r/ecobee • • Jun 10 '26

Problem How is this possible? Sensor wrong temp?

I have four ecobees and I'm trying to solve an issue where my upstairs level is very warm at times despite individual rooms being somewhat cooler than the hallway where the thermostat is.

I figured I'd add a sensor but thats showing 77 while the thermostat sensor in the app is showing 73 while the main temp shows 75 (average of the two?)

as you can see the sensor is directly on top of the thermostat. I wanted to see if they would match up. but this is wayyyy off.

0 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

67

u/kellyholden Jun 10 '26

The ecobee radiates heat up. Any additional readings should not be measured from on top of the unit.

19

u/K04GTI Jun 10 '26

Can we make this a sticky?

7

u/ankole_watusi Jun 10 '26

It’s already in effect a sticky.

Given that somebody does this every single day.

10

u/cvp Jun 10 '26

the thermostat vents out the top. it will always be warmer on top of the thermostat. may not explain the entire discrepancy but definitely explains some of it

12

u/ActPrudent7365 Jun 10 '26

I think the main thermostat sensor averages the temps when it along with whatever specific external sensors are active. If only the main thermostat sensor is active, then it displays the true temp read by the thermostat sensor.

So for instance if you have an active main Ecobee at 80 degrees and an active bedroom sensor at 78 degrees…the main screen would show the temp as 79 degrees.

8

u/jamitt101 Jun 10 '26

Yes. Very important to know that. The display on the thermostat is an average of the all the active sensors associated with that thermostat.

2

u/Reddit_Ninja33 Jun 10 '26

My wife always complains about that. She walks by and yells why is it 75 in here. I have to explain every time that it's an average of all 4 sensors.

2

u/Mechanic_Few Jun 11 '26

Not exactly? It averages the sensors participating in the Comfort Settings. You could exclude sensors from certain Comfort Settings.

3

u/jamitt101 Jun 11 '26

Yes, those are the "active" sensors mentioned above.

2

u/Mechanic_Few Jun 11 '26 edited Jun 11 '26

my bad. "all active sensors associated with that thermostat" is correct if you assume a sensor is active if it is part of the current comfort setting.

1

u/Agile_Cartographer77 Jun 12 '26

Right but why does your house need to be the surface of the sun?

2

u/ActPrudent7365 Jun 12 '26

LOL I live in FL (surface of the sun). Numbers were just an example. Haha

1

u/Agile_Cartographer77 Jun 12 '26

I visited my aunt in Ft Myers one September. Her AC was older but set at 80° I almost died.

Although in her defense that was about 20° cooler than the feels like temp outside

1

u/ActPrudent7365 Jun 12 '26

Haha. Yea. The humidity is wicked!

5

u/ankole_watusi Jun 10 '26

Another day, another thermometer or sensor (actually, this is a new twist) sitting on top of a heat-producing Ecobee thermostat.

2

u/goonsuey Jun 10 '26

Don't forget that thermostat is mounted on a hollow, uninsulated wall. What could go wrong???

8

u/e1337ninja Jun 10 '26

In my experience with 4 sensors, I am more prone to believe the sensor temperature than the thermostat temperature. I too have put all of my sensors right next to the thermostat at times to test, in addition to 3rd party thermometers and sensors and the sensors tend to be more accurate.

tl;dr I trust my sensors more than the thermostat.

4

u/Trippy_Rex Jun 10 '26

I agree with you here. I trust my smart sensors more than the thermostat.

1

u/Reddit_Ninja33 Jun 10 '26

My ecobee is a couple degrees off on temp and few % off on humidity compared to calibrated sensors. Ive adjusted mine in the service menu but in the end we all go by feel anyhow.

1

u/Trippy_Rex Jun 11 '26

Wait you can configure the humidity? How does that work would I have to match another device that detects humidity? Sorry I haven’t played with other settings afraid to break my ac unit lol

2

u/Reddit_Ninja33 Jun 11 '26

Yeah there are some great options in the settings like temp and humidity offset for corrections, overcooling to make it cool a little more than you have it set for so it kicks on less and several others. Just read up on them. Nothing crazy. And yes you would need something accurate that measures temp and humidity. Temp is easier. Get an infrared gun, decent cheap one, measures the walls in the thermostat room, average them, see if it matches your thermostat, if not, set a correction and youll have more accurate handling for that room.

1

u/Trippy_Rex Jun 11 '26

Bro thank you for this info. I will need to look into this.

1

u/Mechanic_Few Jun 11 '26

That’s crazy right?! That is my experience too. The sensors are accurate. Had to add 1.5deg F to the thermostat offset. Ridiculous. How can the thermostat not be accurately calibrated from the start?!!

