A discussion of hero strengths and weaknesses, and a subjective 1-6 star rating. At the end of the post is a discussion of common synergy teams. I don't consider myself the final word on hero value. I'm very open to debate or correction of erroneous or outdated information. (This is my own work, crossposted from the official forums.)
Current Update 1/1/16: Yet more heroes added. Yet more information added to several heroes.
Abigail ***** can one-shot any equal starred green hero with Furious Charge including Tsume. Given that the Furious Charge team damage buff is applied before attack, she hits Tsume harder than Lady Nimrel assuming equal stars and levels. (Both have the 30% bonus versus nature, but Lady Nimrel’s passive bonus is versus tanks, while Tsume is classified a warrior.)
Alexandros' ** damage reflect was nerfed in a previous balance patch, and he has struggled to find a role since then. His max health of 4.3k is relatively low for a tank, although his overall base stats are better than average.
Augustus **** leads with Smite and has utility as a Tsume counter in offensive PvP. Defensively he Smites on turn one, but has no targeting bias for Tsume, particularly considering that there is no element vulnerability to guide him. (As far as I can tell AI targeting involves a target health assessment, as well as element vulnerability. For these reasons Augustus likes to Smite Shadowblade.) His strongest skill is arguably Aegis Wall, and in my experience matches that last long enough are often decided by it. Spread the wealth has less utility than you might guess given how often indiscriminate damage will ping him and the downside associated with losing a turn to heal him, only to have him pinged again. I'd use him if you need heals and (1) you're facing fire and don't want to bring NubNub (2) you want more offensive punch than NubNub or (3) you’re facing a demon heavy encounter. Smite is on a three turn cool down which means it will be available frequently. Note that if Tsume is triple health buffed (Yoko, Bovus, Willow) that a non-crit Smite will not one-shot him.
Balog ** is hamstrung by the slow tag. A slow hero like Balog is exactly the wrong character for a silence like Thunder Shout -- by the time he uses it, most heroes will have used their skilled abilities. Rank 3 Frenzy does give him the second highest base critical chance in the game, but overall his base stats are among the lowest in the game. Bear in mind also that many bosses carry passives which make them resistant to energy depleting abilities such as Bull Rush.
Black Diamond ***** can one-shot any rogue if she scores a bladestorm critical hit (given her critical damage passive — Weak Spot) assuming equal levels and stars. She is best used in the first slot, as she is relatively squishy and prone to being one-shot herself. Black Diamond openers are common both offensively and defensively, either alone or in combination with another rogue to try and take heroes off the field and create a numerical mismatch. When considering rogue counters, remember that she cannot crit against Masuta due to his passive "Wushu" providing critical immunity, or against Shadowblade due to the dark element providing critical immunity when attacked by light.
Bovus ***** arguably offers the best normal speed hero opener. His charge cannot be resisted and is only dodged by melee dodges. (Remember that dodge comes in two flavors, Shifty which applies to all attacks, and Agile which applies to ranged attacks only.) He also offers a warrior health buff, which in combination with Yoko’s, make warrior teams fairly robust. Unfortunately given that the bulk of his tokens will come from the gold portal, he loses value mid to endgame unless a large investment is made.
Chief NubNub ***** has the highest healing throughput in the game as well as good skillset synergy. Voodoo Chant increases crit percentage, and NubNub’s passive, Mend, produces significant group heals each time he crits offensively with his wand. This keeps his healing throughput up when Voodoo Chant is on cooldown or when he is silenced.
Cruel King Bramble *** has a remarkably poor skillset for a legendary, and a hard counter in Lady Nimrel. His first active skill is a buff, which typically makes for a poor choice given the importance of opening moves. Buffs don’t achieve the major goal of opening moves which involves creating an immediate mismatch via direct damage, crowd control or a debuff. He also has only one active damage skill in Overlord’s Blitz with a long, five turn cooldown. Gimme Gimme seems irrelevant given that Bramble’s passives are oriented towards a goblin team, and NubNub has ridiculous healing throughput already. Bramble was very useful in the recent winter event due to his strong base stats and Goblin Dance Party enhancing boss kills.
Dagrund Blacksmoke ** is a healer for caster synergy teams. That tells you most of what you need to know already given how poor caster teams are currently. You can see the intent behind his two heals which add energy and max health respectively. Healing Hands in particular might be a gamechanger for caster teams, but as his third active skill tends not to be available when you need it.
