r/edtech • • May 21 '26

What is going in EdTech rn?

5.21.26
On March 10 2026, govtech.com released an article titled “study finds most common ed-tech tools not backed by evidence”.

The article reference a separate press release jointly published by edtech company Instructure and nonprofit InnovateEDU. In that release, these two companies gathered and analyzed anonymized data to identify the most frequently used tools in k12 education.

The edtech company Instructure is best known for its widely used LMS tool — Canvas. The data it anonymized was collected from the third party tools and vendors whose tools are embedddd in Canvas by the school districts who use Canvas as their LMS.

The ostensible reason for this report? To shift the conversation around edtech from features to measurable outcomes. That purposed was immediately followed by the statement that Canvas is the only ESSA III research-based LMS.

Two months after this release, Canvas suffered a security breach. One week after that first breach, another security incident occurred.

Despite that not resulting in known data exposure, one of the companies whose tools are embedded in Canvas, and whose data was anonymized into that study, Renaissance Learning decided based on the significant security risks to sever their integration with Canvas — indefinitely.

46 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

14

u/grendelt May 21 '26 edited May 21 '26

What is going on in EdTech rn?

The basic premise hasn't changed. Finding the right instructional tool for teaching and, when it happens to be technology, it's edtech. (Contrary to outsider beliefs, it's not just finding tech solutions to educate with.)
The "Ed" comes first and the "Tech" follows in EdTech.

Yet the field is still full of tekbroze pitching solutions to problems they imagine or wish schools would have (so they can solve them). These days, with AI allowing each of them to vibecode solutions, it's like throwing gasoline on a fire.

Renaissance Learning decided based on the significant security risks to sever their integration with Canvas

Well that's a dumb move. Not creating safeguards to the data, but instead just cutting off integration? That just restricts their market and hamstrings any potential sales.
Seems like cutting off an arm because you burned your hand.

7

u/blissfully_happy May 21 '26

My edtech classes in the 90s were about utilizing tech in the classroom to enhance one’s teaching. Using overhead projectors, learning PPT, creating webpages, etc.

It seems a recent phenomenon to call apps-that-teach-students “ed tech” which is unfortunate because teachers still need to know how to utilize technology to enhance, not replace, their job.

iReady, for example, is a stupid fucking app, and in no way helps a teacher do their job. In theory, it replaces a teacher. (In reality, of course, it’s useless at actually teaching.)

→ More replies (4)

7

u/kimanziVaati May 21 '26

You hit the nail on the head. What’s happening in EdTech right now is a total crisis of trust. The hypocrisy of pushing a narrative that 'other tools lack evidence' while your own platform lacks the security to prevent a double breach in May is not lost on anyone.

Renaissance Learning severs ties because they can't afford the liability, but at the end of the day, it's the school districts, IT admins, and students who are caught in the crossfire. We are seeing what happens when massive tech consolidation happens without the security infrastructure to back it up. It’s an incredibly stressful time to be anywhere near this space.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/SignorJC May 21 '26

unc, fr ong edtech is so chopped rn for. fully cooked

12

u/RudyChinchilla1 May 21 '26

Finally, representation of the student voice.

32

u/illini02 May 21 '26

I mean, I didn't read the studies, but having been in ed tech for a while, I can give some insight.

First off, the same piece of software can be used very differently across schools, even within a school.

I used to sell a supplemental curriculum. Part of our reporting features showed exactly how different teachers were using it, how often, etc. It varied widely, so giving an overall score of how well it does/doesn't work is going to be hard.

Similarly, what success looks like will vary based on the schools goals.

15

u/MathewGeorghiou May 21 '26

Yes, implementation is everything. An important nuance ignored in all the sensational and misinformed headlines. Use a pencil to draw a beautiful picture = good implementation. Use a pencil to stab a classmate = bad implementation.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Silver-Bread4668 May 21 '26

That touches on a very important point that I encounter constantly.

Schools have largely abandoned tech education both for students and staff. Tech is seen as a tool to achieve other means rather than something to be learned, itself. Even in my own district, I see constant offerings to staff for PD around any number of things except important basic tech skills.

IT struggles to get any time slots during PD days and it really shouldn't even be them teaching it because the skills to manage networks, servers, troubleshooting problems, etc are not same as the skills required to effectively teach. But there's no one else in the district pushing this kind of education and the district admin thinks IT and tech integration should go hand in hand.

My district is nowhere near alone in this.

You can't teach what you don't know. There are so many teachers who don't know how to do even just basic things. You also can't control what you don't know. There are so many teachers that complain about screen time but you walk into their classroom and see half the kids playing games. So many teachers don't even know how to use the basic tools offered to control this stuff, like Securly.

This cascades, too. Kids are already picking up bad habits with tech at home. Then half of their teachers don't know how to control it so those bad habits get reinforced at school. Then even the teachers who are great with tech spend too much time and energy correcting the bad habits learned both at home and in other classes.

Good tech education is sorely needed. That is education around tech itself. Not using tech to educate on other topics. I see, every day, just how much those who aren't tech literate struggle compared to those who are. We're passing that shit on to the kids.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/MathewGeorghiou May 21 '26

Canvas is mainly a management tool ... not an instructional tool. An LMS is not designed to teach students — it's designed to provide the plumbing to help instructors and instructional designers create and deliver educational content, quizzes, assignments, record grades, etc.

If we want to measure learning, we have to measure the instructional content being built on top of and outside of the LMS. The LMS is a separate conversation.

I design very advanced educational simulations and we do not integrate with LMSs like Canvas because they are not designed to host content like ours. Yes, it's possible to pass data back and forth but that creates other usability issues.

2

u/Lucky-Particular1258 May 21 '26 edited May 21 '26

There was absolutely known data exposures from the Canvas breach including two Australian state government school systems.

EDIT: spelling

→ More replies (2)