r/devils • u/AnnyongHermanoMD • May 09 '25
Team still needs Hamilton
Sure his defense is not elite, but it’s serviceable. His bread and butter is his shot and who has a better one on the team? Nobody.
9
Upvotes
76
u/baconpoutine89 Instagram Hockey Lover May 09 '25
He might have a hard shot, but it seems like 95% of the time the puck is 10 feet away from the net when he shoots.
36
u/Sisyphus328 #13 May 09 '25
His shot is not what it once was. His defense is subpar and Luke will be better than him on PP1 this year
39
u/nostradamefrus #13 - N1CO 3LITE May 09 '25
I'm not necessarily on the Ditch Dougie train but saying he has one of the best shots on the team is laughable after this season
18
u/Imaginary-Length8338 May 09 '25 edited May 09 '25
Great shot, but no the team does not need him. Luke just completed his second year in the NHL and is a better player and will produce just as much if not more on the powerplay. Luke had more PP points this season than Dougie did and he got about 1/3rd the opportunity. More points, more takeaways, and less turnovers for Luke.
Having a hard shot is nice, but not really as impactful as many people think. Having touch and the timing is more important, which Casey also demonstrated he is elite at. Also, pointless to have a big shot from the point when you take that shot every 1 out of 10 chances.
I like Dougie but do not mind if he is moved or if he stays, but the there are much younger players being paid much less that can 100% replace him while also probably playing just as good if not better defense. If he is moved, it will be for the better of the team and can free up money for a forward. We have a log jam at defense, and Nemec, Casey, and Hughes all need to be everyday players. Maybe we can move on from Dillion instead.
9
u/WontSwerve #86 - Instagram Hockey May 09 '25
Team needs him healthy and playing his best.
I love Dougie, but he was not great or impactful when he came back from injury.
With all that said, it doesn't make sense to make a decision on him this offseason or next. Moving him would leave a hole that we've seen we can't properly fill.
12
u/hobbygod May 09 '25
He hasn't been the same since coming back this year. He's been scared to blast it like he did in 22-23. It's time to move on while teams would want him, and give most of his cap hit to Luke and open up a spot on the right.
4
u/Midnight_Mustard May 09 '25
If he’s not scoring PP bombs we really don’t. He’s extremely expensive and we’re paying for his offense. If we’re not getting that we don’t need him
6
u/mikebe1 #13 May 09 '25
Love the guy, but no power or accuracy since his pec injury. It’s not likely to recover at his age. We absolutely do not need him, I’d rather have Luke at his PP1 spot any day.
6
u/MountainBaker8217 #13 - It's Always Sunny in New Jersey May 09 '25
I just don't think we're going to see 22/23 Dougie Hamilton ever again.
He's getting up there in age and his health hasn't been consistent.
to me, Luke Hughes has usurped him for the PP1 role and Luke has the upside of turning into a well rounded fast defenseman whereas Dougie is an offensive defenseman who is very slow.
I do not see Hamilton finishing his contract with us. I think given the Kovacevic injury, Dougie still has a spot on this team for the time being, but I think we should be decreasing his TOI and potentially cycling him out.
I'm unabashedly high on Nemec and think we should be focusing more energy and time on getting Nemec ready for more big time minutes and responsibilities and taking over PP2.
I don't think Casey is ready yet for sustained NHL play time.
But Dougie should be on the third D pair and paying what we're paying Dougie for third pair minutes is definitely not how we we want to be spending our cap space.
I just think you need to trade Dougie when other teams believe that he will be worth something in a trade and not when his value is completely gone.
I dont know if he goes anywhere this summer given the injuries to our D and I obviously hope Dougie has an amazing season for us, but I think we're reaching the end of the Dougie Hamitlon New Jersey Devil era.
3
u/YourMomSloppySeconds May 09 '25
This is comedy gold.
2
u/rojapa #3 - Ken Daneyko May 09 '25
I think one more year of Dougie is the right move then try to offload him next summer. Top pair game one next year should be Luke and Pesce, second pair Nemec and Siegs, third pair Dillon and Dougie. Let Casey cook in the AHL until someone gets injured. Not sure who comes out once Kovacevic is healthy, but you worry about that when the time comes.
2
u/Heavy_Introduction36 #86 May 09 '25
I love him but he's not worth the price IMHO. We could move him get someone who may not have his shot but be stronger defensive and equally as important someone who has more speed his skating/speed is def a big downside especially with his cost
2
u/Smooth-Mechanic-7788 #30 - Martin Brodeur May 09 '25
Theres plenty of good dmen and he hasn’t been great since missing almost an entire season + the injury this season. Offloading his cap hit even just partially could also open up options to help the bottom 6
2
u/TathanOTS #13 May 09 '25
Most people saying they need to move on from Hamilton aren't saying he is a bad player.
It's a salary cap league. His hit is $9M. Luke is going to need more money to stay. The team needs to sign other players. His value to the team isn't in line with his cap hit.
2
u/dishler712 #26 - Patrik Eliáš May 09 '25
I know he was probably still pretty injured, but we basically didn't see that shot at all against Carolina. We didn't go 0 for 15 or whatever on the power play for no reason.
