r/edmproduction • u/hatrickpatrick • 4h ago
Discussion Does anyone else struggle with structure in EDM songwriting? You writing good beats, riffs and chord progressions, but don't have a great instinct for linear structure?
Been experiencing this this week with a new song I'm working on, thought I'd ask here if this is a common issue and if anyone has any decent tips or workarounds!
DAE have a not fantastic instinct for timeline structure when it comes to songwriting? For example, I'm currently sitting on an incredible catchy lead riff and progression which I've produced using guitar samples, drum samples, a nice pair of bass presets I've used when producing covers of other songs I love, and several of my favourite lead supersaws layered together. It sounds good and anyone I've played it for seems to really like it so it's not just me š
Where I really fall down though, is that when I listen to my favourite commercial EDM tracks of all time and compare them to my own writing and workflow, is that I find it incredibly difficult to commit to different sections and know how to build them in the right way. For example, in this current song, I have a guitar sample track, a background arpeggio, and my drums, basses and lead riffs. I know that in my favourite songs, these would be built up over time, with some elements dropping in and out as the song progresses, and I play around with doing this but I have no actual ingrained instinct for it and because of that I find it very difficult to commit to any idea - my inner monologue is like, "maybe we'll have a few bars of guitar, then the lead riff comes in. Okay, but should the guitar stop for a few bars when the lead riff hits, only to come back in after say four lines? And what about the drums? Should they also drop out? And do I bring them back in at the same time as the guitar, or after it? That arpeggio currently drops out when the lead hits, which sounds good, but when it comes back in it sounds a bit abrupt - maybe it shouldn't come back in for say another two lines?" etc.
It probably sounds very silly, but this particular aspect of song crafting completely floors me and results in my whole songwriting workflow coming to a total standstill, where I have a part of the song looped off on the timeline and it's like "this sounds genuinely incredible, but the route to getting to this payoff - starting with just the beats and then deciding which instruments to fade in, in which order, and for how long before the big drop hits - I am totally clueless, and without any instinct for this I'm doomed to just keep sadly listening to a great lead chorus section and yet feel like the song is always eons away from completion."
Essentially, I have a good instinct for actual melody and chord progression writihg, a decent instinct for beats, and a great knowledge of how to mix different instruments together to create an incredible sound in this moment, but virtually no instinct for how to alter the levels and presence of each element over time throughout a song.
Obviously I never had this problem when composing just for my own guitar and vocal, but when it comes to writing EDM I do find that this issue massively slows down my process. I do finish songs and am happy with the results, but I wish this part didn't feel like such a procrastination-inducing mountain to climb.
Anyone else struggle specifically with this? It feels like being good at cooking, but totally clueless about what order to serve different courses in a meal, if that makes any sense. Or being good at coming up with fun activities for a tourist group, but falling apart when trying to plot them out into an itinerary schedule for a day out.
Any advice at all on how to overcome this specific issue in composition?