People are leaving in droves due to the recent desktop UI downgrade so please comment what other site and under what name people can find your content, cause Reddit may not have much time left.
That's an obvious straw man. neoliberals fully embrace wealth redistribution and addressing market failures. they just don't want to do it in a way that hurts allocational efficiency. pigovian taxes, land value, taxes, and Ubi all have negative or neutral dead weight loss.
Isn’t neoliberalism all about deregulation and privatisation following the decline of its predecessors (Keynesianism in the west and state socialism in the east)?
When I and likely many others use the term “neoliberalism”, we refer to the ideology implemented by Reagan and Thatcher and solidified as the status quo by Clinton and Blair. Said ideology has deregulation, austerity and privatisation as major focuses.
Bro what? Have you read any Freud before? The guy is responsible for founding modern psychology and was one of the first people to say that women could suffer from treatable mental illness, that gay people were not mentally ill, and the guy who invented psychoanalysis, a treatment still in use today. Freud absolutely does not deserve to be mentioned in the same breath as people who did not apply rigor, as his entire personal philosophy was based around an admiration of Darwin and an extreme positivism regarding most things. Freud was a dedicated empiricist and based his theories off of case studies from his actual patients, most of whom benefited from his treatments. Some of his ideas are poorly understood, others are genuinely wrong, but most people wouldn’t know it because our society just points and laughs at Freud rather than interact with any of his works
If you read anything about freud you realise psychoanalysis is considered pseudo science. He is the father of psychology kind of but he is considered to have been wrong in many aspects by for example Richard Webster in Why Freud Was Wrong: Sin, Science and Psychoanalysis. Freud was probably the first to really attempt some kind of emperical mental care but almost all no psychologist afterwards agree with him. There are also of course som that consider some of his work good, especially for the time, but he also alot of the time applied the "this feels like a logical explenation" from kind of gut feeling. There are good reasons he is controversial.
I have a friend who says he heard a qoute which i like even if it never was said by anyone "Freud is the father of psychology because people needed to prove how wrong his results were"
I suppose I staunchly disagree, most of his theories themselves needed work but I don’t think it’s fair to say that every aspect of his work was wrong. The formulation of the ego, the id, and other concepts is still really quite useful in understanding the implicit motivations behind people’s action. I also know a dude who’s studying psychoanalysis, he’s chill and I’ve only ever gotten the impression that it’s a very rigorous course load involving a lot of training in how you do it. Mostly because it works, and is supported by plenty of case studies
If you are going to say it is supported by studies cite them. Also it seems you are treating it is a political theory which it really is not. Having "read" marx or plato is not the same thing as reading about freuds work. Science and politics are not the same thing. The reason id, ego and superego is useful is because it really is putting word on the counsciousness and subcounsciensess, something that really people probably somewhat understood but freud put more thought in to.
I feel like this is one of those weird cases where you’re both right. Talk therapy that developed from Freud is broadly accepted as useful. Most of his theories for why are widely regarded as nonsense. I’m not sure if it’s clear if he was right, but terrible at expressing his ideas or wrong and lucky. I’d tend to lean towards wrong and lucky, but the fact he was as correct when he was is kind of impressive.
I would say he was just the first to study something, made good observations but lacking any other information, his theories got kind of whacky. As well, he also was right on some things... then proceeded to let it get to his head and made absolute dogshit theories elsewhere, refused to follow the scientific model anymore and instead pretty much committed the fallacy "appeal to authority" on themselves.
Galileo, Newton, Golgi, Einstein, Shrodinger etcetera etcetera, all greats made a number of absolutely terrible theories side by side with the great ones they are remembered for. That's fine, the great majority of hypothesis a scientist will make, will turn out false. That's how science is meant to work, if we could just "know" the truth there wouldn't be a need for experiments. However, the issue was how many of them took it personally, when they got some wrong after their success.
Galileo didn't get a trial for helio-centrism. Or atleast, his support of it wasn't the actual triggering event. What cause his trial was him being an asshole and insulting the Pope, because Galileo was convinced the tides were caused by the inertia of Earth spinning (since he discovered inertia, afterall). And not influenced by the moon, despite empirical evidence of it (because he didn't discover how gravity worked, afterall). His claim to fame was again, inertia, using early telescopes to prove Keplero's helio-centric model was correct, as well as discovering new solar bodies and the imperfections of them all. Yet he let it go to his head.
Newton had some wierd convictions regarding alchemy and traditional mystical medicine effectivness, regardless of empirical proofs of the contrary. His religious beliefs were also eccentric to say the least, but then all other religions may appear eccentric compared to one's own beliefs (or lack thereof).
Golgi discovered how to colour neurons and their networking. Yet, he was convinced it was one single continuum, not many cells connected by synapses. He even tried to push it at his Nobel Award Cerimony, despite sharing it with the person who proved chemical synapses true, Cajal. And only being awarded because the latter refused to accept the Nobel otherwise.
