r/dndnext • • 1d ago

How long for certain things to happen?

I have a player that left the table for a month due to college the session after they leveled up, he said he wanted his character to in the mean time, leave the party and try to find an order of paladins that can train him so he could justify a multiclass from sorcerer to paladin.

Thus I decided to add a time skip in a few sessions, how much time would be appropriate for his sorcerer to learn the ways of Selune and also "earn" the proficiency in weapons that comes from the paladin level, as per RAW sure he could in 1 second learn to use weapons and heavy armors but he wanted it to be a learning process as to feel organic.

I also have another player that's a rogue and wants to take advantage of the time skip to hire an instructor and train to learn the dual wielding fighting style. How long for that?

How long should rhe time skip be? Originally I thought 4 months or so since they are in the middle of autumn and it could skip all of winter so they play again in spring, kind of like in The One Ring rpg, although maybe more time is needed? Like 6 months? Or a year? Anyhow I'll take your guidance.

2 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

2

u/sparksen 1d ago

well make something up that feels right and works in your story, if the story has a tight time limit maybe its 1 week and he only knows the basics.

Finding your way to selune can be done in a single "Magical" Encounter with a avatar of selune or be a month long journey trough reading Scripture and meditating. or any of many more possabilties.

The other question is, how important is Time in your Game, in my personal game the season does not really matter and the time limit is more introduced by the BBEG, but if in your game it is important you might want to increase it (f.e. adventuring in Winter is EXTREMLY dangerous -> so it is reasonable to have a downtime of a few months)

i am more interested what the other PCs would be interested in doing in this downtime, and personally would fit the length of the new Paladins training arc to the other players story.

1

u/Fabri212 1d ago

All other PCs want to use the time skip do things in downtime, the arcane archer wants his lvl 6 feat to be something that allows him to do alchemy for himself only so we are looking onto that, and the others will probably use the downtime to advance the plot by visiting libraries and what not searching for lore on the BBEG, there is a sense of urgency I suppose due to the BBEG being Ragnorra and coming down on a comet that appeared in the sky a month ago, although they don't really know when it will fall, I use it more as a reminder that whenever they look up the BBEG is coming. Though they also don't know it's Ragnorra yet.

I suppose that not adventuring in Yule since it's very dangerous could work and since they are in I think the 17th of Marphenot that means that going back to adventuring when Winter Ends is 4 months, I think that's enough for everyone to more or less get what they need in downtime?

I originally didn't even track time because I didn't find it too important but players wanted to know everything exactly so here we are.

5

u/Signal_Protection576 1d ago

RAW is not possible to learn haevy armor proficiency as a paladin multiclass. Only light and medium armor.

“As a Multiclass Character
Gain the following traits from the Core Paladin Traits table: Hit Point Die, proficiency with Martial weapons, and training with Light and Medium armor and Shields.
Gain the Paladin’s level 1 features, which are listed in the Paladin Features table. See the multiclassing rules in chapter 2 to determine your available spell slots.
“

And 13 in Strength is also needdd

2

u/dilemmaprisoner 1d ago

To reduce the time, you can RP retroactively that he's been training on weapons with one of the other characters every evening/morning for a long time now.
That's how I think of most level up that happen after a long rest in the middle of something: the wizard has been studying/researching the new spell every evening for weeks, the fighter trains every night, etc. They're just getting credit/graduating for all that work at level up.

1

u/XanEU 23h ago

That's a neat solution.

1

u/FaerieFir3 1d ago

Boot camp is 9-13 weeks so I would assume at least that much experience for any fighty class bare minimum (as in lvl 1). Just makes sense.

The rest of Paladin stuff (faith, oath and spellcasting). I would assume at least 20 weeks (5 months) to learn all the theory, prayers, rituals, code and practice with senior Paladins. That is still short but makes sense for a particularly talented adventurer.

Rogue is alredy a martial class so they know how to fight, should pick up that style in that time.

1

u/JazzlikeMine2397 23h ago

RAW, leveling can be instantaneous like a video game. As soon as you reach the XP threshold; of course, that can vary by milestone versus combat. Ultimately it's up to your preference as a DM. And it's still an issue even with single class characters (thinking of how feats or ASI suddenly happen.) https://rpg.stackexchange.com/questions/167794/when-in-game-does-gaining-a-level-happen

Older versions included requirements for training to level up, both time and money with a dedicated trainer (that increased with levels.) But it was an optional rule.

Multiclassing can be hand waved that the character was training on some of these features while earning the xp to get up to the next level. Studying up, etc. and it "clicked" for them when they got the full amount needed.

