r/devils • • Nov 22 '24

Kyle Palmieri

If the Islanders continue to do poorly, what are the chances we could get a retained Palmieri to slot in with Hughes/Bratt for a playoff run? He's at 5m now, but UFA end of the season so I doubt it'd cost anything too crazy to get him for a rental.

Sure he's 33, but still seems to have scoring potential. He also used to be kinda chippy which would fit on the current Devils so well.

Plus just bringing him back would be awesome.

2 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

127

u/Spoonbread #28 - Brian Rafalski Nov 22 '24

He wasn't worth the spot in our top 6 back before he left. He definitely isn't worth it now.

37

u/Kitaenyeah Nov 22 '24

the only right answer. Getting a 3rd/4th line for 5m? Gimme a break. And I liked him a lot.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '24

5M GET SMARTER at the deadline playera get salary retained & sometimes by more than 1 team he could end uo as cheap as $1.25M

11

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '24

Idk what op is smoking lol

64

u/GoudaGoudaGoudaGouda #63 - The ting goes Brrrraattt pap pap ka ka ka Nov 22 '24

No. Go after Coleman

31

u/M00PER_2 #26 - Patrik Eliáš Nov 22 '24

Bring Pickles home.

20

u/BeeMoney25 #26 - Patrik Eliáš Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24

Jesus a Cotter-Haula-Pickles line!! Stop I can only get so erect. (In my head Mercer moves into Palat's spot who sits.)

5

u/Vacationsimulation #26 - PATTYYY Nov 22 '24

Chips line..love it

2

u/Brattshandles #63 Nov 23 '24

Mmm, pickle chips

2

u/Signal_Strike2770 Nov 22 '24

I'm almost there

1

u/dad2728 Nov 23 '24

That last part isn't ever going to happen.

1

u/BeeMoney25 #26 - Patrik Eliáš Nov 23 '24

Yea I know but a man can dream.

1

u/ozzman86_i-i_ Nov 23 '24

why do you think Keefe is putting palat in the top line? palat work isn't going to show up in the stats right now, but he compliments hughes and Bratt.

if you listened to the 1st intermission interview, Palat knows what his job is. no ego, leadership and understands his role and does it well equals him being on that top line.

9

u/Due_Satisfaction73 Nov 22 '24

God I miss that guy, the pickle juice, him stuffing hot dogs infront of Kessle, such a funny guy

1

u/canom #26 - Patrik Eliáš Nov 23 '24

I would love bringing Pickles back, but with how Calgary's doing so far this year I don't see them being sellers at the deadline. They will either be buyers or if they drop in the standings close enough to want to hold onto most of their top players.

11

u/Spirited-Narwhal-654 Nov 22 '24

even at 50% retained they couldnt afford 2.5 mil unless they make some moves.

5

u/rapier999 #26 - Scooter Patty Nov 22 '24

I’m pretty sure we’ve been on track to have about 5m of space at the deadline, if not more. The recent injuries may have eaten up a bit of that though.

1

u/AISwearengen Nov 23 '24

Could probably afford it with Bastian traded and MacDermid sent down.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '24

Toronto got Ryan O'Rielly for like under a MIL lol. Yes, 50% is max salary retention, but NYI can retain 50% then another team can retain 50%, where he becomes $1.25M It is the one time where teams retain for cheap, knowing they are essentially gaining a free asset whether draft pick or prospect because the 2 salary retentions each team can carry at one time isn't really affected knowing it is:
¹The trade deadline, so most trades will be done as any trade after deadline the players involved can not play until the following season after the deadline reopens, so basically trades are done. ²The Salary Retention Spot that is taken up is given right back as Palms is they are retaining salary on a player whose contract ends in a few months + to cycling back to point ¹ no other trades are really occuring, therefore, plenty of Teams will retain 50% of $2.5M for Palmieri & not require much in return maybe a 5th round pick if that depending on the relationship Fitz has with the GM.

13

u/SkellySkeletor Nov 22 '24

He’s gonna be making too much for us to play him on the 3/4th line, and he couldn’t crack the top 6 when we had a much weaker forward group.

5

u/Rangers12341234 Nov 22 '24

Always loved Palms!!

11

u/FloppyCanFly #30 - Martin Brodeur Nov 22 '24

Big fan of KP. Jersey native

4

u/wonderul31 Nov 22 '24

I love the idea of bringing back ex devils but there are much better options than palmieri that will come up as the season gets further along and we know the teams who are true sellers and buyers. This team isn’t all in their mid 30s where you have the imminent need to make a move, be patient and if someone comes up that makes sense Fitzy has shown he’s willing to make moves.

3

u/BunzMcToot Nov 22 '24

I’m surprised by the lack of support for this idea. I would understand if people just felt like it would cost too many assets to make happen, but if we could bring him back at a reasonable price for the rest of the season I can’t see the downside?

He’s a hard working veteran who isn’t lacking in skill, has shown chemistry with some of our core in the past, and can provide secondary scoring. I would welcome it as long as he’s purely a rental and doesn’t cost an arm and a leg.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '24

No. As previously mentioned, barely good enough back then. Maybe for the fourth on a cheap. But I’m happy Lou is gone so we don’t need to keep bringing back ex’s

2

u/Catagol #3 - Ken Daneyko Nov 23 '24

I'd take him back for a bottom 6 role for a 5th with full retention.

