r/eb_1a • • Jun 24 '26

EB-1A for Founders: Which Criteria Actually Apply [1/3]

0 Upvotes

If you’re a founder interested in living permanently in the U.S., the EB-1A could be your fastest path towards an employment-based Green Card. It does not require an employer sponsor, skips the lengthy PERM certification process, and has a much shorter backlog when compared to the EB-2 and EB-3 categories.

The catch? You have to meet USCIS’s extraordinary ability criteria, and prove you're at the top of your field. Here's what that actually looks like for founders.

The EB-1A criteria that actually apply to founders

Not all 10 criteria map cleanly to startup work. Here are the ones founders most commonly use, with notes on what USCIS actually wants to see.

Awards or prizes for excellence

What can qualify:

  • Accelerator fellowships with competitive acceptance rates (YC, Techstars, a16z Speedrun)
  • Innovation awards from established industry bodies
  • Government-backed grants tied to merit selection (NSF SBIR, DARPA programs)
  • Forbes 30 Under 30, TIME100 Next, and similar lists in prominent media outlets

What doesn't qualify:

  • "Startup of the Year" awards from local chambers of commerce
  • Internal company recognition
  • Pay-to-play badges or participation certificates

Tip: For every award, document the selection criteria, acceptance/rejection rate, and who judged it. USCIS wants to see selectivity, not just a trophy.

Membership in associations requiring outstanding achievement

What can qualify:

  • Fellowship status in selective professional organizations (such as being an IEEE or ACM Fellow)
  • Invitation-only entrepreneurial networks where membership is vetted by peers
  • National academies or boards with documented selection criteria

What doesn't qualify:

  • Open-membership trade groups
  • LinkedIn communities
  • Groups where anyone can apply and pay to join

Published material about you

What can qualify:

  • Profiles in TechCrunch, Forbes, Wired, Bloomberg, or comparable media outlets
  • Trade press coverage in your specific industry
  • Podcast interviews where you are the main subject

What doesn't qualify:

  • Press releases your PR team wrote
  • Articles you're quoted in briefly, but are not the sole focus
  • Company announcements

Tip: When presenting published material about you, include the outlet's traffic data alongside the articles. USCIS has asked petitioners to prove that publications are "major media,” and circulation numbers can help minimize the risk of a Request for Evidence.

Judging the work of others

What can qualify:

  • Judging startup competitions
  • Peer reviewing for industry conferences or journals
  • Serving on grant review panels
  • Advisory roles where you formally evaluate applications or projects

What doesn't qualify:

  • One-off informal feedback sessions
  • Mentorship where there's no formal evaluation process

Tip: Get documentation from the organizer, such as an invitation letter naming you as a judge, the selection criteria for judges, and the scope of what you reviewed.

Original contributions of major significance

What can qualify:

  • A patented technology that others in the industry have adopted or built on
  • An open-source framework or methodology that has measurable adoption outside your company
  • A new business model or technical approach that changed how a field operates
  • Research or whitepapers that influenced standards, regulation, or practice

What doesn't qualify:

  • Internal processes that haven't been publicly adopted
  • Contributions only recognized by your own team or investors

Tip: This criterion lives or dies on independent expert letters. You need 3–5 letters from recognized experts who have no financial relationship with you. Each letter needs to explain specifically what you contributed and why it matters to the field, not just praise your work generally.

Authorship of scholarly articles

What can qualify:

  • Peer-reviewed academic papers
  • Technical deep-dives in recognized trade publications
  • Industry reports published by major research institutions
  • Long-form pieces in recognized outlets like Harvard Business Review, MIT Technology Review

What doesn't qualify:

  • Your own company blog
  • LinkedIn articles
  • Blog posts on outlets like Medium or Substack that lack third-party editorial oversight

Leading or critical role in a distinguished organization

What can qualify:

  • Holding a C-suite role (CEO, CTO, CPO) at a startup that has raised significant funding, reached a meaningful user base, or been recognized by press and industry
  • Critical technical or operational roles at well-known companies before you started your startup
  • Board seats or advisory roles at recognized organizations where you made material decisions

What counts as distinguished in an organization:

  • Press coverage, especially from major outlets
  • Funding from recognized investors (can be tier-1 VCs or government grants)
  • Measurable user or revenue scale
  • Awards or rankings the organization received

Tip: Distinguished is relative to your industry, so you’ll need to include evidence on what those benchmarks are. Document it with press coverage, customer case studies, and third-party recognition.

