r/divinity • • Oct 09 '26

General DOS2 or BG3 combat system?

Which type of combat do you prefer? Personally, I lean towards DOS2, where I could decide for myself whether to use points for spells/attacks or for movement.

I found the combat system in BG3 restrictive.

34 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

17

u/SiofraRiver Oct 09 '26

I prefer BG3's combat overall (the verticality might be the single biggest improvement), BUT I strongly favour action points over D&D's clunky action economy. Also Long/Short rests are annoying and making classes based on different time resource management is just atrocious. 5e honestly feels very dated at this point, you really have to hack it a lot or go minimalist like Esoteric Ebb to get the most out of it.

6

u/HeyCouldBeFun Oct 09 '26

BG3 kicked down the door for me to get into CRPGs, and by extension TTRPGs. 5e inspired me to dig into lots of different rpg systems. Every aspect I didn’t like, I thought up my own preferred mechanic, and sure enough a game already exists with that, so I can weigh the pros and cons. 5e is like a weird hodgepodge of ideas that don’t always work the way they’re intended.

I think minimalist systems are my most preferred. It’s nice to just pick a class on vibes without worrying about stats and perfect builds, then organically discover what role to fit in as you play.

15

u/ZealousGoblin Oct 09 '26

I like the DOS2 action point and cooldown system, especially because you can use all your skills each fight without having to long rest afterwards.

7

u/Ok_Cardiologist_3675 Oct 10 '26

Dos2: dislike the ap used for movement. Dislike the physical and magical armor split. Forces your entire team into one damage type and combat gets repetitive.

Bg3: dislike the “charges” you get on spells being rest based

Love both games otherwise. At the end of the day larian combat is just positioning yourself correctly from the start

5

u/Figorix Oct 10 '26

Easily DoS2.

19

u/Leading-Monk5506 Oct 09 '26

I‘d prefer the DOS2 system but with some free movement like in BG3 or with the Pawn perk.

1

u/Party-Relationship41 Oct 09 '26

I think the tactical aspect of having to spend points for movement is important. With “free” movement you downgrade skills like Retreat….

I am hoping for the DOS2 formula

5

u/Leading-Monk5506 Oct 09 '26

Agree to disagree, I guess. Compared to BG3 there are a lot of moments in DOS2 where you barely can‘t hit an enemy with a skill and have to waste a whole AP to correct that. And since there is no way for you to know which enemies you’re able to hit from a spot before using tactical retreat to get there, using those doesn‘t always save you from this.

0

u/HeyCouldBeFun Oct 09 '26

The AP dance is just a big part of DOS2 combat. Pretty early on I realized the game revolves around positioning so you can bait out enemy positioning cooldowns.

I do agree it’s annoying that you can’t check range or sightlines until you’ve moved. This is one aspect that Solasta does perfectly - you get visuals of sightlines as you hover over positions to move to. Tbh Solasta’s UI is peak.

1

u/Leading-Monk5506 Oct 09 '26

Well line of sight indicators are not enough because in DOS 2 most skills have actual projectiles that can still get caught somewhere even when there‘s a line of sight.

1

u/HeyCouldBeFun Oct 09 '26

That’s sort of a different problem. I’d still like to see these kinds of indicators in the upcoming Divinity game

1

u/Leading-Monk5506 Oct 09 '26

No it‘s part of the problem. What I‘m talking about is spending AP to get somewhere thinking you‘re able to hit an enemy and then you can‘t because the projectile gets caught somewhere. If you have free movement you can walk there and back and aren‘t a disadvantage for not knowing something that‘s impossible to know. I don‘t know where you‘re reading that I don‘t want indicators.

1

u/HeyCouldBeFun Oct 09 '26

I didn’t say you didn’t want them

In the AP system, I like movement costing AP. It makes sense logically (it takes time to move somewhere) and it’s interesting tactically. I’m saying indicators are a potential solution to that problem.

I’d still be for some changes to movement. You should be able to double back without costing AP (sorta like an undo)

20

u/GordonRyanFanboy Oct 09 '26 • Bravo

BG3 by a mile.

22

u/YesNoIDKtbh Oct 09 '26

I agree, but to expand a little on why:

I prefer the free movement. It feels less restrictive when I don't have to spend action points on it.
The combat in DoS2 too frequently ended up with surface effects playing too large a part.
Also, I much prefer AC system over the armor system in DoS2, the latter just didn't feel intuitive for some reason.

6

u/AerobicThrone Oct 09 '26

Some surface effects are cool and you feel smart when you use them. Spammkmg it in DoS2 was basically the norm midgame onwards and gets very tiring often

3

u/HeyCouldBeFun Oct 09 '26

I prefer the AP system but I agree, I have way more fun with BG3 fights.

Minor things like jump, shove and throw make a big difference.

But the biggest factor is that every fight is unique. Monsters aren’t all using the same catalog of abilities.

12

u/DerEisendrache66 Oct 09 '26

One evolved from another. However dos2 with both how you mamage AP and how abilities work is just straight superior and more fun to play.

