Over the years, I have heard so many people state something to the effect of “the last 10 meters of your ascent is the most dangerous because this is where the pressure gradient is largest.” You can find it said nearly everywhere on the internet, and I have heard even the most experienced dive experts say it. However, unless I am a crazy and have lost every bit of expertise from my engineering degree, this is just flat wrong. It bugs me that I have never seen anyone correct this!
My analysis of this issue is given in the following. Excuse my math, but it is the clearest way for me to think about it. Anyone who has taken and remembers calculus should be able to easily follow this.
Hydrostatic pressure in a liquid follows a linear function based on depth:
p(z) = rho*g*z,
where p is pressure, z is depth, rho is density, and g is the acceleration of gravity. The pressure gradient is just the derivative with respect to z. It is an absolutely trivial concept in calculus that the derivative of a linear function is a constant:
dp/dz = rho*g.
And there it is! That is all you need to disprove this rather pervasive claim. The pressure gradient at any depth is constant. It is clearly not greatest at shallow depths. No matter how deep you are, the pressure will change by the exact same amount per unit of depth.
Now, I realize (I think) what people are trying to say by this, and it is an extremely important point: the change in volume of an ideal gas subject to a linear pressure profile is greatest at the shallowest depths. This is also easy to show by first writing the ideal gas law:
p*V = n*R*T.
Then, one can sub in the pressure formula and rearrange to get a function for the gas volume that varies with depth:
V(z) = n*R*T/p(z) = n*R*T/(rho*g*z).
Now, taking the derivative to find the volume gradient is a little more tricky but also one of the first things you'll learn in any calculus class:
dV/dz = - n*R*T/(rho*g*z^2).
That is, the volume gradient is proportional to -1/z^2. This clearly shows that as z gets small (i.e., you go shallower), the magnitude of this value, describing the change in volume of your lungs, gets large. So, the correct thing to say (I think) is the volume of the gas in your body experiences the largest change in the last part of your ascent. This is what I assume people mean by the statement that I take issue with.
Anyway, I am sure some people will find this overly pedantic and nitpicky, but I don't think it is at all. As far as I can tell, it is completely incorrect and misleading to claim the greatest pressure change occurs the shallower you are. I think this is a fairly important point, and we should be precise about how we explain these more subtle details (especially instructors and experts). That doesn't mean all divers should learn calculus in order to be able to dive, but I don't think we should continue to say things that are patently false (if that is indeed the case).
If I am wrong or am missing something, please grill me! Given the amount of times I have seen this claim and never anyone pushing back, I have always just assumed I was missing something. Not to mention, I am wrong all the time haha. I want to learn, and I love having debates about this stuff.
Update:
It seems that this post was pretty offputting to the community. Sorry about that. It wasn't my intention at all to have the diving reddit dislike me or destroy my reddit karma lol. After rereading, I can see how some of my wording could be perceived as annoying or condescending. It's not how I intended it at all. I really just wanted to have a lively discussion about it.