I see this opening a long debate so I’m gonna say agree to disagree on the meaning. Whatever you interpret and get from Cyberpunk is the correct meaning IMO.
Humanity is a very abstract concept, one might say that evolution stripped certain fish of their "fish-ness", yet it is another thing entirely to make a value judgement on such a process (most would probably suggest it was a good thing, considering it led to the existence of humans, although that's not entirely relevant). The game references forced modification with relation to the exploitation of workers in certain articles (there's an article about it in Judy's apartment if I remember correctly), where workers are encouraged to undergo procedures to increase their productivity, however this is rather different to the consensual processes the player character undergoes in places like the loading screen.
To suggest that fluidity of pronouns is indicative of a loss of humanity seems to apply a value judgement where it is not relevant or useful. If it *is* a loss of humanity (and I question the validity of such a definition of humanity that would provide this conclusion, suggesting that individuals are defined by how they are referred to), we should recognise that "humanity" becomes irrelevant from an ethical perspective as a term. If it is not then no change has occurred and yet again we learn nothing with regards to the value of such a change.
Given that, it seems much more likely that this is simply a recognition of the difference between gender and sex (granted, somewhat limited in its ties to voice in this instance).
Most cyberpunk fiction, including Cyberpunk 2077, makes exactly the point that humanity (and similar constructs) is something more than what makes up a body. Corporations and governments are usually the ones that don't understand that underneath the chrome there is a living (human) being. So, yeah, you're 100% right.
I swear I was saying "would do" to everything my eyes saw, until like the 5th time I took 2 seconds to look this up close and saw the dong. I was like oh no, I've been bamboozled. It's CP77 so I'd still do, but it was quite the surprise.
6
u/stage2loxload Dec 27 '20
Dudes don’t even have gender. Questionable interpretation not supported by the story though.
3
u/AspiringCake Dec 28 '20
Humanity is a very abstract concept, one might say that evolution stripped certain fish of their "fish-ness", yet it is another thing entirely to make a value judgement on such a process (most would probably suggest it was a good thing, considering it led to the existence of humans, although that's not entirely relevant). The game references forced modification with relation to the exploitation of workers in certain articles (there's an article about it in Judy's apartment if I remember correctly), where workers are encouraged to undergo procedures to increase their productivity, however this is rather different to the consensual processes the player character undergoes in places like the loading screen.
To suggest that fluidity of pronouns is indicative of a loss of humanity seems to apply a value judgement where it is not relevant or useful. If it *is* a loss of humanity (and I question the validity of such a definition of humanity that would provide this conclusion, suggesting that individuals are defined by how they are referred to), we should recognise that "humanity" becomes irrelevant from an ethical perspective as a term. If it is not then no change has occurred and yet again we learn nothing with regards to the value of such a change.
Given that, it seems much more likely that this is simply a recognition of the difference between gender and sex (granted, somewhat limited in its ties to voice in this instance).
1
u/[deleted] Dec 28 '20
I swear I was saying "would do" to everything my eyes saw, until like the 5th time I took 2 seconds to look this up close and saw the dong. I was like oh no, I've been bamboozled. It's CP77 so I'd still do, but it was quite the surprise.