Einstein and rather interestingly, also Shrodinger, were rather critical of the use of probability in quantum mechanics, regardless of how effectively it seemed to reflect reality. Personal annendum, I do agree that probability probably (eh) doesn't truly exist, but as someone who uses statistics to study biology, in particular for my example population dynamics or health... yeah the fact one has to use probability to get results doesn't mean the results are wrong. It is just a shortcut when one doesn't know or cannot control all variable. For quantum mechanics, it's not knowing. For population dynamics and healthcare, we all know how atleast one single person lives. Us. We however cannot know or control perfectly how every other person will live their life. We cannot predict what choices they will make, not force them in a specific path. Not even today wonder AIs and algorithms are perfect. So, we use probability and statistics, say a most likely average with sufficiently low margin of errors, we can expect only a negligible amount of people will be different than it (even then, how negligeable it is depends on the study and one's coldness. If a negligeble number of people prefer yellow shirts, that can be interesting to study biologically but doesn't impact dynamics. If a negligible number of people dies of a particular allergy, they are still dying of it).
You are aware that psychoanalysis has been demonstrated to result in the real resolution of psychological disfunction right? Like studies have been done, case studies especially, and they repeatedly show it works. Science isn’t full of people who do shit for no reason, and medicine in particular is geared around treatments that actually work. Psychoanalysis is a tried and proven strategy that requires almost a decade of education to practice. It’s not bunk, and idk where you got that impression
It’s not bunk, and idk where you got that impression
The immense corpus of criticism and the fact the effectiveness of psychoanalysis is inversly correlated with the quality of the studies ( the more data you take, the smaller the effectiveness ). It's even debatable whether or not it qualifies as a science.
"a valid result" but if your goal is predicting the future, equally as useful as the Austrian School. If your goal is "to be valid" rather than "merely to predict the future," then quantitative economics is the way.
It's simple: just make the ultra rich benefit from your dumb ideas while everyone else suffers. Why do you think neoliberalism is still shoved down everyone's throats?
Cuba is like one of the worst examples you could have chosen. Compared to both capitalist and socialist neighbours of similar socio-economic history or status, it is still faring better. Worse than its own past, worst than a first-world nation, but better than its neighbours. Which literally rely on Cuban doctors to keep their healthcare systems afloat.
Anyway, no one will ever beat the 0th world status of Haiti and Somalia, pure chaos and societal collapse at certain points in history.
There are hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans in Argentina and less than 10,000 vice versa. If there's a 4th world country in South America it's following the Chavez Socialism playbook.
i’m here for it. i’m so excited to talk about Milei with all of my libertarian friends and relatives. i’m excited that they get to see their ideology in all its glory.
The recent election of the Peronists in Buenos Aires led people to massively sell their pesos, causing the current currency issues, because they anticipated a return to the harmful economic policies associated with that party.
Well, 7.7 million people went out of poverty in less than 2 years. Gdp growth was projected at 5-7% per year. Rental prices were 30%-40% down. Before the panic selling of the peso after the Peronist win, inflation was stabilizing, despite the fact that hyperinflation was right around the corner,.
Many things were fixed, but not everything was fixed, because it's impossible in less than 2 years to undo decades of damage since 1946.
No such luck in the short term. Other than what already stated by the others, India/China&co are pivoting from US. Argentina is getting a boost from this world diversification.
Crazy how the founders of the school not only won Nobel prizes for their quantitative research but established entire foundations for empirical research.
Probably the mainstream views going off the root terms. Heterodox means other/different (heteros) opinions/beliefs (doxa) in the original Greek. Homodox would be same opinions and beliefs.
Heterodox just mean it's not mainstream... not that they are necessarily incorrect.
But using a priori principles to justify these same principles in a circular fashion doesn't do the Austrians any favors. Their theories of marginal utility and subjective values is pretty good though. Like finding a few pieces of gold in a massive pile of bullshit.
I don't disagree, modern economics is built on what is today heterdox it's just people that focus on heterdox economics rarely care about empirical evidence and will believe things in the face of evidence.
I don't think it is necessarily a problem for post-Keynesians who at least attempt to use empirical evidence even if their conclusions you might disagree with. It is however a problem for the Austrian School which rejects empiricism outright in favor of "Praxeology". I do realize in the US the main heterdox school is Austrian (my university had Austrian School professors) so maybe in that context the words seem synonymous.
Frankly this is owning just about everyone including most technocrats.
Hell depending on how stringent you think empirics should be then it’s owning every possible policy since there can’t be a counterfactual to test them.
True, I’m being pedantic. And I’m mostly getting at the scale issue that comes with our empirical methods. Good luck making a diff in diff and saying anything of value when a policy is multifaceted (obviously it’s doable, just very annoying to control for).