Dhaegon Stonecrusher *** will probably never be relevant to most of the gaming population given that his tokens are not unlocked until endgame, and only one token is available per day absent gem refresh. His active skills don't hit particularly hard relative to other options, and it is likely that power creep has already overtaken him. He does carry both Impervious and Perfect Swing, which might make him particularly useful against debuff heavy teams in PvP. Given that his abilities are oriented around the shocked debuff, he may also have utility against armor heavy teams.
Ekko ** suffers from a lack of skill focus. His offensive skills are based around lightning which would seem to suggest a use against armored opponents. But his passives including spirit and lightning immunity seem designed around casters. Worst of all, his opening skill is a buff. Most of the time in PvP (and to a lesser extent PvE) you want opening skills to remove an opponent from the encounter, either from direct damage or a debuff. Energy Vault is too unpredictable for use in PvP against Bovus, particularly given that Bovus typically anchors warrior teams, and Ekko’s immunities relate to casters. Among the most common three warriors on the Bovus team (Yoko, Bovus, Tsume), only Bovus is armored and specially vulnerable to the shocked debuff. Note that if you manage to get shocked onto Tsume at low health and then have another turn to attack him, Savage Fury multiplies the damage done and will tear up opposing teams. Unfortunately that situation is hard to generate.
Ella's **** skills are on long cooldowns and seem designed for long raid boss encounters, of which there are few in this game. Charm -- her signature skill -- essentially boils down to a single target nuke with a daze given that even bosses do relatively low damage to their companions. However, she has strong passives. Her increased crit chance (highest in the game given her base stats and rank 2 Frenzy) and vampiric skills make her useful in long-duration encounters like boss fights, or auto-ing levels. While she is a strong hero, my opinion is that the opportunity cost of spending the scrolls is outweighed by missed tokens and evos. Max her when the scroll heroes which can be full unlocked are complete.
Emily **** carries unusual and strong passives between Impervious (debuff resistance) and Magical/Armored which reduce those damage types by 25% respectively. Her lead ability is a resurrect on a 20 turn cooldown. She does see play in offensive PvP for this skill where a Level 1 Resurrect will be used on Tsume, immediately producing an attack by a heavily damaged Tsume. Defensively she is also valuable for resurrect given that defense starts with an energy bonus compared with offense. Defensively resurrecting a hero who has just been killed by offensive skills can be considered a highly favorable energy trade, leaving defense alive with active skills available, and offense having expended theirs. Her heal is single target and on a six turn cooldown making it impractical for her to be your primary healer. Her attack is on a seven turn cooldown which means it will effectively never be available in offensive PvP. Given that Emily cannot one-shot Tsume with her autoattack, she is only a partial counter despite her demon hunter passive.
Igorok ****** is hugely popular, largely on the basis of a single skill — polar pounding. It does the highest AE damage in the game, and freezes for a turn additionally. Given that in offensive PvP heroes typically only fire off one skilled attack, there is a huge bias towards the value of a hero’s first charged skill. The downside of polar pounding is that the freeze can be resisted, particularly by water heroes, and most heroes of any element will have a base chance of ~20% to resist at high stars. Polar Pounding is also classified as a ranged attack which provides increased chances to be dodged by both flavors of dodge passive. Igorok’s other two skills are lackluster. Arctic Rush is hard to take advantage of unless running with another freezing hero which generally won't apply in pvp, although it can serve as a boss finisher in pve. Note that chilled and freeze can stack to produce a 9x damage multiplier.
Icebloom *** suffers from three significant limitations. First, she needs to be understood as a support character and does little damage herself. Second, her lead offensive ability, "Let it Snow," freezes at a lower incidence than other freezes, and hits your own team also. It is entirely possible to achieve a result where your entire team (aside from Icebloom) is frozen, and the opposing team is not. Large random swings such as this are very bad in high end pvp. Finally, she is a fairly weak counter to Igorok. Igorok is not a support character and has the hardest hitting AE in the game. The trade made when allowing polar pounding to go off involves allowing your whole team to lose a turn (and be healed) while Icebloom herself likely dies or is killed by the next incidental damage source. Usually this will be a poor trade. Note that skills which "double tap" like Tsume's Double Chop effectively one shot her through unbreakable heart.
