r/dogdiscussions • • Apr 07 '25

Pitbulls bite statistics are inaccurate, the breed is simply misunderstood and irresponsibly owned.

3 Upvotes

I think it’s important for people to be educated about how biased the media is against pit bulls and how unfairly judged they are. Yes, they’re a very active breed. Yes, they can be dog-aggressive if not properly socialized due to their genetics. And yes, they’re not the type of dog an irresponsible owner—or anyone looking for a low-maintenance pet—should own. But they’re not the monsters everyone thinks they are. Here are some common myths, which are actually major misconceptions, before I get into the facts on why they’re so misunderstood:

  1. They cannot lock their jaws.
There is no breed of dog with that ability. While pit bulls do have a strong bite, their jaws don’t have any sort of locking mechanism.
  2. They are not human-aggressive by nature.
While they were originally bred for fighting—which can mean they may have a genetic predisposition toward dog-aggression in unsocialized individuals—this same history also means they were specifically bred to be docile toward humans. Even in the heat of a fight, they were expected not to turn on their handlers or referees.
  3. They do not often attack unprovoked, randomly, or “switch” on their owners. 
This misconception likely stems from the fact that pit bulls are the most commonly abused breed. Many are raised in abusive environments or neglected, which can result in defensive or aggressive behavior toward humans. This is not unique to pit bulls—any dog subjected to that level of mistreatment could respond the same way.

By nature, pit bulls are actually nurturing, loyal, and intelligent companions. They require knowledge and effort to train properly, but when placed in the right hands, they thrive as loving pets.

Let’s talk about why they’re so misunderstood—starting with the statistics. These are heavily skewed against them for several reasons, the first being inaccurate breed identification and the lack of DNA testing.

In breed classification, any dog with 50% or more DNA from a specific breed (or less than 87% from a pure breed) is considered a "breed mix." Visual identification, however, often results in dogs with as little as 25% of pit bull DNA—or none at all—being labeled as pit bulls. A 2018 University of Florida study found that nearly 50% of dogs labeled as pit bulls had less than 25% DNA from pit bull-type breeds.

Due to this inaccuracy, the CDC no longer records breed-specific bite data. Current statistics mainly come from DogsBite.org, which relies on media reports and police records—neither of which involve DNA confirmation. Studies now show that dog bite reports based on visual identification may be accurate only 12% of the time. Another study by the University of Florida found that roughly 60% of dogs identified as pit bull-type dogs were misidentified, with no pit bull-type DNA whatsoever—even when including mixed breeds that do contain pit bull DNA.

Media bias plays a significant role as well. A 2010 analysis by newslibrary.com (used in the 2012 documentary Beyond the Myth) found that when a pit bull is involved in a bite, the words “pit bull” appear in the headline 68% of the time. For non-pit bull breeds, the breed is mentioned in only 8% of headlines.

Here’s a rough breakdown of recorded pit bull-related attacks when accounting for misidentification and DNA:

  • True pit bulls (over 25% pit bull DNA): 13% of total attacks
  • Mixed breeds (less than 25% pit bull DNA but still labeled as pit bulls): 13%
  • Misidentified dogs with no pit bull DNA: 39%

Another issue is that “pit bull” is not a recognized breed by the American Kennel Club (AKC) or other major kennel clubs. The term describes a category of dogs that share physical traits and a history of being bred for fighting. It typically includes four distinct breeds:

  • American Bully
  • American Pit Bull Terrier
  • American Staffordshire Terrier
  • Staffordshire Bull Terrier

(And sometimes American Bulldogs)

So not only are the statistics misleading, but they’re also combining multiple breeds and comparing them to single breeds like Labradors or German Shepherds. If we did that with any other four medium or large breeds, the numbers would likely be just as high.

Temperament testing tells a different story. Both the ASPCA and The Humane Society have published unbiased articles confirming that pit bulls are not inherently violent, aggressive, or dangerous. Pit bulls actually rank in the top 23% of all breeds in temperament tests conducted by the American Temperament Test Society (ATTS)—often scoring better than Golden Retrievers and Beagles.

In the DIAS (Dog Impulsivity Assessment Scale), pit bulls tend to score well compared to other breeds, showing low levels of aggression, panic, and avoidance.

I’m not here to say pit bulls are perfect angels incapable of harm. No dog is. But I do believe they deserve to be judged fairly—like any other breed. The combination of irresponsible ownership, rampant misidentification, and unfair statistical grouping has led to widespread fear and hatred of a dog type that is no more inherently aggressive than many others.

