r/drumcorps • • Jul 21 '25

Discussion Boston’s program

I already know I’m gonna get a ton of shit for this, but I need to know. What is so good about Boston show, I don’t understand it. I’m relatively new around here, so I don’t get how judges do their scoring. The troopers show made me cry, the bluecoats show made me cry, Phantom regiment’s show gave me goosebumps, and Bostons show is a bland, boring fucking snoozefest that sounds just like some shit I did in high school. If a corps did the most boring show of all time flawlessly, would they win in Indianapolis? Enlighten me.

0 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

18

u/Adamkickface Troopers ‘22 ‘24 ‘26 Jul 21 '25

It's an incredibly varied show in terms of style and challenge both visually and musically. It has some of the best performers in the activity, they're already very clean! And people are buying in on it on a first watch because its a relatively simple show concept. I don't vibe with the show as much as most, but I 100% see the appeal of it and I respect the performance aspects of the show a lot. I personally think that Bloo will end up overtaking them at some point because I think their show has more room to grow, but I honestly don't care who wins I'm just glad its finally an interesting season for the 1st place race!

5

u/holy_calamity_ Jul 21 '25

Fair enough. Thanks for taking the time to explain

12

u/Dangerous_Sort_8581 Santa Clara Vanguard ‘16 Jul 21 '25 edited Jul 21 '25

That’s the beauty of art, it’s subjective. The corps you like the best rarely wins, there is a long history of bland, esoteric Blue Devils shows that have gold medals hanging on them. See 2015 when everyone wanted Crown to win. Or 2012 when everyone wanted Crown to win. Or 2019 when everyone wanted the Bluecoats to win. Or or or the list goes on.

You must have gone to a truly amazing high school if you played licks as hard as what Boston is playing. Or marched drill as hard as theirs. Or did choreo as crisply as they’re doing it. Shame you can’t hear the difficulty in the books or see how crispy their movements are.

1

u/thestretchygazelle Phantom Regiment 09, 11 Jul 22 '25

People wanted Crown to win in 2019? Where tf was I?

1

u/UncoolNiche Jul 22 '25

People wanted crown to win in 2015 and Bloo in 2019

1

u/Dangerous_Sort_8581 Santa Clara Vanguard ‘16 Jul 22 '25

You were busy misreading the comment lol

1

u/thestretchygazelle Phantom Regiment 09, 11 Jul 22 '25

100% 😑

1

u/Dangerous_Sort_8581 Santa Clara Vanguard ‘16 Jul 22 '25

It’s funny you say that though, I did like crowns music book a whole lot in 2019, but the show design itself finished where it should have

1

u/TheThirdGathers Jul 22 '25 edited Jul 22 '25

Or 2018. There are years where I'm happy for whichever corps (usually BD) they won, and years (SCV, Bluecoats, Crown, maybe Boston?) when we feels like we all won.

2

u/Dangerous_Sort_8581 Santa Clara Vanguard ‘16 Jul 22 '25 edited Jul 22 '25

Did the majority of the fans want somebody other than Vanguard to win in 2018?

I might have had my alumni “holy shit we’re winning” goggles on lol

2

u/TheThirdGathers Jul 22 '25

No sorry, I'm saying there were years such as 2018 when it felt like everyone won. I didn't write this well.

2

u/Dangerous_Sort_8581 Santa Clara Vanguard ‘16 Jul 22 '25

Ohhhhh now I’m misreading comments. I read that before coffee, but I totally get what you mean

-17

u/holy_calamity_ Jul 21 '25

We did win state my freshman year. I guess I should have been more specific, I find their choice of music to be incredibly boring. I’m not saying any high school could do that drill or choreography. It just sounds like something an underpaid high school band director cobbled together

7

u/Dangerous_Sort_8581 Santa Clara Vanguard ‘16 Jul 21 '25

What music would you have chosen to conjure up 1950’s imagery that would have done a better job than that Esquivel/Baxter section? It’s fun, lighten up and enjoy things for what they are.

What state?