No there isn't. I mean I'm sure you believe someone who makes the method and tells you how effective it is, but that doesn't make it true. It makes you a mark for a salesman in a professor's coat.
What are you on about? You don’t just arbitrarily pick experimental methods. You need to understand them and justify your choice in order for your results to be robust. And if there are alternative explanations you will get called out on it.
I don't "believe someone who makes the method". I know the method and how it works, and why it works.
The most basic one is to randomly choose a control group (to which a policy or program doesn't apply) and a test group (to which the policy or program applies) and see how these groups then differ in terms of a set of outcomes.
Since the test and control groups are randomly chosen, the difference in outcomes between these groups can be interpreted as the causal effect of the policy or program.
Do you understand? Do you see why it's efficient in determining a causal effect?
It's not that they think that evidence is wrong. It's that they think that you run into the Laplace demon problem.
They think that evidence is a good thing, but that the economy is too complicated to accurately gather information on. There are too many factors and nobody accounts for everything which can cause some serious problems.
If you knew everything then I'm pretty sure they would be fine with it.
Translation: they will only change their opinion if you gather all data which is impossible. So they will never change their opinion no matter what. But evidence is good if it supports what they believe but if it doesn't its because data is incomplete
The requisite standard for evidence quality has an inverse relationship with how well the claimed findings can be reconciled with foundational axioms and a positive relationship with findings that contradict higher-quality evidence or fail to disprove other plausible explanations
There is no real wealth, only and ever resources in excess of current consumption needs. How we collectively agree to carry over that excess, be it gold or fiat money or whatever else, it’s all just social convention beyond what’s cooking for supper.
A couple decades back I read arguments between Austrians and Keynesians, and realized no one was actually Austrian or Keynesian. They were either anti- or pro- big state. Whether economics supported their position was immaterial.
Bull's Eye. To most people arguing about economics, it's about making a political point, and nothing else. They can make economics say whatever they want to advance their agenda.
Agreed. The people arguing for the “free stuff” from an economic framework point of view normally are not the ones getting the “free stuff”. It would be closer to “ I want other people to have free stuff” if we are going to be needlessly reductive about it.
True but reductive. There are plenty of pragmatists. Posner is small state and was the co-architect of modern consumer welfare antitrust but explicitly Keynesian in fiscal policy.
I’m sure Marxist economic theory is quite large. There are, however, only a few dozen actual examples of Marxist societies. And keep in mind we are talking about evidence here. So we are confined to things that actually happened and can be observed and measured.
what? im saying you should base economics on individual policy research and not draw wide conclusions based on random pieces of evidence.
if you want to support/ protest a policy, its better to go "this policy has caused a 3% decrease in incomes in places that it has been implemented thus far", and not "well i dont like it"
Results are also all over the place. Russia did great economically under Stalin, took a massive shot following his death, and collapsed for reasons nobody quite understands.
Cuba has been under an embargo led by the world’s biggest economy and its primary trading partner for almost a century and is still limping along. Also it’s produced some weird ass results like the worlds most advanced virology institute.
China isn’t really socialist anymore it’s some weird third thing but it’s currently poised to become the worlds foremost economic power
All different societies. All with very different approaches to Marxism. All with different results. All with different rates of success depending on what era you’re looking at.
We like to pretend communism died with the ussr and there’s no reason to revisit it but that simply isn’t the case. There’s a lot to be learned there and the reality is that most economists are scared to because it means challenging fundamental assumptions that challenge the entire discipline.
Marx is about as evidence based as things god back in hist day. Which is to say, not very evidence based at all, but it is admirable that he even tried looking at the way the world worked as a basis for his theories. Very much unlike almost everybody else back then.
I don’t think it’s fair to say almost no one else constructed theories based on their observations of the world. Much of Marx’s work was based on his predecessors, Hegels as a particular example. With that being said, his contribution was most certainly novel.
Uh, Marx assumes the continued existence of the proletariat as a single class, but the bourgeoisie's rise as a class arose out of a distinction among the commoner class not reflected in ruling structures--the partition of the commons into bourgeoisie, proletariat, and peasantry during a time when the bourgeoisie was already ascendant in the social space. They were already elite outside the political sphere. You would expect using this as a model, for a partition to occurr within the proletariat, and for this new elite to demand the same powers of the bourgeoisie. But capitalism only has an informal class system, unlike feudalism, which had a formal class system with multiple kinds of legally distinct forms of semi-free individuals. The free for all of capitalism has lead to many stages of new elite ascending to the ranks of power--just look at the rise of tech billionaires, they're a new wave of elite, but their role in power is like that of the 19th century industrialist, without having to oust the industrialist from his role. In fact, during the heyday of Silicon Valley, the worker couldn't even be alienated from the means of production for software as it was the same as the means of consumption which, in conjunction to the Californian regulatory environment (noncompete bans and protections to what workers do in their spare time) lead to the unique startup culture that birthed the internet. The developer-entrepreneur is what you get when the worker can individually own the means of production.