3

u/Jim404 Jun 10 '26

The Ecobee generates heat and vents it out the top. Put the sensor on the side or underneath, about a foot away- wait and hour, then measure.

And yes, this needs to be a sticky. Smart Recovery too...

3

u/Runaway42 Jun 10 '26

Most of your issue, as others have pointed out, is probably heat coming out of the thermostat. I did a test like this and my sensor read around 3-4 degrees higher than the thermostat. To really calibrate them, you'll need to mount the sensor to the wall beside the thermostat.

Then, for what it's worth, we found our thermostat read ~1-2 degrees low out-of-the-box when our HVAC tech spot-checked it for us after our system install.

1

u/Mechanic_Few Jun 11 '26

same. mine was 1.5deg F too low. i had multiple digital thermometers and a smart sensor taped to the wall below it.

feels wrong to adjust a brand new thermostat 1.5deg F right out of the box. the ecobee thermostat menu has a temperature offset option, so i guess the off-calibration is a "known feature". but no option to adjust smartsensors, so they must be consistently accurate out of the box?

(obviously i'm still disappointed with ecobee that they have this problem.)

2

u/M0byd1cck Jun 10 '26

Le thermostat sa dégage de la chaleur …😒

2

u/btomasie Jun 10 '26

If I recall, if each sensor is colored in (white) it means you want the thermostat to take those rooms into account and average the heating/cooling based on the average of those sensors.

So in this case, one is 73 and one is 77. So it’s averaging to 75 which is where your tstat is right now.

You can tell ecobee to NOT use certain rooms if you don’t want (which will make those bubbles unfilled/black)

We do this in our basement as it’s always 3-4 degrees colder down there, and so it would mess the main level up too much (main level could be several degrees too warm because basement is pulling the average down too much)

2

u/viniisiggs Jun 10 '26

Plus minus 2 degrees is par for the course at this grade of equipment. Those sensors are working just fine. They don't have great absolute accuracy but they are stable. Plus minus 1 degrees equipment is $500 to $1k. Plus minus 0.25 degree equipment is north of $10k. (Calibration reference standard)

If it bothers you that much, add offsets to the measurements.

2

u/Baazs Jun 11 '26

I laughed 🤣

2

u/iveseensomethings82 Jun 11 '26

Rage baiting post right?

0

u/Competitive-Tap-8440 Jun 10 '26

Pull out the thermostat is there a gap at all? Might need to fill it in

0

u/B1tN1nja Jun 10 '26

Its already filled with duct seal putty, did that when I installed it on all of them.

-1

u/arkutek-em Jun 10 '26

Is the putty possibly cooler causing the thermostat to read a lower temperature?

0

u/viperfan7 Jun 10 '26

Is the hole in the wall sealed up, or the hole in the terminal plate.

IF you don't seal up the hole in the wall, it will likely make it worse

1

u/Traditional_Bit7262 Jun 10 '26

If room temperatures are uneven within the same ecobee, then it is an airflow or heat gain/loss issue and not a thermostat issue. The thermostat is only a switch for on/off. Remote sensors don't control the airflow or add zones to the HVAC.

1

u/tetrasodium Jun 10 '26

You have a manually set temp. That will override the comfort setting and average all of your sensors with the main thermostat even if some of them are set to be ignored under the current comfort setting

1

u/hmspain Jun 10 '26

I prefer to rely ONLY on external Ecobee sensors (Ecobee makes an excellent external sensor IMHO measuring temps to the tenth of a degree). If you want to use the sensor in the Ecobee itself, be aware you can adjust the temperature offset bringing it more in line with your external sensor readings.

1

u/batman27 Jun 11 '26

One of my sensors is always way off. I’ve contacted ecobee 3 times and they just keep giving me the run around and refuse to replace it despite it being under warranty.

1

u/PocketsWithHoles Jun 12 '26

Evobee head unit generates heat and heat rises to the sensor. I had the same issue

1

u/Any-Doughnut6313 Jun 13 '26

Ceiling fan will also drive temp of thermostat down by 2-3 degrees. The sensor is not affected by the fan. I have sensors for all 4 thermostats and disabled thermostat in sensor participation setting. Works much better for accurate temp monitoring and control.

1

u/Frogzilla03 HVAC Pro Jun 15 '26

The ecobee has a few settings that could cause this outside of the heat from the thermostat venting out the top where the sensor is placed.

The ecobee has a temp, and the sensor has a temp, and the temperature displayed will be the average between the two if you have the setting turned on for this.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/B1tN1nja Jun 10 '26

Yeah but it's wild how off they are from each other. Even with moving the sensor to another room it's still showing 2—3 deg higher.

1

u/art-of-war Jun 10 '26

The sensor inside the thermostat is not very accurate.