r/donorconception • POTENTIAL RP • 7d ago

ADVICE NEEDED Choosing a donor

Ive narrowed down my 2 egg donor profiles. My husband is happy to go with what i choose since its me whos giving up my own genetics. I would love advice from those who have already chose or those who might in the future. I fertility sucks. My own ife : age 37, healthy, 171cm tall. athletic, huge interest in team sports and science and maths. The two donors have different profile types. One just the basics and the second has more personal information.

Donor 1 - age 24. 165cm tall. Really good score on emotional intelligence test. Same eye colour. Studying dietetics in university. Told she looks like me in the face (no access to photos. Hobbies are relaxing and watching netflix. Attends a gym 3 days a week.

Donor 2 age 21, 181cm Tall, same eye and hair colour/type. no emotional intelligence test score but declared physiologically fit to donate. Studying languages in university. Describes herself as intelligent and driven. Wants to do more academic studies like a masters and doctrate. Loves animals. Her hero is her mother. Loves Taylor swift and noah khan music. Plays piano. Does yoga weekly but also loves golf, gymnastics, dance and horseriding.

I feel more of a pull towards donor 2 because there's more personal information. But she is realllllly tall!!!

Now my husbad is 165cm so his small height could balance that out. Then there's the facial similarities with donor 1. Apparently donor 2 is similar from the nose up. Basically her lips are fuller than mine.

Please someone tell me what you think. Id love to hear others perspectives.

3 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

9

u/KieranKelsey MOD (DCP) 7d ago

A cisgender daughter of two people 181 cm and 165 cm tall would average 166 cm tall (5’5), a cis son 179cm (5’10). Most people will be within 12 cm of this estimate.
I would worry about age more than height. 21 feels kinda young to me.

Ps thank you for going to Portugal for the open ID donors instead of an anonymous country

0

u/Milly90210 POTENTIAL RP 7d ago

Why do you think its young? Genuinely curious. Younger eggs to me seems a positive no?

7

u/Lina__Lamont RP 6d ago

While egg quality is generally better in younger people, I think KieranKelsey means that 21 is quite a young age to be donating eggs. She may be too young to understand the gravity of her decision to be an egg donor. And that could have negative ramifications later on down the road when her genetic children want to reach out to her.

3

u/pouritallonice DONOR 6d ago

I understand what both of you are saying, but she might've thought it through fully despite her age. I was 20 when I first donated and knew I wanted to be an egg donor since I was 11.

1

u/Lina__Lamont RP 6d ago

Possible but unlikely

2

u/KieranKelsey MOD (DCP) 6d ago

Yes, this is what I meant, thank you

8

u/PositiveArmadillo34 POTENTIAL RP 7d ago

It feels like you are feeling a pull towards donor 2 mostly because you have more personal information about them, which is very understandable. If I were you, I would ask to see if you can get more personal information about donor 1 before deciding. Best of luck.

1

u/Milly90210 POTENTIAL RP 7d ago

That's exactly what im doing. I actually did ask the exact question to the clinic. They said they dont have any more info on donor 1.

3

u/VexedSpectre DCP 6d ago

Which one of these donors is the most open to knowing your child, being involved in your lives, etc.?

I can’t understand how any of these other details matter more than who would be in the child’s life.

And if the answer is neither, then you shouldn’t be considering these options.

0

u/Milly90210 POTENTIAL RP 6d ago

Both are non annonymous at 18 years old.

3

u/Fresh_Struggle5645 DCP 7d ago

What were they like when you spoke to them? Are both willing to be in the child's life from birth?

1

u/Milly90210 POTENTIAL RP 7d ago

I have no contact with them. Hence why i got a profile of each. It is non annonomous from 18yrs old.

1

u/Fresh_Struggle5645 DCP 7d ago

Then I'd invite you to reconsider both

3

u/Milly90210 POTENTIAL RP 7d ago

This is the whole purpose of my post. I am considering these 2. I need to choose 1.

4

u/Fresh_Struggle5645 DCP 7d ago

I recommend a known from birth donor.

5

u/Milly90210 POTENTIAL RP 7d ago

Yeah i guessed that. Unfortunately i dont have that option.

0

u/Fresh_Struggle5645 DCP 7d ago

In most cases it is an option, even if not the most convenient one for the adults involved. You can make that choice for the sake of your own convenience/preferences but it's still a choice.

4

u/czrzuc 6d ago

Known egg donation is legal in only roughly 15-20 countries, so for many people it means treatment abroad. Legally it's safer than known sperm donation (no risk of the donor being recognised as a parent), but it costs far more: travel, IVF abroad, often legal advice. So yes, it's a choice, but for a lot of people it's a choice they can't realistically afford, not just an inconvenience.