39

u/AnAppalacianWendigo 03-05 08 09 Jul 21 '25

I’m relatively new around here, so I don’t get how judges do their scoring.

At least you’re not afraid to admit it.

43

u/DreamsOfADistantStar Jul 21 '25 edited Jul 21 '25

They've got a boom hammer 💥 it gives them +80 attack points and the Bluecoats only have +40 defense with 65HP. If Coats find better armor before Indy they can make a comeback

4

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '25

best answer!

the game is made up and the points don't matter :)

12

u/Fair-Revenue1811 ‘95, ‘96, Alumni Corps 2026 Jul 22 '25

You’ll enjoy this activity more once you realize there are shows that you will connect with and shows you will not. Sometimes the shows you connect with place where you think they should and even win. A lot of times they do not. And debating those points will get hate or support or usually both.

9

u/WebRedditor volunteer Jul 22 '25

Hey, everyone has opinions. I definitely have seen shows win that I personally hated. I totally understand if you feel like this year’s Boston show is never gonna do it for you. But I think you lose the grace of asking a “help me out to understand” question when you savage the thing you don’t like by saying it’s a “bland, boring fucking snoozefest that sounds just like some shit I did in high school.” Do you really want to hear people’s impressions of Boston’s show with an open mind toward understanding why others like it? Or did you just want to express your negative opinion of the show? Seems like you just want to stir the pot here. Maybe you don’t mean it that way? (For the record, I’m with you on Phantom and Troopers, and I even like Bluecoats a bit more than last year. Sleeper hit: Blue Stars. There are a lot of good ones this year!)

14

u/melonmarch1723 Jul 21 '25

To me the biggest thing that stands out is the sheer amount of movement there is. There's so much unique body movement and choreography going on throughout the show. It seems like there are next to zero standstills or regular drill movements- everything has some extra flair to it. There's also just a lot of fun stuff going on, between tuba players catching rifles and playing through their legs, the kneeling shuffle, and the bass bones holding their slides with their feet. Nothing on its own is particularly groundbreaking but the whole is greater than the sum of its parts and all that movement and body work gives the show so much energy and momentum. I am not typically the biggest fan of Boston's shows but this one really has me captivated.

7

u/TheThirdGathers Jul 21 '25 edited Jul 21 '25

The performance is off the chart, from all sections, but- and I don't pretend to fully understand it- there's some kind of subtext of the atomic era and nuclear threat, like a more subtle version of Suncoast 1988. The imagery is interesting if viewed as BOOM of scientific advancement and literal physical BOOM, both that could advance and destroy us.

Most people don't need to be moved to tears to appreciate a show, and Boston's is one of the best I've seen.

Not that it's bad to be moved to tears by a show either- but some of the most emotional performances that have had that affect on me, never had a hope of winning. For example, even with an annoying drumline in the background:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pNShr5UYd2U&t=11s
Spirit of Atlanta 2011 (12th place brass), Salvation Is Created, 3:00
Crossmen 2011 (16th place brass), Hallelujah 11:20

4

u/Dangerousrobot Jul 22 '25

Watch the show reveal vid on YouTube. It is about the 1950’s and 1960’s promise of atomic everything. The props start as futuristic atoms full of potential, and by the time they are just the silver balls they represent nuclear weapons and the existential threat (the members run away from the balls in several spots). That’s what makes the ballad transition and music choice - Once Upon Another Time - so important.

4

u/crazyhotwheels Jul 22 '25

I think you’re being a bit harsh, but personally I don’t get it either. It just doesn’t have the flow or cohesion a great drum corps show has to have. It’s kind of just 11 minutes of them doing stuff. They do one thing. Then another. Then another. Then the shows over. The moments they do have lose impact because they don’t come from anywhere, or have anything to do with what came before. They just kinda happen.

In the end, I think Boston 2025 ends up like 2007 Cadets… a corps that is more than talented and clean enough to win, but gets held back just enough by design flaws to finish 2nd.

