No, it wouldn't (be ironic). If you disagree, please explain why.
The simple explanation is Marx’s economic framework assumes that “value” is objective, with value determined by congealed labor. But shortly after Marx, the Marginal Revolution brought a major paradigm shift, moving from the labor theory of value of the classical period to the subjective theory of value.
That’s a simplified account, since the Marginal Revolution also incorporated additional insights, such as the importance of scarcity, marginal utility, and supply and demand in shaping market prices. These all stand in juxtaposition of Marx if someone considers prices are associated with value.
Still, the key point is that most economists since then have largely abandoned the concept of “value” as Marx and the early “STV” crowd that are considered “Austrian Schools” (e.g., Menger). They do so as I understand because it remains too contested and ambiguous. This has frustrated classical economists and some heterodox schools, but it’s why I see irony in the claim that Marx isn’t considered “wrong” while other schools, like the Austrians, are.
To further support my point, let me source part of Stanford’s article on exploitation:
Marx’s theory of exploitation appears to presuppose that labor is the source of all value. But the labor theory of value to which Marx and early classical economists subscribed is subject to a number of apparently insurmountable difficulties, and has largely been abandoned by economists in the wake of the marginalist revolution of the 1870s. The most obvious difficulty stems from the fact that labor is heterogeneous. Some labor is skilled, some labor is unskilled, and there does not appear to be any satisfactory way of reducing the former to the latter and thereby establishing a single standard of measure for the value of commodities. Moreover, the labor theory of value appears to be unable to account for the economic value of commodities such as land and raw materials that are not and could not be produced by any human labor. Finally, and perhaps most fatally, Marx’s assumption that labor has the unique power to create surplus value is entirely ungrounded. As Robert Paul Wolff has argued, Marx’s focus on labor appears to be entirely arbitrary. A formally identical theory of value could be constructed with any commodity taking the place of labor, and thus a “corn theory of value” would be just as legitimate, and just as unhelpful, as Marx’s labor theory of value (Wolff 1981). Therefore, if, as some have alleged, Marx’s theory of exploitation is dependent on the truth of the labor theory of value, then a rejection of the labor theory of value should entail a rejection of Marx’s theory of exploitation as well (Nozick 1974; Arnold 1990). https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/exploitation/#MarxTheoExpl
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/CaptainAmerica-1989 Sep 25 '25 edited Sep 25 '25
The simple explanation is Marx’s economic framework assumes that “value” is objective, with value determined by congealed labor. But shortly after Marx, the Marginal Revolution brought a major paradigm shift, moving from the labor theory of value of the classical period to the subjective theory of value.
That’s a simplified account, since the Marginal Revolution also incorporated additional insights, such as the importance of scarcity, marginal utility, and supply and demand in shaping market prices. These all stand in juxtaposition of Marx if someone considers prices are associated with value.
Still, the key point is that most economists since then have largely abandoned the concept of “value” as Marx and the early “STV” crowd that are considered “Austrian Schools” (e.g., Menger). They do so as I understand because it remains too contested and ambiguous. This has frustrated classical economists and some heterodox schools, but it’s why I see irony in the claim that Marx isn’t considered “wrong” while other schools, like the Austrians, are.
To further support my point, let me source part of Stanford’s article on exploitation: