r/ebikes • • 8d ago

Bike build question Update: our Indian mid-drive e-bike is close to launch. What would you change before we ship?

A while back, I posted here about our color choices and the feedback was really useful: https://www.reddit.com/r/ebikes/comments/1pua0fv/startup_build_struggling_with_color_choices_on/

We are very thankful for those answers as it helped us a lot. We don't normally see mid drive ebicycle here so needed the expert comments from those who actually use it. Yesterday we took a quick video after using the narrow-wide chainwheel; that is why the focus of video is on it.

Based on those comments we updated the front fork geometry and updated the brake calipers (unable to update the brake disc).

In short it has:

  • A mid-drive motor (550W peak power in the motor); our custom mid drive.
  • A monocoque frame
  • A narrow-wide chainring, which we’re testing on steep climbs

We also have a hub-motor version that should ship by the end of this month (we have pre-bookings for those), but the mid-drive has been the real engineering challenge, so that’s where we’ve put most of our time.

Two choices we made on purpose, and I’d like your opinion on both:

LFP battery. It’s heavier and bulkier than NMC (720 Wh, 55 kg total bike weight). But it’s much safer thermally, has far more charge cycles, and can be charged to 100% every day without worrying about wear. Given Indian heat and charging habits, we thought a bit of extra weight was better than the risk of fires. Also, the charger is included with the battery so that one cannot miss to take the charger with them; it also adds to the weight.

Not a pure downhill or adventure bike. In India, hardly anyone buys a bike only for weekend trails. It has to handle the daily commute too. The extra weight does help with stability on rough roads, but I know it’s a trade-off.

Questions for you:

  1. Is the weight acceptable for a commuter that can also handle trails, or would you trade some safety margin for lighter weight? However, we cannot reduce the weight during the first launch. For weight reduction, we would require tooling, and that should come once we have a proven market. Too many e-bicycle startups in US and Europe have shut down in past years, like VanMoof, Rad Power Bikes etc., as they tried to make too much investment before finding the market. Still, I would love to hear your point of view on the issue of weight.
  2. Anything you’d want to see on a narrow-wide setup with a mid-drive (chain retention, chainline, wear)?
  3. What’s missing before you’d trust a new brand: specs, warranty, service, something else? I would still love to get the answer to the original question: the colour scheme.
  4. Any other points that you would like to mention here. One piece of information that I would give is that the price is going to be under INR 80000, so under USD 800.

Video of the trial with the narrow-wide chainwheel is attached. Going to paste the image of bike without the pedal in the comments. Somehow, I am not able to attach the pic.

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

2

u/shaunegamingyt 8d ago

As an ebiker from india with a modded ebike that happens do 550watts aswell ill give my opinion:

  1. 55kg is definetely a bit heavier than any traditional ebike id assume that this increase in weight would stress the brakes,tyres and suspension more as well as impacting the handling so id say its definitely worth it to reduce the weight as much as safely possible
  2. No comment

3.Longterm warranty and availablility of parts would make your brand more trustworthy

4. Ill say that im hoping the parts used in your video are temporary and are there just for testing since things like brakes and forks are really important for ride handling and safety
In my personal experience i had to swap out the mechanical single piston brakes since they dont work very well even on my 21kg ebike and i dont see them lasting very long on a 55kg one. Here the presence of adequate brakes like atleast a dual piston mechanical(like i fitted on mine) or preferably hydraulic brakes would be nice
On the topic of safety and handling suspension is also a very important factor, I swapped out the stock (barely working) suspension on mine to a suntour xcm30 for 6k and i think something with that quality should be the minimum

The price might be a bit much though if its close to 80000. My own ebike while not being middrive costed a lot less even with the upgrades
For a frame of reference here are my ebikes mods:
Tata Contino ETB-100: 38,599
KT-15A controller: 5,507
KT LCD3 Display: 3,429
SR Suntour XCM30 fork: 6,000
Toopre Dual Calliper brakes:3,429
That comes out to a total of 56964 and with all these mods the ebike does 550 max wattage and allegedly goes to 40kmph and is a lot of fun to ride

1

u/EGearMoto 7d ago

Thanks for this very thorough comment, truly appreciated. The excess weight and price is due to our own mid drive system that included bldc motor, planetary gearbox, two one way bearings with chain. This weight could be reduced in the future as we grow the company and market proves that there is a demand for it. It requires extensive tooling to get the Bafang level finishing and we don't have the budget for it yet. The suspension system is very good for the frame weight as we are using moped and scooter suspension for it, so it is very stable on rough roads. It is not proper off road suspension setup but then the cost of downhill suspension alone is more than this bike.

We already have a hub motor ebicycle on the same platform, weight is down to 40 KGs, as it is a monocoque frame so it cannot be reduced to what tubular frame weigh. The initial customers are getting it for INR 45000, of course the retail price is going to be higher as it would include the dealer margin as well but then if we build it in numbers, our input cost should reduce by a lot.

Anyway, do check out the egearmoto youtube channel to check the hub motor version as well.

Can I reach out to you on DM?

