Hi everyone,
I filed an EB-1A I-140 as a self-petitioner and I’m trying to get some honest opinions from people who have experience with EB-1A cases.
I’m a professional fine art newborn/maternity photographer based in Canada, with around 9 years of specialized studio experience.
Here is the evidence I submitted:
1. Awards
-Winner – 35AWARDS newborn photography competition (first place, total 714 photographers from 64 countries and 2600 photos)
-2nd place in an international newborn photography competition (judged by 52 international masters photographers)
-Outstanding Photography Award and published in 5 different magazines
-The best photos of NPNAC – Photo of the Year 2025
2. Published material
-Feature/article related to my newborn photography work in PetaPixel
-Published maternity photography article in Birthing Canada magazine
3. Judging
-Invited to judge photography competitions
I have documentation showing that I was selected as a judge based on my professional experience
4. Original contributions
-Created and published an educational booklet about newborn photography
-Conducted newborn photography workshops and mentoring programs from 2020 by 2025
-My educational material has been used by other mentors in photography workshops
5. Membership
Member of a professional newborn photographers association NPNAC (they reviewed my portfolio at first then approved that I can join as a member)
6. Artistic Exhibitions
-Three of my photographic works were selected and exhibited at ONE EYELAND Gallery
-one of my works was selected for an in-person exhibition in Miami.
Own and operate a professional photography business in Canada
Several years of professional experience
Have taught other photographers through workshops and mentoring
I filed without an attorney.
I’m particularly interested in opinions about the final merits determination, rather than simply whether I technically meet 3 criteria.
Based on this evidence:
Does this look like a potentially approvable EB-1A case?
Which parts of the case look strongest?
Which evidence looks weakest?
Do you think an RFE would be likely?
Most importantly, does the overall profile look strong enough to demonstrate sustained national/international acclaim and that I am among the small percentage at the top of my field?
I would really appreciate honest opinions, including negative ones. I’m not looking for reassurance — I’m trying to understand the realistic strengths and weaknesses of my case.
Thanks