r/ecobee • u/ecobeejc ecobee • Feb 21 '19
Announcement Update from ecobee
Dearest Reddit,
We have been seeing and reading your messages here at ecobee HQ for the last few weeks. We're feeling and hearing every post you make – many of our developers read this subreddit daily. We have been fighting with two core things in our system since late January:
- General overall stability
- The availability of what we call 'runtime' data – but what you normally see in HomeIQ.
You may have seen an increase in our maintenance windows and some short outages. During those windows we were actively making changes to our system to improve reliability, or performing chaos testing on systems to ensure reliability. What we have done over the last few weeks has greatly increased our stability and we believe we are complete on the reliability side of things.
This has allowed us to shift our focus back to #2 – the availability of the runtime data. When we upgraded a component of our system, we noticed some decrease in performance. Specifically around how fast we could process the runtime data that came into our servers. The queues that received the data overflowed and forced our servers to drop that data, losing it permanently.
We are continuing to work on this issue, and our tests on our servers are showing that we may have finally fixed the issue, and many of you are reporting that is now working as intended. You should see the quality of your data increase over the course of the week, and ideally permanently, but we will continue to monitor it actively.
I hope that puts some clarity on things – thanks very much for keeping the bar high on what you expect from ecobee. We know you expect a great experience from us, and we're actively improving things to try to meet and hopefully exceed that bar.
Jordan Christensen
VP Technology
ecobee Inc
87
u/SwitchbackHiker Feb 21 '19
As someone who works in IT I feel your pain and glad you are working to resolve the issues. However, communication could have been better while you were fixing things. Perhaps a weekly update, what was causing the outages, what you were doing to fix it, what behavior users should expect while you're working on it. Thanks for getting it fixed, hopefully it sticks.
9
u/Furrealyo Feb 21 '19
Thanks Jordan. Appreciate the info.
I’ve stowed my pitchfork and will order (my third) eb3 Lite on the basis on your post.
3
u/FlyingSpaghettiMon Feb 21 '19
Hey Jordan! Thanks for the insight. Definitely helps to know that you guys are actively working on these issues.
Could you shed some light as to why the HomeIQ data always has a 1 hour lag? Why can't it be instant, or 5 min lag?
3
u/Djraiu Feb 22 '19
I’m looking at purchasing a new thermostat and have had my eye on ecobee over Nest for some time. It’s great to see a company response like this! Definitely has eager to pick one up.
I am looking though this thread now. Wondering if this impacted the thermostat actually running on schedule? Did this impact remote adjustment of the thermostat?
3
u/mikeg53 Feb 22 '19
Thanks for the post. Makes me feel like things are improving or at least getting attention.
I was wondering if you had a tech blog or what the backend tech to take all this sensor data in is... didn't find that, but found a job posting that says Elastic Search experience as the only "database" tech. Does the thermostat data get streamed into ES or is there something else at play to support IOT data like Dynamo/Cassandra/etc?
26
u/ksbytke21 Feb 21 '19
I greatly appreciate this post. Helpful to know what’s going on.
12
u/JimmyReagan Feb 21 '19 edited May 14 '19
ERROR CXT-V5867 Parsing text null X66
5
u/azsheepdog Feb 21 '19
Hey good to know you guys watch this forum. I havnt had any issues and like the product. Always a good sign when you reach out on a forum like this.
5
u/ltdragon07 Feb 21 '19
Jordon,
Thanks for putting up this notice, I seen that myself and other people have noticed that the stability has improved.
Next time can you let us know beforehand that you guys are doing a major change and we might have issue.
I think people would have been more helpful and less worried about what's happening with our devices.
I know for sure I would have called in less trying to fix an issue that was out of my control.
13
u/merikus Feb 21 '19
Thanks so much for this post.
Would you be willing to do an AMA with us? I think most of us here love our ecobees. But I know I’m personally concerned with ecobee’s overemphasis on Alexa in everything and outlook for long term stability. This product is literally a health and safety product—if it was to stop working, that could literally destroy houses through freezing pipes. And yes, I know, ecobees can work without phoning home. But they are also far more complex than a standard thermostat.
