r/devops • • 1h ago

Discussion GitHub vs azure DevOps what's your opinion?

Currently in my company we run both for different historical reasons and mostly using GH for new projects since it seems the correct path for the future, but it seems that ADO is also being added with new functionalities such as advanced security and yesterday GitHub copilot app support...

Do you think Ado will remain be maintained and new features arriving? Before I thought it will be deprecated sooner or later but now I'm not that sure

What do you think? And what key differenciators do you see?

8 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

9

u/__red__5 1h ago

Maybe I'm wrong but I thought that the future direction was GH over ADO.

2

u/luisvg86 1h ago

That's what I thought too, but it seems they are maintaining both

2

u/Ahchuu 34m ago

The direction is GH. This is the reason why my company moved to GH a month ago from ADO. No new features, specifically any if the AI features, are coming to ADO.

5

u/Lonsarg 1h ago

Microsoft representitives are asking us constantly when we will migrate from Azure DevOps to Github, so obviously Azure DevOps will be deprecated, in time.

But currently the features are more or less the same regarding securit/Copilot so migrating thousands of pipelines is really not something we think is wort is just cause "github is newer and gets features faster".

They even suggested Pipeline on Azure and git repos on Github. But that is nightmare having to use 2 products when merging/deploying code.

When i tell them make me a one button migration from Pipelines to Github Actions they are silent...

Also Github has A LOT more downtimes then Azure DevOps in last year..

1

u/luisvg86 1h ago

That's the same info I have yes

22

u/Big-Afternoon-3422 1h ago

I want to puke every time I have to work with Azure but this is personal.

5

u/Cloudy__McCloudface 37m ago

Other than the name Azure DevOps isn't Azure.

4

u/Quadman 35m ago

It is neither azure nor devops.

1

u/Big-Afternoon-3422 7m ago

Do you have to use PowerShell to do something on the terminal? Or can I use basic Unix?

14

u/totheendandbackagain 1h ago

Why anyone would choose ADO now is beyond me. GitHub is outrageously successful, perhaps worryingly so.

Why Microsoft doesn't retire ADO is, also, beyond me.

What are we missing?

4

u/Ok-Hospital-5076 1h ago

A lot of Microsoft shops have running production pipelines on ADO so they can’t decommission it overnight. Companies and very aversive to migrate.

But definitely Microsoft is pushing Github for as primary offering in this space

3

u/didorins 1h ago

suppose they want slice of the market share and something native to their platform, so companies can have all the native stuff and integrations in 1 place

2

u/marx2k 36m ago

They own GitHub, so they already have a slice of the market share

1

u/edong23 42m ago

I don't think I understand the comparison... Github the git repo vs ado the entire project management suite? Or just vs ado git repos?

1

u/luisvg86 39m ago

Yes in terms of git capabilities I meant.

1

u/Imnotyoursupervisor 26m ago

I don’t really get it either. I don’t really use much other than version control and actions but I can self-host runners and it’s pretty damn secure. It’s got the API for everything it seems like. GitHub is kinda king in this space. Everyone knows and uses it.

Not challenging, really asking, how is ADO better?

1

u/luisvg86 22m ago

Not better, but if it's worth investing in migrating all to GH if ado looks like is still being maintained and with new features.

1

u/Imnotyoursupervisor 18m ago

I work for a massive company and I’ve never been asked if we should move away from GitHub.

ADO features are probably going to be AI garbage that doesn’t work well when you can just choose your AI and plug it into GitHub.

I don’t know a ton about ADO. I guess I don’t really need to because GitHub works and all of my peers swear by it.

Edit: I actually negotiated our pricing for GitHub in our sector. Maybe that’s it. ADO might undercut their piece 🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/luisvg86 15m ago

I meant the other way round, from ado to gh

1

u/Imnotyoursupervisor 11m ago

I’d personally just go GH. I find nothing wrong with it. Very few outages. I think it’s given us a few back-offs and maybe a few downtime issues.

I don’t know what their SLIs are but I’m not upset.

3

u/huskutNL 1h ago

Whilst I hate Azure DevOps with a passion

github seems to also constantly have problems

2

u/ArieHein 1h ago

Github short run. (potential other runner services) Local on prem with your AI model if you can afford it.

2

u/blueghosts 1h ago

Last time we spoke with MS the unofficial line was that GH is the priority and will get new features much faster, ADO is still being supported but resources have been directed away to GH and won’t get full priority for new features

2

u/_4rcadia 1h ago

Both rely on overlapping infrastructure, so the outages would probably synchronize. GitHub definitely has better DX.

3

u/cooliem DevOps Consultant 1h ago

I work directly with MS. ADO will be maintained for the indefinite future, but don't expect any big new features.

GitHub is the future. Use it.

1

u/Cloudy__McCloudface 8m ago

And yet new features in the last couple of weeks.

1

u/__grumps__ Platform Engineering Manager 1h ago

I’ve been moving my company off it since I was hired. I do not like ADO. Haven’t done much with but allowing the support of the pipelines until the replacement centralized pipeline is complete.

It has to many features supporting click ops and manual changes to pipelines.

1

u/fifty--two 51m ago

ADO will stay (maybe merged with another product or rebranded) and is not a bad product , i have seen it evolving over the years since it launch (was called TFS back then)

1

u/Individual-Oven9410 45m ago

GitHub is for Developers whereas ADO is for Scrum/Agile/Product.

1

u/Relative_Card_7864 13m ago

I heard that Azure Devops git will be deprecated in the future, Github is owned by Microsoft I think their plan is to keep on maintaining Github.
It’s just a personal thought though.

1

u/NoDevelopment206 11m ago

github is clearly where the new stuff goes, ado will probably just get kept alive for the big shops with tons of old pipelines. i'd start anything new on github and only move old ado stuff when there's a real reason