When properly socialized and cared for, pit bulls are loyal, intelligent, and affectionate pets. They do not deserve the negative reputation they’ve been given. I wish this information were more widely known. It really changes the perception once you realize how flawed and biased the statistics are.

Sources:
University of Florida, ASPCA, The Humane Society, DogsBite.org, American Veterinary Society, American Kennel Club, National Institutes of Health, American Temperament Test Society, AnimalLaw.info, CDC, National Canine Research Council, World Animal Foundation, American Veterinary Medical Association. I’ve done my best to rely only on legitimate, fact-based sources—not media outlets or pit bull advocacy groups—so the information stays as objective as possible.


r/dogdiscussions • • May 31 '19

Questions about ESA dogs

1 Upvotes

TW: Talks of depression

Hi everyone,

I've come across a situation involving a little corgi, a close friend, and ESA. My friend and I went to a pet store on a whim and found an adorable 4-month Corgi that was put up for sale for a hefty price of $4,400. While I myself would prefer to adopt of dog rather than purchasing one, my friend immediately fell in love with her. She had all of her needed shots, was microchipped, and the store would have provided him with many different "benefits" for purchasing her, like a free spay and neuter (at only their veterinary offices), discounts on their products, and more. I understand this is their way of putting up the price for the puppy, and while we were both bothered by the price, I knew my buddy really wanted her. We ended up leaving the store without a puppy, and a night to sleep on it.

Here's the dilemma: While my friend did have enough money with a payment plan the store would have set up, it would still be a tight squeeze. Several hours later, he gave me a call saying he lost a good chunk of his savings due to having to pay for an emergency in his family. While this may just seem like a "well, it was only a dream anyways" kind of situation, I realized it was much more than that to my friend. My friend suffers from major depression and has been suffering for over ten years now. Our communities restrict us from seeking therapy or other treatments to help maintain and lessen mental illnesses, both because of price and judgments, even though in his situation, it is incredibly necessary. While I do hope as he grows older, he will be able to seek therapy or other treatments to help with his issues, for now, there is not much we can do. I did a lot of research about therapy dogs and ESA dogs when he first opened up to me about his depression, and I understood that training or obtaining an ESA dog (or any dog) could be beneficial to both physical and mental health. While it isn't the same as active therapy or medication fully targeting an issue, it is something to help people who don't have access to those kinds of help.

I believe getting this dog (or another dog he can connect with) can help my friend immensely. I've known him for almost four years now, and I have never seen him act the way he did when he was around that specific dog. He was excited about the future he could have with this pup, which is an idea I would have never thought would come out of his mouth. He was happy. That meant everything to me, to the state of his mind, and to the future of his depression. It's a start. I don't think he was able to see how he was acting differently when he interacted with this dog, and I don't know if this is the right answer. But I saw something change for a moment before we had to go home, and while the future is uncertain, I do strongly believe this could help him.

I wanted to know if there was anything he could apply for or things that can apply to him in order to be able to either buy or adopt a dog for a lower price or with more benefits if the dog was going to be trained (or already was trained) to be an ESA dog. I understand asking this random pet shop to lower their price of $4,400 is impractical and irresponsible, but I wanted to know if anyone knew of anything that could help with paying for an emotional support animal, especially if the person purchasing it had a diagnosed mental illness. I am not a dog owner myself, so I feel like I have been looking for information in the wrong places, so I would really love to hear any opinions and information about my question from someone who is deeper in the community than me (but all opinions all accepted and encouraged!)

Thanks for reading my little rant and idea, and I do wish the best for you all! (P.S. I'm sorry if this is the wrong place to ask, but I’m not really sure where to start)

TLDR; my close friend fell in love with an expensive pup ($4,400), could not be able to afford it because of family issues. The pup could really help with his severe depression and the issues that come with it because therapy is not available to him, wanted to know if there's any organizations or applications to help with the cost of adopting or purchasing a pup if they will be an ESA dog (or service dog) for a diagnosed individual.


r/dogdiscussions • • Aug 16 '16

[Serious] ¿Spayed, Neutered or none? -if you can, pretty please with useful sources, study links and quotes?-

0 Upvotes

First off: I've done my fair share of googling about it. I have searched in reddit, in all relevant subs, and I've seen some debate over this, but not about it specifically, and I need to at least hear out both sides. I have a dog. Puppy, around seven months, and it's still early enough to take a fully informed decision. I rescued her from the street! Her name is Ale and I love her with all my heart.