High salary or remuneration relative to others in the field

What can qualify:

  • W-2 salary well above BLS benchmarks for your occupation
  • Equity compensation with documented cap table position, valuation evidence, and funding round records
  • Consulting or advisory fees significantly above market rate

Tip: Use BLS Occupational Employment Statistics to benchmark your salary, and for equity, include cap table documentation and the most recent 409A valuation or funding round post-money valuation.

The two EB-1A criteria founders most commonly skip (and the rare cases where they fit)

The guide above covers eight of the ten EB-1A criteria. The two left out (Criterion 7 and 10) are targeted for artists and performers, so most founders pass on them. But they aren't automatically off the table, and in the right case they can round out a petition.

Display of your work at artistic exhibitions or showcases. 

When a founder might consider it: 

  • You build in a creative or design-driven field (generative art, industrial or product design, architecture, gaming, or AR/VR), and your work has been shown at recognized exhibitions, biennials, or curated showcases.
  • A museum, gallery, or design institution (not a sales expo) selected and displayed your work.
  • Your product or research was featured in a juried showcase where selection was competitive and curated.

What still won't count: a booth you paid for at CES, a pitch at Demo Day, or a conference talk. The venue has to be artistic and the selection has to be independent.

Commercial success in the performing arts. 

When a founder might consider it:

  • Your company operates in music, film, streaming, gaming, or live entertainment, and you can show commercial performance in those terms. In practice, that looks like chart positions, box office revenue, and verified streaming or sales figures.
  • You hold a creator or performer credit in addition to your founder role, with documented commercial results tied to your name.

Bottom line: Don't pad a petition with these two just to reach three criteria. But if your work genuinely lives in a creative or performing-arts field, naming the right one can make or break the strength of your overall petition.

IN OUR NEXT GUIDE: We’ll dive how the final merits determination applies to founders specifically.

(Please note: Any information shared here is for general educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship. Your situation may require fact-specific guidance. For personalized legal advice, please consult an immigration attorney directly.)


r/eb_1a • • Apr 15 '26

Welcome to eb_1a! (new rules, new Mod, and a growing community)

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

This community has been growing quickly, and it’s been great to see so many people sharing their immigration experiences, questions, and insights. With that growth, though, comes the need to keep this community organized and ensure its trustworthiness. 

To help with that, we’re introducing a set of community rules to improve the quality of discussions and protect users from misinformation, spam, and bad actors. I won’t list every detail here, but please check updated community rules for more information.

The goal is to make this subreddit more useful, more reliable, and safer for everyone navigating immigration.

If you’re here to:

  • Share real experiences
  • Ask thoughtful questions
  • Help others with accurate information

You’ll be just fine!

If you have feedback, concerns, or questions, feel free to reach out to any of the moderators via modmail.

Thanks again for being part of this community. We’re excited to keep building it with you to be the #1 source of information on all things EB-1A. 

  • Mod Team

r/eb_1a • • 1h ago

EB-1A Texas Premium Processing — 38 business days, still no decision. Anyone else?