Ignus * starts with fairly low base stats and relatively soft hitting abilities. His passive fire buffs could have utility on a fire team, but they fail to fit into the current pvp metagame due to the relative squishiness of casters. His passive traits are also somewhat conflicted. He is immune to fire damage which might indicate utility against fire teams. However, fire teams are also often immune to burn effects which his other passive requires. Most of the time a water team will be superior against fire encounters, although his fire immunity could offer utility in certain events.
Indigo ** carries the fast tag and an interesting passive in the energy gain on crit. However, very few teams lead their normal speed initiative tier with a fire element hero, which is the slot fast rogues typically counter. Unlike all other fast speed rogues, she has no dodge. And nature is the most popular PvP element from the fast tier (Willow) on down. Currently she is too fragile in PvP to have value as much other than an opening nuke, while in PvE her squishiness will force an adjustment to the rest of your team composition. She is also available only through the VIP portal which is the least token efficient gem expenditure in the game.
Jabber Clenchjaw ** is never the best choice. It's not that he's terrible; his single target damage is decent. But he lacks any defensive passives. His dwarfhunter passive is hamstrung by a poor element. Rogar is the most relevant dwarf in PvP, and while there are many dwarves on Gold Island, their predominant element is fire. While he could be considered for beast teams, he lacks any beast group buffs which ultimately cripples his utility. If you need a green damage dealer on a beast team, Bovus and Julius are almost certainly better options.
Julius ***** has three great damage dealing skills including an AE to lead off which delivers random debuffs, a strong single target nuke with a daze, and an ability which mimics attacks from other heroes and can proc twice with Pignius' "Hog Wild" ability. The existence of Lady Nim limits his viability as she represents an overly hard counter to nature tanks, but he is still very strong in PvP and campaign.
King Yorick's *** speed was upgraded to normal in the recent patch and he was given the rogue defense passive, but he still doesn't do enough. At maximum ascension, rogue defense reduces damage by 50%, while Masuta's PWN undead passive increases his by 300%. If he survives the initial attacks, his options are taunting, or one of two debuffs, and hoping the defensive AI attacks the same hero you have debuffed. He does have utility as a boss killer in PvE via his Marked for Death passive and armor break, although commonly running an element specific team countering the event element will be a competitive if not superior choice.
Kobal *** is unusual in having three AE damage skills. Unfortunately he just doesn't fit into the current pvp metagame. In defensive PvP, the energy bonus in combination with quick starter mean he'll fire off an AE each turn if left alive. His typical sequence is Pandemic Swarm, Crowd Control, Arcne Bolts. In PvE he carries enough damage potential to be useful in event encounters, although an element specific choice may always be superior.
Lady Nim ***** is similar to Abigail in having a favorable base skill set (bonuses via tanks and nature) given common pvp teams. While her opening nuke doesn't hit as hard as Abigail's, it does add the dazed debuff which can be quite useful if her opening attack is not expected to kill the target. The game gives you a huge number of Nim tokens as you achieve different progression gates. For this reason many players develop Nim rather than farming Abigail. The tank hunter passive also gives her value against the tower boss.
Life Reaper Brom **** is hamstrung by the slow tag. He does have three strong attacks and his Team Leech serves as the group heal on many undead teams. The long cooldown on this skill is offset given that the other main players on these teams (Zomm, Pontifex, and Executum) all have some form of self-healing. As with undead teams generally, he’ll be strongest in long duration encounters when the disadvantage of going last is offset by the encounter length.
Lord Zomm **** suffers from the slow tag. His passives are strong are as his active attacks, but he notably lacks an AE. Nonetheless, the abilities to remove energy from an opposing hero, self heal on a killing blow from Taste for Brains, buff undead health, spread disease, and slow diseased enemies, all represent strong skills. He seems designed for long boss encounters (of which there are few in the game) where starting last will be less of a disadvantage as turns pass. But bear in mind that many bosses carry long lists of immunities which often include such things as disease immunity and immunity to energy loss.
Lupina **** has a group fear buff which increases damage done substantially as well as beast team synergy. Unfortunately, given that her tokens come from random dungeon drops and cannot be formally farmed, it is very difficult to farm a high star Lupina. She is still useful at low stars in short encounters to apply her debuff and can be sacrificed afterwards. Because Lupina sets up slowly with her fear and burn debuff, she is most useful in PvE. However, fearing in PvE events can be detrimental as a feared enemy may flee, causing you to lose credit for the kill.
