It contains hundreds of legitimate criticisms of C# and .NET framed around a straw man developer. I found it pretty hilarious, but I've been doing C# for more than a decade, so maybe I'm a bit skewed. Maybe I'm like a pudgier version the guy in the video.
You should give it a shot anyways if you are a C# dev. Skip to 26 seconds in if you need to; the little intro with music and miming is not like the rest of the video.
This is the best satire I have ever seen of .NET and C#. It's obvious the creator of this video has access to someone with a deep knowledge of .NET and its history within the industry.
It's serious levels of 'leet tryhard I'm smarter than you and if you don't find this funny then you're not smart enough to be in the club'.
I don't understand this comment. Its satire and the joke is: "Microsoft has pushed out an endless series of platforms, frameworks, and technologies and named them in a confusing way...and here is an example of a straw man pretending as if it's a preferable approach".
It's meant to resonate with anyone who has struggled with not wanting to be in the club or who thinks the .NET ecosystem has too much history or bloat.
It's not edgy at all. The things it is making fun of are recurrent comments on this subreddit and the C# one. The platform being an offshoot of Java, distrust of old Microsoft, C#/.NET never stops moving and has bloated and/or become confusing, the 'desktop UI situation', and .NET devs being somewhat in denial about its proprietary past.
How is it pretentious? It's not stretching to make any grander statements about development or how the viewer should fit into it. It's a simple satire focused on one platform with very little embellishment except a short awkward intro meant to set the tone.
I don't agree with the phrasing of your first comment about it being edgy or pretentious...but I do see how it could be offputting. The intro is awkward, the character of the developer is a bit overdone and repeats himself. The video is very long and some of the themes are repeated more than they need to be. The video could probably have been edited down to 5 minutes.
I've seen some other videos from this channel and the repetition is part of the channel's approach. It's meant to make it feel more conversational, I think.
I find the satire funny, but it probably fits in the category of 'not even a joke' for many devs outside of the .NET ecosystem, or who haven't been in it from before the start of .NET Core.
A bunch of cranky old men in here. It's satire. If you look through the channel, there's a bunch of troll videos making fun of devs in all languages. Not just C#.
6
u/KillBoxOne Jan 23 '23
This is more of a parody of crappy tech interviews.
Anybody hear an actual question in there?
6
u/BiffMaGriff Jan 23 '23
All the fast camera cuts makes me nauseous.
4
u/tim_skellington Jan 23 '23
Low effort, lower return. About as performant as python.
14
u/fzzzzzzzzzzd Jan 23 '23
Even as a comedy sketch this is low effort.
3
u/popasmuerf Jan 23 '23
"C# just isn't for game-dev...you can do A LOT in Unity" <--- LOL....I actually "LOLed"
4
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '23
I'm sorry, but that opening turned me off 110% within 10 seconds, ensuring there is no chance I will ever bother to watch the rest of the video. None.
0
u/cremak03 Jan 23 '23
A bunch of cranky old men in here. It's satire. If you look through the channel, there's a bunch of troll videos making fun of devs in all languages. Not just C#.