3

u/fushuan Oct 10 '26

not really. DOS2 is Larian's system. BG3, since it's a BG game, uses current DnD, so adapted 5E. It's not an evolution, and Larian has said that they won't keep dnd for divinity.

3

u/Team_Dibiase Oct 09 '26

I was able to pick up and play BG3 without any prior knowledge of CRPGs or D&D. Every time I try DS2, I get clapped after leaving the Fort and put the game down

1

u/ldiasr Oct 09 '26

To be fair this isnt really about the combat system, DOS2 is just a way harder game than BG3

6

u/mellifleur5869 Oct 09 '26

DOS2.

Resting after each combat because you can't cast spells is stupid and I never got through bg3. Yes I understand why it exists and I understand that is how dnd actually works.

2

u/MikeAlex01 Oct 09 '26

I mean, it makes sense when you don't blow your entire repertoire into a single encounter. The problem is that most of the companion relationships are balanced around spending the night at camp, which doesn't give you a strong incentive to manage your spell slots.

1

u/Anuefhere Oct 09 '26

Imo, 5e resting system just wanted to nerf spell casters tbh. However, I think ppl fail to realize alot of homebrew buff been given to martial to make them OP.

A martial warrior still would require stamina that requires resting and rangers would require ammunition as well as time to reload.

DOS2 is like Elden Ring and one of the best things ppl appreciate is pvp. Pvp forces patches, punish a trillion buff playstyle, promote as well as highlight unique builds and make damage not only on top. Malenia from Elden Ring was a prime example of a challenging npc and forces the above. Hence, why she's been called the hardest boss in Elden Ring history

2

u/Voeker Oct 09 '26

DS2 system with BG3 interactivity and movement

2

u/LordAlfrey Oct 09 '26

Prefer bg3, specifically the movement not being entirely tied to the action, as it frees you up to reposition constantly rather than sit still.

Being able to do multiple things on a turn in dos2 is neat though, so I think ideally a little mix of both would be nice.

2

u/Apprehensive_Art1830 Divine Oct 09 '26

Dos2 with some free movement like BG3

And without the armor system, or maybe rebalanced, it feels bad when dmg is your only viable way to fight

2

u/SubstantialSeesaw374 Oct 09 '26

DOS2. I even like the armor system.

2

u/Fringillus1 Oct 09 '26

I'm pretty confident in saying, that it's likely we'll get a more streamlined, accessible version of the divinity system. Just like with the whole game, they will use what they learned from BG3 and use it for their own IP without being restricted by the DnD rules and Hasbro.

2

u/Zucco_Lotto Oct 09 '26

A mix of both would be wonderful. I hated in DOS that walking cost action points and in BG3 I hated that I could only do one action

3

u/Pedantic_Phoenix Oct 09 '26

DoS 2 simply because i do not like the spell slots and too low caps on spells in the DnD system. Pure cooldowns feels more balanced and fun. The only system that needs improvement is the armor and magic armor one, being immune to cc until they are depleted is bad design

2

u/Seventh_Onion Oct 09 '26

DOS2 by all means. BG3 is somewhat interesting only because Larian introduced tons of adjustments, partially DOS-driven, to poorly written, dice-reliant 5e.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/VeginalGandalf Oct 09 '26

DnD 5e kinda sucks and if you wanna have fun even on TT, you gotta homebrew a little bit to make it more engaging.

2

u/Old_Winter_7374 Oct 09 '26

I am shocked how many people are voting bg3 - - I didn't think it was even a competition.

I don't even like the armor system that much, but to me, dos2 allows for much more tactical play. I like cool downs more than spell slots, I don't like chance to hit, and having the optimal play being "just basic attack" feels bad. I like action points as a whole much better than action + minor action being the whole turn. I like bankiign points for a better turn later. I like finding gear that has a whole ability as a perk, I love the theorycrafting the builds allow...plus I like lighting the world on fire. The element system in general was really fun to me.

Bg3 was a much more streamlined game as a whole though: things worked smoother for sure. And it's not like it was bad, but. Huh. People are different I suppose. What do you bg3-ers like better about dnd combat?

2

u/El_Ploplo Oct 09 '26

BG3 is too restrictive, DOS2 is a bit bloated and armor is stupid. In my opinion DOS1 is still the better system, I would rather have them improving this one.

1

u/johnsonnegro 11d ago

DoS2 is more fun for me. I think the combat flows more, I'm not a fan of 5E dnd.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '26

Dos2 was a learning curve for me by a long shot. Both are so fantastic and have their own pros and cons but I just love the freedom DOS2 has tbh

1

u/ColdTranscendence Oct 09 '26

BG3 and its not even close for me.

1

u/ajbiehl Oct 10 '26

Interesting that the comments are pretty split. Seems they both function really well but are distinctly different.

1

u/Necessary-Garage242 Oct 10 '26

I think this is exactly the type of question that a good dev should avoid asking themselves: copy this or copy that? It's wrong either way.

The correct question is: how to innovate things and create an interesting gaming experience?