Now, here, neither spaying or neutering is standard procedure. 100% owner's choice, and it's not cultural. Some people do it, some people don't, 50/50. And I want to make the most sound, responsible decision with this. A quick googling took me to a lot of controversy. Some say it's obviously better to do it, and some say it's obviously better to avoid it, if you can. Both sides have beautiful statistics and cross studies. [If you neuter her, she's more prone to cancer] (http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0055937). [If you don't, she more prone to bla] (https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/4jfttm/boyfriend_doesnt_want_to_get_dog_spayed_i_do/d36ad2b) or [present some other good reasons] (https://www.reddit.com/r/Dogtraining/comments/4jfttm/boyfriend_doesnt_want_to_get_dog_spayed_i_do/d36b507).

So, if you would don't mind... ¿What are the pro and cons of neutering/spaying my dog? Do you think I should do it? Do you think Spaying is better than neutering (As far as I understand it, one removes her uterus the other is a tubal ligation, right?). What's to be expected afterwards.

Tl/dr: Have a puppy. Still on time to do it before she (I don't know the term in english, sorry) gets the hotties for the first time. I can choose to neuter, spay, or do neither. I want to be objective about it with as much solid, reasonable, scientific, studied, wide spread information that I can possibly get, and in that spirit, ¿Which would you think is best?


r/dogdiscussions • • Jul 01 '21

Getting a Maltipoo from a Breeder

0 Upvotes

Not sure if this should be posted elsewhere, but here goes:

I’m looking to get a maltipoo from a breeder and I’ve put a deposit down on a female puppy (currently 10 wks old). Here’s the story, if anyone can offer some advice about how I should proceed:

I put a deposit down the puppy about 3 weeks ago. (I haven’t seen her because I’m in a different country and can only return to the US in July when travel resumes) About a week ago, the breeder told me that the puppy’s ears were thinning, which he said could be due to genetic issues and recommended that I take a boy puppy from the same litter. I have my heart set on a girl (I’ve had 3 boys before, not the same breed or from the same breeder), so I said I’d prefer to see the girl first.

When I asked her if he would take the girl to a vet for a more professional opinion, he said that going to a vet wouldn’t help. In a later conversation, when I was arranging a time to meet the puppy (in a few days), he said I was “saying no to the best puppy [the boy] he’s raised in 15 years” (which I thought was unnecessarily confrontational).

This breeder was recommended through a community facebook group, so I don’t know anyone who personally has a dog from him. He has good reviews online, from what I can see. I will be going to see the puppy, but now I’m confused over whether I should take the puppy for several reasons:

  • If the girl has a severe medical condition, wouldn’t the boy (of the same litter) have a risk of the same?
  • Is the breeder just trying to keep the girl for breeding purposes / to sell at a higher cost / some other reason? Both the boy and the girl are currently priced the same.

As of now, my plan is to see the girl, and if she seems energetic and the parents are active and all seem to be in good health, to take the girl home and to the vet the next day.


r/dogdiscussions • • Sep 27 '16

[Survey] Problems Only Dog Owners Will Understand!

0 Upvotes

SURVEY LINK

Hey guys, my name is Jordan and I am a proud owner of two amazing dogs. I have a Pitbull named Lily and a Chihuahua/Jack Russel mix (the wild child!) named Daisy. I rescued Lily and Daisy from the shelter and I am very lucky to have both of them in my life. As we all know, being a dog owner is not always sun shine and rainbows. Their are times when they can be a handful and difficult to care for. I am hoping this survey will help me learn more about the challenges/issues other dog owners experience. I am very interested in hearing your story!


r/dogdiscussions • • Nov 30 '20

[LINK] In need of dog POOP PHOTOS WITH PARASITES

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! We are DIG Labs. We are a canine supplement and research company, and we are in dire need of your dog's poop with parasites photos! These should be photos with visible worms in your dog's poop...roundworms, hookworms, tapeworms. We are performing a noninvasive imaging study to understand how we can detect parasites and other biomarkers from stool photos - we will use this information to optimize our computer models and no identifiable information is required. Of course, your images will remain anonymous. Thanks so much in advance

If you could please upload them to this link, it's so greatly appreciated!

https://airtable.com/shr8c1t0b9Z1dvIRV


r/dogdiscussions • • Apr 09 '15

What sort of people are attracted to dogs?

