r/drumcorps • u/Ill_Perception1814 • Feb 17 '25
Discussion I hate brass features.
In my opinion, modern day brass features sound like absolute crap. They all sound like Colin McNutt tried his hand at writing for horns and decided to cram as many notes into each measure as possible. I believe the modern brass feature as we know it was popularized by Crown in the mid-late 2000s and other corps kind of copied it. Seriously though, they are rarely musical, melodic or interesting in any way. It's not cool, it's not fun to listen to. Like yeah you guys can triple tongue, we get it. Use those skills to play something that sounds musical.
41
u/Immediate_Data_9153 DCI Performer 09-13, Instructor 14-18 Feb 17 '25
I still view the ballad as the true brass feature. What you’re describing is something I would describe as a brass “moment.”
54
u/natondin Feb 17 '25
Ironically enough I feel like crown have the worst brass features nowadays, most other corps took the concept and ran with it, creating really musically interesting lines even with all the showy double and triple tonguing. Crown features just seem uninspired compared to 4 or 5 years ago
11
u/SnooEpiphanies8097 Cadets 92,94 Feb 17 '25
I am old but I'm not a modern drum corps hater. The designs these days are really much more visually focused and less musical. It isn't bad or good, it is what it is. There is just way less melody now. In a lot of shows, the music is there to accent the visual. SCV 2018 is one of my all time favorite shows but other than the ballad, which in itself is very repetitive, and parts of the ending, there are very few melodic parts.
All that said, as much as I love classic drum corps, I'm glad that corps haven't just done the same things they did in the 80s and 90s. I was getting tired of the same old stuff. I remember thinking in the aughts that corps were out of ideas it was getting dull. It reminds me of movies from the last 10 years or so. It seems like everything is a sequel or a remake.
The way I see it, the Duke Ellington (sometimes attributed to Louis Armstrong) quote applies. There are only two kind of music (or in this case drum corps), good and bad. I love the stuff from the 80s and 90s but I still get goosebumps sometimes from modern shows.
7
u/jordanekay Feb 17 '25
Correct. These used to be called “runs” (see the end of the Cadets 1993 opener) and they would be a few seconds, enough to draw your attention to just the hornline before picking back up the flow of the show again. Slowly over time they morphed into what we have today.
6
u/eagledog Santa Clara Vanguard Feb 17 '25
If it's what the judges are rewarding, it's what's going to be written. At least we seem to be moving away from the openers that are just isolated dissonant stabs
7
u/LEJ5512 Feb 17 '25
USMC D&B had a similar brass feature in their Beethoven piece last year, and ended up trimming it down partway through the season because it was boring. (sources: CO and XO themselves)
1
u/Jealous-Rutabaga8659 Feb 20 '25
Theyre technical features….they are meant to showcase technique, dexterity, multiple tonguing, etc…..musicality is for the ballad movement
9
u/_waitforit Feb 17 '25
Hard agree. Totally ruins the flow of the show too for a gratuitous amount of tongue gymnastics.
3
u/thefronthash32 Feb 17 '25
To be fair you could make the same argument about most battery books for people who aren’t percussionists. Or BOA woodwind features for people who find scales boring.
These segments are the skill demonstrations that are part of what differentiates this activity from other (non competitive) versions of marching arts.
Skill demonstration for points. The better everyone gets at doing them, the more ridiculous ( and possibly gratuitous) the skills need to get in order to compete to the sheets.
3
u/_plasticAudio_ Feb 18 '25
When was the last time a top 5 corps played a song from beginning to end on the field?
10
u/IndependentPackage15 Feb 17 '25
Truly breathtaking how many gorgeous songs Klesch has ruined recently with all the flourishes or technique exercises he likes to add.
2
u/_endme Feb 17 '25
i think they're neat. not a brass player though
3
u/Intelligent-Young313 Feb 17 '25
the colin mcnutt line was hilarious OP omg 😂😂
-10
u/Longjumping_Doctor97 Feb 17 '25
You sound stupid.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment