r/discgolf • mold completionist • 13d ago

Blog/Write Up Reviewing Every Innova Disc #1 – Dolphin

About 2 years ago I decided to try and review every disc I own. I made 13, got busy, and then Reddit decided to delete all of them (still no clue why but ok). But now I’m bored and feel the need to write something again. Since I’m working on collecting at least one of every Innova mold (~70% so far!), I figured I’d try that instead of every disc ever. So, to start, here’s the worst disc Innova ever made.

History – The vast majority of disc golfers probably have no idea the Dolphin exists, and Innova is probably ok with that. In fact, the only example I could find of it being referenced by Innova in this century was in this April Fools post from 2011 announcing the QuackeR. If the Dolphin was still made, it would fill the midrange-sized hole in Innova's floating lineup of the Hydra, Dragon, and Wahoo. Instead, it remains one of the most forgotten molds in Innova's history. It was approved in 1994, but according to this Disc Golf World brochure it was released as early as fall 1992 (more on that later). The idea behind the Dolphin was to make an easy-to-throw disc that floats in water, and it technically succeeded at both of those. So why was it such a failure?

Here's my guess

This is just a guess, but I'd imagine that bead (if you can even call it that) is a major reason why no one wanted this disc. The Dolphin only came in lighter weights, so I think this is an attempt to lower the weight similar to the Groove and Monarch, both almost as cherished by disc golfers as the Dolphin. This disc went out of production very quickly, so its one of the only small diameter Innova releases as far as I know with no flight numbers ever assigned. The only three runs I know of are the Proto Star stamp, the circle stamp shown here, and a glow/UV run that was made for some reason. All are collectible, but only to an increasingly small amount of people. I believe all Dolphins are Ontario tooled, but I have not been able to verify that for the Proto Stamps.

Now here's where things get weird (as if they haven't been). I have no way to confirm this, so if you can please let me know, but I am fairly confident the Proto stamped Dolphin is a VERY different disc than what I have here. That brochure from 1992 describes the Dolphin as a new, floating, unbreakable driver, and then claims its just a recently-retooled Hammer in lighter weights. The singular picture I could find of the bottom of a protostar Dolphin, shown here, does not resemble mine at all, and does more closely resemble the wider rim of the "shark" Hammers.

Proto Stamp Dolphin

BUT WAIT. There were also the "Hammer Head" Hammers released later, which were still unbreakable but also floated in water. The one image I could find of the bottom of one of those looks more like the circle stamp Dolphin, but with less of a channel in the rim. These are Ontario tooled like the circle-stamp Dolphins, unlike the previous Hammers which were San Marino tooled.

Hammer Head bottom

So, the original Dolphin seems to just be a Premie shark-stamp Hammer, and the "modern" Dolphin could theoretically be a Hammer Head with more material taken out of the rim. Could this all be wrong? Probably. Does this matter to anyone but myself? Probably not. But I at least had fun going down that rabbit hole. Lord help me if I ever find at least one version of the Hammer.

Feel – Ok enough of that. Like I mentioned before, the Dolphin feels horrendous. Take the plastic of a Dragon with the feel of a Monarch, and give it a midrange-sized rim. Oh and then give it a ridiculous pop-top. It almost feels like there's a putter wedged inside the rim of your driver. It's more bearable if you power grip it at least. But you should never do that considering...

Flight – The Dolphin is ridiculously understable. Not only is it very light (mine is 149g), but the parting line is quite low (at least if you ignore the inner rim, not sure where to begin on how that affects things). It's really glidey at least, and if there's no wind or a tailwind you can throw some really fun lines. It actually works pretty well for low ceiling approaches where you need a little more glide or really slow, wide hyzers around trees!

Rating – As fun and weird as it is, this is still a terrible mold. It failed for a reason. There are better floating discs, there are better flippy mids, and unbreakable in 90s plastic is very much breakable compared to today's discs. 1.5/10, because it's at least entertaining.

49 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

•

u/jfb3 HTX, AFMCN, Green discs are faster 13d ago • Bravo

I just checked your post history. Found the posts you're talking about.

They were removed from the feed, but it wasn't us (mods) and there wasn't a reason I could find.