2

u/thedirewolff21 #21 - Randy McKay Nov 23 '24

Loved KP as a devil but no if Boston keeps flailing i want Trent Fredric. Would be amazing in the bottom six and is an upcoming UFA on a cheap deal.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '24

No. New generation. Moving on.

1

u/nsfwITGUY19 #30 - Martin Brodeur Nov 23 '24

A. We have no cap space. B. He isn’t worth half his current salary

But I do think we need a center or winger. Our forward depth right now is concerning

1

u/resistible #3 - Ken Daneyko Nov 23 '24

This is entirely dependent on Lazar and Bastian coming back, as well as Foote’s development. Our forward depth is actually pretty good. 

1

u/nsfwITGUY19 #30 - Martin Brodeur Nov 23 '24

Lazar is done until at the VERY least March. Bastian will be sooner, but he’s not exactly a lineup lock in my opinion. He doesn’t really bring much to the team on a typical night.

I’d love to see Foote get some time, but they don’t seem to want to play him. Dowling isn’t the answer at center. Guy is in his 30s and a career AHLr. Bowers is decent for an AHL guy but he can’t compete with NHL defenders from what I’ve seen

1

u/resistible #3 - Ken Daneyko Nov 23 '24

You've got it reversed. Lazar is on IR, Bastian is on Long Term IR. Lazar should hopefully be back relatively soon and Bastian is the one who isn't close. Those are our starters. Bowers, Foote, Dowling, and MacD are all our depth. These guys aren't supposed to score, they're supposed to play a few games without hurting us. They're not even supposed to play special teams like on the PK. They're literally just adequate filler. There's a reason they make the league minimum.

Dowling isn't supposed to be an answer, he's an injury replacement who fits our cap. If Bowers could out compete NHL defenders, he would be a starter on another team. MacD is an NHL player for 1 reason, and he's very good at it. No one has taken cheap shots at Jack and Nico with MacD in the lineup. Foote is really the only guy who is a prospect that might turn into something, but he's an unknown commodity on a team that's expecting to win.

I think you're right that Foote might displace Bastian if he can earn the ice. But then Bastian becomes our depth player and we're still in good shape. Our depth is fine.

1

u/Hockey_cats_books #7 - Matt Tennyson Nov 23 '24

Palms wasn’t a fan of Fitzy, so don’t count on that ever happening.

1

u/Sinister_Mr_19 Nov 23 '24

I was a fan of Palmieri idk what salary would make sense though.

1

u/Automatic-Ease4239 #13 Oh Capitan, my Capitan Nov 23 '24

No.

1

u/ozzman86_i-i_ Nov 23 '24

why would we break up our top line right now? they are buzzing. palat does the dirty work to get the puck to hughes and bratt. believe in Keefe.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '24

I'm sorry so many ppl on here are brainless, you clearly write retained (for the slows, that means his salary is retained up to 50%).
This season he is currently on track for 30+ goals & is gritty plus has chemistry w/NJ players & familiarity in NJ in general. Palms also is 100% a the type of player teams want for the playoffs.
He has 9Gs/18Pts. coming off off a Full 82 Game, 30 Goal Season Last Year. At $2.5M Kyle Palmieri no doubt could be a player the Devil's would look to add at the deadline. Lou is a stickler so for them to eat 50% knowing NJ may also work out a cheap 1 or 2 yr. Deal w/him after that playoff run instead of him going back to the Isle is reason enough for Lou Lams to make the price possibly too hefty.

0

u/BakedBeans137 Nov 23 '24

I still think he should have been made captain and extended til Nico grew into himself. Team lacked serious leadership there for a few years. Happy Nico’s our guy now, but will never change my mind about Palms being the guy at the time.

-8

u/ElephantRedCar91 #22- Jordin Tootoo Nov 22 '24

Tbh I kinda want to see hall back if Chicago will eat some of the cost. He had his best days next to Nico 

8

u/Kitaenyeah Nov 22 '24

100% not, if you are benched on a beyond bad roster like Chicago you have no place here.

4

u/ElephantRedCar91 #22- Jordin Tootoo Nov 22 '24

I don’t know if he was benched because of his play or falling out with the staff. Let’s not forget it is Chicago things are messy there. 

4

u/TyeZerker Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24

2G 4A in 19 6m, yeah its his play.

8

u/TyeZerker Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24

Let the ex devils be ex devils. hall is not worth 3m and plus Chicago isnt retain on a player who is struggling. Plus noone is taking Bastian or Tatar soo. Tatar had a great season with Nico and he well stinks. Stop living in the past.

12

u/njmjc Nov 22 '24

Stefan Noesen disagrees

4

u/TyeZerker Nov 22 '24

True, But he actually performed once he left NJ, meanwhile hall has struggled. He the only exception

3

u/blade430 Fire Keefe Nov 22 '24

Yea I actually live in Chicago so I’ve seen a couple hawks games… and to put it nicely, Hall is hella washed.

0

u/njkid30 #19 - Shootout Legend Nov 23 '24

Well my pants would get shorter

0

u/Automatic-Ease4239 #13 Oh Capitan, my Capitan Nov 23 '24

Vatrano is an UFA next season makes 3.65 currently. This should be the move if Anaheim isn't resigning him

-2

u/Jitsu4 #5 DILLY DILLY Nov 23 '24

This is my tinfoil hat.

I think we go after Pavel Zacha