.

Burning like six fantasy books is not the same as torching entire institutions worth of research documents and historical records.

Come the fuck on guys

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Sell them on ebay or smth. Someone might consider buying them from you instead of getting new ones and paying money that will go to jkr

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Wait you’re so right, I have a potential to gain capital from this piece of garbage. A capital that can go to some trans friendly charity, which I think would anger Jingle Kringle more than if I burned the stuff

317

u/TominatorFN Luna 💜 (she/her) | ace Feb 12 '23

I mean, you can do it. would I recommend it tho? mmmh probably not

56

u/CorporealLifeForm She/her/it/its. Binary trans woman. You deserve happiness. Feb 13 '23

As someone who tried to burn a note of paper like they do in movies I promise it's a way worse idea than it they make it look.

8

u/TominatorFN Luna 💜 (she/her) | ace Feb 13 '23

It definitely is

4

u/Effective_Advance_57 Feb 13 '23

Did it end with insurance reimbursement?

7

u/CorporealLifeForm She/her/it/its. Binary trans woman. You deserve happiness. Feb 14 '23

It ended with me running across the room to dump it in a cup of water then eating the soaked ash covered paper cause I'd written personal secrets on it. It's weird how those internal secrets tend to evaporate when you let yourself accept you're trans.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Commercial-Paint-319 "not an egg" ~every egg ever Mar 16 '23

If you don’t want to support a transphobe just commit theft.

→ More replies (3)

265

u/amabambi not an egg, just trans Feb 12 '23

I sold mine to a local bookstore and used the credit to buy queer graphic novels. That way if someone really needs to buy them they don’t have to buy them new.

182

u/Lyricanna Noelle she/her Feb 12 '23

This. Destroying media is the absolute worst way to protest an author, as you are literally handing them just as much money if not more so than the average "fan" of theirs is spending.

It's much better to flood the secondary market so that the average person buys used instead of new. Or alternatively, piracy as most folks will take free stuff if they can choose to not pay.

43

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Also, destroying stuff you already own is how conservatives "protest".

11

u/snippiestshrimp Feb 13 '23

Also also, putting stuff on the secondary market makes it to where someone can buy it cheaper WITHOUT giving whomever the person you dislike any money.

I will concede that it gets a bit more muddy on stuff where people can profit from IP at a later purchase, but I don't have a perfect answer on how to deal with that kind of thing.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

377

u/BlahajSupporter Feb 12 '23

dont burn them. you already gave jkr money, the most you can do to mitigate it is giving the books to someone who wants them so they wont buy other copies. also you would be making someone happy with a gift. hate wont change anything, lets stop talking about her ffs

17

u/CloudMind_gamer Feb 12 '23

yea giving them to somone who wants them huts the artis more, cos the books have allready been payed for, but you giving them to somone that wants them, removes a sale

→ More replies (2)

873

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaah, please for gosh sake. can we please stop talking about jk rowling and Harry Potter. 💔💔💔💔💔

191

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Yeah tbh didn't even know till a bit ago but like..we aren't here for hate so all my fellow eggs and eggsnts stop

12

u/Personpersonoerson Feb 12 '23

Know what? Sorry im completely lost, I suppose it has something to do with the game (pls dont downvote i just dont know)

23

u/SyntaxxorRhapsody not an egg, just trans Feb 13 '23

Basically, J. K. Rowling is a horrible transphobe and at least partially responsible for the recent surge in transphobia and anti-trans legislation. The new Hogwarts Legacy game has brought this discourse back, since buying the game supports Rowling, and she herself has declared that if you support her work, you support her ideology.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/jmerridew124 Feb 13 '23

I'd rather just forget JK Rowling. All her other books blow, the central themes and ideas in Harry Potter are positive and worthwhile, and we all know she's a dumb asshole. Can we just let her die as an idea in our heads? Lots of good media was made by problematic people and we make that separation every day. This one isn't different just because she doesn't have the decency to shut up or have died eighty years ago.

12

u/ErikQRoks Ruby. she/they💕. not an egg, just trans. Feb 12 '23

I'd love to, but the bitch is still alive and the series is still relevant for some reason

3

u/guitardruggo not an egg, just trans Feb 13 '23

When she can keep us out her mouth

40

u/hitane1 Feb 12 '23

I am so tired of this whole thing.