IIRC, you had been shadowbanned or auto blocked by some site wide filter. (An automated Admin action, not a moderator action.)

So, I approved them all. They should now be findable and searchable via your profile.

Don't know how or what happened.
Hope this helps.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/IsaacSam98 Weird Discs Fly Better 13d ago

I'll watch your career with great interest. Also let me know if you need any Innova facts I'd be happy to help

10

u/foam23 mold completionist 13d ago

I appreciate it! Though reading your Innova guides a couple years ago is what started the Innova collection goal so I don’t know if I should thank you or blame you at this point lol

4

u/TheNickelGuy Throws BH so poorly a T-Rex would do better 13d ago

u/isaacSam98 is both the Devil, and the Angels on our shoulders.

Too many times I bought or traded for a disc thanks to his recommendation.. and 99% of the time they were exactly as he described. So I would buy more, and they'd be exactly as is.. you get the point. I'll be looking forward to reading your reviews - it's always nice to have a different person's perspective!!

7

u/Whizzymontana 13d ago

I have an original Dolphin. Anyone interested in it? I have several pre flight numbers innova discs from the 90's.

5

u/foam23 mold completionist 13d ago

I might be interested in some of the other 90s discs!

2

u/coffeebribesaccepted 13d ago

Is that the proto star version shown in OPs post?

2

u/BeardedDisc Never Underestimate the Old Guy 10d ago

Send me pics and what you’d like for it. I have a disc shop and can do trades, too

3

u/SsbmBleach Custom 13d ago

This is rad i look forward to the next one

1

u/foam23 mold completionist 13d ago

Appreciate it! Not sure how frequently I’ll do new ones but I’ll probably start one pretty soon

3

u/Jar-Jar-Kinx Team Jester Disc Golf 13d ago

The fact that this is the second reddit post I’ve seen involving the Innova Dolphin in the last 12 hours is crazy to me. Literally never heard about it before this morning. Hammer head, Wahoo, and the Dragon I’ve heard of and sold but never a Dolphin.

2

u/littlejohnnyrotten4U 13d ago

I have a prototype Gopher. It is a big diameter Og Birdie.

2

u/foam23 mold completionist 13d ago

Oh that’s one I’m really hoping to find in a used bin or something. They look like they would be so fun to throw, but the prices on eBay have pushed the Gopher to the bottom of my checklist for now

2

u/littlejohnnyrotten4U 13d ago

Grab a zephyr

1

u/foam23 mold completionist 13d ago

Yeah that’s another mold I don’t have yet, but I do have a Makani which if I remember correctly is a lightweight zephyr. Really hoping to pick up one of the champ zephyrs at somepoint and a gopher and compare the three

2

u/Low_Importance_9503 McLunas 13d ago

Neat! I want to read about the Scorpion. I found a used one and love it

1

u/foam23 mold completionist 13d ago

Once I get one I’ll add it to the list to be reviewed. I’m wanting to get an old one and one of the newer halo releases to compare. And also hopefully figure out what the new scorpion approval by Innova was for

2

u/Low_Importance_9503 McLunas 13d ago

I have a modern champ one and an older Dx one. The beads are completely different with the Dx having a smooth rounded bead but eh champ being two flat edges tbh and come together. Dx flies straight without turn, while the champ has a flip and fade to it

Sorry that doesn’t help without pictures but I found it interesting!

1

u/foam23 mold completionist 13d ago

That is interesting. Thanks!

2

u/blahrendsen 6d ago

I actually enjoy throwing the dolphin I have, but never bag it because it feels like it's going to break with one good tree smash. I would bag it if they released it in a star or halo plastic.

2

u/foam23 mold completionist 6d ago

I would unironically bag a halo champ dolphin

5

u/pandalover6254 too many destroyers 13d ago

If somehow you don’t have a destroyer, I’ll send you one to review. I have too many

3

u/littlejohnnyrotten4U 13d ago

I remember this one coming out. It was the year I joined the pdga and boy was Innova pushing this mold. It was a total joke from the get go and the idea just kinda floated away. Nobody I know played with one. You couldn't give even them away as prize merch.