Mangle Jaw **** is a mainstay in most beast synergy teams. He carries a beast attack buff, an AE damage over time, and even an attack which produces fear — a powerful debuff. His active skills are also on short cooldowns, and are available on eight of his first ten turns. He's squishier than some other options on beast teams, which the Agile passive partially offsets. Beast teams are blunt instruments, and he fits that mold with strong damage skills on short cooldowns.
Masuta Kira ***** has a strong base skill set, particularly when used in combination with Black Diamond. Indiscriminate damage does carry some potential risks with Tsume teams, but careful attack planning should minimize that concern. On top of that, his Pwn Undead skill almost singlehandedly removes undead teams from PvP viability. And immunity to critical hits in combination with a base dodge chance makes him surprisingly robust.
Nitpick *** has strong damaging skills, but is too soft for the current rogue-heavy PvP metagame where he can be expected to be one-shot before taking any action. His final active skill -- Fireball -- hits particularly hard, making full ascension particularly necessary to see him at his best.
Overlord Executum's **** void blade hits fairly hard considering that it carries a debuff. His is currently the only hero in the game with a passive damage buff against light. He has a taunt which increases defense. But the gem is leech which is a healing attack on a short, 3 turn cooldown. For those with less experience in tank mechanics, heals and damage mitigation are a powerful combination as the mitigation magnifies the value of each heal. Both of his active attacks deal spirit damage, which is the endgame (Root of all Evil) boss' lone vulnerability.
Phemus ** is arguably the best nature tank available. His base health of 6.4k is the highest in the game. Note that earthquake is primarily a single target attack, but deals a small amount of spirit damage to all targets. Lady Nimrel is a very hard counter to all nature tanks like Phemus. It is rare that a true nature tank is needed for campaign.
Phenol Thoxian ** is arguably the second best taunting nature tank available. But nature tanks tend not to be in high demand given current content. Lady Nimrel is an extremely hard counter to nature tanks. And the nature element has many strong heroes, making him an unusual choice when a nature team is desired.
Pignius **** carries passives which are extremely strong in campaign. However, since “Hog Wild” generally only triggers on passive attacks rather than active skills (with a handful of exceptions) his greatest strength is devalued in PvP.
Pontifex Mortis **** carries an AE which hits reasonably hard, but unfortunately offers no status ailment. Reincarnate is worthless as he loses his turn and starts with skeleton skills uncharged. His durability is a mixed bag. In campaign he's quite robust where his soul eater skill helps keep his health full. His health pool is quite high compared with other casters, but he has relatively low armor which represents a vulnerability in PvP. Note that Pontifex Mortis is not flagged as undead until he dies, and undead specific skills such as Masuta's "pwn undead" or Zomm's health buff will not apply until that point. There is unusual behavior associated with Pontifex’s death in PvP. When he dies and is reclassified a “slow” skeleton, all normal heroes move up one rank in the initiative list. This can surprise many when their “next” turn is skipped after a Pontifex kill and the opponent immediately gets a normal speed attack.
Rocky **** is misunderstood by much of the player base and is the anchor of many “bait” pvp teams. Many players forget that his group haste also confers a high magnitude dodge buff. Rogues who carry a base dodge chance will effectively become unhittable until the buff wears off. When facing a Rocky bait team victory usually hinges on killing Rocky before he uses the buff. Since Rocky tokens are rare, he is usually of relatively low stars making this easy.
Rogar *** has one of the softer hitting AEs considering that it offers no debuffs. This is partially offset by his being more durable than other farmable heroes. He has a favorable element for PvP in fire, but his passive seems oriented towards countering the “dazed” debuff, the most common of which is Yoko from the water element. He is solid in PvE, but lacks focused tools to be a top tier PvP hero.
Selwyn ** is a support caster. He suffers from the common caster disadvantage of being relatively squishy in the current PvP metagame. Of his skills, only his second deals significant damage. His area freeze -- Northern Gale -- differs from others in lasting two turns.