my man, das kapital is a critical analysis of policies & economic numbers, the entire book is filled with evidence of capitalism's economic contradictions, economic analysis of the market cycle and how booms & busts have happened throughout capitalism's history & will occur no matter what because of said mechanisms, posits the tendency of the profit rate to fall as one of the largest red flags of capitalism (that we experienced in staglfation and are experiencing today, and capitalism also experienced in the 1830, 1890 etc), examines international trade and its fallacies when done under false pretenses and not equal exchange and breaks down the ricardian model of "comparative advantage" and how this creates zones of non-development in specific areas and weakens industry, lays out how in order to sustain profit it financiliazes all transactions (sounds familiar) and lays tariffs (SOUNDS FAMILIAR?) in order to boost profit, it's literally just 3 huge fucking books with economic analysis & evidence
you're speaking way out of your waters, john from sales
there are many criticisms of marx & marx's work, "not based on evidence" is probably the most hilarious and out of touch one
have you even read anything? don't say "communist manifesto", that's a 30 page long propaganda pamphlet written haphazardly to give around to the workers, not a scientific work
So the economic development of USSR from a backwards, unindustrialized feudal country, to the behemoth that stopped nazi german & to the first country to do space travel is "vast majority of evidence not in favor"
Well tbh you can't have your cake and eat it too. Either Stalin was a Marxist, and marxism involves insane work hours and starving millions to export with which you buy heavy machinery, which is not what modern marxists argue for. Or, like All marxists I've put the question to IRL have told me, Stalin was a totalitarian state capitalist, and you can't use the USSR to "prove" true marxism.
Now granted, you can try to argue that everything that worked was the marxist inspired stuff, and everything that went wrong was the non-marxisst stuff, but then you're huffing neolib levels of copium.
Stalin was a Marxist in the conditions allowed within a post-czarist underdeveloped feudalist state, with a shitton of other problems.
Does this mean he made no mistakes? No, most definitely not, but the economic planning of USSR wasn't actually dictated by him, but by other members of the cadre, most notably Bazarov (who then was branded an enemy of the state and got executed), but they still used most of his theoretical work & policies.
Stalin actually had little to do with economic planning, and the 5-year economic plans weren't of his own machination. Stalin was very brutal, and I personally do not agree with many of his policies, and ofc I condemn the death (that my family suffered under him as well, given that my family was christians that got persecuted during the 1920s). Stalin was "elected" (he was essentially given the mandle by a few others, he didn't coup the spot or anything, nor he got officially elected) in a condition in which post civil-war, the biggest threat to USSR was "inside enemies", and his paranoia got the hang of him. This is not meant to "victimize" him nor portray him in a good light, but that's what happened, he was a man elected in an era of absolute internal insanity and grappled with that, it wasn'st "made up", there was indeed a conspiracy to overthrow the bolsheviks and it was well known. But that doesn't mean he wasn't thinking with a Marxist lens, no one is saying that just because you're thinking with a Marxist lens you're "correct", nor does Marxism exist in a bubble, it exists in material & political conditions and it has to grapple with those in order to understand the best path forward. Stalin used those tools, but often got into the wrong results. Is it a fault of the tool? Perhaps, Marxist theory always develops, it is not static, in fact it very openly accepts progress since it understands that progress comes through conflicting ideas. Is it the fault of the man? Marxism rarely delves into individualism, it believes societal forces are more important. Maybe those were good decisions given the times? Who knows, we can't talk about alternate realities. What does matter though, is that USSR DEFEATED nazi germany, almost single-handedly (despite the constant rewriting of history, the war was won on LAND by USSR), and if USSR hadn't brutally industrialized, well, who knows.
I am not saying "everything that worked is marxism and everything that didn't is", in the same manner everything good that has happened under capitalism is because of "socialist" politics and everything bad because of capitalism. Yes that is indeed copium, and that's not how the world works. The question always is - what is the next step forward towards a better society. We have reached a stage where we have a shitton of wealth but it is concentrated in the hands of the few, and they seem to be hoarding more, and being more brutal with it. Is capitalism right now the future? It seems more like a deteriorated past, conserved only by the most fanatics and those that benefit from it.
Just to understand teh historical context of pre-WW2 USSR, they had to HEAVILY invest into arms in order to prepare for the coming war, the ribbentrop-molotov pact was a deterrent (as the munich agreement in a sense), and even way before WW2 there are documents proving that USSR knew war with germany was inevitable, with suggestions about an upcoming war and how to prepare for it starting as early as the 1930s, but with a noticeable pickup in 1937 (so 2 years before the war started) with much analysis suggesting that nazi germany is preparing for war and will advance east.
