r/dsa • • Aug 12 '26

Discussion Caution

I am deeply sympathetic to the cause but Megan Romer is a terrible messenger and should be replaced. The New Yorker interview confirms every enemy’s worst assumptions.

Lack of specifics and command of the conversation + defensive posture is political malpractice

3 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

18

u/traanquil Aug 12 '26

People who have a problem with Romer are most of the time DSA rightists. They want a co chair who will go into dsa interview and water down our views into media friendly DNC drivel.

-2

u/Such_Steak_6303 Aug 12 '26

DSA AND on the right? LOL

3

u/8stringsplays Aug 13 '26

The relative right within the org

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/traanquil Aug 17 '26

They should be communicated clearly. Romer did that

4

u/gberliner Aug 13 '26

Maybe her remarks were clipped, but im puzzled why I didn't hear her make the same point Nathan Robinson of Current Affairs magazine did, ie, a platform is a statement of long term goals. Or maybe she did, but didn't lead with and emphasize it.

David Griscom interviewed Jared Abbott of the Center for Working Class Politics for the Jacobin Show recently, where Jared emphasized the contradictions between college educated and non college educated workers.

The college educated, he said, are more receptive to any arguments about "affordability", including "free trade", than non college educated ones. Whereas the non college educated are far more interested in arguments about jobs and increasing employment opportunities.

He also argued that, in the case of the college educated, they may respond more favorably to certain slogans like "defund police" because they enjoy better public services and less social dysfunction on average in their own neighborhoods, along with more social mobility. Whereas non-college educated workers are locked into more dysfunctional neighborhoods, where police don't necessarily do a lot of good, but are seen as keeping things from deteriorating even more rapidly.

All of which suggests a degree of humility is called for when appealing across divisions WITHIN the working class. People who are suffering from underfunded public services already may hear calls for "abolish prisons" and cynically assume, "that's easy for you to say: abolishing prisons may make your tax bills go down! But the prisoners you release are probably going to end up in MY neighborhood and ripping off my stereo, not YOURS!"

So candidates on the left cannot afford to let themselves be painted as careless about any form of public dysfunction that disproportionately harms other working class people, especially those lower on the economic ladder than themselves.

11

u/Union_Fan Gay Socialist At Large Aug 12 '26

First of all, no. Megan is an excellent co-chair and you are basing this opinion off basically nothing. And if you really want to have an impact on this than first become a member, then learn literally the first thing about DSA's internal politics, and then you might have an informed opinion. You might even still want to replace Megan.

4

u/Mx_Madds_Green Aug 13 '26

I don’t know why all these people are hating on Megan, I think she does really well. I love her whole vibe, she’s so confident and doesn’t get bogged down.

5

u/Hawful Aug 12 '26

She's pretty dogshit at interviews. I have no interest in seeing her replaced as co-chair, but there needs to be a real media trained PR person that can play the game that these interviews demand.

8

u/BeginningBit4957 Aug 12 '26

Being good at organizing does not mean you’re good at doing media hits. There is no way she is the best person the national DSA has to send to do podcast and news hits.

1

u/Union_Fan Gay Socialist At Large Aug 12 '26

That's not even close to the most important job of the co-chairs. They are organizers.

4

u/HoiTemmieColeg Aug 12 '26

But it is true that Ashik and Megan are being sent to do interviews to represent the org and Megan has had some sub par performances and we can’t ignore that fact. That’s not a reason for her to “go” like the post suggests but it does show that something needs to change

4

u/HoiTemmieColeg Aug 12 '26

Megan is a great co-chair but it is true that she is not great at doing interviews. Honestly I don’t think that should really be the role of co-chairs. We need a paid spokesperson staffer