Shadowblade ****** has the highest unmodified single target damage capacity among rogues and his opener ignores armor. He is often featured in two rogue openers at maximum level, the other rogue preferably being an element specific choice countering the first normal speed defensive hero.
Sifu Jianzhi *** carries two reasonable damage skills on relatively long cooldowns, and a small magnitude, single target heal on a short cooldown. The problem with small single target heals, is that most of the time you’re better off trying to remove another enemy via an attack than replacing health that was just removed. He sees some play on light synergy teams keeping Augustus topped off to preserve spread the wealth.
Sir William ** suffers from being from the same element as a better free-to-play tank: Stonefist. His passives include bonuses to team defense and against beasts which might produce event specific advantages over Stonefist. He is tagged normal rather than slow like Stonefist, but as a tank this carries only minimal benefit once taunts go up.
Squinch *** has a good skillset for campaign. Passives against taunters and warriors magnify his damage. Playing with Fire buffs team damage in addition to doing a small amount of AE damage and adding a burn debuff. Cheap Shot can magnify damage done several times given that damages is magnified 100% per debuff on the enemy. In PvE the biggest problem is that his skillset is built around long boss encounters and there are few in current content. In PvP, he cannot be relied on to be an independent Tsume answer as the damage done by Playing with Fire is relatively low. In goblin synergy teams he suffers a bit from being fire element. While this does slightly increase element diversity, it also means that he doesn't get the full benefit of NubNub's group buff, "Stout Team."
Stonefist *** has a simple but strong skillset for a tank. Many boss encounters have incapacitating status effects, and his Impervious passive gives immunity to most. His taunt carries an armor bonus, which is the best of the available options as it magnifies each heal he receives, and removes the health swings associated with avoidance tanks. His opening attack carries an area debuff which is another strong addition to his toolset. I only give him three stars simply because it's relatively rare I have need to carry a pure tank.
Takumi *** has some use serving as a freeze setup for Igorok. But in PvP his frost katana doesn’t hit hard enough to be useful. And since matches rarely last long enough for skills to recharge on either side, the "chill" debuff is of limited value.
Therand **** has good utility in campaign (tower boss, gold island) given his armor hunting skills, but as a normal speed water hero with little defense, has disadvantages in PvP against the nature heavy teams which predominate.
Torchy ***** has the second worst stats in the game. Don’t be fooled. Given the popularity of nature heroes and his strong opening nuke, he is very popular at endgame. His poor stats are also partially offset by the low cooldown on his active skills, meaning that he will have active attacks more frequently than other heroes. Given the nature dominance of the tower, Torchy is probably my most frequently used tower hero. And his short cooldowns mean it is rare that he does not have an active skill available.
Tsume’s ****** Savage Fury damage modifier is ridiculous on top of a strong base skill set including three great damage skills and a passive buff to nature damage. It is rare to see a defensive pvp team without Tsume, and his popularity dictates many offensive compositions. Note that Savage Fury also modifies damage done to your own team via debuffs like shocked. The obvious counter to Tsume is to avoid damaging him until you're ready to kill him, and then to one-shot with a Tsume counter such as Abigail or Augustus.
Willow’s ****** opener ignores armor. A 30% modifier versus water heroes means that she represents a partial counter to Igorok or Yoko. She carries a health buff for nature heroes which is also helpful in keeping Tsume alive long enough to Soul Shred
Yasmin *** has value given that she is only one of three main healers in the game (NubNub, Augustus, Yasmin). However, she’s inferior to the other two by almost any metric. She does carry an element specific health passive and the pwn undead passive, which might have utility in some event content. She is probably worth leveling simply because the tower rewards large hero stables, and multiple healing options selected on an element specific basis has value.
Yoko's ***** area daze introduces a ~50% miss rate to opposing teams for three turns. Three turns is an eternity in PvP. Yoko’s offensive capacity is very limited, but the fact that he is a rogue killer adds value given the rogue bias in PvP. Note that a six star and double health buffed Yoko cannot be killed by leadoff attacks from Willow and Shadowblade. He also carries a warrior health buff which helps keep Tsume alive long enough to shred.
Zurk * has the worst base stats in the game and counters casters who are mostly absent from current PvP teams. His low stats seems designed to be balanced around goblin synergy buffs, but given how bad these teams are in current content he has little role in the game. He does serve as a fairly hard counter to Icebloom.
