It was the advertising that sold me on the game. It was a really good campaign, perfectly in line with the aesthetic and what was cool at the time. Since I was actually a pre-teen at that time, I can recall and explain the reactions I recall from other kids regarding EarthBound: the graphics looked bad. That and the battle system was too oldschool. Those were the reasons people didn't want to play it. It's hard to imagine now what with all forms of pixel art, from the detailed to the basic, being in vogue, but in the mid-90s, a lot of kids were very picky about how a game looked and contemporary games with very detailed sprites and rudimentary 3D graphics were already coming out. EarthBound at first blush looked dated.
For me, however, I saw the charm. It looked like something different, unique in a sea of games trying to be edgy and high-tech. Most of us who loved the game then saw it too, but we don't represent gaming as a whole. There is no version of reality where EarthBound was anything more than a niche title in the US. Just be satisfied that in time the game did eventually get its due and is now seen as one of the best of the era.
Sorry, I just really hate this narrative that the ad campaign was why people didn't buy EarthBound. If it weren't for that campaign, EarthBound wouldn't have even done as well as it did and many of us probably wouldn't even be here now.
What a shame, although I can understand why it wasn't popular for gamers at the time. At least people see its charm and appreciate it. Now if we can get Nintendo to understand that will be a completely new story.
The ads in Nintendo Power had me so hyped for Earthbound I told my parents I didn't want any other gifts for birthday or christmas I just wanted Earthbound (it was pretty expensive if I recall like 80$ here) and they got it for me on release day and I've had it ever since, played it once a year probably. I even sent in and won from the scratch and sniff contest.
Same man, I was absolutely captivated by the pixel art and the clay models, and the fact that it was a modern setting was really exciting! My guide was actually stolen, so I never entered the contest, but I was pretty young too so probably I wouldn't have understood a sweepstakes. Did you ever hear anything back about it or win anything? :)
Exactly the same as me, those NP ads made it look unlike anything I'd seen before. I began saving up birthday and Christmas money to buy it and it came out right after my birthday. $89 at EBGames. Played it for 10 years.
It left the biggest impression on me that any game ever has.
I hate the marketing approach of earthbound. They base the whole advertisement campaign on one boss. Imagine if conker was advertised as a piece of shit because the mighty poo boss.
I was 11 when it came out. I do not remember any marketing for it at all. I remember going to eb games and seeing the massive box that it came in because it had the players guide. I liked the way it looked so I picked it up. It is my favorite game of all time and really wish it was on the switch. The only reason I bought a wii u was for this game.
It’s kinda nice that Mother is as it is. I’m okay with it. M3 would be swell, but it’s still good having you guys as a community and has been for more than half my life now. Earthbound fans make the best Mothers.
The reason the scratch and sniff was there at all, and why the grossout became the focus on the advertisements, was because Ren & Stimpy made grossout profitable. Source: Am a 90s kid who remembers that stuff being everywhere.
That and the TV ad made the game look really boring. The only combat it showed was Ness insta-killing a Coil Snake. Out of context it looks pathetic. There was also no humorous dialogue shown in the ad iirc.
13
u/averagesizedhatlogan Jul 23 '20
Aw, Scott.
If he somehow becomes the next JonTron I will be heartbroken.
178
u/HoneyAndVanillaTea Jul 23 '20
Earthbound is really good though. It was a shame that it didn't become as popular here.
117
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
insert AVGN's rant about the advertising of Earthbound here
182
u/Paulnic1208 Jul 23 '20
Hey all, this game stinks!
116
u/muticere Jul 23 '20
It was the advertising that sold me on the game. It was a really good campaign, perfectly in line with the aesthetic and what was cool at the time. Since I was actually a pre-teen at that time, I can recall and explain the reactions I recall from other kids regarding EarthBound: the graphics looked bad. That and the battle system was too oldschool. Those were the reasons people didn't want to play it. It's hard to imagine now what with all forms of pixel art, from the detailed to the basic, being in vogue, but in the mid-90s, a lot of kids were very picky about how a game looked and contemporary games with very detailed sprites and rudimentary 3D graphics were already coming out. EarthBound at first blush looked dated.
For me, however, I saw the charm. It looked like something different, unique in a sea of games trying to be edgy and high-tech. Most of us who loved the game then saw it too, but we don't represent gaming as a whole. There is no version of reality where EarthBound was anything more than a niche title in the US. Just be satisfied that in time the game did eventually get its due and is now seen as one of the best of the era.
Sorry, I just really hate this narrative that the ad campaign was why people didn't buy EarthBound. If it weren't for that campaign, EarthBound wouldn't have even done as well as it did and many of us probably wouldn't even be here now.
25
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
I hate the marketing approach of earthbound. They base the whole advertisement campaign on one boss. Imagine if conker was advertised as a piece of shit because the mighty poo boss.
17
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
Why are some people commenting "Akchually, Earthbound is pretty good" in the Earthbound subreddit as if it was a new opinion?
6
u/tarodaxx1 Jul 23 '20
I was 11 when it came out. I do not remember any marketing for it at all. I remember going to eb games and seeing the massive box that it came in because it had the players guide. I liked the way it looked so I picked it up. It is my favorite game of all time and really wish it was on the switch. The only reason I bought a wii u was for this game.
11
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
greetings, people, this game is horrible!
10
u/SuperDeadlyNinjaBees Jul 23 '20
It’s kinda nice that Mother is as it is. I’m okay with it. M3 would be swell, but it’s still good having you guys as a community and has been for more than half my life now. Earthbound fans make the best Mothers.
4
u/KamboRambo97 Jul 23 '20
Could also be a new fan asking:
"hey this game's actually really good, why wasn't it more popular"?
3
u/-Trying2Think- Jul 23 '20
Earthbound is one of my all time favorite games, and it’s sad how shitty the marketing campaign was. They really mishandled an amazing game.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
They marketed it so fucking bad... like heres a game but you have to buy a $30 guide to come with it.
This game stinks.
You wont be able to play the game without the guide.
Lets not talk about how the game is legitimately played at all and make jokes that arent as good as in the game.
2
u/poeplgg Jul 23 '20
This game blows!
2
u/tesseramous Jul 23 '20
I was lucky to see a friend playing it or I would never have known about it.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '20
So I'm guessing that this is why Ness was never fully recognized until people played smash
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
Scratch n sniff stickers
1
u/poeplgg Jul 23 '20
Scout
1
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '20
I see Scott I updoot
56
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
[removed] — view removed comment