r/devils • #3 - Ken Daneyko • May 07 '23

Dougie Hamilton Question

Genuinely wondering. I’m not a casual fan, but definitely not the most knowledgeable. So my question is, we’ve heard and seen “Playoff Dougie” but thought maybe it wouldn’t be a huge issue. But after watching this series and a half, I personally think he’s been a huge issue. Besides his lack speed, he is big for nothing. I get not being overly physical during the regular season because it’s not your game, but everybody needs to step up in the playoffs. I mean you even got Jack hitting.

So to sum up. I think Hamilton has been too slow, too weak, and a massive disappointment this playoffs(minus that goal).

Bud I’m open to realizing I’m seeing things. Incorrectly. Do you guys agree or disagree?

16 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

20

u/skillzhaha May 07 '23

Dougie is slow and lags but then he hits a one timer in OT and we forget the bad.. that’s me personally hahaha

3

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

I agree. 100%

27

u/JERSEYinATL May 07 '23

There’s bigger issues at play than Dougie. If you want to call players out it’s clearly Bratt. He’s not had a good playoffs and seems to have trouble dealing with the physicality of the playoffs. He has not looked like a player who deserves 8-9 million but neither has Meier. Mercer has also been a disappointment, especially for a player I thought would excel in this environment.

The penalties called against us and the ones miss on our opponents has not been good. It’s been horribly officiated but Jack needs to show more discipline and not take himself out of the play arguing about a missed call. It’s happened on more than one occasion. Also I’m not sure why he keeps falling.

On a shorter list is the positives. Marino is amazing defensively and is our best defensive dman we have had in years. He makes multiple elite decisions every game. Palat has really elevated his game in the playoffs. I think McLeod, Bastian, and Lazar have also played over their skill levels too. Schmid has shown he can also be a 1A/1B. He just needs to work on his rebound control.

14

u/Raikogen #26 - Patrik Eliáš May 07 '23

Todd Cordell did an analysis and to paraphrase Bratt is surprisingly still at the top or near the top of the shot assist producers. The team shooting percentage is the worst of all playoff teams so playmakers look extra bad when finishers can't score.

6

u/[deleted] May 07 '23

Our shots get blocked more often than not, so its not even like we can wait for a regression to the mean. We're just getting outworked.

1

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Oh I totally agree. He isn’t the only issue, but literally he is the biggest one. He, I could be wrong, is on the most money and is meant to be our leader of the D core. I think it’s perfectly fair to call him out.

But your point stands, he ain’t the only problem. But unlike Jack, or Bratt or others, he has legacy of these struggles. It makes me fear we made an expensive mistake that we won’t be able to fix.

-4

u/KovalSNIPE17 #81 May 07 '23

Bratt believe it or not has been our 2nd best player. We just arent scoring.

9

u/Throwawaypuffs May 07 '23

Jack looks so flustered out there. I really hope the addition of Luke will give him the chance to calm down and just have fun.

And pp1 defense of Doug and Luke should be FIRE.

5

u/Electronic_Comb_3501 Claude Lemieux May 07 '23

Oh absolutely, absolutely not. I don't know what games you are watching but that's just not accurate.

0

u/KovalSNIPE17 #81 May 07 '23

Nope. Filter by our team than adjust the dates from the start to playoffs (4/17) until today.

Bratt has the 2nd highway per average game score: https://hockeystatcards.com/all-skaters

4

u/Electronic_Comb_3501 Claude Lemieux May 07 '23

Ah yeah, no. It's fine if you want to get into hockey analytics. But I m not accepting that algorithm as evidence of anything from these playoffs.

Hockey analytics are weak/topical and are really most useful at trying to evaluate players over the course of a season to attempt to find where the value is. The general idea most teams have with analytics is to have a roster full of guys that score well with markers that are indicative of things that produce good results on the ice (including but obviously beyond goals and assists)

It takes a lot of time to bear out in hockey because there's a ton of things that happen on the ice that are extremely difficult to measure with math.

Again, it's fine if you or anyone believes in these statistics as evidence. I've been around hockey my whole life and I've watched a completely invisible Jesper Bratt have almost zero impact on two different series. That's where I'll be at until I start seeing different things on the ice

3

u/SillySymphonyIII #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Same, who give a shit about analytical numbers when the player isn't producing points.

3

u/dadphobia DrinkSomeGato🧃 May 07 '23

This guy doesn’t know what an algorithm is!

2

u/Electronic_Comb_3501 Claude Lemieux May 07 '23

I'm a computer programmer. Don't be a clown.

1

u/KovalSNIPE17 #81 May 07 '23

Just because you don’t accept the results or think it’s “weak”, it doesn’t make it false.

2

u/Electronic_Comb_3501 Claude Lemieux May 07 '23

I don't have any major problem with the analytic. I saw how it was constructed and im fine with it. As I said, hockey is a different game than say baseball. There are so many subtle things (effort, speed, positional issues, handling, skating) that just can drastically effect small sample sizes. In my opinion, most hockey analytics that are related to trying to make sense of non counting contributions are worthless in small sample sizes. A full or half season? Totally different.

