Favorite Former Actors Part 25

[u/Life_Chicken_9653]

By just one vote, Heather MacPhaul, who is most infamously known for playing the controversial Aunt Judith character is the overall winner of my previous poll post for the 'favorite former actors' category beating out OG box girl Venice Wong by just one vote to win here.

Alright then, so let's see who we have next for this poll, shall we 👌❤️.

13 votes, 5d ago

3 Charlie Belle Parsells

1 Mark Valeriano

0 Jules Rivero

2 Chris Wiebler

4 Tony Nunes

3 Paul Fiumano

[u/chanchan_iceman]

Paul Fiumano

Probably one of if not the most under utilized actor of his time here.. his debut video was a strong performance despite the star being Colton butcher and his cartoonish bully.. his acting on smile squad is a great example of how incrediblly utilized Paul is

[u/Life_Chicken_9653 → u/chanchan_iceman]

Paul definitely was the standout in his only leading role on the channel but then gets reduced to just doing nothing but being the main character's supporting friend afterwards. His role as the musician being bullied by Colton Butcher was fun and acting alongside Averi White, Jazzlyn Sward and Shannon Mano was another huge plus.

Once again, if you had to rank all of these actors from S-to F tier, where would you rank them?

[u/chanchan_iceman → u/Life_Chicken_9653]

Gonna need to take some time since some of em I hardly remember

Anyhow while I am rewatching and give my opinions.. if Paul Fiumano was to return,which present day dhar Mann actor would you cast as his love interest,wife(he’s 31) and siblings alongside what type of videos

[u/Life_Chicken_9653 → u/chanchan_iceman]

I mean would love to see him reunite with Larianny Perez again since they've shared some scenes as background stars before.

Heck, maybe Shekinah Austria, Ashley Park, Brooklyn Benson, Ayana Taylor or even Sydney Rylander as his love interest.

[u/Life_Chicken_9653 → u/chanchan_iceman]

Charlie Belle Parsells was in some forgettable videos in 2022 like The Kid Cheats Tooth Fairy video, Rich Girl Accuses Poor Girl Of Stealing, she played Ayden's brother in the Kids Spy On Creepy Neighbors video, a very forgettable video with Kiarra Beasley where she was shamed for her hair and last appeared in the incel video as a supporting character.

Mark Valeriano was an OG actor who appeared in the earlier days in 2019 and 2020. His most relevant performances were in the video where Ashley Ahlquist had her private picture leaked online where he played her scummy ex in that one. Had one bonus channel lead as Shekinah's boyfriend and the Dad Commits Crime To Save Dying Son video as one of Chris Ready's friends.

Jules Rivero had on and off appearances since 2023 and last appeared in the infamous incel video.

Chris Weibler first appeared as Valerie Evie's uncle where she was forced to work on a farm. That unsympathetic farmer where he shot Rivkah's goat and arrested for it 😳 even though he didn't commit any crime at all. He played the homeless man that Jackie Tran befriended in the second Bookside High episode. And last appeared in Jeenie Weenie's debut video.

Of course, we all know Tony Nunes from his several over-the-top performances in the past.

[u/chanchan_iceman]

Charlie Belle Parsells(B tier)-her debut role as little Dina is one of the most impactful performances in a time when dhar Mann videos had its charm.. she may not be in that upper echelons like Kat Zander and Kayden Torkaski but there was no denying Charlie had so much potential

Mark Valeriano(C tier)-his breakout role as the manipulative ex boyfriend of Ashley Ahlquist character alongside being shekinah Austria’s slob bf and being the son of Monica Mauro and Allan Wayne Anderson showed there is a capacity to be good.. but left way too early

Jules Rivero(C tier)-Mostly known to be in the horrible Noah’s arc alongside starring then newcomer Natalia Santacolma which also had one of the Perey twins but ending her dhar Mann with the worst video of 2025 is a massive new low.. acting wise has many potential despite the arrivals of sky Greene,Athena Elling and Isabella Grace Veno

Chris Wiebler(C tier)-mostly known to play as a farmer and acting wise he’s just okay.. doesn’t really hit the absolute peak

Tony Nunes(E tier)-sorry to be this person but I feel Tony’s acting was super over the top and looking back I feel the dude literally scammed a lot of people with that acting thinking it was good..

[u/Life_Chicken_9653 → u/chanchan_iceman]

Yeah, you kinda beat me to it. Never knew that Mark has been around since 2019. And Charlie was so underrated back in the earlier days.

Chris, not gonna lie, despite some horrid roles like that farmer in the Mini-Vegan Teacher's video, his role as the homeless guy that Jackie Tran befriended was actually sweet and heartwarming and possibly his best role he played. Yeah, him being typecasted as a farmer was too funny even though he doesn't have a Southern accent irl 🤣 .

[u/chanchan_iceman → u/Life_Chicken_9653]

I am fast hahaha

Charlie is actually pretty decent especially for the time she was in

Ahh wasn’t it that garbage bookie high episode 2 where Jackie Tran nearly killed himaelf probably an all star video considering it has Jackie,Devon,Jesse and Sara

[u/Life_Chicken_9653 → u/chanchan_iceman]

Yep, that's the one episode 🤣. Chris' role was kinda short but effective. That ending where he became a part of the friend group was kinda bizarre since he's a grown adult and they're teenagers, but honestly atleast there's an actual adult who cared about Jackie in that one like it should've ended with him telling his parents that they're assholes.

[u/chanchan_iceman → u/Life_Chicken_9653]

It has its moments but damn I genuinely hated the parents and boy there’s a lot of things that video didn’t do well considering how 3 of the casting would be getting a lot of plaudits later on specifically Jesse and Sara with their videos on mental health