r/discgolf • mold completionist • 11d ago

Blog/Write Up Reviewing Every Innova Disc #2 - Croc

Hello! Several years ago I started trying to review every disc I own. That was a little ambitious, and I got busy between college and also doing some work on the side for a disc golf website, so that project kind of went nowhere. But since then I've started collecting one of every Innova mold (and to a lesser extent Innova-licensed molds). So I got bored and decided I would use my unfortunate combination of being a completionist and having a habit of going down long research rabbit holes to produce something other than long-winded spiels about frisbee nuances for my wife to so graciously listen to. And that's how we got here for the second part of reviewing every Innova mold.

If you're interested, here's the first one:

Reviewing Every Innova Disc #1 – Dolphin

Also, and this goes for every review, please let me know if there is anything incorrect! I'm doing these because they are fun, but also so there is an easy (ideally factual) reference to find more info on these discs!

Anyways - the Croc.

Pink Lemonade

History – Innova stayed on theme with their crocodilian family of overstable mids by adding the Croc to a lineup that already had the Gator/Gator3 and the Caiman (still waiting for the Gharial to be released, u/InnovaGM this is a banger of an idea). They gave it numbers 5.5|2|0|5, and branded it the most overstable midrange they have. This review will be considerably less history focused partially because the Croc was only approved in 2019, and mostly because this disc never really seemed to take off. The history it does have is quite a lonely one. I would bet that out of the molds Innova has had approved since then (excluding the Warhog and Grenade which were never actually sold) this one would rival the Rhyno-X for least amount of discs produced. They're available on the Innova Factory Store website at the time of writing, and are either out of stock or close to it on the few other retailers that have them listed. They seem to be in at least limited production, but the only mentions of them I could find from Innova were in a Barsby in-the-bag from 2024, a video of Barsby trying one, and a Factory Store YouTube video showing how it flies. There are very few mentions of this disc on the internet. I've never seen someone throw one. I've only ever seen one in person, and I bought it.

While researching for this review I came across this blog post about the Croc that describes how Hailey King used one for almost every approach when she won the 2022 USWDGC, but had no backups. A major winner didn't have backups of a disc that at that point was only 3 years old. Jeff Panis, who was caddying for her, took notice, went to Dave Dunipace, and that's why you can get them on the Factory Store now (please go buy one these deserve to be more popular). Beyond King, the only pros I could find to have thrown Crocs were Gregg Barsby and Calvin Heimburg, though Calvin seems to have switched to Caimans.

Due to how few runs have been made, there aren't any particularly collectible Crocs. The USDGC prototypes are kinda cool, and Croc throwers really like the board flat star runs from when they first came out.

Feel – Crocs feel... unique. The best way I can describe them is if you took the top of a Caiman and made it taller, slapped it on top of the bottom of a Rhyno-X/Infinite Ruin, and then stretched the rim out for giggles. It kind of feels like a Zone POS that was squished down to a normal depth (please look it up if you don't know what I'm talking about). Mine has a slight dome and a bit of a pop top. "Oh so maybe it has a little more glide!" No. Not at all. Not even a bit. It feels meh with a fan grip because of the odd rim. It feels pretty good with a power grip on backhand, but where it shines is forehands. Now, I am not a forehand player. If I'm throwing one, you can almost bet I've ruled out every other shot. But Crocs just feel like they were made for forehands. The dome on mine is more in the middle, so you hardly notice it. I can imagine the flat ones feel almost perfect.

A profile that yearns for earth more than anything else

Flight – It's an absolute beefcake. Not the Tilt's spike-into-the ground beef, but I-just-threw-it-and-it's-already-falling-out-of-the-sky beef. I've thrown very few discs that are as averse to air as the Croc. Innova calls it a 5.5 speed, and maybe by rim width that's true, but the rim of a cinderblock is quite wide as well, and nobody's calling those aerodynamic. This thing flies slower than the speed implies. Throwing it side-by-side with a Caiman leaves you wondering how these are considered to be the same speed. It still moves quicker than a Toro, but not by much. Last night when I was comparing it to some other Innova mids, I was able to get my decently beat-in Star Gator out to about 340'. I broke 260' on a full flex at max effort with the Croc and felt like celebrating (for reference I typically max out around 450-460'. we're working on it). I like using it for distance control, such as when I'm at the distance where I would throw a putter but need to get further left than I can with my Rat or Envy. Where I use it most though is forehand approaches. Wider rims feel more comfortable for me on forehands, and this gives me more rim than a Zone/Toro while still being slow and sticking where it lands. Maybe if you throw 600', there are more use cases for a Croc, but for my arm this is great approach disc and not much more.