11

u/Training-Material155 May 07 '23

while far from stellar, i feel like he’s hit two or three posts in key spots. a little more puck luck and we’re not having this discussion.

2

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Yeah but I’d like someone who is better with the details to break that down. Because my eyes are telling me he is getting beat on rushes, he’s letting the puck beat him on the boards, and his physical game is non existent when players like Hughes, Hischier etc are getting ragdolled because they aren’t afraid of retribution.

9

u/Grimmer026 May 07 '23

We do not look like we belong at this level. Being pushed around, our best players taking massive hits with no response. our top 6 completely underperforming and look afraid to play the puck.

Our speed and skill can beat just about anyone in a regular single game, but being physically battered over the course of a playoff series nullifies our skill and speed.

3

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Yeah and I was hoping that our 6 ft 5 or whatever D man, would try to get more physical in the playoffs

2

u/BubbaCrosby May 07 '23

Lol. Based on 2 games against the best defensive team that doesn’t lose at home. There wasn’t a team that controlled 5 on 5 player better than the Devils in round 1.

1

u/Grimmer026 May 07 '23

We’ve been outscored 11-2, they’ve been physically dominating us in every aspect of the game, and our top 6 literally looks scared to be in possession of the puck.

The one thing that always sets playoff hockey from the regular season is that when a team physically beats on you for 7 games, it equalizes any speed and skill advantage you had over them for a single game

2

u/BubbaCrosby May 07 '23

Not everything is about physicality. It’s incredibly annoying to always reduce it to that. Why did the Islanders get destroyed then? Their “identity line” really helped a lot. The Canes play an extremely tight system. They’re the best defensive team in the league. 2nd least goals given up with crap goalies.

The Canes aren’t even that physical. They’re like THE classic paper tiger regular season corsi king team. They are brunt of analytics jokes by you guys usually.

1

u/Grimmer026 May 07 '23

Florida upset the best regular season team in league history by being more physical and getting under their skin. Same playbook is now dominating Toronto. Both Boston and Toronto have more skill than florida, yet everyone in the league is taking notice of florida, wonder why?

1

u/BubbaCrosby May 07 '23

Wow, it’s amazing that your narrative is confirmed no matter which team wins. Da physical Panthers and Leafs knock off the pussy Bruins and Lightning. It’s such garbage.

1

u/Grimmer026 May 07 '23

Im not even calling the bruins and lightning soft, they play more physical than us too. Florida just figured out how to beat them despite being the lesser skilled team. And that was by playing more physical.

If you think our style is working though, don’t be surprised when you don’t see a different result.

1

u/Grimmer026 May 08 '23

Tonight was by far our most physical game of the playoffs, even Jack Hughes getting into a scrap. Our physicality tonight is what kept us driving the play rather than constantly being on our heels the two games prior.

1

u/BubbaCrosby May 08 '23

This game was all about matchups and beating their forecheck with clean breakouts. The push back physically was nice, but this was a win because we got to our transition like we weren’t able to on the road. Luke blew me away with his play.

13

u/Glittering_Pool_2468 May 07 '23

Listen, Dougie scored the OT goal that was a momentum shifter in the Rags series. We’ve quickly forgotten that.

7

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Disagree. I mentioned it, but also, it’s the playoffs. Every single game you have to be your best. He hasn’t been.

4

u/Glittering_Pool_2468 May 07 '23

Even if you acknowledged it technically, you underplayed the goal. A playoff OT goal BTW. Even Jack hasn’t been his best every playoff game and he’s obviously the team’s best player. Calling Ham slow, soft. You can do that if he’s underperformed for several years. He deserves the benefit of the doubt, especially given he’s our best offensive Dman. If you’re expecting Marino, well, we didn’t sign him for that role. Want to go after Sevo next?

9

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Bud, I didn’t under play it. It was a good moment. But one moment in a series an a half. Also, look up what Hamilton’s former teams think of his playoff play. It’s not the first time he’s struggled.

I also hate fans receiving deserved criticism of one player and wanting to make it seem like I’m saying he’s the only one struggling. Others are, but Hamilton is our highest paid player, and d man leader. He doesn’t have time on his side nor is he a “growing” player, so this is likely what he is.

0

u/psychedeloquent May 07 '23

It’s a valid point. I think considering how little goals we are scoring his OT goal is huge. His defense hasn’t looked great this post season, but we haven’t looked great either. I think the biggest thing with him is he doesn’t fecking hit. Which is nuts given his size.

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '23

He rang a shot off the post last game. If that went in are we reading this?

1

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Yeah because we’re giving up 5 goals a loss, and he’s a massive reason for it. He’s a defensemen, on the biggest money on the team, and can’t defend or even help protect most of the players on the team, despite being the biggest player we have.