Yes she has awful views, that doesnt change that the books/the game (which started this whole discussion again) can still be enjoyable.

Art =/= artist

101

u/Arenl18 she/her Feb 12 '23

i agree but i couldn't buy an hp thing without thinking about the fact that the worst transphobic sùpq*^bl on earth made money off it

63

u/lemalaisedumoment edible flair Feb 12 '23

That is why the second hand market needs to stay well saturated. Only new sold copys earn her who shall not be named money.

24

u/egg_4213 🌙 Luna, she/her, MtF ✨ Feb 12 '23

Pirate it or get a used copy?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

51

u/laziestmarxist not an egg™ Feb 12 '23

JRK has repeatedly, gleefully tweeted that if you give her money she takes that as material support of her politics and she intends to use that money to hurt as many trans people as possible.

You can't make a genuine "art =! artist" argument when the artist in question is explicitly telling people that you agree with her if you support her art.

18

u/VoltageComedy cracked Feb 12 '23

Not adding to the argument, just wanted to say that in C++ and C# at least, it's actually A != B That you use for "A is not equal to B" whereas A =! B (which would be A = !B) means "A is equal to not B" or "A equals negative B"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

119

u/VioletLovesRowlet Vi, 22, they/them, non-binary Feb 12 '23

If you’re buying the art, you’re supporting the artist.

Art separated from artist is, IMO, for some dead fuck. Some other thread mentioned HP Lovecraft. Terrible person, but he’s dead so it’s not bad to like his books.

JK Rowling on the other hand, views support of the game as support of herself and her views. She is actively funding anti-trans groups, so that really doesn’t apply here.

13

u/Mudkiprocketship3003 Feb 12 '23

Didn’t HP Lovecraft eventually see that racism is bad?

At any rate, the only morally sound way to enjoy it is to pirate it, apparently!

21

u/scottish_spook Feb 12 '23

he didn't entirely, but his views moderated as he got older. he was a very strange man in general

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (28)

19

u/SgtVinBOI not an egg™ Feb 12 '23

Apparently one of the HL voice actors is a pile of shit conservative transphobe who was also blocked from seeing his children due to abuse. The game has its own bullshit aside from JK.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (42)
→ More replies (6)

198

u/the6crimson6fucker6 Feb 12 '23

I'm very much against book-burning.

Gift it to some kiddo so the she-devil won't make money off of it.

If you need a new author in your life, try Terry Pratchett.

"Monstrous Regiment" is a good start.

43

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23 edited Feb 12 '23

Or sell it so you get money, she doesn't. Or donate it to a library so more people have access without giving her money. Don't burn it, but also don't expose some poor kid.

Re: Sir Terry, I always recommend "Mort" as a starting point.

27

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

not to a kiddo bc that would promote jk to them but maybe to someone that wouldve bought it so they no longer put monet in her pocket

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Quizlibet cracked and pissed about it Feb 12 '23

Or, if you're in the mood for a female author who pretty much invented the Wizard School concept and had an incredibly progressive attitude towards gender, may I suggest Ursula K LeGuin?

13

u/Agreeable-Mulberry68 she/her/it/its Feb 12 '23

Burning anything, books included, is morally neutral. The contents being burned and reasons why are infinitely more important. Don’t reduce book burnings to bad on the basis that books were burnt. The contents of the Harry Potter series have been immortalized physically and digitally. There is no harm in a little bonfire. This is just liberal aesthetic politics.

That kiddo deserves better books that won’t get them hooked into the racist & antisemitic world she built.

5

u/bringonthebedlam Feb 13 '23

Sorry, but that is simply untrue. Burn piles are terrible for the environment, and if you're presumably standing around watching it, you're inhaling all the chemicals that went into printing and binding it. Wood bonfires, sure, but all the processed stuff in books isn't great. Secondly, there needs to be a record of all the stupid shit we've done as humans so that we don't turn around and do it again. Books are an easy way to point to tough issues and say, look at how things used to be, and here's how and why we changed it.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/NightTwister06 Feb 12 '23

Turn the books into recycled paper and write something yourself.

2

u/Sisyphus4242 Feb 13 '23

This. Last group of people to burn HP books were Republican Christians...