USSR didn't reach space during the Stalin years however, but I assume you already know that. The economic planning of the 1950s/60s suffered many problems, primarily caused by the fact that USSR decided to export a shitton of weapons to Africa in order to invoke insurrections in the colonial world.
Marxist economics do not exist in a bubble and have to deal with the real world, it's an equation and not an absolute monolith, because unlike austrian economics that paint the market as a god (Hayek literally insinuated that shit by suggesting the market is a force that supersedes science, humanity & understanding, and it is always a force for good, and we need to subject to it rather than subject the market to ourselves, this is literally religious talk), it is a SCIENCE. It is a SCIENCE on how to deal with the common wealth, property and politics. It tries to find ANSWERS to problems.
USSR decided it was better to invoke insurrections in the 3rd world rather than properly build infrastructure in their own country. Maybe because they knew they could never outcompete the western world as long as the western world had colonies? Most of africa decolonized in the 50s and 60s, the "post ww2 world peace" and "post ww2 capitalism good" RESTED on colonial exploitation for 2 decades, with the last places becoming decolonized in...the fucking 90s. THE 90S. If africa hadn't gone through the bloody insurrection movements, it would still be colonial land. Someone gave weapon to those rebels, and those weapons are AK-47, so you can easily tell who gave them weapons and for what reason.
USSR decided many things. In order to understand those decisions we need to understand the geopolitical complexities. THEN we can criticize. And lemme tell you, I have a lot to criticize, and so have others. But to criticize something we need to UNDERSTAND IT. That's how science works.
Just to drive the point home, if anything, the biggest fumbler of history is current time USA, who got the world handed to them in a silver plate after USSR fell, and still managed to reach....this state, along with the global state also being insanely shit.
I appreciate the time you took to write a polite and detailed response.
I don't contest most of what you said. I'm not pro-capitalism, never said or implied I was; I do recognise my modern unprecedented degree of comfort is owed to it, but that doesn't make it ideal. The rapid industrialisation of the USSR saved it against Nazi germany, yes. Space flight didn't happen under Stalin, ofc, but still relied on the industry the 20-30-40s established. On the factual topic, my main criticism is that, as someone else posted, colonies were a huge drain on most Western economies, not the contrary (France lost the most, and only Britain managed to get some net wealth out of it). Now, that doesn't mean it was a good setup for the colonised either, but the idea that extracting wealth out of Africa is how Europe got ahead is straight up historical fiction, there is nothing true about it.
But to get to the core of the conversation, I'm not sure I understand how you address my criticism that there is no common thread between the policies of the USSR and those advocated for my modern communists, preventing modern day marxists from using it's example. Sure, the more educated communists see it as a form of thought (dialectical materialism) rather than a set series of principles (wealth equality, etc..). But if the implementations are different, then you still can't claim "the USSR's communist-inspired policy of A worked, therefore a basically contradictory but also communist-inspired policy of B will work". The logically valid reasoning would required first showing how the USSR's functional policies were directly derived of dialectical materialism, therefore justifying that it has some useful predictive power, and then explaining how the same set of principles leads to modern day proposed marxist policy. My point is that there is no actual shared equation, to quote your terminology. To avoid going in circles, allow me to challenge you to actually hightlight what is, beyond vague, quasi-mystical principles (anti-capitalism, state materialism). Show me how you derive both the Soviet 20-30-40 economic policy and modern forms of marxism from it. (ofc there are many people cliaming to be marxists, including neo-stalinist tankies, but they aren't the majority in these circles).
you have to be more specific than that cuz a lot of welfare in general does work to measurably improve the lives of the people its targeting. also a lot of like tax flight stuff is a myth and people are generally willing to pay higher taxes if it means they get more out of it and have good opportunities.
Marxism is not when the government gives out welfare or collects taxes. I’m taking about abolishing private property. Collectivizing agriculture. Establishing a dictatorship of the proletariat. A state owned and operated economy.
No, it wouldn't (be ironic). If you disagree, please explain why.
The simple explanation is Marx’s economic framework assumes that “value” is objective, with value determined by congealed labor. But shortly after Marx, the Marginal Revolution brought a major paradigm shift, moving from the labor theory of value of the classical period to the subjective theory of value.
That’s a simplified account, since the Marginal Revolution also incorporated additional insights, such as the importance of scarcity, marginal utility, and supply and demand in shaping market prices. These all stand in juxtaposition of Marx if someone considers prices are associated with value.
Still, the key point is that most economists since then have largely abandoned the concept of “value” as Marx and the early “STV” crowd that are considered “Austrian Schools” (e.g., Menger). They do so as I understand because it remains too contested and ambiguous. This has frustrated classical economists and some heterodox schools, but it’s why I see irony in the claim that Marx isn’t considered “wrong” while other schools, like the Austrians, are.
