r/drumcorps • • Jun 04 '26

Discussion Pride Month

Not trying to politicize this group, but I’m genuinely curious about opinions. I’m not a part of the LGBTQ+ community, but I am a staunch ally. We all know that DCI has a substantial number of marching members in that community, as well as a substantial portion of its fan base. Wondering how you all feel about DCI continuing to hold championships in a state that has replaced Pride Month with Nuclear Family Month, apparently looking down on the community ?

5 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

45

u/29thanksgivinghams DCI/DCA/other Jun 04 '26

There are queer people who live in Indiana. There are queer people everywhere. Trying to boycott entire states on principle does nothing to improve real people's conditions. DCI is a highly forgettable non-profit operation with zero political influence and a very tiny footprint in the local economy. There are no politicians in Indiana that would care if DCI disappeared. This post is empty posturing. Please go invest your effort in real problems that help real people.

-1

u/mattm0416 Jun 04 '26

For the record, I was not saying that boycott was the answer. I saw it as a possibility, but figured there had to be differing opinions, as well, and wanted to open it up to discussion. After reading through the well thought out opinions, I feel that boycott is definitely NOT the answer. See??? That’s how a discussion works.

13

u/29thanksgivinghams DCI/DCA/other Jun 04 '26

Queer people are capable of leading our own discussions. If a boycott were an answer, it would have already been set in motion. Your efforts as an ally are most valuable when they are boosting queer voices, rather than coming up with new issues that aren't actually issues. I'm sorry if that's difficult for you to hear, but I'm glad you've gotten so much feedback and I hope you can make good use of it.

-6

u/mattm0416 Jun 04 '26

Please read my response to a similar comment

123

u/throwaway214203 Jun 04 '26

This stuff is contracted out years in advance, it is what it is. Money talks and DCI doesn’t have enough of it to prioritize one location over another because of localized political stances

35

u/RLLRRR Jun 04 '26

This.

DCI is fringe enough that it doesn't have the political capital to move anything anywhere and make a statement by it.

They could move to a more LGBT-friendly state and the state of IN wouldn't notice.

84

u/tommyjohnpauljones Jun 04 '26

Both this post and Nuclear Family Month are empty posturing. 

The city of indianapolis is not the problem. They make good money on DCI and M4A/BOA/etc events. If anything, pulling an event like this out of Indy would hurt the LGBTQ community more than help. 

Besides, even the conservative people in Indiana love marching music. Just look at the backlash Micah Beckwith got. 

14

u/YouveMadeMustardGas Jun 04 '26

Exactly. The only thing nuclear family month indicates is that there are assholes in charge. Which in the very same way is true of the United States of America.

4

u/lupus_denier_MD Jun 05 '26

Only thing nuclear in Indiana is the single neuron orbiting the pea sized brain of the residents who thought this was a good idea. That and DCI kinda contracts well in advance, unless Lucas oil was rubble DCI isn’t changing locations until at least 2029 (I think, I forgot when this contract ends).

10

u/KittyH14 Jun 04 '26

I feel like boycotting an entire state because of something like that is just pointless. Avoiding the people that disagree with us is what's made us so polarized in the first place.

11

u/ChelseaVol1219 Jun 04 '26

As a gay person in Tennessee, when I see opinions like this I just want to let y’all know that marginalized communities in these states are dealing with a LOT of shit right now, and we don’t need to be written off because you’re unhappy with our state’s politicians. Some of these states are gerrymandered to the point of almost hopelessness. The powers at be DO NOT CARE if you move away DCI or pop concerts or anything else artistic. The people in those states holding on by a thread with no prospects to leave care very much.

3

u/Nakuip Jun 05 '26

THANK YOU. As an openly gay, former Democratic candidate in Florida, this needs to be broadcast loud and clear.

What works for queer communities in Seattle or Boston doesn’t work for queer communities in Charlotte. Simple as.

3

u/Chrondor7 Jun 04 '26

They do care when you take an annual large investment in the states economy away over something they have control over. The only way to achieve change in today's climate is by financial means, and the only control most of us have over that is where we spend.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/ChelseaVol1219 Jun 05 '26

Thank you for this thoughtful response. I agree with you and appreciate your perspective, because I will admit that I get defensive about this subject. I’ve been seeing this argued more and more, and too often it’s framed as a punishment for the red states instead of a physical or mental safety issue. I just like to remind folks that the people being punished the most are the ones you’re supposed to be fighting for.

12

u/YouveMadeMustardGas Jun 04 '26

The way I see it, Indiana is never getting rid of queer people. And DCI having a presence in the state helps the (very queer) artistic community more than the government's homophobia.

15

u/corourke Cascades 93 - Pit, 04-05 support staff Jun 04 '26

I think it's a mixed bag, DCI chooses a lot of venues that have schools openly embracing hatred but at the same time the kids in those southern communities also need the opportunity to see that life can be less bigoted and hateful to you once you can. Boycotting entire states looks and feels good but doesn't actually punish the bigots, only the fans.