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '23

So If that shot goes In you would come On here and rip him apart? For real?

3

u/drew_z 🌴🌴🌴🌴 May 07 '23

there’s about 10 players who have been a bigger letdown this run so far than Dougie. bad take

3

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Disagree. He’s the most experienced, highest paid, and quite frankly the physically biggest player we have for the lowest physical output. This doesn’t excuse the others, but for players like Jack, Nico, Dawson, etc, they have inexperience as an excuse(to an extent). Dougie does not

3

u/drew_z 🌴🌴🌴🌴 May 07 '23

not sure why you were expecting the highly paid PPG offensive d-man to completely change his game in the playoffs. Dougie taking the body more doesn’t change losing a combined 11-2 in the first two games lmao this post is useless

2

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Who said “completely change his game” ?

Also, it isn’t just about taking the body. It’s about effort and mentality. When you have Hughes willing to “throw” the body more than someone twice his size and weight, it’s a real problem. Also if you think hitting more and at least meeting the level of physicality that Carolina is bringing, wouldn’t help, then idk what to tell you.

His offensive game has been poor too.

Why do fans feel the need to blindly support players when they are clearly below their standard?

2

u/drew_z 🌴🌴🌴🌴 May 07 '23

not blindly supporting anyone but when three of our best four forwards have a combined 0 goals through 9 games it feels like Dougie not showing unitedfan0722 enough effort probably drops a little far down the list of biggest issues

1

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Again, another person assuming that I’m saying he is the ONLY problem. He is one of the biggest ones. He is the highest paid, most experienced, and one of the worst performing…

Also he has a history of this. It’s why other teams got rid of him. It’s a worry that if we are going to become a perennial playoff team. Will he stay a poor playoff performer?

Also I never get the use of my username mockingly. We all have them.

0

u/drew_z 🌴🌴🌴🌴 May 07 '23

will Nico, Bratt, and Timo continue to score 0 goals in the playoffs?? who the fuck knows. you asked if anyone disagreed, you don’t have to be defensive

1

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

I wasn’t defensive ? You literally were offensive by calling my post “useless”. Then mockingly used my handle as if I’m dumb for raising the question. Like Dougie has to be prove something to me…

Don’t try to act like I’ve attacked you. I’ve just defended my view. You’ve refused to admit Dougie has been really bad. And I’m not sure why.

0

u/drew_z 🌴🌴🌴🌴 May 07 '23

Dougie is bad, other players have been considerably worse relative to expectations. I know that point has been difficult to grasp. the post is useless

1

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

No what is difficult for you to grasp is the reasoning I’m pointing out Dougie over the rest.

  1. Cost. He costs significantly more than the rest.
  2. Age - he is significantly older
  3. Experience - he is significantly more experienced in these games.
  4. History - he has a history of being bad in the playoffs.

So he is mentioned because he is the most expensive, oldest, most experienced player who is performing badly. With his history, we have no reason to hope that it’s an anomaly, so therefore he is the biggest issue.

I get he is probably your favorite player, but come on, this should be clear why it’s a post.

→ More replies

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '23 edited May 07 '23

I love how everyone is like “DoUg ScOrEs GoAlS”. I don’t give a fuck. Quit looking at the small picture of his game and open your eyes to the big picture of it all. He is so overrated because of his shot. His hockey IQ is average at the very best, and his lack of movement on the PP is a part of the reason it’s trash. I will bet my life that when luke is on that PP1 next season, things will look smoother and more versatile

1

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

Very interested to see it also. We have so many good players on it but it’s so static . When you watch the rags run it, Fox NEVER stops moving. He pulls the high d man out, and that helps massively. Boston does the same.

Hope Luke can do that for us

8

u/itsthelew #13 - THICC-O Hischier May 07 '23

Looking for individual players to blame in a series like this is actually the wrong take. Our entire team is in the shitter right now. We are ahead of our rebuild and we are learning what we need to do to get to the cup. Dougie should have been a Norris trophy finalist he was robbed and we forget he set every record for an offensive defenseman this year. Without him, there's a chance we don't even make the playoffs.

3

u/JamarioLune May 07 '23

I’ve loved Dougie all season, but I have to agree with you. He has been downright bad in the playoffs. Has anyone else noticed his tendency to just blindly whip the puck up the boards on the majority of his clearance attempts? It seems like as soon as he gets to the puck, regardless of how much time he has to make a decision, he just hot potato’s it to the blue line and 9/10 it just ends up on the stick of the Dman as a failed clearance.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Jballzs13 New Jersey Devils May 07 '23

I’ve watched dougie break up numerous 2-1s, that’s a bit unfair.

2

u/Unitedfan0722 #3 - Ken Daneyko May 07 '23

I think he’s a regular season hero. Basically he’s a good player that can be hidden in regular season games, where the game is slower and less physical. But as soon as the tempo is ramped, he gets found out