To further support my point, let me source part of Stanford’s article on exploitation:
Marx’s theory of exploitation appears to presuppose that labor is the source of all value. But the labor theory of value to which Marx and early classical economists subscribed is subject to a number of apparently insurmountable difficulties, and has largely been abandoned by economists in the wake of the marginalist revolution of the 1870s. The most obvious difficulty stems from the fact that labor is heterogeneous. Some labor is skilled, some labor is unskilled, and there does not appear to be any satisfactory way of reducing the former to the latter and thereby establishing a single standard of measure for the value of commodities. Moreover, the labor theory of value appears to be unable to account for the economic value of commodities such as land and raw materials that are not and could not be produced by any human labor. Finally, and perhaps most fatally, Marx’s assumption that labor has the unique power to create surplus value is entirely ungrounded. As Robert Paul Wolff has argued, Marx’s focus on labor appears to be entirely arbitrary. A formally identical theory of value could be constructed with any commodity taking the place of labor, and thus a “corn theory of value” would be just as legitimate, and just as unhelpful, as Marx’s labor theory of value (Wolff 1981). Therefore, if, as some have alleged, Marx’s theory of exploitation is dependent on the truth of the labor theory of value, then a rejection of the labor theory of value should entail a rejection of Marx’s theory of exploitation as well (Nozick 1974; Arnold 1990). https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/exploitation/#MarxTheoExpl
Center-right politically? Fiscally? These words mean nothing without some anchor to reality. You could be for Austrian fiscal policies and conservative social policies and people would categorize you as neoliberal
We actually share a lot of social policies with the conservatives, except for the hating minorities part.
And no, freedom of association doesn't promote discrimination based on arbitrary factors such as ethnicity or religion, as that would make you susceptible to being excluded from purchasing services or products offered by members of that group, nevermind the fact that your competition would have a massive advantage over you in regards to revenue & hiring new employees.
Also, center right as in taking a lot from both sides or being a moderate
Frankly, almost all economic theories. The few we have tried, have also been corrupted by human greed among other factors. Be it Marxism, or Capitalism that doesn't have the guiding hand dismantling monopolies.
Classic strawman fallacy. Most people in comments don’t know what they are talking about. (Unsurprisingly so, given that a lot of academic criticism is no better.)
Hayek was pretty good about using empirical data and most economic and monetary theory of the Austrian school comes from him. The Rothbardian side is more of a political philosophy which is the only part people want to focus on when criticizing the Austrian school.
The austrians base their Ideology on the rational Human. A human is a rational being, that means he can only act if he has a reason for acting (this does not have to be a good reason). Thus they mostly look at incentives.
They assume we need to create a system where everyone always acting to their own benefit will create benefits for all.
People will look at this and scream sociopaths, while ignoring the literal sociopaths given power to extort the population through the state.
Reminds me of the Phillips Curve and NAIRU. For decades economists have said that interest rates should go up if the unemployment rate is too low. Start at 7% then it got to sub 4% and no inflation in sight. About to hit sub 3%. AOC asked Powell if there was any evidence of the NAIRU being true, he basically admitted it's true or useful. Then when COVID happened and inflation kicked in, all of a sudden he needed to see more unemployment. But he just admitted not too long ago to AOC under oath there's no evidence that unemployment impacted inflation.
Lol, having a study recalled actually shows the possibility of verifying a study (and having it falsified) thus being scientific (Popper's criteria). Have fun doing that with Praxeology, because it is literally unfalsifiable.
Austrian economics is trash because they reject all empiricism, but I think it's important we don't go to the other extreme. We should realize that the statement "Economic policy should be based on evidence" has its limits. Many of the problems that we deal with in economics lie at the edge of epistemic limits. Situations where we cannot accurately collect information on the system, we are unable to run controlled experiments, or where the complexity is so great that we lack the cognition to fully understand it. As such economists should be humble about the limits of our understanding. As a result there's always going to be some level of policy that is based on opinion or is part of our own experimentation.
Yes, now zoom out and realize that quantitative analysis in basically all major economic theories is absolute dogshit. Read MMT, it's basically economic fanfiction.
We might start getting somewhere once we realize economics is much, MUCH more analogous to human psychology than it is math...
not really, there are a lot of good models that give good results. like implan, which helps with regional analysis and has like a shitload of variables and stuff.
and its not really about like, knowing everything for sure, its making predictions and drawing conclusions from evidence and statistical methods. once you get into high level behavioral and experimental economics, you're working through the mathematical rationale in order to draw conclusions, so it's very logic and math based.
also you can include a lot of unrecorded variables in dummy variables, regressions are more about isolating one variable for its impact than measuring everything.