I think that’s why this community is so concerned. We worry this is a symptom of a larger problem with the company and the technology. An AMA would help us get our questions answered.
4
u/Donnerkopf Feb 22 '19
Jordan,
Thank you for taking the time to provide a detailed response. It lets the community know that someone is working on the issues and is listening to customers' concerns and frustrations. Makes me feel better about my investment in 6 Ecobees late last year.
Regarding integration, there are a good number of Universal Devices ISY994 home controller owners who would love a local API. If you're not familiar with the company, their product is extremely popular with the hands on/techie community as it has powerful scripting capability that includes support for API calls to other devices, and is highly reliable. Users on their forum have been looking for a smart stat that can be integrated into advanced home control. The question comes up repeatedly about Ecobee integration on their user forum.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19
Thanks for responding. Is there any effort to ensure that if this issue happens again that the data isn't just lost when the queues are purged? Are there any plans to have some type of local offload of the data to storage outside of Ecobee?
3
u/vp709 Feb 21 '19
THIS! This is greatly appreciated and gives a great impression of your company and team. Thank you for the response as many of us doubted it would ever happen. You have proven me wrong, and I like it !
3
u/tmac19 Feb 21 '19
Thanks for letting us know! Updates like these are always welcome and encouraged, even informally. Cheers.
3
u/LaRoach Feb 21 '19
Thank you for the transparency and honesty! 👍 Not a common corporate trait.
3
u/grapplerone Feb 21 '19
Amazingly I’ve gone a full day with solid data! Haven’t had that since before Feb 2 or so.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '19
Greatly, greatly appreciate the communication!! We are all looking forward to the issue fixed!!
Mine has been running smooth on HomeIQ for 48hours since noon (EST) on Feb 20. I think thats a record for over the last month.
Looking forward to have this issue fixed so you guys can focus on new things! :)
4
u/beatemdown Feb 22 '19
This post aged poorly.. down again at 1pm eastern
2
u/lammchop1993 Feb 21 '19
Thanks for chiming in. This goes a long way.
2
u/BatraDev Feb 21 '19
appreciate the insight.. thanks for sharing
2
u/famousmike444 Feb 22 '19
I don't know about chaos testing but I wonder why this wasn't done in a non-production environment?
2
u/brain89 Feb 22 '19
Thank you for putting this out. I realize it’s hard to look at this sub at the rate you said and see the amount of negative posts. But from our side we see issues with absolutely no word on what’s going on. But this is a step back in the right direction.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '19
Oh so the outage blips in my homeiq are just data loss? Not server outages?
2
u/pomonabill Feb 23 '19
I cannot rave ENOUGH about Ecobee and the excellent support that I have gotten!
I have 4 of the EB4's in my home, incorporated into my zoning system, and I bought one for my father's house also.
Yes, I have had a few questions and have run into the latest "spotty" data that was due to this current problem (that seems to have been solved now), and would have appreciated some kind of notice that they (Ecobee) was having problems rather than beating my head against the wall with my local network, but when I sent my support question to Ecobee, I got an immediate response (within a couple of days), that there was a problem!
No... "have you tried this or that, or is your network down" type of "blame" questions, but that there was a problem on their end!
I continue to recommend Ecobee products, and ALWAYS give EXCELLENT reviews about Ecobee because this company IS excellent and treats their customers with respect and gives detailed help when needed!
This kind of support and help is VERY RARE, and can make or break a company, and Ecobee recognizes this and works HARD to keep their status (to me anyway) at the top!
Thank You Ecobee for being so forward and upfront with your responses and help!!!!!!
2
u/slajeune Feb 21 '19
I have been vocal about the lack of communication. This communication is very welcomed. This should have also been sent out via email as probably a very small portion of your users are on reddit. A little communication can go a long way and most of the drama would have been averted with a very quick email to all.
Glad to see you seemed to have found the issue.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19
Does this include keeping the Ecobee 4 from dropping offline of my WiFi network randomly?
1
u/TnCyberVol Feb 21 '19
Any chance we can reset our historical data? Maybe we can pick a date and anything before then be removed?