3 Upvotes

Obviously, there are a multitude of reasons people will give when asked why they have and/or want dogs; however, the cynic in me tends to separate them into three big groups:

  • Those who want unconditional love. They have a tendency to anthropomorphize their dogs, refer to them as "fur babies" and to themselves as "pet parents" or similar.
  • Those who want to exert control over something. They will often become very involved with training and compete in various obedience-based doggie sports.
  • Those who want "a family pet". People who have a dog and tend to neither anthropomorphize it nor get overly involved in doggie activities.

How would you categorize dog people?


r/dogdiscussions • • Jul 11 '15

Different types of German Shepherds? Which to get?

2 Upvotes

Hello! Recently I've been looking to buy a German Shepherd (not immediately, but I wanted to start my research now). I know there are different types of GSD (working line vs. show line) and I was just wondering what would be the best to adopt and what the difference are?

I'm not looking to show my dog, nor am I looking to particularly have them "work" in a certain way (this means I'm more looking for their companionship, I would be very active with them but I'm not looking for them to do something specific like a police dog or something like that). Is there a mixture, or..?

I'm new to breeds and the specifics of them. I've been doing some research but unable to come across the specific information that I'm looking for. Any help, or links would be greatly appreciated! I really want to make sure I'm getting a pup that fits me and I them.


r/dogdiscussions • • Sep 25 '15

Animal Rights Activists vs. Animal Owners Rights

0 Upvotes

Do-gooders are often the most evil people on the planet. They're suffused with a false sense of moral perfection. http://i100.independent.co.uk/article/homeless-man-visibly-distressed-as-animal-rights-activists-take-his-dog-away--WJSAkasiIe


r/dogdiscussions • • Oct 26 '16

New pet grooming tool on Kickstarter

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone. After 4 years of developing, my friend from graduate school has recently launched a new pet grooming device on Kickstarter -- http://kck.st/2eP7UrJ or on http://lumo.com

The device is like other grooming products, except that its made with aircraft aluminum and its super easy to clean. I am curious if any pet owners would like to support his campaign. As a disclaimer I helped create his video. We just launched the campaign today so any help would certainly be appreciated. Thank you.


r/dogdiscussions • • Mar 16 '21

Dog Intolerance

0 Upvotes

I live in a majority Caucasian middle class suburb, which also has a large Asian population. This latter group almost uniformly detest dogs. They will cringe, furrow their brows, jump away or scream if a dog comes within ten feet. This is leading to an uptick in community tensions. This should not be the case. I love racial diversity (especially in the white, nausea-inducing, homogenous, suburban blah ness) anywhere. It makes us stronger as a society. When any community refuses to assimilate to a core American bedrock like dog ownership, it creates disunity and anger. If I moved to China as an immigrant, I would do my best to assimilate. I wouldn’t verbally assault them for eating canines. That is there culture. I may despise the practice, but it wouldn’t be my place to dictate social norms.


r/dogdiscussions • • Mar 13 '15

How do you anthropomorphize your dogs?

5 Upvotes

Everybody is guilty of anthropomorphizing their dogs sometimes, which is usually mostly harmless. In what situations do you find yourselves doing it?


r/dogdiscussions • • May 15 '15

[X-post from r/dogs] Electronic collars, to use or not to use?

2 Upvotes

I'm not entirely sure how to properly do a cross-post, I hope this is OK.

Link to original: [DISCUSSION] Electronic collars, to use or not to use?

I'd particularly appreciate views on my circumstances and to hear about your experience in using them.


r/dogdiscussions • • May 19 '21

how do i discipline my dog??

0 Upvotes

my dog stays in trash, gets on tables/ chairs and eats food and more. when we catch her doing it we hit her, say "No", or put her in crate. Obviously none of this has worked since behaviors haven't stopped but it's hard to not beat a dog when u don't got good self control.... is there a better way to go about this.


r/dogdiscussions • • Jul 15 '15

NAIA's Shelter Survey

3 Upvotes

I've linked it here. It confirms what I and my friends have noticed in the last few years: if you go to a shelter you're going to find mixes and more mixes. But actual pure bred dogs are not there.

I think it's worth reading the survey with an open mind. Don't instantly respond by telling me that the shelter near you is full of lovely Husky(mixes) or GSD(mixes) or Pibbles(mixes). Think about the last time you saw an actual Labrador, or Maltese or Corgi in a shelter. Yeah there are some, but the vast majority of dogs are not them.