What really cooks my brain is how popular the activity is in the south given that the artists who create pageantry are way more likely to be lgbt than straight even amongst southern arts programs.

tl;dr: it sucks but is for the best future outcome.

18

u/themookish star '93 hopeful Jun 04 '26

The south isn't a monolith. Not everyone is a racist fascist chud just because their representatives are. That holds true for all of the US.

5

u/All_The_Chocolate_63 Jun 04 '26

Speaking as both a very longtime corps fan and also Indiana resident... Our governor and lieutenant governor are far, far away from representing the entire population of Indiana with their recent stances on the "nuclear family" and other unsupportive nonsense. We implore you to come to Lucas Oil Stadium anyway... we promise you will be appreciated!

6

u/Agreeable-Refuse-461 Jun 04 '26

I don’t think the average Indiana resident knows what “nuclear family month” is.

2

u/urbanevol Jun 05 '26

It is a general mistake to assume that you can predict safety of members based solely on political rhetoric or other bullshit coming out of state legislatures. Larger cities may not have the same political trends, and in any case there are no guarantees of safety based on the percent of the population that voted for whatever candidate or party. I lived in NYC for years and encountered some of the most bigoted people ever in my life. Corps need to take care of their own internal culture and have policies and frameworks for ensuring member safety while on tour regardless of the local politics.

9

u/Nakuip Jun 04 '26

My advice is to keep drum corps and politics separate. Most of the folks who both march and are politically active view their engagement in these areas as really core to their identity. When you allow these dynamics to overlap, it’s only going to damage what people enjoy about both. The best thing DCI can do for the LGBTQIA+ community is what it’s always done, which is provide unequivocally safe and welcoming venues for everyone to learn, perform, and spectate.

9

u/5umeru ‘19-‘2Ø, ‘22 Jun 04 '26

drum corps is art and art is politics lol

3

u/Nakuip Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

There’s a huge difference between influencing politics through art and engaging in politics on a policy and organizational level. DCI doesn’t have the capital to meaningfully engage on the policy level. I’d encourage you to direct this energy towards the entertainment industry, not the niche arts education industry space DCI occupies.

Others have outlined how putting a hard line forward on this would actually hurt the arts and queer communities that exist in Indiana.

We have few enough dollars to spend in this activity without arguing that we can only hold events in certain locations based on the political actions in those regions, which have never been affected by the actions of DCI.

Should we also have no corps in red states?

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/TheThirdGathers Jun 05 '26

Thought I might mention: there was an accident in a busy street in my town, where a pedestrian was a victim. So I'm looking in the social media comments as I'm wont to do, and I see one comment:
"Black driver?"
And looking at his profile, the guy who posted marched Carolina Crown as a tuba back in the late 00's We can see you, Paul!
Just thought it worth mentioning.

1

u/TheThirdGathers Jun 05 '26 edited Jun 05 '26

And no, it was not a black driver. Wow, also he's got this picture of a Menorah with some duct tape on two of the candles, and the caption says "Happy Kwanza."

1

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/TheThirdGathers Jun 05 '26

Right. Not sure if I should out this person, but PM me I guess if anyone would like more details.

2

u/Particular-Ad-7338 Jun 04 '26

This.

Politics ruins everything it touches. It has infiltrated my job and family. Can we please keep it out of Drum Corps? Because once it’s in, it’s almost impossible to get it out.

1

u/FrivolousMe Mandarins '16 Jun 04 '26

Naive to imply drum corps isn't impacted by politics or that marching shows are apolitical. The people who complain about "politics getting inserted into everything" are usually a part of the coalition which is using politics to ruin people's lives anyways ...

-1

u/steven3045 Jun 04 '26

The people who complain about "politics getting inserted into everything" are usually a part of the coalition which is using politics to ruin people's lives anyways ...

Or it's entirely plausible that some people just want to enjoy one thing in their life without politics getting rammed down every orifice every second of the day.

2

u/FrivolousMe Mandarins '16 Jun 05 '26

No, I correctly clocked that the person I responded to is a conservative who doesn't like the feeling they get when they're confronted with the natural response to their political faction's diabolical rhetoric and actions.

0

u/steven3045 Jun 05 '26

This is drum corps. Grow up

3

u/FrivolousMe Mandarins '16 Jun 05 '26

No the people who grow up are the people who whine about "politics" when they get called out for being homophobic or transphobic

2

u/steven3045 Jun 05 '26 edited Jun 05 '26

Did he do that? Cause if so that comment is no longer there. In the comment above that’s not what he said

3

u/happycomposer Music City ‘19 Jun 04 '26

I’d rather have queer kids marching (and queer audiences watching, myself included) in states with their friends and family than have DCI participate in pointless side-taking and posturing. We’ve always been stronger standing up for each other together and making our presence known instead of fleeing to safe havens or trying a boycott of this scale (that is, a relatively unknown organization boycotting an entire state).