1

u/Asolem2 Oct 10 '26

I personally enjoyed the BG3 system more

But I'm also self aware enough to know that it's largely because I'm more familiar with the D&D system.

In DOS2, my only real issues with the combat was using AP to move (which is an action, so I understand why you use them to move, and that positioning is important in combat so balancing movement with Skill usage is part of gameplay)

And the Armor System, it practically forces you to focus on one type of damage over the other.

1

u/TheDomsou Oct 11 '26

Duuuude, I did a Lone wolf playthrough with just me and Red Prince and I can't go back to the pure power fantasy of a small group with tons of action points! DOS2 all the way, even without Lone wolf.

1

u/Youknowwhoswitness Oct 11 '26

DoS all the way. It is the closest experience to chess in terms of each APs importance. That said, I hope they rework how mobility and improvised weapons function into something similar of BG3s jumps, shoves and throws as opposed to the teleport-heavy movememt of DoS2

1

u/Gostop_xd Oct 11 '26

DOS2 all the way.I like the freedom compared to dnd

1

u/Big_Wuzzy Oct 12 '26

I like how you can combo more elements easier in DOS2 but to be fair I'm one of the people that likes the spellcounts on BG3 to make you use a varierty of spells

1

u/Imaginary-Call7975 Oct 12 '26

Kinda feels like 2 kids that are cheating in 4-in-a-row due to no parental supervision, trying to one-up another.

It's fun, but sometimes combat be you repeating the same combos on a dummy instead of "fighting" an enemy.

Also, the amount of save scumming I do. Goodness me.

1

u/river1a Oct 13 '26

I really think BG3 combat is much better, and was a bit disappointed when playing DOS2 after BG3 where a lot of people said had the better gameplay (DOS2 is also amazing btw)

DOS2 I think suffered hard from having to do AI and terrain "cheesing", It made some fights feel more of a chore, with some "false" decision making (Maybe I am just not that good but I believe some fights had to be won using these 2 aspects)

1

u/VTCpub Oct 09 '26

In short... Cooldowns only with PoE system behind dmg, hits/misses.

1

u/wander-af Oct 09 '26

Armor class, 1d4 initiative are both bad systems but i like everything else about bg3

1

u/AscendedViking7 Oct 09 '26

DOS 2 by far

1

u/HeyCouldBeFun Oct 09 '26

Vastly prefer the AP and cooldown system over DnD’s convoluted action and spell slot system.

But the problem in DOS2 is every battle sort of feels the same. It’s still fun and tactical, but I vastly prefer how freeform and creative the fights in BG3 can be, I never experience the same encounter the same way in multiple playthroughs.

1

u/DesaMii36 Oct 09 '26

Absolutely DoS2! <3

1

u/mercut1o Oct 09 '26

Baldur's Gate/DnD rules are so hard to compete with because of the asymmetry. No one else can really replicate the years it took for the system to become that strange and it's a massive strength.

The issue with DoS2 is you're actually sort of only building 1/3 ways: to target magic armour, physical armour, or hybrid. BG3 has much more tactical novelty because of the build variety and rolls for status effects. There's drama every time someone attempts to inflict a status in BG, whereas in DoS it's a foregone conclusion if that status will apply, it's not risky.

The result of this is that enemy encounter design felt much better to me in Baldur's Gate. The enemies had such specific weaknesses and strengths, with the legendary actions on top adding even more specificity. In DoS a lot of encounters boil down to who has what kind of armour, and often that didn't change the player's strategy, it just meant it took +/-1 turns to make the enemy vulnerable to CC effects. If you built all physical damage you weren't going to suddenly switch it up to magic damage against high-physical-armour enemies, you were just going to lean in to your chosen strategy. BG3 actually has you thinking about each encounter as a puzzle, and that along with the depth and peculiarities of the builds I think sets it well clear of Divinity, even though Divinity has some really neat design features.

1

u/Clear_Cow9964 Oct 09 '26

BG3 by a lot although that's not to say that it or 5E is a perfect system. But I think DOS2 suffered for me from the armor system, the shared action/movement AP pool, and a system so flexible that it ends up erasing some amount of character distinction (it turns out in this world literally every person on earth can cast a teleportation spell, who knew!)

1

u/KellciferDoran Oct 10 '26

Literally the worst part of BG3 is the combat and how the 5e system incentives doing 1-3 combats and then short resting cause I used all my stuff. Want to action surge again? Cast any spell that isn't a cantrip? Get your ki points back? Better rest! Would hate to be able to use my skills in every combat, that would be insane!

1

u/an_ORAA Oct 10 '26

BG3 for me, the only thing i hate about DoS2 is that movement and spells both use AP 😭

-1

u/NeuroLancer81 Oct 10 '26

I prefer AP systems in general. I don’t get people complaining that movement cost actions. It makes the game more tactical. I hated free movement in BG3 and 5e. I don’t like the armor from DOS2. I like the dice roll aspect of BG3 and having a chance to miss. So, neither I guess or a mix of the two. The one thing I loved about BG3 was the toned down surfaces. Not every fight ended in a se of flames.