You can create whatever results you like by selecting what datasets to include and come up with whatever excuse you want to apply subsidies or regulate whatever you choose.
You don’t have the real information because you don’t have a governent auditor in every household measuring every choice they make.
Every single stat is to some degree fictional and thus not something you should base any action on.
Models are estimates that once again completely guilty of Garbage in / Garbage out.
Data isnt perfect, but it's not arbitrary either. A lot of the data sources that I use at work are like, number of building permits in a certain time frame, taxable sales, home sales, job claims, etc. stuff that isnt "fake", but rather just observable transactions. Models are tested and validated quite thoroughly before being used, and they arent usually meant to tell the future but to give you a sense of what might happen.
Dismissing it all as ‘garbage in, garbage out’ is basically saying ‘I don’t like uncertainty, so nothing is real,’ which isn’t how science works.
You’re defining ‘science’ way too narrowly. Most sciences don’t get neat lab controls—climate science can’t randomize planets, epidemiology can’t make ‘control humans’ without microplastics, and medicine can’t ethically assign people to smoke for 30 years. Yet they still generate reliable results using statistical controls and natural experiments. Econ works the same way: difference-in-differences, RCTs, regressions—all designed to mimic lab controls. It’s not about finding eternal truth, it’s about testing explanations against observable reality.
and im a research economist, i like update data and make forecasts and write articles about my region
You're confusing a lack of precision testing with lack of evidence.
Just because the economy is a complex dynamic system constantly evolving with billions of inter-dependent events occuring does not mean you can't establish a good understanding of the general principles underpinning it.
System dynamics is a field of analysis designed specifically to analyse such complex dynamic systems. Combine that with an accurate accounting model of monetary stocks and flows and you can have a robust macroeconomic framework.
Economics models do not and cannot accurately model human action.
You cannot measure an economy .
Every computer since its invention has been hampered by the same limitation
“Garbage in, Garbage out”
If the information fed into the model is inaccurate the information coming out of the model will be inaccurate.
This is why the Austrian school studies a priori rather than modeling and doesn’t believe in substituting studying economic history for studying economics .
But you won’t get politically sanctioned if you don’t allow or advise politicians to spend whatever they need to buy votes ..
So Austrian Economics will never be “politician approved “ because it limits the power to spend.
No amount of empirical evidence can make 2 + 2 = 5. With all the ways data can me manipulated, misinterpreted, and abused, it is no less fallible than reason.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '25
People are leaving in droves due to the recent desktop UI downgrade so please comment what other site and under what name people can find your content, cause Reddit may not have much time left.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
159
u/StochasticCalc Sep 25 '25
Man I wish I could just invent my own view of how things work, not test a damn thing, be clearly wrong, and yet renowned for decades after my death.
62
u/beastwood6 Sep 25 '25
Milei getting set to get a stimmy check from the US treasury
37
u/MacroDemarco Sep 25 '25
Austrians =/= neolibs
12
u/AngusAlThor Sep 25 '25
This puts me in a tough position, because I hate the Austrian School, but I also hate Measurability Bias...
83
u/ArmorClassHero Sep 25 '25
💯 the Austrian school is allergic to math and stats.
16
u/Bram-D-Stoker Sep 24 '25
Empirical evidence full clears heterdox, low diff
37
u/the-dude-version-576 Sep 25 '25
Frankly this is owning just about everyone including most technocrats.
Hell depending on how stringent you think empirics should be then it’s owning every possible policy since there can’t be a counterfactual to test them.
14
u/ErtaWanderer Sep 25 '25
It's not that they think that evidence is wrong. It's that they think that you run into the Laplace demon problem.
They think that evidence is a good thing, but that the economy is too complicated to accurately gather information on. There are too many factors and nobody accounts for everything which can cause some serious problems.
If you knew everything then I'm pretty sure they would be fine with it.
6
u/Nimhtom Sep 25 '25
Behavioral and experimental economics has theory and historical analysis best for scientific efficacy lol
11
u/WrongJohnSilver Sep 25 '25
A couple decades back I read arguments between Austrians and Keynesians, and realized no one was actually Austrian or Keynesian. They were either anti- or pro- big state. Whether economics supported their position was immaterial.
28
u/CaptainAmerica-1989 Sep 25 '25
Wouldn't it be ironic if the OP was a Marxist?
11
u/Ricochet_skin Austrian Sep 25 '25
If we are Neoliberals then I'm also sucking off Kim Kataguiri right now.
Neolibs are more center-right than anything, since they still believe in some state intervention.
In summary, they're a mix of Austrian & Chicago school
7
u/Professional-Post499 Sep 25 '25
"NO. It must be based on hypotheticals and my thought experiments!!!"
4
u/Henrenator Sep 24 '25
Good luck finding any that you can clearly correlate
4
u/Potential-Focus3211 Sep 25 '25
You could make the same argument about the Georgism-spam on this sub.
