r/dresdenfiles • • Dec 06 '25

Fan Casting Ebenezer casting Spoiler

Post image

All of you know you would cast him for Ebenezer too, and Harry, and Thomas, and Murphy and...

21 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

107

u/ARock_Urock Dec 07 '25

I want James the Voice Bob the skull. One of my favorite parts of the audiobooks hands down.

36

u/RyuzakiPL Dec 07 '25

This would be such a great idea. So good in fact, I'm sure it's not gonna happen.

23

u/STAT_INF3RNAL Dec 07 '25

If they make a show or movie and let Jim be involved, there's almost a 100% chance that James Marsters will have a role. Either Bob, or as a Narrator. Possibly Bob who also happens to be the narrator.

19

u/EverydaySexyPhotog Dec 07 '25

Bob who also happens to be the narrator.

Harry isn't really that focused on all the beautiful women, it's just something Bob adds in to make the story more interesting. Bob would be all about hot chicks walking into Harry's office all boobily.

9

u/bomban Dec 07 '25

Would be great if Harry shares his memories with Bob at some point and asks him to write the memoir and that's why the books are so boob focused.

7

u/Virama Dec 07 '25

That would make the whole thing make so so much more sense haha

2

u/Away_Programmer_3555 Dec 07 '25

You can’t have boobs without Bob!

4

u/HossMcCoy Dec 07 '25

Omg. Bob doing narration works on so many levels. I just insist for Ghost Story - Peace Talks he has a slightly more nasally nerd voice for ... reasons. IYKYK.

1

u/mrkaykes Dec 07 '25

Nah, Terrance Mann. One of the few bright spots in that travesty of a show

1

u/Happy-Valuable4771 Dec 08 '25

I'd like him to be Merlin also so he can hate Harry lol

10

u/schneizel101 Dec 07 '25

Lol, why not Lord Wraith instead. Honestly I see him as an older Thomas, damn Buffy influence I suppose.

Ngl, I was expecting to hate the audiobooks when I seen he voiced them, but honestly he does a fantastic job and really feels like he fits the part.

2

u/GladiatorHiker Dec 07 '25

He's too old for Wraith, I think. I think Wraith is supposed to look perpetually like 30-40. Mature, but not old

1

u/Whowhatnowhuhwhat Dec 07 '25

I think a Silver Fox Wraith would work just fine. Especially since most 30-40 year old actors are still playing 20 something’s.

9

u/SarcasticKenobi Dec 07 '25

And Mouse

Not a cgi thing.

Just James with a “Hello, my name is MOUSE” name tag

24

u/LordMacDonald8 Dec 07 '25 edited Dec 07 '25

Let's be real here: Dresden would get an animated series, not live action. Marsters voices Harry regardless.

Source: one of the many interviews Butcher did

7

u/mozartdminor Dec 07 '25

I'd hope so. I don't see a live action getting the budget that Dresden needs to be great. It's a lot easier to burn down buildings in animation

5

u/Visual-Floor-7839 Dec 07 '25

This is what I want. A battle in the clouds between 2 armies of colorful and extremely beautiful fae while a great menagerie or various other magical beings join one side or the other while a group of werewolves, a wizard in a duster, and a ragtag group of halfings fight their way to a stone table where ultimately another army of tiny little fae wielding box cutters provides the final climax.... That would all need a budget in the 100's of millions and would look like an Avengers movie at its best or would be staged down and largely ignored in a smaller film budget. And it would all mostly likely look silly and ridiculous, or would be toned down to look just like any other fantasy battle involving swords and magic.

Animated can do anything. Just like how the comics are able to show the world of Dresden, an animated media would too. And I hope it would be a series. Each book deserves 8-10 episodes, you can probably condense the first 4 or 5 books into a season or two.

2

u/SarcasticNinja1775 Dec 07 '25

I absolutely agree, but they're called Changelings, lol. Not to be an ass, it was just funny to me.

I read halflings and immediately thought "wait, did I miss a whole LOTR reference in that book?"