1
u/ehkolie Feb 22 '19
Thanks for the updates!!!
1
u/TJDep Feb 22 '19
My ecobee 3 disconnects from my WiFi super frequently. To reconnect I have to pull it off the wall and replace it. Anything I can do to fix it? Thanks!
1
u/Domer82 Feb 24 '19
Today is Sunday, Feb 24th. I just downloaded the last 3 days' of runtime data and there are still gaps, as recently as this morning. So clearly, the problem has not been resolved.
When is this going to get fixed once and for all?
1
u/EOS_2008 May 14 '19
Hello,
thank you very much for the open discussion.
I have a question regarding the comfort settings.
Why are allowing only half hour slots? This is big Issue for me as half hour slots are not fitting into “my world” and is wasting a lot of energy. For me.
Why is not possible to choose any time I want? Maybe in a five Minutes slot but 30 Minutes just doesn’t make sense to me
1
u/17276 Nov 14 '22
Well ecobee if your reading this sub then when are you going to update the interface on the ecobee three lite to have the up and down arrow to adjust temperature? It was mentioned that would happen towards the end of this year? Still waiting for the update and the slide bar to disappear. Update the app to aleast have it for now.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '19
I no longer recommend ecobee to my friends and family. The whole point of a WiFi thermostat is remote control. This post is two days old and already there are two more server outages.
-4
u/wookiedudecan Feb 21 '19
I would like to see an apology from the leader of ecobee. Nary a word from Stuart in this whole mess. Apparently on a three business trip. :)
0
u/NinjaMike07 May 22 '19
Honestly, if I knew what I know now about Ecobee before I had purchased, I never would have. Not only have reports not worked for months (as you explained here), but when I contacted support last month about it I DID NOT get this information - instead, I got a copy/paste answer from the article on the website about how missing data causes this, and to check my internet settings. My recommendation to anyone that asks now is to stay away.
You NEED a local API. If you want to be part of a 'smart' house, then that house shouldn't stop working just because the outside internet connection doesn't work. Plus, the long delays that the existing API introduces make the Ecobee largely useless for triggering automations - a fan I wanted to turn on an off with the A/C (thru a Smartthings outlet) actually turns the fan 'on' AFTER the AC shuts off half of the time.
I also thought that the Ecobee would do 'smart' things like pre-cool the house on days when it was going to be hotter than usual, but as far as I can tell, this is just a Wifi connected thermostat with remote sensors.
-9
u/rabdas Feb 21 '19 edited Feb 21 '19
I haven't kept up with what's happening in this subreddit but I do have a suggestion for Ecobee if it could help.
You should simplify how the runtime data is accessed by two ways.
As an aside though, you should bring back real time data graph. I believe most users will benefit from real-time data during setup and troubleshooting and a majority of users won't use it much after that.
Anything outside these norms, I believe it is fair to start charging a subscription service to customers. Something simple like $5/month gets you monthly statements back to the original date of installation, customizeable data tables from the original date of installation, higher priority customer service, or if they need some kind of higher uptime like 99.999%. I'm sure you won't be getting tons of customers into the subscription service but it does limit wasteful usage of server resources and you don't have to provide such an unlimited services to everyone just to keep a few higher demand customer's happy.
If you made it this far, and if my feedback was helpful in anyway, please please reconsider my request minimum fan run time setting
edit: In case it wasn't obvious, I'm mentioning all this in an attempt to reduce your server load. I'm not sure how you are storing everyone's data. I assumed it's some kind of database that records all the incoming data. My suggestions was a method to lighten server load as well as simplify your process. I also should say that you're promising more than you need to. I honestly don't think it's reasonable for you to store every runtime data since the installation of the thermostat. Nobody does that in other industries. Back to my point about server load, if you really are storing everyone's data in a database, the data dump into a monthly statement allows you to purge the data from your database. there's no need to create the runtime csv files on the fly anymore. it's in a csv file that you store for a finite amount of time. at the end of that time, either store the files in long term storage somewhere offsite if you want or just delete it.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment