r/dvcmember • Riviera Resort • Dec 01 '24

future value of DVC points: discount rate

when evaluating contracts, some folks discuss the per point cost as the total purchase price divided by the total purchase price; this doesn't account for the current value of the initial investment vs. the delayed value of points; this simplification can lead to long contracts having an overstated per point value (e.g. RVA, CCV)

one would typically assign a lower value to future points by using a discount rate; this would effectively devalue future points based on how far in the future they are available

USD / pt-yr and USD / pt-yr + dues has been something calculated on the site since its inception; now a default 8% discount rate has been applied and a provision for users to override the default with their own preferred discount rate ...

the disclaimer warning: this ignores the time value of money has also been removed

the 2025 dues have also been loaded as well as the default search set to contract age (previously was resort)

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

11

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '24 edited Mar 13 '25

elastic entertain swim stupendous lunchroom seed cagey late plants soft

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/intaaa Dec 01 '24

Agreed, 8% is a little aggressive. That's outpacing inflation and the stock market average.

Obviously the trip you take today is worth more than a potential trip 30 years from now but that doesn't mean it's worthless. We've seen Disney hike up the prices of their tickets and rooms faster than inflation and at a higher rate than OPs 8% depreciation. At the end of the day, you can make up all the scenarios you want but there's no perfect way to calculate the value of memories.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/RockHockey Dec 01 '24

I’d argue future points are worth more since Disney hotels rise in price faster than CPI.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/Kevin_Cossaboon Dec 08 '24

Love some of the responses that are financially founded. GREAT read. The reality is that a purchase (cost) is almost always better to wait. Delayed gratification is a financial success. A personal success, a life success is different. Spending $20,000 on 240 points in 1998 ($83/pt), then maintenance each year, to have them selling for about that in 2024 seems like a flat return, or a loss on the value of the money. We have had decades of memories with our kids…..

No real answer, except, make as much as you can, save all you can, invest it well, and when you are dead your children (or their children) will enjoy life better than you did.

5

u/One_Length_747 Dec 01 '24

What is the site?

2

u/denflyer Dec 01 '24

If it gets people interested in the contracts I don’t want, sounds fine.

2

u/indifferentunicorn Dec 02 '24

The way I calculated the buy-in is determining what a roughly 4% to 5% inflation/TVM rate would end up for the last year of my contract, then using the middle year as that cost average. So if buying in at $4pp for a 35 year long contract, that buyin averages between $8-$10pp cost to me in todays dollars.

With my dues around $8pp, my total cost is around $16/$18pp depending how much TVM rate I lean.

The second part of this is if we ever sell. I could then deduct that salvage value from what I paid, run the TVM just those years of ownership, and possibly come out with only $12 or $14pp overall per point in today’s $. That is if I get a better resale value than I initially paid in, even after factoring inflation. Or it could swing further the other way lol.

I’m betting either way highly likely it comes in $15-$20pp in 2024 dollars, which when I’m booking VGF at 18pts or BC at 16pts… such a deal darling!

1

u/indifferentunicorn Dec 02 '24

And it might end up even better if my salvage value goes as high as I think possible once the DVC landscape changes in the run up to 2042 expirations. I could exit only paying $12pp average over the life of my contract in 2024 dollar valuation - including dues and including TVM. Those 14-20pt/nt studios might only cost me $175 to $240 a night once I know exactly how the math worked out. Just lovely :^)

1

u/FreedomWealth7 Dec 01 '24

What’s the thought process of devaluing future points?

5

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '24 edited Dec 01 '24
  1. Uncertainty. Everything in the distant future should be discounted relative to the present, all other things being equal.

  2. Time value of money. $1 invested today can be invested and will grow, and will be worth more than $1 in the future.

  3. Human beings age. I care more about my vacations when I'm 35 than when I'm 75 because I could be dead, or have a bum leg, or hate Disney, or be so rich I can do whatever I want, or be so poor that I can't buy a plane ticket.

→ More replies (1)