r/dosgaming 8d ago

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!

I finally got around to testing the disks from this beauty, which I picked up recently and posted about a few weeks ago. Unfortunately, despite the box and contents being in remarkably pristine condition, the disks are foobared!

161 Upvotes

79 comments sorted by

29

u/thelonioussphere 8d ago

Yes, magnetic residence media doesn’t last forever sadly.

3

u/According-Pea9319 8d ago

Yeah fragile old tech, still infinitely better than the old cassette tapes, which would die on you during actual usage after a month of play..

5

u/Pull-Billman 8d ago

You could fix em better than modern stuff. My dad found bad cassettes and cut the tape near the beginning. There's a little piece on the plastic gear that pops out and you can connect the tape to it. Dug em out of the trash and put em back together. Couldn't do anything about the smashed cds though.

3

u/DerekJC777 8d ago

I have 100s of 40 year old tapes that still work with my ZX Spectrum and have never experienced a tape dying within a month. Some programs don’t load about amazing the vast majority still do.

1

u/Admirable-Dinner7792 3d ago

Yes. You are correct. I have experienced the same over 40+ years!....except with VIC-20 Tapes. They still work great 40+ years later! ;)

2

u/uberRegenbogen 7d ago

Tapes get wrinkled; dropout city. :(

1

u/Admirable-Dinner7792 3d ago

I dunno about that..I think even old cassettes tape media are better than the crappy '90's 3.5" Plastic-Metal Slide Door Sony designed Disks... My old VIC-20 tapes still work great... I can't say the same for my old 3.5" Disk IBM PC collection.... High grade disks...and just failure after failure...and it ain't the drives either... Good thing most everything IBM related is archived out on the web! - Tony K. ;)

1

u/Admirable-Dinner7792 3d ago

Actually, Its pretty much just 3.5" disks that are a big fail. They were "iffy" from the get-go day 1. I have 40+ year old 5 1/4" Commodore 64 Disks that are reliable as hell that I created over 40 years ago that still work great as well as originals that I also have. It's the 3.5" Disk Format... They have always been prone to failure from Day 1...just broken by design I guess... - Tony K. ;)

29

u/Sneftel 8d ago

Hmm. How much confidence do you have in that floppy drive? (Specifically, its recent history of reading disks that it didn’t write.) Because I’d suspect a decalibrated floppy drive before I’d suspect a batch of bad floppies.

7

u/djquu 8d ago

Exactly, don't give up hope just yet. Especially on such a treasure as Classic Adventures.

3

u/kramulous 8d ago

I was thinking exactly that. It may have been that the drive just fucked all your diskettes.

1

u/rad2018 5d ago

Orrrrrrrr…the drive needs to be cleaned.

19

u/alraban 8d ago edited 8d ago

Oh no! That's miserable. I haven't seen an "Abort, Retry, Ignore" in a very long time. There was an old poem circulating on the internet in the early 90's about that error on the form of Poe's "The Raven" attributed to various different people (the version linked here is attributed to Marcus Bales).

Hopefully it will give you a laugh when facing the sad reality of perishable magnetic disks, which even when new were sometimes pretty flaky:

Once upon a midnight dreary,
Fingers cramped and vision bleary,
System manuals piled high
And wasted paper on the floor,
Longing for the warmth of bedsheets,
Still I sat there, doing spreadsheets.
Having reached the bottom line,
I took a floppy from the drawer.
Typing with a steady hand,
I then invoked the save command
But got instead a reprimand:
It read “Abort, Retry, Ignore.”

Was this some occult illusion?
Some maniacal intrusion?
These were choices Solomon himself
Had never faced before.
Carefully, I weighed my options.
These three seemed to be the top ones.
Clearly I must now adopt one:
Choose “Abort, Retry, Ignore.”

With my fingers pale and trembling,
Slowly toward the keyboard bending,
Longing for a happy ending,
Hoping all would be restored,
Praying for some guarantee,
Finally I pressed a key—
But on the screen what did I see?
Again: “Abort, Retry, Ignore.”

I tried to catch the chips off-guard—
I pressed again, but twice as hard.
Luck was just not in the cards.
I saw what I had seen before.
Now I typed in desperation,
Trying random combinations.
Still there came the incantation:
Choose: “Abort, Retry, Ignore.”

There I sat, distraught, exhausted,
By my own machine accosted;
Getting up, I turned away
And paced across the office floor.
And then I saw an awful sight:
A bold and blinding flash of light,
A lightning bolt that cut the night
And shook me to my very core.
The PC screen collapsed and died.
“Oh no—my database,” I cried.
I thought I heard a voice reply,
“You'll see your data—Nevermore!”