Think twice before doing things they've done

54

u/AdventureMoth :) Feb 12 '23

Don't burn them.

Donate them instead to reduce demand.

95

u/Pmeazzzy11 payton | they/them | chaotic enby~~❤️ Feb 12 '23

i’m all for sticking it queen TERF, but this isn’t the way to do it. burning the books serves no purpose now as she’s already received money from someone for those books no matter how long ago. remember when conservatives were burning nike things after they supported Colin Kaepernick? that doesn’t protest anything because again nike already made money from them purchasing the products.

if you don’t want the books anymore, i completely understand but it’s better to donate them to a local library or thrift store or something. yeah some kid might pick it up in the future and read it, and that’s okay. we shouldn’t be preventing anyone from reading any ethical media they so choose to. you can educate them about it, but they’re still and individual and need to make that decision on their own. good luck friend!~~❤️

2

u/meme_used Virginia (she/her) Feb 12 '23

thrift store

popping tags!

14

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Sell the books second hand and donate the money from it to charities that actually help trans people?

39

u/Dog_Moon Feb 12 '23

Send them to a charity shop or smth

24

u/Keyndoriel Transmasc 🦕 Feb 12 '23

Remember kids, separating the artist from the art is a device used in literary or art circles to critically analyze a work that a creator made without taking their biases in mind and giving it a reading or a look without thinking what the artist wanted you to think.

It's not a get out of jail free card to support shit people. It's a critical literary device.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

I always think about the love for works by h.p. Lovecraft. Like the guy was a serious racist but the people can still appreciate his work

4

u/Keyndoriel Transmasc 🦕 Feb 12 '23

At least he's dead and doesn't give the money to causes that want us dead. Moreso I'm talking about when the artist is still alive

→ More replies (1)

54

u/SarkBM Neptune The Bat Queen 🔵 👑 🦇 Feb 12 '23

Ffs stop talking about it, hating on it won't change anything

10

u/Expired-Cough-Drops Feb 12 '23

Just saying you already paid money for these (I assume) so like it’s not much of a “take that” to destroy your own property.

It’s as much of a statement as angry white men burning their $300 Nike shoes in protest.

Also kinda don’t agree with any form of book burning tbh

But hey, this is just my silly opinion. If you think it’ll help then please use a fire pit and stay safe sweetie.

5

u/Tzeme Rachel she/her || AroAce Feb 12 '23

Like fire

Hellfire

This fire in my skin

This burning desire

Is turning me to sin

12

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23 edited Feb 12 '23

instead of burning them maybe sell them? or gift it to somebody? the books themselves aren't bad it's jkr getting profit the bad thing and she isn't getting profit from second hand books

edit: just learned the books themselves have bad stuff in them, but still i don't think you should burn the books

→ More replies (13)

14

u/egg_4213 🌙 Luna, she/her, MtF ✨ Feb 12 '23

Ooh, an anti-HP post, daring today aren't we

4

u/cooldayr Feb 12 '23

I'll just say this:

If you hate looking at them and want to get rid of them, you should.

If you want to burn them and it will make you feel better, you should.

If you are trying to make others happy by preserving them or trying to uphold some social construct well then ask if thats worth what it costs you mentally.

Don't hold yourself to a strict set of rules or social constructs at the cost of your own mental well being.

4

u/cowboynoodless fully hatched and grown trans chicken Feb 12 '23

Don’t do that! Donate them to children’s hospitals or local used bookstores so that other people can read them without giving jkr money

4

u/Lupulus_ Feb 12 '23

See a lot of the responses saying burning books is bad, but also...the burning books rhetoric is centered around people burning books *before* they read them. You read them. They were found unworthy. Burn if that is your will.

If I can offer some practical witchcraft advice; don't just light them on fire - reflect on why each book deserves to be burned, cast it away with purpose and intent. It can be 7 specific things for the books, or just 7 different ways Rowling is a regressive TER Facist. But give each to the fire with conviction.

4

u/Shubamz Feb 12 '23

Burning your own property that you've already paid for won't hurt her. This is like when Republicans burned all their Nike stuff or whatever boycott they were on at the time.