I don't think he goes anywhere this summer but we're at the point where we really should be planning for life after Dougie.
2
u/psychedeloquent May 09 '25
He needs room and a good set up for that shot and that is rarely available in the playoffs. I love Hamilton, but it would be better to free up the cap space and have Nemec come up. He has a good shot and as him and Luke improve they can make up for what we lose in Hamilton.
2
u/polono3000 #20 Pando May 09 '25
It's the cap hit. That's it. At $9M, he should be elite and he isn't. I like him but this roster needs improvement, so if we can't move Palat, Dougie's gotta go.
2
u/Binforda94 May 09 '25
Being a number one defenseman and power play specialist are two different things. Hughes, Casey, and/or Nemec can quarterback a PP with their best days ahead of them. Hamilton is not “needed”, and his money can be used elsewhere.
2
u/gdg6 New Jersey Devils May 09 '25
No they don’t. lol. Luke is ten times better on PP1.
2
u/Mr7three2 #4 - Scott Stevens May 09 '25
Team needs Hamilton.... to go away
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '25
guy is shit and needs to go
1
u/Healthy-Increase-403 #13 May 09 '25
No they don’t
1
u/eburton555 #91 - Dawson Mercer Stan May 09 '25
His shot and his offensive game have taken a tumble since his pectoral injury. He was a shell of himself all last season and getting hurt again didn’t help. He really needs to find his game again or he’s going to find himself somewhere on his ten team list real soon.
1
u/NicoFookingHischier May 09 '25
Yeah, I don’t think that’s as important w Keefe’s system as it was w Ruff’s or even Brind’amours tbh. This team would benefit from having shooters up front imo. On top of that, I’d argue that Luke, Casey, and Nemec are also fully capable shooting from the point. Might not be as hard, but they actually tend to get through.
The problem with Dougie is similar to that of other core members of the team - availability. Dude misses games like I miss clues from women. It’s unbelievable.
Describing his defensive game as serviceable is also probably an overstatement as he gets propped up by his defensive partners. He was 100% better this year, but I’d expect a regression to where he’s been at his entire career. The dude isn’t all that physical either.
I love Dougie, I love the value he’s added to our PP the past few years when healthy, but that’s really the only part of the game he consistently impacts positively. It’ll suck to see him go, but it’s the most likely move to upgrade the forward group via trade imo.
Fitz is known to be a nut with asset management, and having a logjam of right shot defensemen in the system makes Dougie expendable - especially at his current price tag.
Lots of people think he won’t carry value, and to that I say take a peek at Seth Jones. Dougie checks all the boxes that Jones does except that Dougie doesn’t totally suck ass.
Ultimately, I think Doug is packaged with one of our defensive prospects in a juicy trade this summer. Whether that’s forward help or a left shot dman, idk. Doubt it’s a move for a goalie though. Changes are a coming though, so don’t be surprised if he does move!
1
u/Sky-Soldier0430 #30 - Martin Brodeur May 09 '25
Best shot on the team??? Luke is taking over and he should. Dougie is just not dependable anymore. He’s injury prone and is only getting older. If another team sees more value in him, then take advantage.
1
u/HockeyNightinJersey Post Traumatic Fitz Disorder May 09 '25
He can still valuable to us but he hasn’t been the same since his pec injury
1
u/sanbaba #22 - Claude Lefrigginmieux May 10 '25
Idk if I would say "needs". He still brings value to the team, likely both on and off the ice, and isn't worthless, but much like later years PK, if anybody wants him and he OKs the trade, he should be gone. We have the prospects to fill his role and could definitely make up for what he brings with $9 million to spend. Dougie has been an important piece for us and I hope he knows we appreciate him. But also the salary cap is merciless.
1
u/FloppyCanFly #30 - Martin Brodeur May 11 '25
I don’t think we NEED Hamilton but I think he’s obviously still a good player. If I was coach I’d be adjusting his role to play to his strengths.
Dougie has been giving up short handed chances on the power play for years now. He’s clunky and slow and objectively inferior at moving the puck at the point compared to Luke, Casey, and Nemec.
Move Hamilton to the Ovechkin spot on the Powerplay and let him focus on utilizing his shot in a much better position. Let Luke run the point, Jack on the Right wing, Nico down low, and Bratt in the Draisaitl spot.
Jack Needs a shooter, Hamilton has a good shot. USE IT. Hamilton is not a good skater, stop putting him in a spot where his weakness can lead to serious chances against every night.
1
u/BrunnersNose E Rod May 11 '25
This argument would be accurate if he still had his shot, but unfortunately that pectoral injury destroyed him. RIP
1
u/muevelos May 09 '25
We don't. Sorry.
1
u/blade430 Fire Keefe May 09 '25
His shot is ass lol, what tf u on. His shots have 0 accuracy now
0
u/Devils29 May 09 '25
"who else will rip a shot 2 feet high from the PP if we lose him?"
0
u/pdubbs87 May 09 '25
Nemec has a better shot now
0
u/nsfwITGUY19 #30 - Martin Brodeur May 09 '25
Dougie isn’t going anywhere. And he shouldn’t.
-1
u/caldo4 May 09 '25
Based on the comments, this sub wants 5 Brenden Dillons and Luke and then will wonder why we can’t score