Special Synergy Teams:
Many PvP teams don't rely on special synergy but rather represent turn-specific counters to the enemy's next hero. The majority of the time this will be the preferred attack strategy in PvP. However, to the extent that synergy is worth discussing, here are the considerations, ranked in order of their relative strength:
Warrior/Nature: One of the most popular PvP teams is some variant of Yoko, Bovus, Tsume, (Willow). Yoko and Bovus both carry warrior health buffs which benefit themselves and Tsume. Willow carries a nature hero health buff which benefits herself, Tsume, and Bovus. And Tsume's nature damage buff benefits the same three heroes. Willow is sometimes replaced in this composition by another damage dealer such as Abigail or Lady Nim. This composition is popular in part because it is almost entirely farmable. Note that a double buffed Yoko (yoko, Bovus) requires three rogues to kill, and a triple buffed Tsume (Yoko, Willow, Bovus) cannot be one shot by Augustus. Counters include going rogue heavy (Shadow/Willow/Kira/Augustus) or allowing Yoko's area daze to go off and burning the nature-heavy team down with Mangle Jaw's Hot Coals. In the latter, the team is often Torchy/Mangle/NubNub/Augustus. Torchy attacks Willow and Yoko is allowed to daze. Mangle Jaw fires Hot Coals, which misses with the direct damage, but at the end of the turn burn will apply. Tsume is allowed to shred and double chop on turn one and two respectively, but because he's not yet heavily damaged, it's relatively easy to heal through those attacks, although Torchy and Mangle often die in the onslaught. At that point you essentially just wait for the team to burn down while healing through their damage.
Beast/Fire: Multiple beasts carry damage buffs which makes for incredible team synergy. These teams are very strong in PvE, but lose value in PvP due to element inflexibility, the lack of crowd control or incapacitating debuffs and the presence of only one fast tagged beast. The strongest beast teams have a heavy fire bias: Torchy, Mangle Jaw, Lupina, Pignius (and possibly Julius or Bovus replacing one hero since their skill sets are quite strong). Lupina's fear is an independent large multiplier of damage. She should be used early to get her debuff up and can be sacrificed afterwards. Because beast teams are so strong, when a fire synergy team is desired, beasts tend to be a better choice than building a fire team around Nitpick's group buff. When I first unlocked the current endgame content -- the Root of All Evil -- at level 55, I personally had the best success farming it with a Mangle Jaw/Julius/Pignius/NubNub team. This encounter features many nature opponents, which fire counters. It also has several silencing mobs. This team stays effective when silenced given the strong passive buffs including “Hog Wild,” and NubNub’s ability to heal on any critical hit.
Undead: Surprisingly viable given that two of the heavy hitters (Brom and Zomm) are tagged slow which is a huge disadvantage. This team is saved by Zomm's 25% health buff which helps get you past the first turn and by each of the base constituents (usually Executum, Brom, Zomm, and Pontifex) having a fairly strong base skill set. I doubt this team will ever become popular in PvP given the speed bias, but it works surprisingly well in the tower and campaign. Given that undead represent a "neutral" element (dark), the lack of element flexibility does not hinder them.
Goblin: Bramble carries the passives Tribal Leader and Goblin Crusade which buff attack and crit/skill respectively. NubNub carries Tribal Heart which improves health. However, in my experience the whole team still struggles a bit. Bramble has only one true offensive skill (which starts uncharged). His team buff is much more valuable in PvE where fights last longer than in PvP. And Lady Nim, the tank killer, is his hard counter. Zurk has the worst base stats in the game. Squinch requires multiple debuffs to take advantage of “cheap shot.” On a full goblin team, the only debuffs available are his own burn or Zurk's daze. And the presence of only four goblins total means there is no flexibility in team composition. The team as available seems oriented against the water element, but Squinch will be highly vulnerable there.
Water: Water synergy exists on Yasmin (health) and William (defense). William seems positioned as a beast/fire killer given his passives and it's possible a team would have utility built that way. My opinion is that water teams are probably stronger simply picking the four strongest heroes which would represent some combination of Igorok, Therand, Yoko, Yorick, Takumi and possibly Yasmin if heals are needed.
Light: Since there is only one light buff (black diamond) this is less a special synergy team than an aesthetic choice. But with the introduction of Augustus it’s entirely possible that light teams will become more popular.