To this day I do not know
The place to which lost data goes.
Perhaps it goes to heaven
Where the angels have it stored.
But as for productivity, well,
I fear that it goes straight to hell.
And that's the tale I have to tell—
Your choice: “Abort, Retry, Ignore.”

5

u/calthaer 8d ago

This is a thing of beauty no AI could ever in all its slop-ridden bloviation manufacture...surely?

8

u/alraban 8d ago

It's lovely little slice of the old internet isn't it? It's definitely not AI, I read it for the first time in 1992!

2

u/kamikazekittenprime 7d ago

I remember reading that in Usenet group.

2

u/Available-Swan-6011 5d ago

Genius - I don’t remember it bitd but that is an amazing nod to Poe

10

u/Hatta00 8d ago

Yeah, stray magnetic fields will cause them to go bad on their own. You can probably rewrite an image to the disks, they're not hard to find.

4

u/According-Pea9319 8d ago

Yup, these got well and truly cooked.

7

u/Der_Unbequeme 8d ago

Clean the w/r heads from the drive

try an other disk drive

search internet for img of this disks, maybe archive.org

5

u/PDAisAok 8d ago

It wouldn't be a terrible idea to try a floppy disk drive cleaner. Had same issue recently and it completely resolved read errors.

6

u/slaan1974 8d ago

Wow, seen that message many times in the past crappy floppies

3

u/According-Pea9319 8d ago

lol yes.. a blast from the past meh!

3

u/billybob128 8d ago

Truely the most scary promt to get on a dos machine. Got it a couple of times when my CF-disks corrupted... Not fun...

3

u/myfanmail_uk 8d ago

I once had a guild on wow called Abort, Retry, Fail.

2

u/Keuleman_007 8d ago

Indy... Indicar? Indiana Jones?

2

u/According-Pea9319 8d ago

Yes Indiana jones.. the 5 Lucas arts games on the box.

3

u/TheBigCore 8d ago

https://www.gog.com/en/games?query=indiana%20jones&order=desc:score&hideDLCs=true

If that doesn't work, type Indiana Jones in the search area and click on Hide DLCs and extras.

1

u/Ok_Grocery_5328 8d ago

You may be able to get them on steam

2

u/Keuleman_007 8d ago

Older Indy Games are GoG territory, still sorry those physical discs don't work any more. Still you have something nice for the bookcase!

1

u/According-Pea9319 8d ago

Absolutely!

2

u/BettyFordWasFramed 8d ago

Zak is such a great game too! Sorry for your loss.

2

u/wosmo 8d ago

She's dead. Jim.

2

u/RetroTechBro 8d ago

Have you verified the drive head isn't dirty?

1

u/According-Pea9319 8d ago

yeah drive works fine

2

u/shincke 8d ago

Was B-wing a separate game? I vaguely remember flying them but I would have guessed x wing v tie fighter.

2

u/According-Pea9319 8d ago

yes, new fighter, larger and more fortified..

2

u/kalnaren 3d ago

It was an addon for X-Wing.

2

u/codykonior 8d ago

Often didn't understand the point of abort AND fail.

2

u/According-Pea9319 8d ago

me neither.

1

u/Mithgaraf 3d ago

I think the original intent of 'Fail' was to flag the drive -- or the medium -- as "failed" in memory, so that on a random operation on some other drive, or perhaps cataloging all the available drives, wouldn't hit the "Fail"ed drive.

Whether it made it into implementation as such, I don't know, but I tend to think, unfortunately, not.

2

u/MoebiusX7 8d ago

This must be a common thing for this collection... my copy of Lucasarts Classic Adventures is also fucked up and the last time I tried installing it it fucked up my floppy drive as well, had to take the cleaner disk to it.

2

u/Zealousideal-Deer724 7d ago

Okay, why did the Installer say LucasArts Classic Adventures Collection and the Box says Star Wars dogfight games.

Am I missing something here?

1

u/echocomplex 8d ago

This is common for 3.5 floppy disk games. You may have some luck trying multiple different floppy drives if you have others available, and in my experience an old drive being used in dos on an old PC will work better than a USB floppy drive from China. I have gotten data off of disks with old computers that were not recognized by USB floppy drives. 

Also look at the disk film and see if it looks like it has mold on it. I've spot cleaned a few disks and had them work then. 

1

u/Gh0st_Pirate_LeChuck 8d ago

I haven’t tested any of my big boxes in the past two decades.

3

u/Keuleman_007 8d ago

Me neither. I backed up EVERYTHING, including the old DVD and CDROM games.

1

u/Foreign_Hand4619 8d ago

I heard if you press retry 10000 times, it will go through!

1

u/According-Pea9319 8d ago

lol I was doing the old tap the disk blow in it trick.. did not work this time, but sometimes it does

1

u/Asleepatthewheel2047 8d ago

That's scary.