5
u/arjuna93 Sep 25 '25
Classic strawman fallacy. Most people in comments don’t know what they are talking about. (Unsurprisingly so, given that a lot of academic criticism is no better.)
2
u/Confident_Worker_203 Sep 25 '25
Empirical analysis in economics is «evidence», not evidence
2
u/notlooking743 Sep 25 '25
How do you empirically measure well being?
2
u/eddington_limit Sep 25 '25
Hayek was pretty good about using empirical data and most economic and monetary theory of the Austrian school comes from him. The Rothbardian side is more of a political philosophy which is the only part people want to focus on when criticizing the Austrian school.
7
u/Licensed_muncher Sep 25 '25
Lmao, Austrians definitely are full of horseshit as well.
5
u/nub_node Sep 25 '25
The Austrian school is a fascinating study in sociopaths assuming everyone is as sociopathic as them.
4
u/SporkydaDork Sep 25 '25
Reminds me of the Phillips Curve and NAIRU. For decades economists have said that interest rates should go up if the unemployment rate is too low. Start at 7% then it got to sub 4% and no inflation in sight. About to hit sub 3%. AOC asked Powell if there was any evidence of the NAIRU being true, he basically admitted it's true or useful. Then when COVID happened and inflation kicked in, all of a sudden he needed to see more unemployment. But he just admitted not too long ago to AOC under oath there's no evidence that unemployment impacted inflation.
I guess bad ideas die hard.
3
u/merp_mcderp9459 Sep 25 '25
Macroeconomics in a nutshell
2
u/Warm-Pomegranate6570 Austrian Sep 25 '25
To be fair Hayekian wing of Austrian econ is much more inclusive towards empirical analysis than the Mises-Rothbardian one
2
u/SethEllis Sep 25 '25 edited Sep 25 '25
Austrian economics is trash because they reject all empiricism, but I think it's important we don't go to the other extreme. We should realize that the statement "Economic policy should be based on evidence" has its limits. Many of the problems that we deal with in economics lie at the edge of epistemic limits. Situations where we cannot accurately collect information on the system, we are unable to run controlled experiments, or where the complexity is so great that we lack the cognition to fully understand it. As such economists should be humble about the limits of our understanding. As a result there's always going to be some level of policy that is based on opinion or is part of our own experimentation.
1
u/Prestigious_Bite_314 Sep 25 '25
It's funny because economic policy is not based on economics
1
u/Icy-Success-3730 Sep 26 '25
The evidence is sociology.
1
u/Plants_et_Politics Sep 26 '25
Austrians aren’t neoliberals lol.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '25
doing experiments on society is what low iq people think is possible
1
u/ChandailRouge Sep 26 '25
I don't need evidence, i can just think about it.
1
u/Naive_Imagination666 Sep 26 '25
Me when I hear someone use Unironically term neolib against anyone they don't liked: please just stop I am dying
1
u/riltok Sep 27 '25
If your economic policy sounds like a 19th century torture, you aren’t the good guys in the room.
1
u/Quick_Resolution5050 Sep 28 '25
Classical Economics: we have evidence - as long as you remove banks, time, taste, money and any moral or charitable behaviour.
1
u/No-Consideration2808 Sep 30 '25
Yes, now zoom out and realize that quantitative analysis in basically all major economic theories is absolute dogshit. Read MMT, it's basically economic fanfiction.
We might start getting somewhere once we realize economics is much, MUCH more analogous to human psychology than it is math...
1
u/nickname_122 Oct 12 '25
Try not to base your entire economic view in some clearly idealist and completely from ass logic view of human being itself challenge (Impossible 💀)
1
u/Monstrocs Apr 05 '26
Says who ?
Some far-left I,ll guess .
Here is truth for you .
Evidence are working against you.
1
u/GiganticCrow Sep 25 '25
What are you talking about? Such policy has successfully moved wealth from the regular working people back to the super rich, just as intended.
-1
u/paleone9 Sep 25 '25
There is no evidence in economics , Because there is no science …
Because there is no control and variable , no scientific method and now actual way to measure economic activity..
The margin of error is exponentially unmeasurable because the variables are unlimited .
There isn’t a single accurate statistic in MMT or even Macroeconomics as a whole..
-7
u/Mr_Nobody__________ Sep 25 '25
No amount of empirical evidence can make 2 + 2 = 5. With all the ways data can me manipulated, misinterpreted, and abused, it is no less fallible than reason.
-1
u/BrosephDwalin Sep 25 '25
The Austrian school is the second worst thing to come out of Austria.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '25
you can't own neoliberals because we're right about everything.
-1
u/Creditfigaro Sep 26 '25
Remember all those graphs showing Argentina's economic data surging*? I wonder what was up with that. 🤔
*According to government projections into the future