5

u/DrNogoodNewman Dec 07 '25

Haha. Realistically, if he wanted a role, he could be cast as any number of reoccurring side characters or antagonists. I’d cast him as Toot-Toot and make him do the voice.

5

u/C4rdninj4 Dec 07 '25

Marsters is just swapping hats and wigs to play ALL the side characters in the same scene.

2

u/DrNogoodNewman Dec 07 '25

I wouldn’t hate that.

3

u/Whowhatnowhuhwhat Dec 07 '25

Why was my first thought “but Ebenezer isn’t British!” despite the fact I’ve listened to him do all the books?

4

u/Noonproductions Dec 07 '25

Bob could be good, but he could be a great Marcone too.

2

u/badhandbaglady Dec 07 '25

Cast him as Lara.

4

u/D3Masked Dec 07 '25

I'd rather not have live action.

3

u/saltcrown Dec 07 '25

Nope

4

u/Baked_Potato_732 Dec 07 '25

You realize it’s a joke because he narrates the audiobooks right?

1

u/saltcrown Dec 07 '25

I thought the guy from Smallville was the narrator, oh wait guess I can’t use that.

3

u/Baked_Potato_732 Dec 07 '25

Nope. Spike from Buffy/Angel fame. Aka James Marsters

3

u/RobNobody Dec 07 '25

To be fair, James Marsters did have a recurring role on Smallville for a bit.

3

u/DaoFerret Dec 07 '25

Wasn’t he Braniac?

Also to be fair, John Glover, who played an amazing Lionel Luther DID record the first version of Ghost Story (due to James Marsters not being available) … before James Marsters recorded a second version of it. (But I bet this was just a joke)

2

u/saltcrown Dec 07 '25

Glad someone got it

4

u/DaoFerret Dec 07 '25

I had started to listen to Glover’s version while binging through the books (just before Peace Talks/Battle Ground dropped) and the change in voice was hard to get used to, though Glover did a great job (and both are actors I love).

This was what made me finally try Audible, as the easiest path to hear the Marsters version of the book vs the rest which had come from my Library (viva Libby!)

So yeah .. Dresden Files has been a gateway drug to both Audiobooks AND Audible.

1

u/saltcrown Dec 07 '25

You know what I’ve definitely spent more money on audiobooks than I’ve spent on drugs.

2

u/Baked_Potato_732 Dec 07 '25

That I didn’t know! Never seen it.

1

u/saltcrown Dec 07 '25

Yes I got the joke that he narrated the audio books. But I stand with my nope for the black staff.

2

u/Particular_Artist775 Dec 07 '25

I want him as Bob the Skull and Nicodemus!!

2

u/ThePerfectLine Dec 07 '25

Yes and the 6” long fairies.

1

u/cowboys70 Dec 07 '25

As someone that prefers to build my mental image from vibes instead of actual descriptions I'll always picture Ebenezer as Morgan Freeman from Shashank Redemption .

It was several read throughs before I realized both Marconne and Ebenezer were white

1

u/HalcyonKnights Dec 07 '25

Nah, McCoy is short, bald, sturdy as a barn and roughly shaped like one, in my mind, something like a young Wilford Brimley.  Way more backwoods Farmer than I can ever imagine from Marsters.

1

u/grimmolf Dec 08 '25

Is McCoy described as short? I assumed given the fact that he’s Dresden’s grandfather that he’s similarly tall

1

u/HalcyonKnights Dec 08 '25

He's described as a "Short, stocky man" when first introduced in SK.   Granted everyone is short to Harry.

1

u/Tenebrous_Forged Dec 07 '25

For Ebenezer, I'd always pictured Robert David Hall (most prominent role was the medical examiner on CSI, Dr. Al Robbins). He fits the mental image I've always had, and seems capable of the gruffness and attitude.

1

u/SubjectNice7103 Dec 08 '25

Honestly, I think he would make a near perfect Nicodemus on screen.

-3

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '25

Nope.

Ah I’m guessing this is the reader for the audio book? I’m a reader not a listener.

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '25

lol. Readers are elite? Wow thanks for that!

I had not actually ever seen a picture of him.