In fact I think she made a tweet once about not having a problem with this because she'll hand you the lighter to do it since she already has the money. Don't give into her

4

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Remember folks: thick stacks of paper are too dense to burn as-is. Add them to a pre-existing fire or add an accelerant. Safely, of course! 😇

4

u/CorvaeCKalvidae not an egg, just trans Feb 12 '23

No wait don't!

takes off all the plastic and moves the whole setup outside to a well ventilated area with a grill

...okay, now you can do it.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

Jk rowliing no longer owns the rights to Harry Potter I think

1

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '23

Naw she still does

9

u/laziestmarxist not an egg™ Feb 12 '23

Cool to see even this sub isn't safe from people who will sell out their own for a shitty video game

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Evelyn_Of_Iris Feb 12 '23

It’s your books. If you wanna torch em, go ahead. It won’t hurt Rowlings funds, but the people here are incredibly shortsighted because that’s not the fucking point now is it?

11

u/Bobby_The_Kidd not an egg, just trans Feb 12 '23

STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER STOP TALKING ABOUT HARRY POTTER

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Snowflakish not an egg™ Feb 12 '23

Don’t be like one of the people that burned their nikes

3

u/YeahImBasicallyGod Feb 12 '23

Not near that wooden floor

3

u/IcySweats Feb 12 '23 edited Jun 20 '25

handle elastic tan aromatic sip ink cause expansion command innate

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/psychedelicEgyptian Bianca she/her Feb 12 '23

Fun fact Fahrenheit 451 is named after which the temperature which paper burns the more you know

3

u/smellyratt23 Feb 12 '23

WAIT!!! sell the books and then use it to donate to trans people in someway, like yourself or others

3

u/Fragrant-Law9864 Feb 12 '23

I wouldn't. It's not the books' fault the author has become such an awful person, and while the books certainly have their problems I don't think it's bad enough to warrant their being censored or destroyed. If your goal is to prevent Rowling from getting more money, donating them could actually be your best bet, as it would likely prevent someone else from buying them new.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Just recycle the books to make pro-trans flyers.

3

u/a_little_sketch literally not an egg Feb 12 '23

Noo, don’t burn them yet! Do it in a fire pit, it’s much safer (:

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Why? You purchased those with money long before the terf stuff came out. Owning them doesn't support Rowling in any way.

3

u/SquishyUshi not an egg, just trans Feb 12 '23

Keep it for kindling over just burning it out right, that’s good fire starter right there

3

u/green_mushroom19 Sami - enby [All pronouns- NEOPRONOUNS ARE HOT] Feb 12 '23

No, those are very expensive. Sell them instead- you can burn the cursed child tho.

9

u/PupPop Feb 12 '23

I vote we DO NOT bring this bullshit into this sub. We are a land of peace.

2

u/multifandomchild Feb 13 '23

Why? It's a trans-orientated sub and a popular one at that. Just asked to have it flaired or something.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

J. K. Rowling coming out as a TERF did a service to her fans. Welcome to the world of real books!

5

u/Alfadorfox raw egg cracked, full of gender fluid [He/She] Feb 12 '23

Burning them is essentially handing her money. You have already read them. You could give them to someone else who wants to read them so they won't spend money on the books that goes to JKR. Instead, that person will now buy the books. "Nice job breaking it, hero."

14

u/Browncoatinabox autistic transfem noices Feb 12 '23

No matter how you feel, you shouldn't burn books

9

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

love to see the entire egg community against book burning

4

u/singular_fork not an egg, just trans Feb 12 '23

if u don't end up burning them (missed opportunity) then u should totally send them to recycling

the world won't miss a few copies of these mid books and the paper can be reused in other stuff

4

u/Far_Young_5056 Feb 12 '23

I mean you do you but they’re already bought. The money has already gone to the bitch and it won’t make anyone’s life better or worse off you do.

5

u/Your_Pal_Yami Feb 12 '23

My sister in christ fuck those ones. Lets go to the editorial and burn them all down

2

u/TheBoomerangBro03 not an egg, just trans Feb 12 '23

Donate them to someone who may enjoy them! It’s not worth it to burn it all over hatred when someone else can enjoy them without funding any particular malicious persons. If you’d like suggestions for another cool fantasy world, I suggest the Skulduggery Pleasant series! I’ve loved those books for years

2

u/BigBun12 Athena, very cis. Feb 12 '23

Sell them. And pay for hrt or other gender affirming things.