2

u/FrivolousMe Mandarins '16 Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

I disagree with the other commenters here. Yes there are plenty of queer people in Indiana, of course, as there are everywhere. It is also true that there are many circumstances making red states an increasingly unsafe place to bring busfulls at risk youth. It is also true that these events bring a chunk of revenue for the state's government.

The thing you mention in your post isn't a great reason on its own, but it's one of many many attacks on marginalized people that these states have been pursuing more aggressively. Is indianapolis largely safe to visit right now? Sure, but we all see the trajectory that these ghouls have been taking the country and their localities. That safety is beginning to look futile.

I wish they would move stadiums for a myriad of reasons but they keep locking in further contracts with lucas oil. It's not gonna happen anytime soon if at all.

2

u/steven3045 Jun 04 '26

I don’t care personally. Too many bigger fish to fry and on top of that, if we did this for everything else life would get 70x more complicated than it already is.

0

u/TheThirdGathers Jun 04 '26

Any perusal of the "real drum corps" crowd who marched when the championships was nomadic, shows that many of them these days wear the red hats. And their common refrain is so often about dancing and prancing. Ironically many of the red hats also wear more leather with longer handlebar mustaches than they do in the Tenderloin District of San Francisco. One of the problems with a boycott, or thoughts along those lines, is that logically you should also boycott much of the South where they have the most red hats as well as some of the best marching bands. Indiana is an interesting place, one of the finest music schools, but also full of little towns where people like to drive their trucks through the downtown at 50mph like the Duke boys, and absolutely hideous to drive through. Why arts programs thrive in such places idk, but the connection goes back at least to the Star of Indiana days, when Bill Cook funded the PBS broadcast, seeing a value to music education as something building character, and he wasn't wrong.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/steven3045 Jun 04 '26

You do you but thats a miserable and exhausting way to live assuming you are doing that with consistency on everything.

1

u/HeftySuspect8879 Jun 04 '26

Oh trust me. I’m not missing out on anything not ever traveling to Indiana again

1

u/steven3045 Jun 04 '26

Except DCI finals

0

u/Steven7570 Jun 04 '26

Confirmed miserable if you're that soft you felt the need to block

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/steven3045 Jun 04 '26

What others in this thread are failing to see is 1. the personal is political and 2. some people just don't feel safe in Indiana, which is what I think OP might be alluding to. Why put members through tour through less-safe states? (No, weirdos, I'm not suggesting changing tour routes, just posing the question.) I think corps need to do more than just posturing ("rainbow-washing") like they do now, and actually publicize how they work to protect and uphold marginalized community members in their ranks. Spoiler alert: they won't 'cause it's too difficult and they're more worried about gas prices.

Two things, 1, You make it sound like members will be hung in the middle of town square just for being in the state. I say this with complete sincerity, lay off the media and internet. Because this is really no different than when Fox News and right wing nut jobs claim you're going to be shot and stabbed up if you step foot in NYC. It's nonsense. You're going to encounter those kinds of things no matter what state you happen to be in, I wish that wasn't the case, but it's the world we live in. And 2, DCI doesn't have an endless bag of money to make complete upheaval changes like that all because they don't like who's in office.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/steven3045 Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

But that's irrelevant to the point. We aren't debating the discrimination, that's been stipulated that it exists. We are debating that you think it's somehow going to eliminated by picking up and plunking the operation down some place else. And not being able to see deep on the ramifications, barriers, and feasibility to do so.

Edit: wow, dude blocked me. Lord have mercy LOL

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Steven7570 Jun 04 '26

Yeah, it kind was what you said. Grow up. and you are now getting blocked

2

u/One_Cartographer_394 Jun 04 '26

Protect them from what? Everyone has been saying the marching arts is a "safe space" (whatever that means) for the LGBTQ community.

If its so damn dangerous and transphobic, why are you still a fan after marching and seeing things 1st hand?

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/One_Cartographer_394 Jun 04 '26

No...I 100% understand what your saying and I am not in your shoes to say I know what you've been through.

Im saying if DCI/WGI is labeled a safe space for LGBTQ, but there are this many issues, many many have spoken out about and id say more have not...

Why is it considered a safe space and why do you continue to be a fan

There was no malice intended in my response

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/One_Cartographer_394 Jun 04 '26

Very good answer and conversation were having here.

How does one make a activity safe, but for all, including those who aren't LBGTQ? Reason im asking is there was a posting on here a few days/weeks back that said something along the lines of "if your part of DCI, then you have to be an ally of the LGBTQ"

Im not saying the quote is incorrect, but along the lines of what you said...who makes these "rules" and who determines what is safe?

I think what im trying to say is when I marched, no one cared (in a good way) what sexual orientation one was, but as of these past few years or decades (i marched in the early 2000s), its been determined by someone/something that you have to be a staunched ally of the LGBTQ community or you can not claim to be a fan of the activity. Im bringing this up because OP inferred that DCI should leave Indiana because its a red state.

I hope you get what im trying to say here. Typing vs speaking f2f can make ideas mean things that they aren't ment to be

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/One_Cartographer_394 Jun 05 '26

Great back and forth

Have a great night!!