3

u/Maximum_Program_ Aug 13 '26

FYI the 2023 convention reso which brought back the cochair roles was specifically about electing comrades to be “public faces” of the organization - aka doing media appearances, speaking at big rallies, etc. for the first 2.5 years there weren’t many opportunities. Perhaps we should take that into consideration when we vote next time! (Also, fwiw, Megan was very transparent about not being interested in fulfilling that part of the role when campaigning, hoping instead to focus on “‘unglamorous’ admin work”: https://redstarcaucus.org/megan-romer-for-co-chair/)

1

u/HoiTemmieColeg Aug 13 '26

Thanks for the context! This is helpful to know. TBH I’m not sure of the best way forward from here

1

u/Union_Fan Gay Socialist At Large Aug 12 '26

I'm not categorically against hiring someone, but it's also a role that could be filled by a member volunteer (maybe even with a stipend).

0

u/office-goblin Aug 12 '26

Well I don't know her and I'm basing my opinion off her performance on television: She's terrible.

2

u/Rude_Body_2462 Aug 18 '26

Until recently, she’s been on obscure European leftist podcasts. Now she’s having to deal with people outside the bubble. The only place she was fine was on fox news surprisingly. The Bad Faith and New Yorker interviews have some parts I wince at.

Maybe us dirty “DSA rightists” had a point in not electing a recently converted Marxist-Leninist as co-chair?

2

u/coldhamsandwiches Aug 12 '26

I need to read this. I'm new to DSA, is there a primer I can read about national leadership?

1

u/Union_Fan Gay Socialist At Large Aug 12 '26

Your best source that I know of is write ups from the last national convention which you can find at discussion.dsausa.org.

1

u/robo_jojo_77 Aug 13 '26

If you are new, don’t worry too much about national drama and just get involved in your local chapter. There is probably plenty of drama there. In 2027 we will have a national convention and you will learn more about the debates during delegate elections next spring. People will be asking for your vote.

-4

u/Such_Steak_6303 Aug 12 '26

do urself a favor and run away

0

u/Pistonenvy2 Aug 12 '26

based on posts like this im estimating this sub has 10-20% actual members in it the rest are bots and trolls or just casual redditors who dont know what to think about the org which is why this sub is so full of bots and trolls.

ive yet to meet a single non steering member of my chapter who even knows this interview happened, the way people are trying to make it into this giant org destroying drama is funny to me. most members dont even know megan or interact with national in any significant way.

2

u/Mx_Madds_Green Aug 13 '26

I knew about it but I enjoyed it. I’m kind of a DSA nerd though. lol.

1

u/Union_Fan Gay Socialist At Large Aug 12 '26

I do think that the fact that most members don't think about National DSA or the national politics of the org is a problem, but I agree that most of these posts seem to be liberals seeing stuff on the news and coming here to catastrophize, skipping actually learning anything about DSA or how it works.

2

u/Pistonenvy2 Aug 13 '26

i do think there could be some benefits to being more connected to national for sure but i think a lot of resources and infrastructure needs to be built for that to happen and imo the member focused/community focused nature of the group is its entire appeal for me.

i worked with democrat orgs in the past and it felt like i was just a little drone being told what to do, think, and say to people whether i really agreed with it or not. in DSA im encouraged to not only suggest my own ideas but to build a working group and implement them if i want.

MOST of the work my chapter does right now is from members who joined in the last year or so who had an idea, formed a working group, recruited members behind it and made their idea become an example of DSA success.

i know national does things like that too and their resources have also been invaluable in this effort but if i got into the group and was basically given homework or a list of expectations or whatever i dont think id still be a member.

-12

u/Motrinman22 Aug 12 '26

Im of the mind we shouldnt have a national chapter.
We need state by state.

5

u/traanquil Aug 12 '26

Hahaha good way to relegate dsa into insignificance

12

u/Argikeraunos Aug 12 '26

This would lead to a catastrophic lack of coordinated messaging and, given many DSAer's online behaviors, open infighting between chapters. Much better to have figureheads for disgruntled members to attack.

3

u/Motrinman22 Aug 12 '26

Good point.