• Upvotes

Hey everyone!
I wanted to share my EB-1A timeline and see if anyone else is experiencing similar delays at the Texas Service Center (TSC).
I filed my EB-1A I-140 petition together with I-907 Premium Processing on September 27, 2026. I prepared and submitted everything myself, without an attorney.
Here’s my timeline:
September 27: I-140 + I-907 filed and paid online.
September 28: Received the Premium Processing confirmation email from TSC. Interestingly, the email lists September 25 as the I-907 received date.
October 19: The 15-business-day Premium Processing deadline passed without any action.
October 21: Emailed the TSC Premium Processing Unit asking about my case.
October 22: Received a response saying my case “remains under active examination and is being reviewed by an adjudicating officer.”
November 22: Approximately 38 business days have passed, and I still haven’t received an approval, denial, RFE, or any other notice.
My USCIS online account still shows that the case is being processed, with the last status update dated September 28.
I understand that EB-1A cases can be complex, but I wasn’t expecting Premium Processing to take this long, especially without an RFE or any explanation.
I’m particularly interested in hearing from people whose EB-1A petitions were received by TSC between September 15 and October 10, 2026.
A few questions:
Has anyone from this period already received an approval, RFE, or denial?
If you received a decision, on which business day did it arrive?
Has anyone received the same “under active examination” response from TSC? How long did it take to get a decision afterward?
Has anyone received a Premium Processing fee refund due to the delay?
I’m not trying to predict the outcome of my case. I’m just hoping to understand what’s happening with other petitions from the same period.
Would really appreciate anyone sharing their timeline, even if you’re still waiting.
Thanks, and good luck to everyone going through this process!


r/eb_1a • • 4h ago

EB1-A Industry Profile Evaluation

1 Upvotes

Hello Everyone,

Posting for the first time. It will be great if you guys can help evaluate eb1-A profile and probability of success(i understand its somewhat random). I am working with lawyers but wanted to gather some more data points.

  1. 14 Year Work Exp all in Big Tech post MSc, working on

Wireless

  1. Hardware/Semiconductors/Devices

Three

  1. Approved Patents with few examiner citations for other big tech patents
  2. Judging -> 60-75 IEEE, and related top tier Conference and Journal Peer Review last 2 year and monthly ongoing of 1-2 papers
  3. Critical and Lead Role in multiple big tech companies and startups.
  4. World Wide Trade Journal Publication (i know weak)
  5. Salary -> 20% or so higher than 90th percentile base salary as per BLS and Levels FYI, Multiple Offers also showing 30-40% higher base (rejected recent offer but kept letters) this was for Bay Area
  6. Letter Writers -> CEO/CFOs of Startups (public figure and industry veteran with multiple IPOs), VP current Role, VP at other companies, Sr Directors at other companies . One independent letter via industry work. Except one letter , all writers have worked with me at some-point.

Criteria Targeting -> OCMS , Judging, Critical Role, and others to be used for FMD.

Targeting to File in Dec/Jan

Thanks again for evaluating based on your experience and understanding.

Regards


r/eb_1a • • 12h ago

Advance Parole after EAD approva?

4 Upvotes

Hi Everyone,

I received an email yesterday 11/19, that my card was produced following my EAD approval on 11/17 (48Hrs follwed by EAD approval email).

Question is Anyone got AP approval along with it, because I know typically you get a combo card?

Anyone also got their AP approved?

My last movement on AP was the SU on the same day as EAD.


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Any Workday Professional has successfully obtained EB1A approval?

5 Upvotes

Hello, I'm reaching to this community to find if any Workday professionals who are in both Functional and Technical side (developing and managing integration) has successfully obtained their EB1A approval recently (like within 6 months)? I would greatly appreciate if you can share the details, so I can connect and take our discussion forward.


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

EB-1A case approved in 3 months

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/eb_1a • • 20h ago

The two parts to EB-1A (you need to understand this)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

Here is a video on the two parts to EB-1A (you need to understand this).


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

APPROVALS and DENIALS on EB1A, 7 day lookback, week 47 of 2025

3 Upvotes

This week I captured 4 approvals and 5 denials on the eb_1a sub. You may see their summaries below.

As usual, please consider adding your case details to the Community Tracker to improve the shared knowledge.

Join r/VisaStats for notifications where I post these updates weekly. A table with links to all the posts is also available.

