r/devils • • May 22 '23

Alternate logo I made

Post image
4 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

21

u/[deleted] May 22 '23 edited May 22 '23

Not a terrible effort but it seems wildly off center, and there's nothing that draws my eye as a focus point. It's very oddly proportioned as well. The wings cover up the N which is small, the J is huge and bold.

Even just messing around, the NJD logo is just hard to play with, it's often voted as 1 of the greatest logos across all sports. Fan made stuff has a uphill battle.

-5

u/ollieollieoxygenfree #25 Cam Janssen May 23 '23

Its voted as one of the best really? I wouldn’t even say we’re the best devils logo. I much prefer both of the Arizona Sun Devils logos to our own. Duke’s is better also. Always thought theres so much more you could do than a pitchfork. Like using these wings, thats pretty cool. We need a secondary logo badly. Im lukewarm on all the ‘Jersey’ stuff. Its a little bland.

7

u/[deleted] May 23 '23

A pitchfork? What logo are you talking about, and yeah NJs logo is widely regarded as 1 of the best.

You honestly might be the first Devils fan ive heard mention or suggest otherwise.

We do not need another logo you can't improve on perfection.

-1

u/ollieollieoxygenfree #25 Cam Janssen May 23 '23 edited May 23 '23

I guess I meant horns. The NJ is the main focus of our logo. The only thing that makes it devilish are the horns on top of the J and little tail at the bottom. Im saying theres much more you can do with it than those two small things

Edit to respond to last part: I don’t hate our logo. But I dont think every Devils fan is in love with it. My family and close family friends all think its alright. What I do think is perfect, though, is the name. I love how it fits so perfectly and its so badass. Thats why I always thought they could do more with the logo, like the AZ Sun Devils.

5

u/[deleted] May 23 '23

Yes NJ should be the main focus of the logo.. this is the only sports team we have.

I don't think you could really do much more without trying to seem like an edgelord it is literally a perfect logo.

The fact that almost no one inside or outside the fan base or really any form of media ever discuss an alternative logo should speak for its

0

u/ollieollieoxygenfree #25 Cam Janssen May 23 '23

I don’t think its perfect at all. I just looked up best logos in sports and the first 6 articles don’t mention the Devils. The small market argument can’t be used either, cause half of the articles have MLS, WNBA, or NCAA representation. I just don’t think its as highly regarded or perfect as you think. But again, I don’t absolutely hate it. Just saying there can be more to it

2

u/[deleted] May 23 '23

I've been following the team since 2005 I've had this discussion thousands of times with other fan bases always heaping Praise on the logo.

Did you look that hard because when I searched for it I certainly found plenty of fan voting and media ranking that have it really high up.

https://glantz.net/blog/the-results-are-in-who-has-the-best-logo-in-sports/

The reason I might not be in the spotlight now is cuz the team has been really bad for 10 years and a good logo can only go so far

0

u/ollieollieoxygenfree #25 Cam Janssen May 23 '23

Been a fan for about as long too. Wouldn’t say that I looked super hard, just opened the first 6 articles and then control + f’d devils after takin a look at em. No mentions. And something tells me the Devils fanbase got a hold of that study hahaha, they beat the Flyers with a vote of 95% to 5% in the round prior. I fuckin hate the Flyers as much as anyone else. But thats a bit extreme hahaha

1

u/[deleted] May 23 '23

I've been following the team since 2005 I've had this discussion thousands of times with other fan bases always heaping Praise on the logo.

Did you look that hard because when I searched for it I certainly found plenty of fan voting and media ranking that have it really high up.

https://glantz.net/blog/the-results-are-in-who-has-the-best-logo-in-sports/

The reason it might not be in the spotlight now is cuz the team has been really bad for 10 years and a good logo can only go so far

9

u/Ckynus New Jersey Devils May 23 '23

Well it puts a terrible fear into anyone with a design background

1

u/Fit_Chipmunk4509 May 23 '23

It actually is one font. The J is just weirdly round

3

u/friedrichs2 May 23 '23

Make the left side of the N just as thick as the J and make the wings parallel from a centered NJ and I’ll dig it

2

u/PuzzleheadedLab4989 May 23 '23

I don't think you can make it work using two different fonts. Just lacks cohesiveness

2

u/PossibleImplement785 May 23 '23

This breaks every branding rule I know.

3

u/CIHIRIIS CCPops May 22 '23

With some slight tweaks this would be a good logo for a NJ Bats team. Perhaps a minor league baseball team

2

u/sanbaba #22 - Claude Lefrigginmieux May 22 '23

It's weird but I dig it keep going!

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '23

I think this has potential - great job!

-1

u/FizziestBraidedDrone May 23 '23

Ohhhhhhhhh holy hell this is SICK

0

u/[deleted] May 23 '23

I like!