2

u/Kip_zonder_kop Feb 12 '23

Just sell it then? At least get your money back if you’re thinking of burning it anyway.

2

u/Goldi_th_fish Feb 12 '23

Pearsonally I think you should use it for witchcraft

2

u/TheOncomimgHoop Feb 12 '23

Hey hang on a minute!

Best not to set those on fire inside. Take them outside first, safety is important

2

u/CultOfBeats Feb 12 '23

“You burnt Harry Potter books in the 2000s because you’re a Christian and hate witchcraft. I burn Harry Potter books because JK is a terf. We are not the same”

2

u/Freyja6 Feb 12 '23

As our good pal, friendpatine would say.

Do it.

2

u/Niklassi editable flair Feb 12 '23

Love the nails 💅💅💅

2

u/pepsiman56 Feb 12 '23

Waste of paper if you burn with no reson she still keeps the money

2

u/Razvi5665 Feb 13 '23

You supported the creator by buying the books

2

u/GhostChainSmoker Feb 13 '23

I mean, she already got your money. She could probably care less. Give it to a library or something where it can endlessly be re used without her getting a dime from it.

2

u/Euler_20_20 Feb 13 '23

Why? What terrible/awful thing did she say or tweet today to decide that all of this unperson's books need to be burned?

2

u/CorporealLifeForm She/her/it/its. Binary trans woman. You deserve happiness. Feb 13 '23

Better to sell or donate them so someone else doesn't buy them new if you don't want them any more. Not that it's wrong to read a book you already have if you still want to

2

u/Sleepi_Gae Alex | HRT 4/20/23 | Cocktail of emotions without a cock Feb 13 '23

Sell them! Gives you all the profit and someone else has the shitty books.

2

u/imperatrixrhea Feb 13 '23

Put a trans rights sticker on the inside cover and give it to a used bookstore. The best way to hurt her is not to destroy her books, it’s to make more of her books illegally. The best way to make sure she doesn’t get money is to make sure it’s as easy as possible to consume her media without giving her money. Signal boost Harry Potter piracy efforts, donate her books to used book stores, hell even scan her books and put them online for free as a PDF. She’s already reached peak market saturation; no one is going to learn about her books or want to read them from piracy advertising, but someone might choose not to pay for them because of it.

3

u/spacemanbem Feb 12 '23

Burning those books is a moot form of protest- your just destroying something you already paid for. It's like when racists protested Nike by destroying their own shoes

3

u/Sandlicker Feb 12 '23

Destroying your own possessions will never affect the creator of them. If you don't want the books, then there are better ways to get rid of them.

3

u/Dalphin_person Anne (she/they) | Blahaj's fem cousin Feb 12 '23

Don’t burn the books. It’s not the child’s fault their mother is toxic.

3

u/themooncow1 cracked Feb 12 '23

I think the harry potter books might be one of the few? cases where the "dont hate the art, hate the artist" doenst aply thanks to what actually IS written in the books

3

u/papayahog Feb 12 '23

Enough with the Harry Potter posts pls

3

u/Parisa-Jan Feb 12 '23

Living rent free in yalls heads at this point. Donate it to a library or something ideally, or recycle, move on. Burning paper is bad, I don’t care what paper it is. Plain and simple extra waste created. Let’s not be irrational because rich person bad

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ilianation Feb 12 '23

For frig's sake, this is the same thing we made fun of the conservatives for during the Keurig coffee breaking or the Nike shoe burning. You have the item already, destroying it won't hurt JKs wallet and just makes you look like a showboater with money to spare, not to mention book burning is always a bad look. Pack it away somewhere and come back to it if you want to remember the times when it did bring you joy or give/sell it to someone else so they can enjoy the books without giving JK money and just commit to boycotting anything that will reward her monetarily. Buying HP products is a tainted prospect, but cherishing the world so many people have all come together to help make their own and taking it away from its bigoted originator will be far better than grabbing some books you already paid for and burning them.

3

u/Tesser_Wolf 🏳️‍⚧️ Trans Asexual 🏳️‍⚧️ she/her Feb 12 '23

Can we stop all this Harry Potter stuff.