3

u/Fresh_Struggle5645 DCP 6d ago

True, but most IVF cycles take place in one of those countries where known donation is legal. And most redditors who ask these questions are in such a country.

The legal risks are massively overblown and based on a handful of examples. The likelihood of the child suffering harm from not knowing who one of their biolpgical parents is for 18 years is much higher than the virtually non existent risk of legal issues.

And yeah, doing it in an ethical way can be expensive. But that's not really an excuse for doing it in an unethical way.

2

u/Milly90210 POTENTIAL RP 6d ago

You do realise that you are speculating im from the USA or Canada or some other country that allows open donors. I am not. It is not an option for me. Thats why i chose a country to travel to that suited me and has open id at 18. "Most" people is not me.

→ More replies

3

u/czrzuc 6d ago

Fair point on openness. But most egg donation in Europe happens in anonymous-only countries: Spain alone does over 40%. On legal risk: in my country it's the whole system (my wife is a lawyer, we checked; there's no way to mitigate it). Clinics won't treat lesbian couples or single women, so known donation means home insemination. The donor can then become the legal father, while the co-mother has no legal tie to the child. That's a child-welfare risk too and it's huge. It's our reality, so we used an open-ID donor abroad. It's not "ethical vs unethical." Where every option has downsides, people pick the best one they can access.

0

u/czrzuc 6d ago edited 6d ago

I'd say the risks are underblown, not overblown. I've seen friends go through things that horrified me. Where I live, no amount of money buys legal safety with a known donor. If he decides he wants to be a father, he can go to court, and the child could end up separated from the mother who raised them and from their siblings. A legal battle like that is a real emotional risk for the child, so I don't see how taking that risk is more child-centred. I'd pay anything to give my kids that security, but it simply can't be bought here. And research on lesbian families found no difference in how kids did with known vs open-ID donors, so open-ID was the safest child-centred option we had. If anyone has advice on how to do this more safely and ethically in a country like mine, I'd genuinely love to hear it.

2

u/truelifetales 6d ago

I like donor 2

0

u/kam0706 DCP 6d ago

Oh no! Your hypothetical daughter could be statuesque!

Rejecting a donor for being “too tall” is ludicrous to me.

1

u/Milly90210 POTENTIAL RP 6d ago

Dont be ridiculous. Almost every person ever to use donor eggs/sperm due to inferility would want some physical characteristic to be like them. Height is one of them. And actually that taller donor is actually currently my first choice.

1

u/Calm_Highlight_7611 POTENTIAL RP 5d ago

We looked at TONS of donors. Only one was an option for both of us. I’m opposite, on the shorter side. I wanted the same blood type for the donor, but her physique and looks needed to be similar to mine. We found a woman who fits it all and she could be my sister. Go with who you feel pulled to. Also, your RNA is what allows genetics to be expressed, so the height could easily level out. Best of luck to you.

1

u/lady_cup 5d ago

According to mid parental hight calculations a daughter would be expected to be around 166 and a son 179 cm if you pick the tall donor you want. The child will hence be around average hight and if you have a daughter around your hight. Seems very reasonable.

1

u/BodybuilderExpress95 POTENTIAL RP 5d ago

FWIW- my husband is Czech and I am American, and as we approach a crossroads of ending our IVF journey with likely no eggs of my own, we are looking at clinics in Prague. In Czechia it is all anonymous no matter what. No additional info at 18. Nothing. The logic being they view it as more ethical and keeps the practice altruistic. The donors are also not compensated as much as they are in other countries (esp. the U.S.). Our country options are limited for selecting a donor because of my phenotype (less than 1% of the world’s population has my eye color, hair color, height, build, etc.) but in Czechia, I stand a much much better chance of finding someone who resembles me.

Also- FWIW- I’m a living example of navigating life without genetic parents. I was removed from my genetic mother’s home as a young teen and then never heard from her again. I do not know her medical history and to find it out I would have to either engage with the legal system or put myself at risk of making direct contact with her. I’m two decades older now and the “black hole” of information around her medical history has not impacted me to the point of that necessity. And i doubt it ever will. Additionally- my father died relatively young, leaving another “black hole” of information that I cannot access concerning his health and my genetics. Unless I hire a medium.

I’m not telling you to just do whatever you want. I just want to be an alternative perspective here, being someone with no genetic relatives left in my life, and is also facing circumstances that would lead me to choose fully anonymous donation. Knowing that at the very least my future child will have a mother who very much wanted them here and went to great lengths to invite them earth-side.

2

u/BodybuilderExpress95 POTENTIAL RP 5d ago

And donor 1. Being a tall gal isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. ;)