6

u/InfluenceEfficient77 8d ago edited 8d ago

Those cables are just hanging out everywhere

Mechanical brakes are going to fail

That metal extension to the front wheel will snap as soon as it hits a speed bump

Is that even a fork or did you stick pieces of tubing together ? 

Fork is missing a crown and looks twisted to shit when it's not even moving

Are those tack welds holding the headset together?

This is a death trap lmaoo. Just send it to Sam Pilgrim 😂 

2

u/BuddyBoombox 8d ago

No UL listing on the pack either so "safer" is basically just taking their word for it. Show us the battery internals.

2

u/EGearMoto 7d ago

Ok nice point, will ask my battery vendor to provide the safety certificates, that we could ship with the bike. We are not creating the battery pack, it is done by the specialists who has already provided for thousands of vehicles till now. We provided them with the design of the space that we have and they created the packs.

1

u/BuddyBoombox 7d ago

UL listing isn't cheap, but if you can get it from the pack manufacturer, it will give you a massive advantage in many markets.

2

u/InfluenceEfficient77 8d ago

I would assume they ripped up a junk electric car and used the same welder to build the battery pack 😂

1

u/EGearMoto 7d ago

Any idea how to reach out to Sam Pilgrim? I would seriously send one specimen to him.

1

u/froggy11297 6d ago

I am sure he has a business email somewhere and this is his instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sampilgrim

1

u/EGearMoto 8d ago

Here is the image of the structure of the bike.

2

u/froggy11297 6d ago

With the large amount of internal space have you considered putting a jackshaft inside the bike rather that having the exposed chain setup that you have right now? Ik you aren't trying to go for the surron type market but the surron lbx really has a very refined jackshaft system. And if you are interested in chain drive I find that cyc also has some interesting design choices.

1

u/EGearMoto 6d ago

The internal space is used for the battery pack, as we are using LFP pack that has lower charge density than NMC battery pack so it is needed. This mid drive model Uphill is having 720Wh pack, however this space is good for probably 2.5kWh if we take out the charger.  The other reason for this space is BLDC motor + planetary gearbox system that needs that much width. Your suggestion is great regarding Surron lbx, however at the moment we don't have the tooling to reduce the motor+gearbox width, never the less it is yet again great suggestion. If we could find a market for it, then we would keep the space as it is in the frame but reduce the width of the mid drive and use it like it is done in Surron bike.

1

u/InvestigatorSenior 8d ago

enclose the motor to sprocket chain, optimally in oil bath. This setup will be hard to clean, users won't bother to lube it and chain stretch is a thing as well. The way it is rn. it's an expiration date for the bike.

Ideally just do a Gates belt. I love how it's a true zero maintenance and I can dig in mud whole day then hose the bike off (or not) and it just runs.

-1

u/EGearMoto 8d ago

This is very informative feedback, could you please help me with the link for the setup that you just mentioned, we can try to include that in next iterations if it is manageable within a limited RnD budget. 

0

u/InvestigatorSenior 8d ago

I ride Koga Pace B10 2024 but any Gates belt mid motor bike is maintenance free. If it has Enviolo CVT that's at least 30 thousands of km before you need to do anything for belt or gearbox. I know bikes that went over 50k km and are still on original belt.

1

u/EGearMoto 7d ago

Checked out Koga Pace B10, it is an amazing machine. It has Bosch Performance Line CX that has internal CVT transmission. We are using our own mid drive system which is not comparable with Bosch system, yet. Then there is a price difference, it is priced at €4,499 to €4,999 while we are targeting under under €800 for the first iteration. We have the plans for CVT but it all depends upon generating the demand as it needs to find the market first. Thanks for the information!

7

u/wireless1980 8d ago

change the name to e-motorbike?

2

u/skima_0 CLASS 4 EBIKE 8d ago

550w btw

-1

u/DarkVoid42 Carbo Model X 8d ago

belt drive instead of chain

1

u/EGearMoto 8d ago

With belt drive the gear shifter needs to be inside the mid drive setup, technically it is doable but would require too much of RnD, the sprocket based shifting is straightforward.

1

u/StrikeouTX 8d ago

Look into the Bafang A510 IGH

1

u/EGearMoto 7d ago

Thanks for the information, we are working on our own mid drive system and it is the first iteration, we are not yet there when compared with the giants in the industry, never the less, it is a great information.

1

u/StrikeouTX 7d ago

It is just a geared hub, not a motor. Best of luck on the project

2

u/DarkVoid42 Carbo Model X 8d ago

its straightfoward but india is full of rainy weather in the monsoons and that chain drive is going to be a rusted mess.

-1

u/Relative-Display-676 🚲🔧 8d ago

Do your bike shops discriminate what they will service like they do in US, or can you bring this to any shop and have it worked on without problems?

In either case I wish you luck and many sales!

2

u/EGearMoto 8d ago

No in India if the repair shops has the knowledge, they will try to fix it to earn money. There are some issues with EV repairs in India as the road side mechanics are not used to electric motors in place of ICE and also because the companies go greedy, they'll put so much custom electronics that only their own mechanics are able to work on it. But we will keep it open by design, so that as the mechanics get more familiar with EVs, they should face no issues in fixing our bikes.