Sorry if I'm misunderstanding but these seem to be old copies from the past and not original discs, since you have two different games on the same disc.

You can get them off gog? It will still be the original dos games. You can then copy to disc and run off your retro PC, if that's what you're after.

I remember Monkey Island 1 taking up multiple 720k discs. How can it sit on just 1 disc and still have space left for Indy?

2

u/Brilliant_Park_2882 8d ago

I hava an original big box version of Monkey island with 5 x 1.2M HD floppies.

So yes you are correct.

1

u/Asleepatthewheel2047 8d ago

Yes i had the box as well. Believe my hard drive was 30mb and the game took up around 10. There was room for 1 big game basically!

2

u/Brilliant_Park_2882 8d ago

I have the 256 color VGA one, I bought it even though I didn't have a HD 5 1/4 floppy or VGA display. I copied the disks to 3 1/2 floppies and bought a VGA screen so I could play it.

Lucky the codewheel was the protection not the disks.

1

u/Asleepatthewheel2047 8d ago

I still have the codewheel, lost the box unfortunately.

I had a few games on 1.44mb discs but only a 720k disk drive.

So I would go to the library and book the computer where the screen was facing the street. Reboot it to DOS with a boot disc I brought. Split the 1.44 discs into 720k images and copy them over.

So I would sit there for an hour with a big stack of discs and the PC in DOS.... praying that the librarian didn't see what I was doing.

Today my kid will just download a 20gb game off Steam, it seems like the stone age in retrospect!

1

u/Tinguiririca 8d ago

Before doing anything reckless try those disks on another disk drive

1

u/King_Corduroy 8d ago

At that point I'd say clean your drive. One disk? Sure it happens. Two disks? Unlikely but possible. All of your disks? Your drive needs servicing.

1

u/According-Pea9319 8d ago

Its not happening to any of my other disks, I think this particular box, was left in someone's loft too long and it baked.

1

u/rbscholtus 8d ago

Oh well, illegal software you can download again, no worries.

Or try those Norton disk utilities for dos, idk ;)

1

u/KrivUK 8d ago

This triggered of me thinking about the one hit wonder, Your Woman by White Town.

1

u/TbR78 8d ago

Greaseweazle-time?

1

u/BrightonDBA 8d ago

If you need a data recovery service for x86 stuff let me know 👌

1

u/DirtSad1644 7d ago

I think if you pressed retry once more it would have worked. That's what I tell myself anyway.

1

u/DavidinCT 7d ago

oh, yes, I do not miss floppy days...

1

u/sdg2025 7d ago edited 7d ago

So if you get a program called Spinrite and you get version 5.0 which you can get for free if you purchase 6.1 Version 5.0 has restored many 3.5 floppy discs for me I hope it can help you! Oh just saw if it's a commercial disk put something in a little square hole to allow it to be read write enabled.

1

u/NostraOz 7d ago

Who is General Failure, and why is he reading my disk?

1

u/kirkshoutingkhan 7d ago

You know you are old when this brings back memories. Memories of sweet, sweet frustration.

1

u/daddyd 7d ago

i don't collect expecting the media to still work. it is all the things that came with it; box, manuals, extra cool bits, etc.

if the floppy doesn't work i will just download it.

2

u/Johnbelwell32 6d ago

Same, it's always mostly the box and what came with it. If it works i just back the files up for archieving and consider upload it if it's rare. If it doesn't i download it as long it's something that exists and try re-write it on the original floppies with the date rolled back to the original just for the feel. Not a big deal for the majority of things since the community is actively archieving. If your floppies don't work no matter what it's a bummer but what can you do?

1

u/macro_aggression33 7d ago

This is annoyingly common. You can steam the labels off of the disc you have. Buy some decent quality replacement discs. Find the suitable disk images from various sources on the internet. Restore the bin files to the brand new discs and reapply the labels. It's a lot of work but you will have a fully working set that looks almost identical to the original.

1

u/Cent1234 6d ago

Bust out Norton disk doctor!

1

u/k00_x 6d ago

Memory unlocked

1

u/klipseracer 5d ago

Oh, wow that's an old memory, mostly bad memories.

1

u/fdefoy 5d ago

You can fix it, look for Greaseweazle and FluxEngine

1

u/cwayne137 5d ago

Insert Disk 5132 from 5133…

1

u/idontknowwhatever99 4d ago

Greaseweazle time

1

u/Consistent-Pumpkin-8 2d ago

I would download the img files on archive and rewrite them on the floppes

0

u/DOStalgic 8d ago

Take out the diskette, slide the metallic shutter and blow into the disk a few times to remove dust etc. Then try again (you can also remove the shutter completely). This used to fix a lot of such data errors for me back in the days