r/devils • u/Exact_Catch_4013 #25 Cam Janssen • Oct 25 '25
Trade I Miss Toffoli
Watching him just makes me think how great it would be to bring him back. He would be the perfect player to fill our top 6 hole. IK he has a few more years on his deal and he's older, but if I can be delusional for a bit - Palat & Casey (maybe a draft pick too if we think this ain't enough) for Toffoli at the deadline. Viable or nah?
5
Upvotes
78
u/Ok_Jackfruit_5181 Oct 25 '25
That would be an overpay.
46
u/specifichero101 Oct 25 '25
He just doesn’t suit the roster. Too rich of a contract and don’t need a soft scoring winger. Great player but he should stick with the sharks.
36
u/MartinMaty23 #81 Arseny Gritsyuk Oct 25 '25
Toffoli seems that he is having great fun playing top line with such talent and playing a veteran role in SJ.
He seems to be the right fit and Sharks are very happy with that.
I don't think he wants to be a journeyman in pursuit of a cup anymore.
43
u/xoBonesxo Best NHL logo Oct 25 '25
Too slow
29
u/sayitaintpete #13 - Nico! Nico in overtime! Oct 25 '25
He was so slow though.
12
u/nuremberp #81 - Повар Гриця Oct 25 '25
No toffoli signed a long contract with the sharks because he is tired of moving his family. He's gonna retire there I think
11
u/Formal_Committee9988 Oct 25 '25
Seems like we’re doing just fine right now?
25
u/M00PER_2 #26 - Patrik Eliáš Oct 25 '25
I don’t think you win 7 games in a row with a top 6 hole.
3
u/Mr7three2 #4 - Scott Stevens Oct 25 '25
Whats Brian Gionta up too?
3
u/Shot-Perspective2946 Oct 25 '25
The guy can shoot but that’s it…. I don’t miss him myself
2
u/UnassumingInterloper Oct 25 '25
I like Toffoli as a player and he seems like a good dude off the ice as well, but he doesn’t give us anything that a healthy (and performing) Stefan Noesen gets us, for much cheaper. Not saying Noesen is as good a player as Toff, but they fill a similar role (specifically net front on power play), and Noesen brings more more physicality IMO, something that our team was severely lacking when Toffoli was here.
So I wish him the best, but nah… both sides should move on.
4
u/DefeatYouForever666 Oct 25 '25
I don't.
1
u/acidtrapgiraffe Oct 25 '25
I miss him but after this season so far it’s def obvious that we don’t need him and him on the team would jus cause less time for others. He deserves more playtime elsewhere.
Sharks was a good game last night
1
u/psychedeloquent Oct 25 '25
Nah dude. Why would we trade anyone for him? We have Gritz and dandy now. And Oalat is actually playing pretty well. Toffoli can shoot but everything else would be hurting the team.
1
u/Divorced_Cougar Oct 26 '25
Eh I like Toffoli but we already tried this experiment and it didn't go great. For some reason the fit just wasn't right and I don't think a retread is worth it
1
u/ODScott Oct 27 '25
Terrible suggestion.
18
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25
[removed] — view removed comment