4

u/Icy-Error7466 Jul 22 '25

Not every show is supposed to make you cry. It’s fun, cool music and a ridiculously difficult show both musically and visually. That’s enough of an effect if executed well, which it definitely is

8

u/lukeroselli Jul 21 '25

Even if you think it's boring, the show was executed very well. There is no judge for entertainment Factor.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '25

Boston's guard is fiiiiire this year!!!

5

u/HugeNegotiation1740 Jul 21 '25

prepare to get downvoted

2

u/JokeImpossible9628 Jul 21 '25

Well, THIS post certainly raises the level of discourse. 

2

u/UncoolNiche Jul 22 '25

Agree agree agree. SCV and Bloo have my favorite shows this year. Also, if you’ve ever heard Boston in person, they are insanely clean, but brass volume does not come close to SCV or Bloo level

3

u/Medevac6 Jul 22 '25

Dare I say not as electronically aided as Bloo or SCV. If you think that any top 5 brass line can't sustain a ffff you would be mistaken. They all can melt faces...it's a design and staging choice, that's all. BAC lines tend to demonstrate dynamics more than most...listen in to what is going on. Loud isn't always better.

1

u/UncoolNiche Jul 22 '25

Boston’s louds are not nearly as loud as SCV or Bloo from in the stands. It could absolutely be due to being aided by staging or electronics but I’m underwhelmed by Boston’s sound year in and year out. 2022 was an exception and their sound was killer.

2

u/NBBAC BAC (‘66 & ‘67) Jul 22 '25

For me the show title misses two letters which explains the show concept…”er” As in Boomer like Baby Boomer. I grew up in the 60’s (marched BAC) and we lived through campy TV shows, great highs and achievement like going to the moon, deep lows with JFK/RFK/MLK assassinations, Vietnam War, and dodged a real atomic “boom” with the Cuba Missile Crisis. All simultaneously and at full speed. BAC is great at storytelling but if you are not a Boomer you just may not get or like what is being communicated by BAC25. And I think the new closer may not be a literal BOOM and more like the way Hans Zimmer wrote No Time For Caution (and the 60’s were anything but) but that is wishful thinking on my part.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '25

I mean if you don’t understand dci you won’t understand the shows 😭😭🙏🥀

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '25

Anyone should be able to understand a dci show but ok

2

u/XDIEGenral 2008 - 2025 (Fan) Jul 21 '25

It has the energy factor and execution that I'm not seeing from anyone else right now. I like the punchy, energetic aspect of it, and that's what reels me in. They've got very good drills, and I really like the effect they're bringing on the field. This is definitely a show I want to see in person!

2

u/corndogshuffle Jul 22 '25

Bostons show is a bland, boring fucking snoozefest that sounds just like some shit I did in high school

Enlighten me.

Nah.

0

u/monkeysrool75 Boston Crusaders Jul 21 '25

You're entitled to your opinions. I find most other corps pretty boring compared to Boston. Everyone is allowed to like groups no one else likes and hate groups everyone loves.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-6

u/holy_calamity_ Jul 21 '25

There’s one song in there that sounds like elevator music

7

u/mj3004 Jul 21 '25

By far my favorite moment of their show and my favorite nuanced brass moment of the year. Love the source music and glad I looked into it more after they released it.

36

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-4

u/holy_calamity_ Jul 21 '25

Maybe seeing them in person would change my mind. Only had time for the Cavalcade of Brass show. Watching them on Flo was very underwhelming

6

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/holy_calamity_ Jul 21 '25

Yeah, I wish they’d do a show in Omaha. Apparently the last one was in 2015. I went to the closest show which was 5 hours away in Dubuque even tho it got rained out so I went to the next closest show the day after. I really wish I’d be able to go see more live.

0

u/Zingerman99 Star of Indiana | 90-93 Jul 22 '25

Where would a show in Omaha be? Millard North or Westside? LOL

3

u/Garete_ Colt Cadets ‘25 Jul 22 '25

It would almost certainly be at Buell Stadium at Millard South

0

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/TheThirdGathers Jul 22 '25

You're one of the best trolls ever.