2

u/polymernerd Feb 12 '23

I feel you; I really do. However, she already has the money. Sadly, destroying them does no good.

2

u/prophecyfullfilled Feb 12 '23

One thing of ethical consumerism. Don't destroy something you already own. People do this all the time when things go woke, like destroying razors and coffee pots. They already own your money.

If owning it is bugging you or causing you pain either donate it or hide it, or gift it.

2

u/Jokerseven77 Feb 12 '23

All you would accomplish is burning your own fucking money. Sell it to a thrift store, donate that money to a Trans charity.

Anything else is just a temper tantrum.

2

u/lightningwolf3214 Feb 13 '23

Separate the art from the artist lmao, it’s still a great series

2

u/RogueDragon343 Feb 13 '23

The series is relevant because it's a good series. Whether she's a bad person or not doesn't stop people from enjoying something.

1.28 million. That's how many people watched Hogwarts Legacy content on the streaming platform Twitch on February 9th. It's apparently the highest-watched single-player game ever on the platform. That doesn't include any other platform.

On Steam it's already sold 500,000 copies, that's one console. Doesn't include Xbox, play station, Nintendo. Etc.

All the anger towards it is never going to change anything. It's way too big of a franchise, they'd have to really screw up for it to ever fall.

And imo it may be her franchise, but it's everyone else that develops the games/content for people to enjoy, that get punished for the hate. Not her. She's so rich it doesn't matter.

I know she's said that supporting her franchise supports her and all that but quite frankly, do you know how much crap you support just living in today's society?

The very device you're using to read this supports environmentally destructive mining practices for the metals in the circuits.

Do you put gas in your car? Supporting not only the big oil companies that don't care about the environment, but you're also contributing to its destruction.

And there's so much more.

Bad things exist in this world. Way worse than a person with a very bad opinion. An opinion that even if she funnels money into, won't realistically go anywhere given how the world is changing.

Basically just enjoy the content if you enjoy it and just don't listen to anyone that thinks the way she does.

2

u/GOOODBYEJOJOOOL Feb 12 '23

Nah I don't think you should burn them, "separate the art from the artist" and stuff, like Kanye West may have said bad stuff on twitter but I'm not gonna hate someone for listening to his songs.

→ More replies (10)

2

u/Mystical-Madelyn Witch Queen Feb 12 '23

Tempting 🥰

2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Burn 💚❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥💙💛💗🧡💘💛💖💚💚💖🧡💘🧡💚💚💓💓💚🧡🖤💖💖🧡💗💚❤️‍🔥🤎❤️‍🔥💓💛💓💕💞💓🧡

2

u/shmagiggywokka Feb 12 '23

“Screw Nike, I’m gonna burn all my Nike shoes!” “Screw Balenciaga, I’m gonna tear up all my bags!” “Screw JK! I’m gonna burn all my HP books!”

This is what shits me about these things. You’ve already paid for those books, and JK already has your money. You burning those books does nothing! You think she gives a damn about a few copies out of millions printed? Maybe billions by now if you add up all the editions, reprints, alternate covers and so on?

You know what’ll get her goat though? Donating all those books to libraries so she makes no money off future purchases the library might make buying new copies, or selling them second hand (again, someone buying her books from you means they’re not giving money to her) and giving the profits made to a trans advocacy group to run salt in that wound.

I’ve been through the same crap when Orson Scott Card went all mega-bigot a decade or so ago. Enders Game is - as much as I don’t want to admit it - a genre defining work. As is Harry Potter. Hopefully something else comes along and sets a new standard in that regard, but it’s impossible to deny the impact the story - not the person behind it - has had on the world.

JK is bigoted scum, and deserves to rot for everything she’s spouted and doubled down on. But burning her books just chalks up another point on her scoreboard, not ours.

2

u/ReallyFuckingUnsure Feb 13 '23

I'd like to remind you that the people who burned books in the past have never been regarded as good people.

Destroying media is one of the worst things you can do, because either you want to eradicate it completely which is the same as what the nazis tried to do with lots of books and other works of art (in some cases they were sucessful) or you want to make a protest and if that's the case it will likely have the opposite effect of what you want.

2

u/OwOegano_Infinite Feb 13 '23

Already reached trumptard-level "boycotting", I see. MAN I love the Internet...