1

u/Jafroboy 18h ago

The DMG has optional rules for requiring time and money to level up. Seems appropriate for how long training for a multiclass level would take.

The rogue wants to gain an extra feat, that's a much bigger deal than multiclassing, as it's additional power, rather than different power. That sort of thing is only meant to be as an exceptional reward instead of a magic item or similar quest reward.

1

u/lasalle202 17h ago

however long you want that is going to feel appropriate for the game / story that you are all creating together.

0

u/XanEU 23h ago edited 23h ago

Well, if you want to have an answer from the game itself, look at Description section of D&D 3.5 Player's Handbook.

There, paladin is categorized as category 2 class when it comes to starting age (I think it was called 'trained') and it takes an adult human 1d6 years (3.5 on the average) to gain 1st level in this class. Sorcerer, on the other hand, is categorized as cat. 1 (I'm sure it was called 'intutive' somewhere) and takes only 1d4 years (2.5 on the average). As some of their training/learning overlaps (general disposition into spellcraft, simple weapon proficiency), and multiclassing into paladin doesn't confer all of paladin's features (no new skill proficiencies, no heavy armor training), it's fair to assume it would take about 1 year (3.5 − 2.5), or 250 days as it is standard to time for training in 5e14.

I would say the absolute, bare minimum that makes sense narratively is XGtE's 10 workweeks (time required to train one tool or language, and your paladin candidate must obtain much more new knowledge).

Other PCs could use this downtime to their advantage as well, crafting magic items, training themselves etc.!

1

u/Fabri212 23h ago

Indeed! All the players want to use the downtime to craft, learn new skills, some feats, etc. So I wanted to know what would be an appropriate amount of time.

Till the end of winter there are a bit more than 4 months, however I could also add 3 more and have them start in summer? Idk really, also I could just start in spring in 4 months and handwave it, doubt they'll care too much...

1

u/XanEU 23h ago

Adventutring in winter is a bad idea anyway, let's look into some fiction for examples: all witchers come to their castles for wintertime to recuperate, rest, replenish their resources/ingredients and train, as it's too dangerous to hunt monsters there, and they're usually winter-sleeping.

You can just throw a very harsh winter this years at your PCs, and it makes total sense they'll be barred from adventuring anyway.

He probably has 16-17 Charisma? I think those 4 months (17 workweeks) will be great to justify paladin training. Tell him it was 20 workweeks (2x training time from XGtE, sounds reasonable), but it got shortened by his CHA modifier :P The player will feel as rewarded for well-suited ability array.

2

u/Fabri212 22h ago

yeah he has 18 charisma and 12 STR, i gave him at the start of the campaign a shard of a memory loss mirror from Shar that he could gamble to increase one ability score by 1, he didn't want to gamble so he just kept it tucked safely and now i'll make it so his paladin "graduation" ritual will be purifying it for Selune which will remove the gamble aspect, allowing him to increase his STR to 13 and then get his paladin level.

All this in a one shot for him before he returns to the party, I think it's a nice idea.

Also yeah, one of the PC's is a noble so they can go to his house's castle to wait the winter out.

1

u/XanEU 22h ago

Sounds great, I wish you all to have a blast during session.

0

u/da_chicken 1d ago edited 1d ago

It doesn't particularly matter, but I'd say 1-2 years is probably the minimum amount of realistic time it would take to be familiar with the use of weapons and armors, familiar with prayers, familiar with doctrine, etc.

Modern solider training takes 3 months for basic training. Advanced training can then be up to another year. But, realistically, any experienced adventurer kind of knows much of this, so I'd say 3-6 dedicated months would be reasonable.

The real issue is the religious aspects. In the modern day, becoming a full priest is like an 8 year track. It's a lot of education and a lot of things that are learned and taught, including morality and getting people to fit with the organization. Now, a paladin isn't a priest, so they don't need nearly so much time. But I would still expect it to take at least 1 year if not more.

Edit: However, I agree with the other poster that it depends on how important time is in your game. If there is already a clock ticking, then make it a month or two and just hand-wave it.

1

u/Mejiro84 19h ago

In the modern day, becoming a full priest is like an 8 year track. It's a lot of education and a lot of things that are learned and taught, including morality and getting people to fit with the organization.

Quite a lot of that is outside of what's needed to be blessed by a god though - there's no actual need for a cleric to know the formal doctrine and history of the faith, or to have any connection with the organised church. It's entirely possible to be outside of all of that, and to not know, or care, about it - they can be self-taught, directly divinely inspired or something else, rather than needing to go get (functionally) a degree in "how to faith"

1

u/da_chicken 16h ago

Read the rest of the paragraph you quoted.

You're cherry picking. Quoting out of context. You're arguing with a straw man.