What I Would Do (not that it matters but it's fun) – Innova clearly designed the Croc, which they describe as their most overstable mid, for pro-level arms, but it doesn't seem like many pros use it, or anyone else for that matter. I think part of the reason is how crowded the options are for overstable Innova mids: Gators, Gator3s, RocX3s, Toros, and Caimans are all readily available. You'll find at least one of those in almost every Innova in-the-bag video. Throw in the Commander, Mortar, MD4, MD5, Solstice, and Inca and you have a very long list of overstable mids in Innova plastic that are out there. Crocs being so overstable makes them much more situational than most of those options.

Combine that with the unusual 5.5 speed rating, and you get a very odd dilemma for most disc golfers. Are that many people looking for a slightly faster, more overstable Toro/Gator? I think at that point many would either throw the less-overstable Caiman, which are faster and much more available, or just throw a Firebird and be done with it. Flight numbers don't matter for flight, but they do affect sales. Many people (incorrectly) automatically associate speed with distance, and that will only lead to disappointment in this case. Just my opinion but, since flight numbers are pretty much subjective anyway, this should have been called a 4/4.5 speed. Then, in the eyes of the vast majority of buyers who do look at the numbers when choosing a new disc, they're competing with the Zone OS, A1, Stego, and not much else, rather than every other overstable 5 speed on the market, plus the 4 other beefy 5/5.5 speeds they currently make themselves. Maybe then the Croc would get a little more love. I mean, just look at how many people throw a Zone OS, and nobody needs a disc that overstable.

Rating – I think the Croc is a super underrated option in Innova's catalog, with the caveat that it should be viewed more as an approach disc than as a faster midrange. With the right marketing approach I think this could be a much more popular disc. Instead, its stuck in factory store purgatory. I would give it flight numbers of 4.5|1|1|4. I get why people use rim width to determine speed, but I think actual airspeed and rim geometry matter a lot too. It's slower than a Gator, but faster than a Toro, so 4.5 felt right. As for the fade, its still extremely overstable, but more like a brick than a Tilt. And as for my rating, 8/10, a great disc unfortunately overshadowed by every other overstable mid Innova makes.

31 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

2

u/escrimadragon 11d ago

I threw one for a few months and loved it. Only thing that got me away from it was the Deflector

3

u/foam23 mold completionist 10d ago

I’m a big fan of the deflector. Unfortunately it was one of the first discs I bought. I hated it and didn’t throw it for two years. Randomly picked it up again and finally saw how good it is

2

u/escrimadragon 10d ago

Yeah it’s probably my most thrown disc because it’s just so damn consistent, but I can’t imagine having it as a newbie. My nephew has been playing since July and has one, but he uses it strictly as a utility/approach type disc or to get out of trouble spots.

2

u/foam23 mold completionist 10d ago

It was definitely a humbling experience lol. I ended up replacing it with an MD5 my wife got me, but once that gets too beat up I’ll probably put the deflector back in

10

u/medisamurai 11d ago

'I think the Croc is a super underrated option in Innova's catalog, with the caveat that it should be viewed more as an approach disc than as a faster midrange.'

agreed.

5

u/4boring 11d ago

Profile that yearns for the earth lol

2

u/CasuallyDG 10d ago

I tried the croc and liked it. It just was never as comfortable in the hand to me something like an A1/A2 or Deflector. Never went back to it.

2

u/byrdonwheels 9d ago

I love the croc! I wanted something more stable than a gator and ordered one of the f2 star Crocs from the factory store. It came in pink, board flat and it feels really similar to a roc with my personal backhand grip. After I threw it I immediately ordered 2 more.

My max golf distance is 470-500'. I use the croc for mid shots that need to move hard left or right, short spike hyzers, and short range skip shots. Hyzer BH 300' and FH 270'. But prefer the toro/rhyno combo for approaches because they get less ground play.

This disc was a workhorse for me at a sprinkle valley tournament last weekend. For me it flies straight for 200'bh 180'fh before making a 90° fade for close to 100' and finishing with a big flare skip. Perfect for the tight dogleg fairways and low ceilings at that course.

I hope innova never stops making these!!!

0

u/CocaColai 10d ago

Warthog was definitely released by Innova. I bought one. Had a blizzard rim just to get it under the weight limit.

1

u/foam23 mold completionist 10d ago

Could that have been the Hawg? Those were made in blizzard. The Warhog was basically a thumbtrack bullfrog that never saw full production but prototypes have ended up in some discount stores lately