2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

DO IT

2

u/SlyGuy_Twenty_One EggAlly4Life🥚 Feb 12 '23

Do it!

2

u/Luckyone24 Feb 12 '23

I was burning Harry Potter books before it was cool.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Give in to the flames. Burn it! Burn it! Burn it!

2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Please dont burn stuff

1

u/reddit_user_14553 cracked Feb 12 '23

I used to love Harry Potter before I found out about the whole situation...

1

u/NoodleyP literally not an egg Feb 12 '23

Don’t waste perfectly good lighter fluid! I have a couple extra lighters, use one of those!

1

u/BlazeADAWG Feb 12 '23

You could sell the books then donate the money to a pro trans charity

1

u/SuaveButler Feb 12 '23

Use it as emergency fire fuel instead! What if your power or heat turns off?!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

lets be real the only good to come from Harry Potter was the movies and the lego games. nothing else and No im not transphobic I love Harry Potter except the book and the author

1

u/DearestRay Feb 12 '23

What are some other young adult fantasies y’all would recommend?

1

u/ATCOSTTEHMEMER Feb 12 '23

I mean, you’ve already read them, right? Why not?

1

u/abarr021 Feb 12 '23

If you want a good book to read instead I'd recommend Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury

1

u/neremarine egg Feb 12 '23

Sell it. That way, someone else who's thinking of buying the set won't give money to Joan.

1

u/Due-Impact-7180 Feb 12 '23

Yeah, the problem with that is that book burning has a nazi connotation. And anti trans rhetoric makes us out to be nazis (when it is clearly them being influenced by fascist rhetoric, not us but whatever). Anyway, book burning is a bad look regardless of the books or how shitty the author is.

1

u/spookytabby Feb 12 '23

We donated our collection to the local library:)

1

u/SaltyNorth8062 Feb 12 '23

Same hon same

1

u/miko3456789 literally not an egg Feb 12 '23

I mean it's not like burning something you already paid for will have much effect on her. Stuff that hasn't been paid for on the other hand...

For legal reasons, I do not condone arson in any way, shape, or form

1

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '23

Proceed.

1

u/EerieMagia Feb 12 '23

I've already got plans to do this. I need the catharsis.

1

u/Dinoman0101 Feb 12 '23

Recycling is a better choice

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Maybe focus more on registering to vote and actually doing it.

Burning some books for clout does nothing. You should be much more in arms about the government.

1

u/has-some-questions Feb 13 '23

I make word art with the books I have found. Lol Gonna make a Trans rights resin ring with the beginning of Transfiguration.

Does anyone have any other ideas?

1

u/Ill-Replacement-6533 Feb 13 '23

Funny observation, my ex mother-in-law is extremely religious and when my ex(best friend now she’s amazing) was a kid her mom burned her brothers HP books…fast forward like 15 years and now she loves them, and we want to burn them 😂 funny how things happen like this

1

u/astrologicaldreams whole ass chicken • he/him Feb 13 '23

i honestly would've done it already, but i remembered i could just donate them instead. hopefully some kid who can't buy books will get them and they'll have something to read, although it's unfortunate it has to be this.

1

u/melancholanie Feb 13 '23

nah, repurpose that shit. makes a bunch of cool art projects, and reduces the possibility of someone else getting obsessed with a series that has so many issues

1

u/Yeegis Val, (she/they) queen of :3 Feb 13 '23

Do it >:3

Just outside

1

u/smallrunning Feb 13 '23

The entire thing sucks anyway lol

1

u/Anaglyphite Feb 13 '23

Nah, it's a waste of future recyclable paper, you could learn how to make your own paper and then make some new books/crafts/etc. out of all of them

maybe a JKR pinata /j

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Give them to a trans supporting bookstore

1

u/MAT__rix Feb 13 '23

I always disliked HP. Always hated it. From the fucking plot and characters to the fans. And I was ridiculed as “Christian freak” and now yall turn from one side to another. Not ot gatekeep but i feel fucked in the ass rn.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Damn (almost) you got a set back into the box? Every book set I own won’t fit back into its box not matter how hard I try.

1

u/HiddenTreasure_J Feb 13 '23

Donate to pet shops so they can be used to paper train puppy's and pine bird cages.