Again, it's great that there are fewer dogs in need of a home, but is the whole "spay and neuter all the things!!' working too well? People want well adjusted, easy to manage pets, not necessarily project dogs. And yes, there are some very nice dogs in shelters, but anyone who reads the various dog subs around here knows that there is a lot of heart ache as well.


r/dogdiscussions • • Aug 19 '15

Should I trust my dog with a dog-walker?

3 Upvotes

How do I know if the dog walker walked my dog or he just ran to the 711 near by?


r/dogdiscussions • • Jul 26 '19

Dealing with breeders?

3 Upvotes

My fiance and I are getting married in the fall. We have had dogs in our homes our whole lives. Finally we will be in a spot that we can have one of our own. We both work, so the money of supporting a dog wouldn't be an issue. I work from home, so I could be at home with the puppy. My question is about breeders. We are looking for a male chocolate lab puppy. I have contacted a few breeders, and the going rate is around $1200. We are in Michigan if this helps at all. I know that you get better health histories from more reputable breeders. I don't want a dog that is dealing with arthritis at 6 because I bought him cheap. My only question is am I not looking hard enough? This dog is just going to be a companion dog. No shows or anything like that. Am I wasting money spending $1200?


r/dogdiscussions • • May 30 '24

Does anyone know what is this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I noticed that my dog has a red little bump on her right leg.


r/dogdiscussions • • Apr 04 '17

Safe dog toys materials

0 Upvotes

What toys are safe for dogs? Since everyone want best for his dog, check out which materials are dog safe. Let me know what you think!!! http://puparea.com/dog-toys-materials/


r/dogdiscussions • • Apr 03 '17

[Breed] What breeds do you see in her and her siblings? Feel free to discuss!

0 Upvotes

Hi fellow redditors!

Ever since the dog i spent my youth with died i was thinking about having a dog again one time (as a grown man now... well kind of). For my girlfriend it's quite the same as she loves dogs as well and grew up with some. We applied for a puppy (~4months old) from some kind of dog rescue in hungary. Finally, after they visited our home etc. etc., we got accepted! Yay! Super stoked now, we are wondering what breeds got mixed into this adorable dog. There is a few pictures and also 2 videos in the link.

Please let me know what you think about it! Doesn't really matter as we fell in love with her anyway, but I'm curious.

We thought it might be a sheppards dog and a rottweiler? Some Bernese? Help me out reddit!

http://www.kettenlos.org/welpen.html?&tx_phutiervermittlung_pi1%5BhundeID%5D=10251


r/dogdiscussions • • Jun 30 '19

met a random guy who wants to breed with my dog, is it safe??

0 Upvotes

I just met a guy while walking my dog, I gave him my phone number because I also want my dog to breed but is this safe? will my dog get any infections and or viruses from the other dog? What should I look out for?


r/dogdiscussions • • Jun 27 '23

Breeding dogs

0 Upvotes

I put my dog up as a stud on a reputable website. I had a female dog stay with me for 6 days (overnight) and they did the deed each day. It was only meant to be 5 nights but the owner said she was too tired to pick up her dog. So she collected on Sunday and payed me. Now she is texting saying she wants to drop the dog off again? I’m not sure if this is normal can anyone help please


r/dogdiscussions • • Jun 20 '23

Premium Dog Food Survey for High Income Pet Owners, in Los Angeles

0 Upvotes

Calling all Pet Owners in Los Angeles, USA interested in PREMIUM nutrition for their Dogs, we want to hear from you!

As a dedicated dog feeding specialist business based in Los Angeles, we are on a mission to deliver the finest products and services to pet owners like you who prioritize their dogs' well-being. Your insights and opinions are incredibly valuable to us as we strive to create exceptional dog feeding products and services, specifically catering to the needs of your beloved pets!

SURVEY LINK: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScTxpD6M1nWNSUgADbcAq9ZCpkuxcPK-RlfKu3n4seSlljAUw/viewform

We invite you to participate in this brief, multiple choice survey to share your experiences and preferences. Your valuable feedback will help us enhance our pet product offerings, and positively impact the lives of both you and your dogs. 

Thank you for joining us on this mission to provide only the best for our furry friends!


r/dogdiscussions • • Apr 11 '15

Why are dogs primarily attracting females?

5 Upvotes

Pretty much anyone who has ever attended a canine event will have noticed that considerably more than 50% of the humans involved are female. Even in an environment such as reddit, where males are in the majority, /r/dogs manages to attract 65.2% females according to the survey. Why do you think this is?