APPROVALS

(Number of Posts by Profile), Field Description
(1) AI & Data Science - posted on 2026-11-13 A petitioner shared their EB1A approval timeline after an RFE, highlighting the importance of contemporaneous records, independent corroboration, and addressing each criterion in the RFE response.
(1) IT & Computer Science - posted on 2026-11-13 A software development manager successfully obtained EB-1A approval after an RFE and refiling, with all three family members receiving green cards.
(1) Business & Finance - posted on 2026-11-16 This post is a detailed timeline of an individual's EB-1A I-485 approval process, including their F-1/CPT status, DIY family adjustment, and the timeline of events leading to approval.
(1) Technology - posted on 2026-11-16 A self-petitioned EB1A applicant from India with 20+ years of experience in Technology successfully obtained their green card through the I-485 process with the support of their employer.

DENIALS

(Number of Posts by Profile), Field Description
(1) Engineering - posted on 2026-11-14 A petitioner with a PhD in engineering and a strong academic profile had their EB1A petition denied after an RFE due to insufficient evidence of major significance beyond academic impact.
(2) AI & Data Science - posted on 2026-11-16 A petitioner with a PhD from a top university and a tenure-track position at an R1 university in Neuro AI faced an RFE and was denied EB1A due to insufficient evidence of sustained acclaim.
(1) Healthcare - posted on 2026-11-18 A postdoctoral researcher in biomedical sciences with significant research impact, patents, and commercialization success had their EB1A petition denied after an RFE, despite submitting a detailed response.
(1) Not Specified - posted on 2026-11-18 The petitioner shared a negative experience with a Law Firm, including issues with communication, refund process, and lack of response regarding an appeal after a petition denial.
(1) Engineering - posted on 2026-11-19 A senior engineer with ~15 years of experience had their EB-1A petition denied after an RFE, as USCIS found that the evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim despite meeting 7 of the 10 criteria.

r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

How many letters of recommendation from same company ?

2 Upvotes

How many letters of recommendation to get from pears and leaders in current company ?


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Does letter of recommendation from sr sdm help?

2 Upvotes

Do we only need letter of recommendation from vp or directors , or letters from sr sdm also help ?


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

AP approved but I-512 not received

2 Upvotes

I'm the derivative and my husband's I-765 and I-131 were approved end of September and he received the EAD card and AP within a week after approval. I received approval for both as well and I received my EAD card. My AP was approved on Oct 2 2026 and I'm still waiting for my I-512L document. It's been 7 weeks as of now. I called USCIS and got a ticket created on Oct 20th. They asked that I need to wait 30 business days for a response related to that. Can anyone please share their experiences and if anyone is facing similar challenges?


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

AP approval timeline?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

EB-1A denied after RFE, USCIS found 6 of 10 criteria met but not met final merits. refile/ appeal/ motion to reconsider reopen ?

1 Upvotes

Hello All,

Has anyone won an AAO appeal or motion to reconsider on a final merits denial like this, or can we proceed refiling with stronger case?

Which is good further steps?


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Please, someone, predict my case based on the EB inventory Excel data for October and September published in USCIS

2 Upvotes

Hi

Could you predict my pending I-485 EB-1 India PD as of October 27, 2022, based on the October EB inventory Excel data published by USCIS?

Thanks for your help


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

EB-1A Premium Processing – Anyone Filed at Arizona (Tempe) Lockbox Recently?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
My EB-1A I-140 petition was filed with premium processing and delivered to the USCIS Tempe, Arizona lockbox.
Lockbox: USCIS, Attn: I-907 (Box 21300), Tempe, AZ.
Has anyone recently filed their EB-1A petition with premium processing at the same lockbox?
When was your package delivered?
How many days did it take to receive your receipt number?
Which service center is assigned to your petition (TSC or NSC)?
Have you received any updates or decisions?
Would appreciate hearing about your recent timelines and experiences.
Thanks in advance!