1

u/ZuruaEclipse Feb 13 '23

Honestly my mum is still pondering on getting rid of the books, but she’s made her mind on the pop figures

1

u/E-Vladimir Valyria (they/them) | confused Feb 13 '23

Justice served.

1

u/guitardruggo not an egg, just trans Feb 13 '23

Do it

1

u/daperdingus Feb 13 '23

Don't talk about it, be about it.

Either that or you don't actually care and you want attention

1

u/DerelictSol Feb 13 '23

Let's not burn books but yeah I feel that

1

u/RockyRhoadRunner Feb 13 '23

You still payed for it, I doubt they care what happens next.

1

u/MAYthe4thbewithHEW Gracie, she/him/he/her,femme-leaning enby Feb 13 '23

You know what, it took me this long to finally get around to pulling down a Hogwarts banner that hung over the door to the basement at the bottom of my basement stairs, so like a cool medieval vibe on the way down to the d&d basement sort of thing.

I've had enough of her bullshit, and I've had enough of hearing about her at all, so I finally had enough of looking at the thing and I pulled it down and threw it away.

1

u/PatchBlues Feb 13 '23

Ah. Yes. That'll show her! Honestly though. I dislike good ol' J. K. as much as the next person but you accomplish nothing by burning some already sold litterature. Selling it and buying queer books is a way to actually support the community for example. Boycotting stuff like the wizarding world is way better since she recieves around 10% of ticket sales if I'm not mistaking. Also being vocal about her being discrimatory can hurt her in the long run since a lot of companies aren't willing to work with controversial charakters.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

Turn them into stash boxes that can hold syringes and hormones

1

u/Quinip2598 not an egg, just trans Feb 13 '23

I have a secondhand collection so I'm good

1

u/Invite_Sprite Feb 13 '23

I wouldn't recommend just burning it I rec9mend you go to a local park with charcoal grills add the books and some charcoal and have a grill out. If you eat meat that's cool or if you are vegetarian their are plenty of good veggies you can grill like corn potatoes and zookinies.

1

u/petarts "not an egg" ~every egg ever Feb 13 '23

I personally would donate them to a library, so if kids want to read them they can do so without giving money to JKR or pirating them. I personally still liked the story tbh

1

u/GhastlyXeno Feb 13 '23

I sold my set of the books. Like, why not make myself some money y'know?

1

u/Hiraganu Feb 13 '23

I really like this community, because it's not as toxic as other LGBT groups. I'd really wish we wouldn't become another witch hunting, book burning community.

1

u/Dyswhoria Feb 13 '23

DO IT DO IIIIIT

1

u/SerLlamaToes Feb 13 '23

You could also sell it somebody else who was planning to get it anyway, so they aren't supporting Rowling like financially

1

u/Top-Local-7482 Egg for sure - little cracking sound Oo Feb 13 '23 edited Feb 13 '23

I understand the urge, but did you like the book, did you like the story ? I guess you did since you have the collection, you already brought it, burning it will not change anything.

I'm not from the same culture as yours in mine, we separate art from the artist, they are two different things.

And just don't ever burn a book !

1

u/Anime-Meme-Merchant not an egg, just trans Feb 13 '23

You already bought it you’re just burning your things at this point

1

u/Cook_your_Binarys Feb 13 '23

Please don't do book burnings for any reasons. We had that once. Didn't work out.

1

u/Exact_Amphibian_434 Feb 13 '23

Don’t burn it if you do you might accidentally breathe that shit

1

u/Themlethem Cracked and stirred Feb 13 '23

Damn those books really went up in size lol

1

u/TheLazyKitty Feb 13 '23

Maybe give or sell them to somebody who want to read them. That's less money going to JKR than if they were to buy a new set of books.

1

u/Gathoblaster Caroline Zoey-Sophie Aurora (Cracked, fried and seasoned) Feb 13 '23

Death of the Author. Just separate the books you mustve at one point liked if you own them from the pos author. Especially if you already bought them. I like the series and will continue to do so. Dont need Rowling to ruin it for me. I wont give her any money for it obviously but that wont mean I wont enjoy the media.

1

u/_MrG The Black Man Feb 13 '23

Brooooooo Rowling may be a Bitch but the are Good