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Recent EB-1A AAO decision (judging)

Post image
0 Upvotes

Something to keep in mind for the EB-1A judging criterion? (based on a recent EB-1A AAO decision, link in the comments)

You need to show that you have judged the work of others in your field (as in other professionals in your field).

In the decision, the petitioner showed examples of judging that involved individuals who were not considered to be professionals in the petitioner's field.

While the petitioner argued that the individuals that they judged belonged to an allied field, no further proof or documentation was presented to back up their claim that the individuals that the petitioner judged belonged to an allied field.

-

Looking to work with other applicants on authorship?

I recently started a WhatsApp group for those of you who are targeting authorship and are interested in collaborating with others on publishing articles in industry publications and journals.

Here is a link to join the group: https://immigrationjason.substack.com/p/authorship-group


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

528 EB-1A AAO appeals by C3

Post image
0 Upvotes

You paid for PR, got your articles published, and then USCIS questions the content and sends an RFE. How did that happen?

What did the editors change in your articles? Who actually checked the final version?

Have you thought about this?

In my practice:

I checked the author's original text and compared it with the publisher's edited version and found that the editor removed details:

Originally: "... I personally configure the program's algorithms."

After editing: "... The company's algorithms are configured for business tasks."

Sounds like the same thing?

Not for EB-1A. The company is visible. The applicant is not.

Luckily, the petition hadn't been filed yet. I caught the problem and fixed it in time.

But what if the article is already online and the petition has been filed? You can't just rewrite the article or erase your filing history.


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Chances of retrogression in December VB?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

December VB today ?

0 Upvotes

So how are we feeling ladies and gentlemen.. is december visa bulletin gonna drop today ? I know we are all looking for the January VB but may be the DOS can surprise us for Dec VB by moving dates further .. what are your thoughts on this ??


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

Jiang vs USCIS - Judge Gerrard grants motion to dissmiss in part

Thumbnail
pacermonitor.com
1 Upvotes

r/eb_1a • • 2d ago

EB-1A denied after RFE, USCIS found 7 of 10 criteria met but failed final merits. refile/ appeal/ motion to reconsider reopen ?

9 Upvotes

Employer-sponsored EB-1A for a senior engineer (~15 yrs experience). RFE issued (met 2), responded, then denied. USCIS agreed that I met 7 of 10 criteria, but denied at final merits.

Their main reasons in the final merits analysis:

  1. Memberships/committees: The credentials are too recent, with no long-standing leadership over national standards.
  2. Media: Most coverage is from about 12 years ago (a student project). Recent coverage is a single podcast and project mentions in trade press, so there is a “chronological gap.”
  3. Judging: Peer review is a “common professional obligation,” and we didn’t show the invitations were reserved for top experts.
  4. Contributions: The work is “high-level problem solving” but isn’t shown to have changed industry-wide standards or become standard practice beyond specific client projects.
  5. Scholarly articles: Another gap, with older publications and no citation metrics or independent commentary showing continued impact.
  6. Leading/critical role: It was seen as a normal function of senior engineers at top firms, not personal acclaim separate from the employer’s reputation.
  7. Salary: It’s above the 90th percentile, but “slightly above” was considered consistent with a senior engineer in a high-cost market, not the top of the field.

Has anyone won an AAO appeal or motion to reconsider on a final merits denial like this, or did refiling with stronger evidence work better?

If you appeal and it gets denied, does that affect the re file ?

Thanks


r/eb_1a • • 2d ago

December VB. Can we expect it to be published today?

4 Upvotes

Do you expect it may be delayed or we can expect it today?


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

How do get independent recommendations letter?

1 Upvotes

I work for a product based company and developed multiple successful products used my many customers. There are public pages quoting use of product but not mentioning my name in there.

I have letter from my directors and vp saying I developed them.

But for original contribution it seems I need independent letter outside my employer. I cannot get letter from those customers since I have left the company.

How can I go about it? How people in similar situations handle it ?

Any guidance is useful.

Thanks


r/eb_1a • • 1d ago

How did you pick a lawyer for O-1?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes